Hunty: 1-S2-1-5437897, BanditKeith: 1-S2-1-6109024

[Gh0st]

Account Name: Hunty
Account ID: #-S2-1-5437897
In-Game Name: Jester

Crimes Committed:
Game-throwing
Skyping
Cheating

#2
Account Name: BanditKeith
Account ID: #-S2-1-6109024
In-Game Name: Vanguard

Crimes Committed:
Game-throwing
Skyping
Cheating

Your Account Name: GhoST
Summary:

14 (Marshall) and 9 (Forger) worked together to lynch/kill all of townies and evils.
I was the DH, and 9 also voted me up and proceeded to lynch me.
Neither were seen pm'ing each other at all. They were somehow in touch via online chat or skype.
Everyone called them out on it, for which they did not have an answer.
End result: townies lost, triads won. (9 won over 14 in the end.)

Replay uploaded, please have a look.

Thanks,
GhoST

-Mafia- (1109).SC2Replay

[Gh0st]

?? 1 week later, and no update? Come on now.

[DarknessB]

@Gh0st , we apologize for the delay in processing this report of yours. There is a little bit of a backlog that we're currently working through, but we will get to this report as soon as we can. We have not forgotten about it, and thanks for your patience.

[Unknown1234]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Hunty: 1-S2-1-5437897: Correct.
Banditkeith: 1-S2-1-6109024: Correct.

Respective Hotkey:
Hunty: Control + 2
Banditkeith: Control + 4

Was The Game Altered?
Yes, the Marshall had lynched off 1 evil and 5 town during his lynches.

Previous Offenses:
Hunty: Pending Result: https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-5437897
Banditkeith: https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-6109024

Player Offenses:
Hunty: Skyping
Banditkeith: Skyping & Intentional Game-throw.
Summary:
Hunty rolls Forger.
Banditkeith rolls Marshall.
Hunty is #9.
Banditkeith is #14.
Day 1: Nothing.
Night 1: 14 writes in his last will "9 is triad.. and black" which is Hunty and himself.
Day 2: 14 says "i have a lead" then reveals himself as marshall and immediately puts a vote on 5 without asking for roles. Then, the marshall follows someones lead and votes up 6 without waiting for claims. Finally, he votes up somebody who claimed Jailor as his third target. a Veteran, Bus driver, and Jailor all appear in the graveyard. Before day ends, he writes in his last will saying "m8z i had some leads" when nobody had pm'd him at all.
Night 2: Nothing important.
Day 3: He reveals again, and decides to lynch a sheriff claim, who pissed him off. He then lynches one of the only other people who pm'd him, and they had claimed Escort. He then listens to 11 (again) about lynching the player they had targeted that night. he lynches a Sheriff, Escort, and Arsonist.
Night 3: Nothing.
Day 4: both 14 and 9 put their votes on 11 (Dragon head). 12, and the other triad, decided to vote him up as well. They then vote guilty and he ends up being lynched.
Night 4: 9 never suggests to kill 14, almost completely ignoring that player and choosing to kill anyone else but him.
Day 5: They both vote together (and agree) to lynch 8, the remaining triad. Even though triad had no way of losing, it made sense following that 9 and 14 had been silently working together throughout the game.
Night 5: 9 does not kill 14.
Recommended Action:
Hunty: Watchlist +3 (Added with other offense, if included.)
Banditkeith: Watchlist x5.

Additional Notes:
Thanks for the report! The marshall showed no signs of playing the game properly, and is shown working with Hunty the entire game. Aside from never lynching a single triad and lynching people who claim reasonable roles and last wills, and the obvious coordination at the end, it is pretty clear to me that these two were communicating outside of game.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-5437897: +3x WL for 6x total
1-S2-1-6109024: 5x WL