Jailor and vigilante

[Yukitaka Oni]

a random shoot vigilante and a random execute jailor, which one you hate more?
- random vigilante?
- random execute (jailor) no matter what you claim?

[DarknessB]

Personally, I think the random Vigilante is worse. At least the Jailor had the chance to talk to you, get your lead, and make a decision that the lead was likely a lie. This partially goes out the window with Night 1 Jailor executions, which are a complete stab in the dark most of the time.

In contrast, Vigilantes should be much more careful about randoming because they could easily walk into a Veteran or attempt to shoot someone being guarded by a Bodyguard, which could result in losing two Town members at the same time.

[Stealthbomber16]

Vigilante because you never know if its a jailor or a kidnapper.

[MattZed]

Vig is worse because they can't kill night-immune scum.

[SparkNuts]

I agree I hate random killing vig more.

[Yukitaka Oni]

Guess this is why 99% people hate vigilante, random shooting like a mafia
Only good thing is his gun evidence is confirmed vigilante, not mafia as least. Execution could be kidnapper but....still, agree that vigilante duty is too high

[SparkNuts]

Vigilante is my fav role but most people are stupid and think you need to use all of your abilities asap.

[DarknessB]

Yup, Vigilante does not mean Town Serial Killer...

Vigilante is my fav role but most people are stupid and think you need to use all of your abilities asap.

[Yukitaka Oni]

Yup, Vigilante does not mean Town Serial Killer...

Bad player make vigilante turn into a town serial killer in (some way)

[lawson]

It is better to never shoot than to shoot every night and help the Mafia win.

[Yukitaka Oni]

It is better to never shoot than to shoot every night and help the Mafia win.

I prefer shoot from the order of marshall or mayor or.......the only confirmed town left...

[DarknessB]

Pretty much -- somehow, the dumbest players in each game always seem to roll Vigi though? Maybe because people with more points are using blacklist / prefer?

It is better to never shoot than to shoot every night and help the Mafia win.