M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread - Page 2
Register

User Tag List

Page 2 of 31 FirstFirst 1 2 3 4 5 6 12 ... LastLast
Results 51 to 100 of 1515
  1. ISO #51

  2. ISO #52

  3. ISO #53

  4. ISO #54

  5. ISO #55

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Your suggestion is based off of the assumption that the joker got detection immunity.

    I believe that he recieved death immunity.
    What would be the point of the arsonist receiving attack immunity over the riddler? The only people who can attack are the mafia and the bodyguard, right? (Excluding the Riddler and the Arsonist themselves)

    Since the mafia don't know who either the arsonist nor the riddler are, and they could be enemies, the smartest idea is to be able to kill the greater threat if needed. Since the mafia, as previously established, are the only real killing force, they need the added maneuverability. The riddler would have a harder time killing the mafia, so he isn't as close to a threat as the Arsonist is. Therefore, a logical mafia would pick the Arsonist as detection immune and the Riddler as attack immune.

  6. ISO #56

  7. ISO #57

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Horse View Post
    What would be the point of the arsonist receiving attack immunity over the riddler? The only people who can attack are the mafia and the bodyguard, right? (Excluding the Riddler and the Arsonist themselves)

    Since the mafia don't know who either the arsonist nor the riddler are, and they could be enemies, the smartest idea is to be able to kill the greater threat if needed. Since the mafia, as previously established, are the only real killing force, they need the added maneuverability. The riddler would have a harder time killing the mafia, so he isn't as close to a threat as the Arsonist is. Therefore, a logical mafia would pick the Arsonist as detection immune and the Riddler as attack immune.
    You have to keep in mind who they want as a potential ally.

    Having the riddler as an ally would be great, however he could betray. Weaking him would be choosing detection immunity, because he can't be seen visiting anyone anyhow.
    Having the Joker as an ally would also be great, but he could betray but it would be harder too. Weaking him would be choosing attack immunity, because he visits and gives feedback.

    The mafia most likely wants them both to be weakened so they can eliminate them should they betray.

  8. ISO #58

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    A little speculation on the Mafia roles.
    Based off of likely-hood of appearance.
    Random Falcone Gangster: Investigative (Gathers information): (Consig, Agent, Mortitan)
    Random Falcone Gangster: Death Manipulative (Manipulates dead player roles): (Janitor, Actress, Tailor)
    Random Falcone Gangster: Manipulative (Manipulates night actions/results): (Drug Dealer, Beguiler, Framer)
    Random Falcone Gangster: Supportive (Supports Mafia in one way or another): (Architect, Consort)

  9. ISO #59

  10. ISO #60

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Town speculation, based off of catagory.


    Batman
    Commissioner Gordon
    Harvey Dent
    Random Town: Defesnvie
    Random Town: Supportive
    Random Town: Defensive
    Random Town: Investigative
    Random Town: Investigative / Supportive / Citizen
    Random Town: Citizen
    Random Town: Citizen
    Random Town: Citizen
    Random Town: Citizen
    Random Town: Citizen

    Defensive (Has the ability to save a player and or themselves): (Doctor, Bodyguard, Bulletproof)
    Supportive (Assists town in different ways): (Architech, Escort)
    Investigative (Helps discover roles): (Sheriff, Detective, Lookout, Coroner)

  11. ISO #61

  12. ISO #62

  13. ISO #63

  14. ISO #64

  15. ISO #65

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Narwhal View Post

    Why is there no Robin?
    An interesting choice for your avatar. Is it hand-drawn? Why choose this one in particular?

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Narwhal View Post

    But our main focus should be finding the riddler. Although he will be hard to find, the easiest way would be to trick him to fail.
    That's some timely advice for the Riddler. Anymore last wills?

  16. ISO #66

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Official Answers

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Can the Architect (Mafia and town version) Put themselves in their nightchat?
    No, Architects of either faction cannot put themself into the nightchat.

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Does Night Immunity affect the Jokers and the Riddlers kill?
    Nope. Burning does not piece immunity, and Riddler's guessing counts as an attack. If a Riddler guesses the role of an immune player, nothing will happen except that I will make a the usual Riddler post when someone dies but no one will die.

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Snake View Post
    It says that the Joker's does not pierce immunity, however, it doesn't specify in the Riddler's rolecard..

    Does the riddler's kill pierce immunity?
    If so, it may be much more likely that the Joker has immunity, since it would allow them to kill eachother and force them to side with the mafia.
    Sorry, I'll add it to clarify. Riddler does not piece immunty.

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Llama View Post
    Are we informed if the godfather dies?
    Yes, the Godfather will appear as Name Role (Godfather) in graveyard.

  17. ISO #67

  18. ISO #68

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Hi, I came on to read up and post in the morning before school.

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Armadillo View Post
    Just in for the moment. I got doused and witched last night. I will be on later, but gotta go.
    Dangit for my name starting with an A.
    You sir... are probably dead. But hey, dat witch tho.


    I personally think the Mafia is a bigger threat then the Joker/Riddler alone, however in the case we know who one of the two (Joker/Riddler) are and a Mafia I would lynch the neutral first without a second thought due to the extra KPN(Joker) and the inability for us to claim(Riddler) being bigger problems to us.

    In the event we have to choose between lynching one and saving the other for the next day, I would lynch the Joker first in order to stop the inevitable Kill he would bring out if we waited a day.

    Alright, going to school now, I'll see you guys in a bit.

  19. ISO #69

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    So, wanted to check in also, nothing happened to me last night.

    To that I believe the riddler is the biggest threat, since he makes us incapable of using clues and roleclaims as earlier stated from a few others too.
    On the other hand that only plays a role, if we find someone and if the riddler is already dead, since we cant share anything with him being alive.
    (Exception is here Batman, who can talk to ppl at night and is immune to the Riddler)

  20. ISO #70

  21. ISO #71

  22. ISO #72

  23. ISO #73

  24. ISO #74

  25. ISO #75

  26. ISO #76

  27. ISO #77

  28. ISO #78

  29. ISO #79

  30. ISO #80

  31. ISO #81

  32. ISO #82

  33. ISO #83

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Moose View Post
    Trying to shift the attention from MFM Narwhal to MFM Armadillo by burning MFM Horse?
    All we know right now is that Armadillo was not doused, and that we are down a player.

    We need to find out why the joker did that. He could of waited and have any information horse had die with him...

    It does seem like drawing attention was the motive.

  34. ISO #84

  35. ISO #85

  36. ISO #86

  37. ISO #87

  38. ISO #88

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Hi. First of all chances are I will not be able to get an avatar due to my iPad being god awful and my computer being the same, what a joy.
    Secondly, chances are to me, Armadillo was drugged doused. If this is the case, we know he was witched for real, which reveals our Neutral. If Armadillo really was Joker why would he light Day 1 after faking doused anyway? Setup by the real Joker much.

    Unless of course, there is no Drug Dealer and he is lying about being doused altogether to play it off as Drug Dealer, possibly. Maybe even both of his claims are lies.
    My apologies for having to speak the obvious, for that I am a criminal of. Frog seems a bit too jumpy voting however.

    @Moose: I believe it has something to do with them going invisible. To lurk? I don't see why any Town would want to go invisible.

    just want to put it out there that I'll try my best to juggle my school work and try to post a little more. On the weekends are my best times. see ya for a bit

  39. ISO #89

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Dudes watching me like a moose. Jealous of my might Tusk with my ability to turn invisible.

    Honestly, I'm invisible because sometimes I can read but I'm unable to reply, and don't wish to be accused of lurking because they see me online. I shall not be lurking.

    But to try and change topic so soon from the burn to me, which moose alone was targeting is a.bit silly. But I'm up for the attention.

    Remember that the douse claimed also claimed witches right after I posted about hoping there isn't a witch in the game.

    Atleast there is a chance that there is a coroner to check the dead.

  40. ISO #90

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    -vote MFM Armadillo


    The chances that you were both drugged and witched are extremely low. Not to mention, dousing is an awful choice for first drug deal, since it pretty much immediately reveals the presence of a drug dealer. My thought is, this claim was meant to alert us to a drug dealer which doesn't actually exist, like Beaver suggested.

  41. ISO #91

  42. ISO #92

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    While the doused claim was obviously drugged or fake, I could see why the Jester would drug a witch feedback, so that players would be lead to believe that the neutral was a Witch. Though, the Drug Dealer could also be faking witch feedback...

    I don't think we should jump to conclusions saying that Armadillo is scum, but he is the only person who has caught my attention so far.

  43. ISO #93

  44. ISO #94

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    I'm back and it looked like I was drugged.

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Zebra View Post
    -vote MFM Armadillo


    The chances that you were both drugged and witched are extremely low. Not to mention, dousing is an awful choice for first drug deal, since it pretty much immediately reveals the presence of a drug dealer. My thought is, this claim was meant to alert us to a drug dealer which doesn't actually exist, like Beaver suggested.
    Also if it is a night 1 why is it super low that I would get targeted? There is no information and I am at the top of list with the only A name. I just know that the douse was for sure a drug deal or a jester fake. I don't know about the witching though.

  45. ISO #95

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Armadillo View Post
    I'm back and it looked like I was drugged.



    Also if it is a night 1 why is it super low that I would get targeted? There is no information and I am at the top of list with the only A name. I just know that the douse was for sure a drug deal or a jester fake. I don't know about the witching though.
    There are only a handful of feedback giving roles, probably something around 5 in this game (Joker, Rand Neutral, mafia support, mafia kill, maybe an escort). It just seems unlikely that out of 20 players, one would get two feedbacks the very first name.

    Also "Armadillo is at the top of the list" seems like a non-excuse to me

  46. ISO #96

  47. ISO #97

  48. ISO #98

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Well, yeah don´t have anythign important to add atm, thought why are we voting the lama now? Cant really understand the logic behind it.

    What Armadillo belongs we can just make random guesses atm, but its sure that the douse was a fake and
    I also think the Joker wanted to show that with his early ignite. What exactly he gains from that is hidden for me thought.

    And I assume the vote on Moose is just Day1 trolling? Doesnt see a reason for him either atm.

  49. ISO #99

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Frog View Post
    That double post was totally unnecessary.

    P.S. I have satisfied my quota of useful posts for day 1. You may not see me again until day 2.
    Yes indeed you have been super useful, Frog. You also seem the tiniest bit confident you will make it to Day 2, how come?

    To be honest, I think Armadillo is actually becoming our best bet. After thinking it over, it does seem very unlikely that he would get both a doused and witched notification, even if he turns town it does give us information to the fact we confirm a Drug Dealer and Witch/Jester, and if he is scum then.. well that is self explanatory.

    Plus, his excuse of being first on the list is petty and seems nothing more than an excuse to get this away from him. Who knows though, it all might be true. But we'll never know unless we act on it.
    xo. I'm going to sleep now. See ya'll when I wake up and skim over what has been said! Have fun.

  50. ISO #100

    Re: M-FM Batman [Gamethread]

    Quote Originally Posted by MFM Beaver View Post
    Yes indeed you have been super useful, Frog. You also seem the tiniest bit confident you will make it to Day 2, how come?

    To be honest, I think Armadillo is actually becoming our best bet. After thinking it over, it does seem very unlikely that he would get both a doused and witched notification, even if he turns town it does give us information to the fact we confirm a Drug Dealer and Witch/Jester, and if he is scum then.. well that is self explanatory.

    Plus, his excuse of being first on the list is petty and seems nothing more than an excuse to get this away from him. Who knows though, it all might be true. But we'll never know unless we act on it.
    xo. I'm going to sleep now. See ya'll when I wake up and skim over what has been said! Have fun.
    What am I supposed to say though? The game started night 1 without information from a day chat. Do you have any logical explanation why I was chosen to get doused and witched? Everything was random and chances are I got doused and witched because I was at the top of the list. I can't defend myself because there isn't a reason as to why I would get chosen yet based on what we know. Just wait a night so maybe we can figure out some more stuff based on newer feedback.

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •