S-FM 299: Insanity 2: the Second One, Gamethread

[BananaCucho]

I just honestly can't tell if Banana is power-wolfing or in care-free town mode. This setup has admittedly had some adverse effects on my play-style as well regardless of my role. Banana wouldn't push that hard for a MC without having his fake-claim on hand so I can see why lynching there might be good.

Weak.

[BananaCucho]

Btw I bread crumbed that I was godfather earlier. Still nobody has found it

[BananaCucho]

Btw I bread crumbed that I was godfather earlier. Still nobody has found it

Thats how you bread crumb @kira . Start taking notes. Its gotta be impossible to spot yet able to be recalled later

[BananaCucho]

I Always Make Golden Opportunities. Don't Fret About The Heathen Escaping... Run..

Right here

[BananaCucho]

Like such a dumb post and nobody called it out

[BananaCucho]

Btw if I'm somehow spared, I'm healing yzb instead of Pringles

[Frinckles]

Weak.

Don't take advantage of the fact that I have other obligations. I can read 61 pages fairly quickly and I will thunderdome the hell out of anyone to find scum.

My statement is valid. You guys want me to play the game, let's play.

[Light_Yagami]

Thats how you bread crumb @kira . Start taking notes. Its gotta be impossible to spot yet able to be recalled later

Nobody Has Found Mine Yet Either...lol And If You Think U Have U Might As Well Say It.

[Frinckles]

What good is a massclaim if only 4/13 people did it? One of whom could have been a Jester starting it.

[BananaCucho]

Don't take advantage of the fact that I have other obligations. I can read 61 pages fairly quickly and I will thunderdome the hell out of anyone to find scum.

My statement is valid. You guys want me to play the game, let's play.

"Banana wouldn't push that hard for a MC without a fake claim on hand"

That's weak. Its untrue. You don't know me long but you obviously don't know me, so don't make untrue statements like this.

[Gyrlander]

No you are untouchable. There are certain players that people would refuse to put up in the craziness yesterday, you being one of them

No veterans were voted up except me, and that was because I led the charge. There's definitely a lot of classism going on at sc2mafia and I refuse to continue to stay silent!

Ah, so you're basically saying that whoever went with your crazy shit yesterday is worthy of your protection. Does that mean you town read them, or not necessarily?

[Frinckles]

Speaking of which, I imagine we do have a Jester King in this setup and I'd wager it's one of the veteran players looking for some grand reveal.

[BananaCucho]

What good is a massclaim if only 4/13 people did it? One of whom could have been a Jester starting it.

I wanted to keep it going silly

[Frinckles]

"Banana wouldn't push that hard for a MC without a fake claim on hand"

That's weak. Its untrue. You don't know me long but you obviously don't know me, so don't make untrue statements like this.

You're a smart enough player to have an out. I know that. I've watched your scum game. Explain to me the massclaim theory.

[Frinckles]

I wanted to keep it going silly

Well, the roast has since been taken out of the oven half-cooked. Scum literally has plausible roleclaims, most certainly from myself.

[Gyrlander]

Make of all of that what you will

Or continue to attack inexperienced and/or different players for weak arguments or for not conforming to the way you want them to play the game

Fly my banner after I'm gone, remember the name is BANANA and not "bc for breadcrumb"

Interestingly I haven't attacked anyone yet besides you a little bit. I have not felt very engaged in the events and I'm sitting far away throwing some random comments.

[BananaCucho]

Ah, so you're basically saying that whoever went with your crazy shit yesterday is worthy of your protection. Does that mean you town read them, or not necessarily?

How did you get that from what I said? If anything, those who went along with the craziness for certain people, yet not for others should be examined. Galeon for example voted secondguessing and yzb. He was willing to out up everyone. Pringles though skipped over secondguessing qnd egged us on, wanting to "chinese fire drill" others, and is now throwing me under the bus for something he encouraged.

[Frinckles]

"Banana wouldn't push that hard for a MC without a fake claim on hand"

That's weak. Its untrue. You don't know me long but you obviously don't know me, so don't make untrue statements like this.

Also, this is an untrue statement. I'm very observant and while we may not go back as far as you and SB16 I've seen how you play. You start really playing with pressure on you to do something. That doesn't mean you're scum here but you need to give me something besides Mech talk.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

We've had the following 4 roleclaims thus far:

The1Ceko - Sheriff
Varcron - Bodyguard
Bananacucho - Doctor
Frinckles - Asylum Counsellor

Ah, so you're still a little behind. No worries then, I was wondering why you didn't comment on this earlier lol.

Also, you're giving SJ wayyy too much credit for his game too far. People are going to be thinking about ways to not look like a neutral evil, and getting into a stupid no-lynch argument is a bait asf way to do that. We've had a million scum players who make their day 1 about questioning the foundations of an FM game to get "spotlight" townpoints and "bravery" townpoints. You're giving it way too much credit.

what what WHAT

Why in the world would you openly claim Doctor on D1... just why? I don't know how to read that. It's so weird, but on the other hand, why do that as scum?
Also, the Frinckles claim is interesting, but it puts a target in his back. Ugh. D1 claims are bad in most cases, and those claims are no exceptions.

I didn't say SJ was lock town I just said that he had townpoints while most other players did not, and that I had a feeling he was town (nothing to do with his personality, being nice doesn't equal being town and I think everyone here knows that).

[Frinckles]

I'm gonna get some food and then ISO MM / The vets. I imagine scum hiding in there.

Unfortunately I'm not sure how many people are actually pressuring the vets besides SJ.

[BananaCucho]

You're a smart enough player to have an out. I know that. I've watched your scum game. Explain to me the massclaim theory.

Bro I was bored and went with a high energy thing that was happening. It was a lot of fun. Not much strategy to it at all. I'm much more calculating as scum, you of all people should KNOW that I do not enjoy power wolfing as scum. Its why I didnt use the heartbreaker role you gave me

The fake claim I made last game was due to circumstance. My scum game is from the shadows.

[BananaCucho]

what what WHAT

Why in the world would you openly claim Doctor on D1... just why? I don't know how to read that. It's so weird, but on the other hand, why do that as scum?
Also, the Frinckles claim is interesting, but it puts a target in his back. Ugh. D1 claims are bad in most cases, and those claims are no exceptions.

I didn't say SJ was lock town I just said that he had townpoints while most other players did not, and that I had a feeling he was town (nothing to do with his personality, being nice doesn't equal being town and I think everyone here knows that).

I refuse to answer this question. Lynch me if you dare.

[Frinckles]

what what WHAT

Why in the world would you openly claim Doctor on D1... just why? I don't know how to read that. It's so weird, but on the other hand, why do that as scum?
Also, the Frinckles claim is interesting, but it puts a target in his back. Ugh. D1 claims are bad in most cases, and those claims are no exceptions.

I didn't say SJ was lock town I just said that he had townpoints while most other players did not, and that I had a feeling he was town (nothing to do with his personality, being nice doesn't equal being town and I think everyone here knows that).

Almost every game recently has had a softclaim D1 that is picked up by people. Doesn't matter if it's Doctor, Mafia Sniper or whatever else.

At this point, I see some merit in letting out other townmembers be informed where they may normally not be. Banana could be a literal Veteran baiting for all we know.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

You're talking as if there was no reasoning backing those accusations. Damn the white knight.

^^^^^^^^

Soon he's gonna dress all red and sing the Internationale. Light has been playing for a long time, and he's not being listened to. It's pretty much his choice to remain in that "class" of people who aren't being listened to. Also, remember that Mafia is a game of arguing, so if more experienced people argue better than others, well... that's the result, and it's part of the game. It doesn't mean we're bashing new players, it means they're new players.

[Frinckles]

Bro I was bored and went with a high energy thing that was happening. It was a lot of fun. Not much strategy to it at all. I'm much more calculating as scum, you of all people should KNOW that I do not enjoy power wolfing as scum. Its why I didnt use the heartbreaker role you gave me

The fake claim I made last game was due to circumstance. My scum game is from the shadows.

Well I at least know you prefer scum over town. :P

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I refuse to answer this question. Lynch me if you dare.

Lynching you today is too risky given your claim, and not optimal compared to an AFK lynch anyway, so no. I am just shocked that you have done such an horrible thing. It's as if you had put bananas on a steak.

[BananaCucho]

^^^^^^^^

Soon he's gonna dress all red and sing the Internationale. Light has been playing for a long time, and he's not being listened to. It's pretty much his choice to remain in that "class" of people who aren't being listened to. Also, remember that Mafia is a game of arguing, so if more experienced people argue better than others, well... that's the result, and it's part of the game. It doesn't mean we're bashing new players, it means they're new players.

Classism, plain and simple.

Well I at least know you prefer scum over town. :P

Like everyone else here I have no clue how to scum hunt. Unlike everyone else I just dont pretend that I do.

There's only 1 thing I'm good at as town but I'm not going to say what it is.

[BananaCucho]

Lynching you today is too risky given your claim, and not optimal compared to an AFK lynch anyway, so no. I am just shocked that you have done such an horrible thing. It's as if you had put bananas on a steak.

...what do you put on your steak then, elitist tool?

[BananaCucho]

Okay the "tool" bit was too snarky. I'm sorry I take that back

[BananaCucho]

Elitist marshmellow

[Ganelon]

Interesting

[Light_Yagami]

^^^^^^^^

Soon he's gonna dress all red and sing the Internationale. Light has been playing for a long time, and he's not being listened to. It's pretty much his choice to remain in that "class" of people who aren't being listened to. Also, remember that Mafia is a game of arguing, so if more experienced people argue better than others, well... that's the result, and it's part of the game. It doesn't mean we're bashing new players, it means they're new players.

I Just Hate Arguing If I Can Avoid It To Be Honest. It Honestly Does More Harm Then Good You Get All Pissed Off For Legit No Reason.

[Light_Yagami]

Also I Scum Read MM For Bringing Back Up PPLs Claims I Legit Forgot What Everyones Claims Were Till He Brought It Up Again.

[SuperJack]

Lynching you today is too risky given your claim, and not optimal compared to an AFK lynch anyway, so no. I am just shocked that you have done such an horrible thing. It's as if you had put bananas on a steak.

Dude you just ranted at him for claiming doc now you say he is safe for doing so. You really gonna fall for this crap?

[BananaCucho]

Interesting

I'm never voting you day 1 btw. I wanna see your day 2 input

[BananaCucho]

Dude you just ranted at him for claiming doc now you say he is safe for doing so. You really gonna fall for this crap?

Yes. Yes he is.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Make of all of that what you will

Or continue to attack inexperienced and/or different players for weak arguments or for not conforming to the way you want them to play the game

Fly my banner after I'm gone, remember the name is BANANA and not "bc for breadcrumb"

Spoiler : Banana's flag song :

You're beyond white knighting, you're red knighting atm... Bandiera rossa!!!

Also, Gyrlander never attacked anyone for that, what are you talking about lol?

[SuperJack]

I'm gonna get some food and then ISO MM / The vets. I imagine scum hiding in there.

Unfortunately I'm not sure how many people are actually pressuring the vets besides SJ.

Join me in my vote to hang a banana.

[BananaCucho]

Spoiler : Banana's flag song :

You're beyond white knighting, you're red knighting atm... Bandiera rossa!!!

Also, Gyrlander never attacked anyone for that, what are you talking about lol?

I see there is a misunderstanding here

Post #1184 is being made in general towards everyone in the thread, not Gry

[BananaCucho]

Join me in my vote to hang a banana.

Bananas are low hanging fruit

[SuperJack]

Bananas are low hanging fruit

Your play today is far too wild.

[BananaCucho]

Its funny how easy it is to be town read or scum read on sc2mafia. I could write a playbook on it.

You literally just have to conform to a basic playstyle and not rock the boat, and bada bing bada boom, you're in as townie 4 life

[BananaCucho]

Your play today is far too wild.

I'm an agent of chaos

[BananaCucho]

If I'm spared I will vote for any big dog veteran player to lynch.

I'm a man of my word.

[SuperJack]

I'm an agent of chaos

I am the Wizard of order. Prepare to be organized.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

...what do you put on your steak then, elitist tool?

Marshmallows, of course.

LOOONG LIVE OUR SOVIET MOOOOTHERLAND

I Just Hate Arguing If I Can Avoid It To Be Honest. It Honestly Does More Harm Then Good You Get All Pissed Off For Legit No Reason.

I mean arguing in-game to convince others.

Also I Scum Read MM For Bringing Back Up PPLs Claims I Legit Forgot What Everyones Claims Were Till He Brought It Up Again.

this reasoning is extremely flawed. "Maybe scum would forget about the claims, so talking about them is scummy!" ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

I'm all in for communism, but help yourself please
Also @Ganelon you say Light is scummy by meta atm? That makes my vote even more sticky, since your meta reds on him hold a lot of value.

Dude you just ranted at him for claiming doc now you say he is safe for doing so. You really gonna fall for this crap?

Yep, I am exactly going to fall for that crap. He wanted to keep the WIFOM, and tbh I see this answer as a towny one, because scum claiming to get out of a bad situation would more likely explain than just say "shut up" (at least I think so). It doesn't mean I agree with the move, but it's not lynch worthy at all.

[BananaCucho]

If I'm spared I will vote for any big dog veteran player to lynch.

I'm a man of my word.

Oh except yzb

[Light_Yagami]

Marshmallows, of course.

LOOONG LIVE OUR SOVIET MOOOOTHERLAND

I mean arguing in-game to convince others.

this reasoning is extremely flawed. "Maybe scum would forget about the claims, so talking about them is scummy!" ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

I'm all in for communism, but help yourself please
Also @Ganelon you say Light is scummy by meta atm? That makes my vote even more sticky, since your meta reds on him hold a lot of value.


Yep, I am exactly going to fall for that crap. He wanted to keep the WIFOM, and tbh I see this answer as a towny one, because scum claiming to get out of a bad situation would more likely explain than just say "shut up" (at least I think so). It doesn't mean I agree with the move, but it's not lynch worthy at all.

Yep You Figured Me Out You Got Me.. GG Im The Bad Guy... At This Point Kinda Wish I Really Was The Ba Guy.. Instead Of The Role I Got.. TBH

[BananaCucho]

Marshmallows, of course.

LOOONG LIVE OUR SOVIET MOOOOTHERLAND

I mean arguing in-game to convince others.

this reasoning is extremely flawed. "Maybe scum would forget about the claims, so talking about them is scummy!" ? ? ? ? ? ? ?

I'm all in for communism, but help yourself please
Also @Ganelon you say Light is scummy by meta atm? That makes my vote even more sticky, since your meta reds on him hold a lot of value.


Yep, I am exactly going to fall for that crap. He wanted to keep the WIFOM, and tbh I see this answer as a towny one, because scum claiming to get out of a bad situation would more likely explain than just say "shut up" (at least I think so). It doesn't mean I agree with the move, but it's not lynch worthy at all.

Nobody called out my over-the-top explanations at how Kira was scum last game lol. No clue why.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I see there is a misunderstanding here

Post #1184 is being made in general towards everyone in the thread, not Gry

Ohh ok, I thought it was referring to the post before itself. Nevermind, then, you didn't lie about Gyr, you simply lied about us all

Spoiler : More music related to your words :

Al fascismo sabremos vencer!

Bananas are low hanging fruit

This post is so small yet so good lol. I'm just not so sure it's true, but meh.