I play way too much Pokemon.
okay i am ending this day;
dont think this ends game but w/e
-vote Whysper
Cya
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
Whysper has been hammered. Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!
Whysper (5 [L-0]): Mike, Marshmallow Marshall, Firebringer, Bahkieh, Bruno
Bahkieh (1 [L-4]): Whysper
Marshmallow Marshall (1 [L-4]): FrostByte
Whysper is lunch, they are Hammer Bro
Night 5 ends when all night actions are submitted or 24 hours, whichever comes first
Originally Posted by BananaCucho
Bruno died last night. He was a Shiny Toad
Frost "where's my nickname" Byte died last night. He was a Toad
Fred died last night. He was Insane Wario
THE TOWN/MUSHROOM KINGDOM HAS WON
(Mike has conceded so I didn't bother processing any actions. Bruno and Frost died cause he ignited them, docs could have saved but it doesn't matter at this point)
Roles (assigned RANDOMLY; order based off of the signup list):
1 - Renegade - Yoshi
2 - firebanger - Mario
3 - dark magician - Geno
4 - bahkieh - Mallow
5 - Whysper - Hammer Bro
6 - Mike - Wario
7 - Martin - Toad
8 - MM - Mallow
9 - FrostByte - Toad
10 - grylander - Goomba
11 - bruno - Toad
12 - Kenny - Toad
13 - ceko - Princess Toadstool
14 - Barker - Toad
15 - Zone - Bowser
Host notes:
MVP vote from host: @Bruno . He had 2/3 scum pegged day 1, and was monumentally important to Bowser day 1 lunch that mafia was unable to recover from. Interactions with Gry contributed to the decision by DM to try to shoot Gry (Gry was saved by OoO), and Ren to check Gry
Special mention: @bakermir . Barker softed/claimed TPR day 1 to try to draw a night kill. He asked me in private if that strategy was okay - I obviously couldn't say anything, but Wario took the bait and shot at him night 1, which unlocked the 2nd cop for town. If Mike holds his shot, Fire dies night 2 since he claimed day 2
There is some discontent expressed in dead chat over the roles that were picked. Firstly, this game is meant to be swingy. You have a town cop that can change to serial killer or 2nd mafia faction. You have an anti-claim role in Wario that can turn into Arsonist. Do you dislike mechanics like this? You're probably on the wrong site.
Secondly - yes there were 2 cops and 2 docs. But this was balanced FMPOV because first, docs cannot chain heal. If any doc claims at any time, town is unable to stop them from being night killed. There were several times in the game that MM or Bahkieh could have been voted up and forced to claim (MM in particular was under constant scrutiny this game), which would result in their night death. Mafia also has a roleblocker that they could use to block doctor heals if they so desire
Regarding that roleblocker and the 2 cops. The game started with: 1 cop 2 docs, 7 count them SEVEN toads/citizens. And scum started with a roleblocker and a DRUG DEALER. When Fire claims Mario day 2, if their drug dealer is alive they have lots of options. They can change his result, or roleblock him. Since drug dealer was LUNCH day 1 and never got to act (other things were possible such as making rando townies believe they were changed into wario and such) they were forced to use their roleblock on him. And even though the 2nd cop was unlocked (they could deal with both if they had both roleblocker + drug dealer, block one and change feedback of the other) fire was roleblocked every single night after n1. So this was towns actions:
n1 - cop check, 2 doc heal attempts
n2 - cop check, 2 doc heal attempts, vig attempt (failed due to OoO)
n3 - cop check, 2 doc heal attempts
n4 - cop check, 2 doc heal attempts
Mafia had the tools, but when you lose your best role day 1 then you can't complain about remaining town roles being overbalanced for town. And to be clear, Bowser's day 1 lunch was not random. It wasn't even a plurality vote. It was a socially deduced scum that rolled over and was bussed by his mafioso teammate, while the 3rd scum lurked.
Lastly the 2 docs - only 1 heal was successful and they both targeted the same person and were able to SOCIALLY DEDUCE that Whysper was a better vote option.
Finally, regardless of any balance talk - Mafia was severely outplayed this game. Well played to town, you guys deserve the victory. 5 days, 4 lunches, and not a single mislunch. That's pretty insane. For the most part, I extremely enjoyed reading this game. For anyone reading the flavor, sorry that it was left open ended.
Dead/mafia/observer chats: https://discord.gg/xvuPKGMB
Originally Posted by BananaCucho
gg
might refrain from reading DM + Bakermir in the future lol
I don't recall a game where I've had a stable & correct read on them while I was town
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
-vote BrunoMVP
i think baker did better than bruno. especially later game but i guess considering how game changing day 1 bowser lynch is maybe not overstatement that bruno did really well.
i was very ineffective. Thx for the carry folks
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
99 votes to hammer.
