Originally Posted by Vader
Lol, of course, the only place I missed. I checked through all seven hundred thousand regular FAQ questions and didn't find it there. Rawr.
Fluttershy, if you find out you you do get both suspicious and not suspicious results, you just check someone you're almost 100% sure is guaranteed town and see which way they flip. Like a mayor or something.
Roger, I don't want to sound mean. But your word vows aren't exactly saying much... Your vows, as broken down (refer to the vow post):
1. If you shoot in the vault, we'd know. There's no way a real vigilante would shoot in the vault this early in the game, unless you shoot first. So you're forced into not shooting if the people in the vault don't wish it so. Or else you'd be in deep trouble. So this vow was implied even if you didn't say anything.
2. Once we're out of the vault, we can't check this guarantee, that you won't fire unless upon agreement. Even if you shoot, you can just say the bullet didn't come out of your gun. And then we'd have no way of knowing.
3. As for conveying the target through code to only the vault members, I'm a bit against this. Especially if there's a Mafia member in here, all the Mafia would know whom you're shooting but only 5 townies max will know. I'd be more comfortable discussing the target with the entire town. You don't have to reveal you have the vigilante gun. But I'd be more comfortable with you taking the target that all of town agrees on. Some WIFOM would be preferable, as in saying something like "Yeah, I just deciphered the code from the person in our vault with the vigilante gun and he says he will shoot..." Something along those lines.
A reminder. We only have 24 hours for day. As of right now, it would seem like no one's going to get the gun. I do somewhat trust Roger however, so I guess my vote will go to him.
-vote Roger for vigilante gun