S-FM 302: Magellan (15p)

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

You have to be kidding me. In no world was Wilbird NE or NB he littly would have thrown that game. This is why he wanted to be lynched to confirm he was TOwn. How do you not see that. That confirmed Quinne was MAfia.

he freaked out as soon as he was actually L-1 though...

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

Open Wolfing is that better????? you have been Open Wolfing

Ok what is Open Wolfing?
I'm just asking. I don't actually know.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

you could call the same thing gamethrowing if they were town, considering it's a part of town's objective to survive, lynching a confirmed town from your own pov is a gamethrow of sorts, bad play at least

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

so in those possibilities, was mulan mafia, or was nick mafia?

I always believed it made the most sense for Marlwyn to be mafia and Lois to be a legit Sheriff.
1. Lois claimed Sheriff straight up, made a suicidal play if he was actually Mafia and then RQed the game which is pretty pissed off Town behaviour in my book
2. Lois got a Mafia read on Marlwyn
3. Marlwyn recruited Wilbird into night chat as soon as Fred used his vig bullet (which Wilbird interestingly also asked to happen) which makes sense if Mafia and NE were trying to network

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

i dont think eod wilberd's fight for survival or lack there of was alignment indicative at all

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

making bad plays =/= throwing the game
it's not like he woulda gamethrew anyways since he was technically a neutral

Yeah I dunno how he has decided to 'know' this either.
Probably because it's the only situation that fits the narrative where I am Mafia.

Oh well after the game I will hang out with all my Mafia buddies Quinne, Marlwynn, Lois, Joha, Lembird, Vlad and wonder why host made a game with 7 mafia!?

WOW really? I was thinking Vlad dead mafia Quinne dead MAfia Joha Dead NE and Bart last mafia. unless Joha was real NB and Lembird the real NE? Hacker I would guess.

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

Ok what is Open Wolfing?
I'm just asking. I don't actually know.

Open wolfing is just playing scummy openly just to push your narrative.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

I always believed it made the most sense for Marlwyn to be mafia and Lois to be a legit Sheriff.
1. Lois claimed Sheriff straight up, made a suicidal play if he was actually Mafia and then RQed the game which is pretty pissed off Town behaviour in my book
2. Lois got a Mafia read on Marlwyn
3. Marlwyn recruited Wilbird into night chat as soon as Fred used his vig bullet (which Wilbird interestingly also asked to happen) which makes sense if Mafia and NE were trying to network

haha got you
you said you thought quinne was mafia in those scenarios
ill be taking note of this

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

you could call the same thing gamethrowing if they were town, considering it's a part of town's objective to survive, lynching a confirmed town from your own pov is a gamethrow of sorts, bad play at least

NO. Quinne claimed he was Neutral. buy him willing to be lynched is not throwing. as long as it helps town figure out the true story so town wins. Wilbird was lock town.
And wilbird did not freak out in L1 I put him in L1 and then back it off e then pushed me to just lynch him. Wilbird is 100% lock town. Quinne is 100% lock Mafia. and anyone not seeing that is not reading the game or just scum.

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

WOW really? I was thinking Vlad dead mafia Quinne dead MAfia Joha Dead NE and Bart last mafia. unless Joha was real NB and Lembird the real NE? Hacker I would guess.

So you think I outed Vlad as disguised Jan and revealed the host's messup to kill my teammate for fun to gain some "town cred"? If you think I am capable of such sophisticated plays does it also make sense that I would then hard defend my fellow mafia buddy Quinne?

Also you think that Quinne just somehow guessed that Lembird was the NE and made a fake cit result on him?

Does any of this actually make a consistent story?

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

So you think I outed Vlad as disguised Jan and revealed the host's messup to kill my teammate for fun to gain some "town cred"? If you think I am capable of such sophisticated plays does it also make sense that I would then hard defend my fellow mafia buddy Quinne?

Also you think that Quinne just somehow guessed that Lembird was the NE and made a fake cit result on him?

Does any of this actually make a consistent story?

game of thrones pfp and talking about consistent story
Lol!

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

haha got you
you said you thought quinne was mafia in those scenarios
ill be taking note of this

TY you finally see?

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

haha got you
you said you thought quinne was mafia in those scenarios
ill be taking note of this

Huh?
Scenario 1 was Quinne was Town.
Scenario 2 was Quinne was Mafia.
Scenario 3 was Quinne was Mafia.

All scenario are possible that's why I raised them.
Obviously if you asked me to choose a Mafia between Lois and Marlwyn then you are asking about Scenario 1.

Good try.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

Huh?
Scenario 1 was Quinne was Town.
Scenario 2 was Quinne was Mafia.
Scenario 3 was Quinne was Mafia.

All scenario are possible that's why I raised them.
Obviously if you asked me to choose a Mafia between Lois and Marlwyn then you are asking about Scenario 1.

Good try.

i thought the /s was implied

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

i thought the /s was implied

I don't understand.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

I don't understand.

sarcasm
im oozing with it

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

Lembird Will you hammer now please? Killing bart will not put us in mylo

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

Lembird Will you hammer now please? Killing bart will not put us in mylo

Fred, how have you determined that Holbird is 100% Town?
You are 100% about most of your reads so I am sure you are 100% on that one too.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

Lembird Will you hammer now please? Killing bart will not put us in mylo

if quinne was mafia
then that means the ne is probably still alive
which means we are very much indeed currently in mylo because we have 3 town vs 2 scum

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

if quinne was mafia
then that means the ne is probably still alive
which means we are very much indeed currently in mylo because we have 3 town vs 2 scum

I already explained why there's not 2 scum left though so hammer me if you think it's the right thing to do (it's not).

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

Fred, how have you determined that Holbird is 100% Town?
You are 100% about most of your reads so I am sure you are 100% on that one too.

Hilbird is not With you you want to lynch him.
If You where Town Both Twinsails and Limbird had a chance to hammer you so they cant be a team with holbird.

Holibird was ok with not going to the end.

You can do the math..

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

Hilbird is not With you you want to lynch him.
If You where Town Both Twinsails and Limbird had a chance to hammer you so they cant be a team with holbird.

Holibird was ok with not going to the end.

You can do the math..

Well some genius deductions there. I guess I can die happy in the knowledge we have an assured Town victory then.










Not.

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

I wonder what the Dead would say to us were they alive now.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

I already explained why there's not 2 scum left though so hammer me if you think it's the right thing to do (it's not).

from your pov, since you're the one at l1
from my pov it's very much possible that scum isn't hitting you because you're their buddy.
it's also possible that there is no ne, which I'm inclined to believe, but i dont know that for fact, so i don't want to be the one to ruin the game for town with a bad hammer because i didn't do my own analysis

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

from your pov, since you're the one at l1
from my pov it's very much possible that scum isn't hitting you because you're their buddy.
it's also possible that there is no ne, which I'm inclined to believe, but i dont know that for fact, so i don't want to be the one to ruin the game for town with a bad hammer because i didn't do my own analysis

This doesn't make sense dude:
Possibilities (in your mind);

1. Either I am Town and there is 1 scum left like I said meaning you won't auto lose once I am dead but you will still lose.
or
2. I am scum meaning it is safe (and correct) to lynch me.

So either way if you think I am scum you should hammer me now.

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

if quinne was mafia
then that means the ne is probably still alive
which means we are very much indeed currently in mylo because we have 3 town vs 2 scum

Dude if you are Town

If there was a world of 2 and Bart was Town

Why is Bart alive sitting on L1??? would mafia hammered they could have and won easy already Twinsails was in here already I beg him to lynch bart just like i did you.

In no world is it LILO and bart is Town. or else it would be GAME OVER MAFIA WON.

BEcuse One of the votes is ME CONFIRMED TOWN.

DO the MAth.

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

This doesn't make sense dude:
Possibilities (in your mind);

1. Either I am Town and there is 1 scum left like I said meaning you won't auto lose once I am dead but you will still lose.
or
2. I am scum meaning it is safe (and correct) to lynch me.

So either way if you think I am scum you should hammer me now.

This is correct. wow.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

you should hammer me now.

i mean if you say so
-Vote S-FM Bart Pilfter

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

Dude if you are Town

If there was a world of 2 and Bart was Town

Why is Bart alive sitting on L1??? would mafia hammered they could have and won easy already Twinsails was in here already I beg him to lynch bart just like i did you.

In no world is it LILO and bart is Town. or else it would be GAME OVER MAFIA WON.

BEcuse One of the votes is ME CONFIRMED TOWN.

DO the MAth.

Fred wrote it in the most confusing way possible, but he is correct in that there's not 2 scum left.

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

i mean if you say so
-Vote S-FM Bart Pilfter

I love you.

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

I think Fred just reached ecstasy.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

Dude if you are Town

If there was a world of 2 and Bart was Town

Why is Bart alive sitting on L1??? would mafia hammered they could have and won easy already Twinsails was in here already I beg him to lynch bart just like i did you.

In no world is it LILO and bart is Town. or else it would be GAME OVER MAFIA WON.

BEcuse One of the votes is ME CONFIRMED TOWN.

DO the MAth.

okay alright whatever, i think you're right in that regard
i believed it myself that there's only 1 scum left

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

i mean if you say so
-Vote S-FM Bart Pilfter

i mean if you say so
[COLOR="#FF0000"-Vote S-FM Bart Pilfter[/COLOR]

The post and the post with broken code.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

I love you.

dont tempt me with a good meme like that again
you wont live to regret it

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

dont tempt me with a good meme like that again
you wont live to regret it

So why arnt you voting?

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

dont tempt me with a good meme like that again
you wont live to regret it

I think I have defended myself more than appropriately.
A misslynch at this point is not on me.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

So why arnt you voting?

because i want to reread bart and we have a full 48 hours or some bullshit for all of us to evaluate our reads and make sure this is something we want to do because depending on where we put our vote we can lose the game

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

i mean we could just win if fred decides to never lynch me after today

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

because i want to reread bart and we have a full 48 hours or some bullshit for all of us to evaluate our reads and make sure this is something we want to do because depending on where we put our vote we can lose the game

PLease do not extend this game please dont.

You know only way for town to win is pick 1 town other than myself and lynch everyone inculding town. No night KP so mislynchess is not bad. plus I belive there is a chance game ends with lynching Bart. if not I know it is not Holibird.

[S-FM Bart Pilfter]

Fred's favourite words to use:
1. "Knowing"
2. "100%"
3. "Lieing"

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

i mean we could just win if fred decides to never lynch me after today

sorry but in no world would I take you or twinsails. But FROM your POV that is a win becuse Twinsails is mafia. plus if Twinsails was mafia and Bart was town why not vote there whe a Confirmed town begged him to easy mislynch. unless Twinsales is team with Bart. eather way . I lynch you and twinsails after bart I dont care who first. and take Hilbord to final 2 . town wins.

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

Fred's favourite words to use:
1. "Knowing"
2. "100%"
3. "Lieing"

Only with you Bart. LOL you played a good Mafia game. You even at times got me to doubt my own reads. Well played.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

sorry but in no world would I take you or twinsails. But FROM your POV that is a win becuse Twinsails is mafia. plus if Twinsails was mafia and Bart was town why not vote there whe a Confirmed town begged him to easy mislynch. unless Twinsales is team with Bart. eather way . I lynch you and twinsails after bart I dont care who first. and take Hilbord to final 2 . town wins.

you see, i uh, don't like that plan

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

Marck there laughing his butt off knowing the full truth behind all this lies everyone are saying. Lembird holding this game hostage. Keeping me in this nightmare.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

you see, i uh, don't like that plan

because you know, what if you're wrong about holbird

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

you see, i uh, don't like that plan

Why are you The real NE?

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

Why are you The real NE?

hold on let me check my rolecard again

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

hold on let me check my rolecard again

uh according to the only two pieces of mail in my inbox, my role is still ensign
the other is the default "welcome!" message from the bot pretending to be dark revenant

[S-FM Fred Attlebish]

hold on let me check my rolecard again

Well if both you and Bart both vote me that gives you a 50/50% of winning. becuse there will be 2 votes on me and 2 votes on bart. and then host will have to RNG who is lynched. So if you 2 want to win that will be your only chance at this point.

[S-FM Lembird Oshay]

Well if both you and Bart both vote me that gives you a 50/50% of winning. becuse there will be 2 votes on me and 2 votes on bart. and then host will have to RNG who is lynched. So if you 2 want to win that will be your only chance at this point.

how about
instead of throwing by lynching the confirmed town
you consider that other possibilities may exist