Originally Posted by BananaCucho
ftr i made 2 claims on day 2 to make it look like i couldn't be mario and was fake claiming to scum; unfortunately no town picked up on it to help CC and shield me. and after day 2 i was like okay i guess im confirmed anad gonna be blocked not gonna change anything.
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
I so thought MM was mafia and I was trying to stop a lynch on mafia I only town read him to keep him from night killing me. I thought wry would be a ML.
Ok to explaine the baker tunnel I was pissed he fooled me day 1 into shooting him I had him as town but pushed for his mislynch. Well played baker you baited my shot. I only hounded you to get you crazy so you could not help town sorry but I was scum lol
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
@Mike is this 3 games in a row you are neut?
*hmmmmmmm face
RNG has been freaky lately
MM has rolled Mallow-related things 3 times in a row (The role MM in the anti-vaxx game, The role MM when I publicly RNG who it was as town in that Anti-vaxx game, and the role "Mallow" in this game)
Mike with his multiple rands of Neut roles
And your discord avi has yoshi in it lol
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
DM rand VT: IM ALWAYS CITIZEN
DM rand TPR: Ḓ̛͙͎̯̦̌̎͒͑̈̔̕r̪̩̬͙͗͂͒́̊͟͞y̨̨̧̻̜̦̠͎̏́̂̃͡ B̵̟͖̱̿̍̈́͘͜͟͡ŏ̴̗̪̰̹͓͚̜̅̇͂̚͘͜͟n̴̡͖̺̠̺͋̾̾̿̔͜͝e͒́̌̀͌͘ ͙̜̼͔̯͈ş̵̫̪͔̥̜̺̐̓̽̽̄
that settles us 1-1 scum!mike LOL gg dude
you have done well with the pushes. koopas could have finished me that day but they didn't. i was expecting little results with that bait claim but it kept snowballing the game, this game could have went either way but town did great and koopa's did a wrong bet by not hammering me or MM earlier.
i fell into gyrs pocket when they refused to hammer ;/ sorry all
i loved bahkieh's breadcrumb btw. town did great gj bois
bruno d1.. my mind is still blown.. mvp bruno
ggwp all
@theoneceko You totally changed your pic to send a signal didn't you.
@Mike you sneaky fuck. Respect.
Umm but the setup was fucking hilarious and confusing as shit, by design. And it was run very well. Thank you @BananaCucho for doing this. Any time you wanna run a game I'll /sign for it.
"huurr-ba-dUwUrr i scared ceko away bc i called him out for his avatar UwOwU-DURR"
That's exactly what happened though. You did some obvious scum shit and got called for it. get ezd.Originally Posted by theoneceko;dicksword
@theoneceko ez
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
I was so convinced there was no way town would get 2 docs lol. Too bad Mafia got fucking destroyed early on, I would've liked to see this game in a better light.
Treecko pfp is a daughter of a mafia member from HxH. I didnt wanna say anything lmao
I play way too much Pokemon.
I'm disappointed in the lack of post game discussion here and on the dischord.
Nice, GG everyone. A lot of good plays were made by a lot of people (thinking of Bruno a lot right now, but other people as well). But my MVP is-vote BananaCucho
I know I'm not original, but this was an extremely fun game, both because of how it turned out and because of the setup (which was unstable, but that really is something you should realize as soon as you look at the setup page, and it was very fun).
@Zone_Q11 literally softclaimed bowser day 1 and didnt think that would look sus 2 the ppl paying attention lmao
also i hope this game entirely dismantled yalls lame importance in meta
meta dont mean shit, this is my first sfm or even mafia game in yrs - i dont know any of u
@Mike ur a sneaky fuck. i had a feeling that u claimed dosed cuz u flipped arso, but i thought a 200iq play was a lil out of reach 4 a dude who cant even spell mario consistently lmao
gg all was fun
The misspelling of Marieo over and over was intentional. I doused DM Night 2. When I saw he flipped dead, I went HMMMMM People don't like to lynch someone doused also mafia don't like to kill some one doused. SO I was why not. I douse The kills Mafia would not target. except for DM But I could not pass that one up. And then burn for the win. Let the Mafia do the leg work.
But Mafia never killed the dang Cops. That screwed me.
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
Also Mafia refused to lynch any town even went I set it up in a Gift wrap with a bow on it. Yes I am talking about Baker. I tryed sOOOOOO Hard to get him Lynched Town was on my side but Mafia would not do it lol
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :