Register

User Tag List

View Poll Results: What Role do you Want?

Voters
60. You may not vote on this poll
  • Armorsmith

    4 6.67%
  • Crier

    18 30.00%
  • Enchantress

    7 11.67%
  • Marshall

    18 30.00%
  • Architect

    10 16.67%
  • Hunter/Snitch

    1 1.67%
  • Timestopper

    2 3.33%
Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 51 to 100 of 126
  1. ISO #51

  2. ISO #52

  3. ISO #53

  4. ISO #54

  5. ISO #55

  6. ISO #56

  7. ISO #57

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by creedkingsx View Post
    Oh god, why is Crier winning?
    It looks like some people who voted Hunter/Snitch first unvoted and put their vote on Crier.
    [FMVI: Angel FMVIII: Gunsmith FMIX: Peasant FMX: Blacksmith
    MFM-I: Serial Killer MFM-II: Citizen MFM-III: Detective MFM-IV: Godfather/Witch MFM-V: Emperor MFM-VI:Host
    SFM-I: Spy SFM-II: Bandit SFM-III: Host SFM-VI: Skeleton Knight
    Awards: MFM-IV MVP SFM-VI MVP]

  8. ISO #58

  9. ISO #59

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Heh seems like crier gets trolled into the game GeGe! xD
    Pls make sure to reveal after the end of the votings who voted for what. :P
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  10. ISO #60

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    i wish we could vote for as many as we want, but only once per. that form of voting is way more fair. you get a view of what most people like, rather than trying to manipulate 2 of your favorite roles into the game.

    FM XVII: Bonney Jewelry (Journalist)
    FM XVIII: Kalou (Savage Godfather)
    FM XX: Joseph Bertrand (Marshall)
    FM XXI: USA (Escort)
    FM XV: Whiskey (Whore)

  11. ISO #61

  12. ISO #62

  13. ISO #63

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I would certainly against rep vote, someone periodically cut my rep for none sense.

    Which means, the higher rep people can always overpower power newer or less rep people.

    Joke or not, I dislike it and I do not support it.

    Quote Originally Posted by Boss View Post
    i wish we could vote for as many as we want, but only once per. that form of voting is way more fair. you get a view of what most people like, rather than trying to manipulate 2 of your favorite roles into the game.
    Same here,

    Not saying crier doesn't deserve that many votes but rather other roles deserve more votes.

    It is currently at winner take all plus one vote only system.
    Last edited by louiswill; April 10th, 2013 at 04:37 PM.
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  14. ISO #64

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Wha... What is this. WHY IS EVERYTHING BLUE.
    There is so much stuff to read! I'm like a kid in a candy store~
    (But really; I would love to see the Enchantress in Sc2Mafia.)

    Be right back, reading all those threads. Eeee~
    Spoiler : FM History :
    FMs: XIV, XV, XVI, XVII, XVII, XVIII, XIX, XX, XXI
    MFMs: XIII, XIV, XVI, XVII, XVIII, XIX, XXI, XXII
    SFMs: Too many.
    SFM Night 1 Death Percentage: 72%
    Hosted: SFM 89, SFM 118

  15. ISO #65

  16. ISO #66

  17. ISO #67

  18. ISO #68

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by MintBerry Crunch View Post
    Enchantress voters please join Marshall, Crier dum that is all.
    Crier voters should join enchantress, then all problems are solved
    [FMVI: Angel FMVIII: Gunsmith FMIX: Peasant FMX: Blacksmith
    MFM-I: Serial Killer MFM-II: Citizen MFM-III: Detective MFM-IV: Godfather/Witch MFM-V: Emperor MFM-VI:Host
    SFM-I: Spy SFM-II: Bandit SFM-III: Host SFM-VI: Skeleton Knight
    Awards: MFM-IV MVP SFM-VI MVP]

  19. ISO #69

  20. ISO #70

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    But i c no cool roles at all :/
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  21. ISO #71

  22. ISO #72

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    And i tried.. OH MY GOD DID I TRY!
    Spoiler : fm history :
    FM 6: Commoner/Legionare(roman)/Legionare(Sin) FM8: Stan Investigator FM9:Yakov German(Sapper) FM10: Fm Rumpel Vigilante FM11: Renekton: Serial Killer FM12: Sandor: citizen = scum FM13: Wicket : Devourer FM14: Torynn: Andrew Ryan (GF)

  23. ISO #73

  24. ISO #74

  25. ISO #75

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    If new roles requires at least 3 or 4 back uper to get in the list, so be it. Crier all the way...
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  26. ISO #76

  27. ISO #77

  28. ISO #78

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by MintBerry Crunch View Post
    I was hunter but switched to Marshall, why does everyone keep saying crier?
    cause they're CRYING out loud?

    joke aside... can't we at least think of new name? Crier sound weird to me... maybe Rabioman? Broadcaster? i mean if we think of the cry-ability as a radio broadcast

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  29. ISO #79

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Deantwo View Post
    cause they're CRYING out loud?

    joke aside... can't we at least think of new name? Crier sound weird to me... maybe Rabioman? Broadcaster? i mean if we think of the cry-ability as a radio broadcast
    Night Radio Host
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  30. ISO #80

  31. ISO #81

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I'm switching my vote from architect to marshall if the vote count on crier doesn't lower...
    I don't think crier will work, especially in SC2mafia.
    Someone's gonna use it for trolling. You know it.

    Spoiler : :
    FM XIV - Rapture : Denizen
    FM XV - Star Wars : Citizen
    FM XIV - FuzzyWuzzyTown : Doctor

  32. ISO #82

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Mugy7 View Post
    I'm switching my vote from architect to marshall if the vote count on crier doesn't lower...
    I don't think crier will work, especially in SC2mafia.
    Someone's gonna use it for trolling. You know it.
    all roles can be used for trolling... if we say no to a role just cause some people will use it to troll... we can remove about half the roles in the game...

    maybe i like the idea of the Crier cause i don't always get to follow the day chat to much... and having someone tell you the highlights of the day doing the lonely night would be nice ^^;

    but out of all the roles in this poll... i still like the Crier best...

    still think a Town role that can protect people from being lynched at day would be more interesting... a kind of Lawyer? it's been suggested a million times...

    Crier would only be really ok if Jester got the same ability
    Last edited by Deantwo; April 11th, 2013 at 02:11 AM.

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  33. ISO #83

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Mugy7 View Post
    I'm switching my vote from architect to marshall if the vote count on crier doesn't lower...
    I don't think crier will work, especially in SC2mafia.
    Someone's gonna use it for trolling. You know it.
    switch to architect. :P
    Marshall is winning now, architect would be tied.

  34. ISO #84

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    i don't think this kind of poll is a good idea, there will be 2 new roles but everyone has only one vote. that means that you only can influence what one of the roles will be. now everyone checks the current votes and then places his vote according to it to influence the poll. better would be 2 polls, the second starts after the first role is clear. or let everyone vote for 2 roles. in such a fair poll crier would probably not win

  35. ISO #85

  36. ISO #86

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Nick View Post
    When is the poll ending. Wolfram alpha please.

    I WANT TO MAKE THE CRIER VOTERS CRY!!!
    change your settings so the website is in your timezone then look at the poll lol

    Quote Originally Posted by S-FM Blue Masquerader View Post
    Hey moron. shut the fuck up or I will shut you up, k? I'm not the person your going to insult and live happily ever after. K? Understand that,

  37. ISO #87

  38. ISO #88

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    even though crier can be trolling, it is still less trolling than hunter.

    Crier at least doesn't kill directly and suicide.

    I think hunter is a legit role so that I think crier is too.

    The problem is that, who can stop crier in the game? Time to let jester own his own radio station! some talk show stuff..
    When we talked about pubs, we are talking about us.
    When they talked about pubs, they exclude themselves.
    They say only bad players want to modify citizens, and they do not satisfy bad players.
    Are we bad players? We include bad players, but that is just a part of us.
    ---They put veteran, mayor, allowed jester to visit for nothing, and they regretted and say those things are brainless.

  39. ISO #89

  40. ISO #90

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by louiswill View Post
    even though crier can be trolling, it is still less trolling than hunter.

    Crier at least doesn't kill directly and suicide.

    I think hunter is a legit role so that I think crier is too.

    The problem is that, who can stop crier in the game? Time to let jester own his own radio station! some talk show stuff..
    nah
    This is a poll for 2 new roles, not new roles and changes to other roles.
    If you don't like the role, as you so clearly state by suggesting further changes need be made, then you shouldn't vote for it.

  41. ISO #91

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    I think Town Crier is potentially just too powerful if he's speaking only to town at night. All he has to do to is say "If you're a town PM X 'this specific phrase' tomorrow" where X is his #/color/name.

    On the other hand, if he's not talking to just town then I feel like it's a pretty bad role. All he's good for is revealing who is he as a town and I feel like the ability would lead to annoying abuse by players much more often than other abilities.
    Last edited by Bergtau; April 11th, 2013 at 11:43 AM.

  42. ISO #92

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Bergtau View Post
    I think Town Crier is potentially just too powerful if he's speaking only to town at night. All he has to do to is say "If you're a town PM X 'this specific phrase' tomorrow" where X is his #/color/name.

    On the other hand, if he's not talking to just town then I feel like it's a pretty bad role. All he's good for is revealing who is he as a town and I feel like the ability would lead to annoying abuse by players much more often than other abilities.
    Quote Originally Posted by Deantwo View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by Elixir View Post
    when it says "entire town" it's meant as "EVERYONE IN GAME" not just Townies... it's a common thing to confuse...
    ...

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  43. ISO #93

  44. ISO #94

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Bergtau View Post
    I was commenting on the two possibilities that this role could have. If it was deemed to be too weak with speaking to everybody then the next step would be limiting who he was speaking to.
    ah ^^;

    but yeah... making it so only TOWNIES could hear him would be very very overpowered...

    i still don't see the issues people complain about... maybe it'd because all the setups i see have PMs disabled

    then that only leave trolling as a reason... and that reason alone is silly... if someone wanna troll they can do that with ANY role
    Last edited by Deantwo; April 11th, 2013 at 12:45 PM.

    Wiki User: Deantwo

    the SC2Mafia Wiki is my playground!
    Spoiler : FM History :


    FM18: Bushwalter (Drug Dealer)

  45. ISO #95

  46. ISO #96

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread

    Quote Originally Posted by Bergtau View Post
    I was commenting on the two possibilities that this role could have. If it was deemed to be too weak with speaking to everybody then the next step would be limiting who he was speaking to.
    It wouldn't be deemed too weak.
    I've literally no idea where you would have gotten the idea that we would ever allow a singular role to only talk to town roles and night.


    3-way tie

  47. ISO #97

  48. ISO #98

    Re: Commisioned Town Roles Voting Thread


    Yayap reads list, sees only PRs listed, where is the most important role? Citizen?
    I'd like to see millers added.. aka Cits that appear evil to investigations but thinks he is a cit.

    Out of those roles listed, I'd have to go with armorsmith for balance/mechanics reasons... however, I would add the hunter/snitch ability to Spy and remove the reading of PMs power to make spy more balanced and it fits well with the rp.

  49. ISO #99

  50. ISO #100

 

 

Similar Threads

  1. New Town Roles Discussion Thread
    By Sinclair in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 20
    Last Post: April 24th, 2013, 08:26 AM
  2. Too lazy to do it myself (voting roles)
    By FireTruK in forum Mafia Discussion
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: February 26th, 2012, 02:25 AM
  3. Recruitment Voting Thread
    By monster in forum Forum Mafia II
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: August 10th, 2011, 05:48 AM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •