S-FM: Prelude

[Fatalis]

This is kinda the most anti climatic ending ever

Which I am kinda sad of given the fact of how exciting this whole game have been

[Fatalis]

I guess this is what happens when the kewl players are killed first

[Fatalis]

And here I am talking to myself

[Glip]

This game was super active up until the point clem was killed :P

Coincidence? I think not.

[Apocist]

Really...? What did he do?

And Fatalis, you already lost, you surrendered and can't just change things because it starts to go your way because of it.

Need a response from Glip

[Fatalis]

Really...? What did he do?

And Fatalis, you already lost, you surrendered and can't just change things because it starts to go your way because of it.

Need a response from Glip

If Glip says I can't unsurrender than it's fine, but I don't think surrender is a command anyway
Hey it's not my fault that Rofl posted his entire jail chat >.>

[BorkBot]

vote Fatalis

Chane probably got culted, because he can prevent culting.

Mason leader gets replaced, so you can still bludgeon the cult.

We should still be able to lynch assuming one other PR is left unculted (2 masons + 2 PRs vs 2 cult and a jester = majority of 4v3). As long as the PRs don't gamethrow and we lynch OR bludgeon a cultist every day, the cult still can't win. Not surrendering really only serves to force a loss on more players.

Does masonbludgeon stop a cultist from converting anyone else to the cult?

[Apocist]

-vote Fatalis

Well...guess we are still in this game, we can at least try

[AppleyNO]

-Vote Fatalis

Die lesser being!

[Fatalis]

fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu

[Fatalis]

MY CULT FRIEND, RECRUIT ALL THE TOWN BEFORE YOU DIE.. THEY DO NOT DESERVE TO WIN
MWAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[Fatalis]

Mason leader just seems 9000 times more op when mafia is gone

[Fatalis]

vote Fatalis

Chane probably got culted, because he can prevent culting.

Mason leader gets replaced, so you can still bludgeon the cult.

We should still be able to lynch assuming one other PR is left unculted (2 masons + 2 PRs vs 2 cult and a jester = majority of 4v3). As long as the PRs don't gamethrow and we lynch OR bludgeon a cultist every day, the cult still can't win. Not surrendering really only serves to force a loss on more players.

Does masonbludgeon stop a cultist from converting anyone else to the cult?

it's -vote instead of vote derp

[Fatalis]

Am I hammered?

[Fatalis]

I think I am ! MWAHAHHAAHHAHAAHAHAHMWAWMAWMAWMAWMAMWAMWAWMAW
THANK YOU SO MUCH BORKBOT CMG APPLEYNO AND CHANE THE CULTISTS

[BorkBot]

Appley, who did you follow last night?

[Chane]

lamo I am not cult

but fatalis you are a fucking faggot for surrendering and unsurrendering like a little bitch.

-vote fatalis just in case, although I would like a cult win i am not gonna throw.

[CmG]

Lol.

[CmG]

@Fatalis: Go play minesweeper! So bad. Lol!

[CmG]

-vote Fatalis


I really tried to give you guys a realistic shot to win this but apparently it seems to hard to recruit a confirmed doctor or the mason recruit from last night. Did u try to recruit Apocist last night? Or what happened?

Unbelievably stupid. =)

[CmG]

I was Executioner turned into Jester when AppleyNO was culted.

Glip thought i am pro so he decided to let me know that i turned into a jester the next day. How nice of him!

So bad!

Smite AppleyNO tonight and this farce is finaly over!


GG no RE

[Chane]

-vote fatalis

forgot coloring

[Apocist]

My questions were still not answered....been waiting for hours..

Did Fatalis surrender?

[straykiwi]

*facepalm* roflcopter....

[Glip]

I was Executioner turned into Jester when AppleyNO was culted.

Glip thought i am pro so he decided to let me know that i turned into a jester the next day. How nice of him!

So bad!

Smite AppleyNO tonight and this farce is finaly over!


GG no RE

Not quite true.

I can quote you the PM I sent you the day of (albeit in the middle, not at the beginning) that states word for word "You are a Jester now."

[Glip]

Really...? What did he do?

And Fatalis, you already lost, you surrendered and can't just change things because it starts to go your way because of it.

Need a response from Glip

He quoted his jail chat.

[Glip]

My questions were still not answered....been waiting for hours..

Did Fatalis surrender?

A surrender for the cult would have required a majority vote from all living cultists in order to pass.

No such majority was obtained.

[Glip]

Also, the day has ended. I'll count up the votes and see for sure if a lynch occurred.

[Glip]

vote Fatalis

Chane probably got culted, because he can prevent culting.

Mason leader gets replaced, so you can still bludgeon the cult.

We should still be able to lynch assuming one other PR is left unculted (2 masons + 2 PRs vs 2 cult and a jester = majority of 4v3). As long as the PRs don't gamethrow and we lynch OR bludgeon a cultist every day, the cult still can't win. Not surrendering really only serves to force a loss on more players.

Does masonbludgeon stop a cultist from converting anyone else to the cult?

If the cultist that is sent to recruit that night is killed by any means, whether it be mason bludgeoning, vigi shot, maf kill, etc., the conversion will not go through.

[Glip]

Twilight of the Fifth Night



Fatalis was lynched! He was the Cult Leader!

Spoiler : Player List :

1. clementine
2. AppleyNO
3. Jr4life24
4. Fatalis
5. Dust
6. Damus_Graves
7. Chane
8. Espozito
9. CmG
10. BorkBot
11. Roflcopter
12. Apocist
13. straykiwi

Spoiler : Graveyard :

1. Damus_Graves, Mason Leader (Killed by Mafia on Night 1)
2. Jr4life24, Consort (Lynched on Day 2)
3. Espozito, Consigliere (Lynched on Day 3)
4. clementine, Jailor (Killed by Mafia on Night 3)
5. Dust, Godfather (Lynched on Day 4)
6. Roflcopter, Mason Leader (Modkilled on Day 5)
7. Fatalis, Cult Leader (Lynched on Day 5)

Night will end when all night actions have been submitted.

[BorkBot]

Resurrected for epic epilogue.

[Glip]

Well, I dunno about epic, but there will be an epilogue.

I am currently working on it as we speak. Time to think up some fancy badge designs for the awards.

[Roflcopter]

so can we have a post saying we won now?

[Glip]

so can we have a post saying we won now?

Hold your horses, bro, I'm working on it. I'm trying to fancy up the awards and it's taking some time

[Glip]

Epilogue

It is highly recommended you listen to the following song in its entirety. If you've ever played a videogame, and are over 12 years old, you will enjoy it.



AppleyNo was found dead. He was the Cult Leader!

THE TOWN HAS WON!

Night Chats: https://fmnc.forumotion.com/

Night Actions/Player and Role List:



Okay, so this game got completely screwed for scum when I decided to extend day and allowed Jr4life24 to get lynched. That shouldn't have happened. I apologize. It would appear that the only part of hosting this game that didn't completely fail were the night chats, which had been the only thing I was actually worried about. Well, perhaps this experience will be helpful in making sure my future endeavours aren't quite as much fail. With more analysis, I realize that giving the masons both unlimited recruitings and the ability to prevent cult conversions was just insanely overpowered against the cult, and screwed over any chance that the cult ever may have had. I was worried about cult being too OP what with being able to convert every night, but ironically, they were only ever able to recruit once, and even then only thanks to a slight bending of the rules by me to allow AppleyNO's conversion even when he had a doc to him. Chane's actions this game were insanely lucky this game. He targeted the same person as the cult almost every night, preventing two conversions and one kill. And that brings us to the awards...

Awards



Chane's night actions here single-handedly saved the town from the cult and the mafia. No other person had such unparalleled success with their night actions. I see the Most Valuable Player award as an award that designates the person who had the greatest influence on the outcome of the game. Aside from me with my fail hosting, that person would undoubtedly be Chane. That is why he gets MVP.



Fatalis would have been MVP if it wasn't for Chane stopping all the conversions. His ploy of coming out as Arsonist to get jailed allowed both his fellow cultist to go convert (although the conversion was wasted) and the mafia to get off another kill. This was the best scum play in the game.



This was actually pointed out by BorkBot. Almost the entire town was WIFOMing their arses off this entire game. No one wanted to reveal their actual role ('cept for poor AppleyNO). Chane the Veteran? Clementine the second Detective?!? BorkBot the citizen/cult leader/executioner/jester/wtf?!?!? Maybe this kept the scum guessing and allowed town to win. Maybe town just won because of my allowing Jr4life24 to get lynched by extending day. Either way, it was an odd enough occurrence to merit an award. I ended up removing Fatalis from this because I decided it should be a Town-exclusive award. Sorry bro.

Player's Choice - ??????

Vote for whoever you think played the best this game, or for whoever you like the best. It can be completely arbitrary. If enough people actually vote for a player's choice, I'll make an award like the others for the winner.

[Roflcopter]

Nice epilogue, I thought I did good enough for an award though

Except I actually forgot what I did since it was like a week ago >.>

[Glip]

Nice epilogue, I thought I did good enough for an award though

Except I actually forgot what I did since it was like a week ago >.>

I considered adding you in to the WIFOMville award. But you didn't really do any lying about your role as the others did. You just withheld the knowledge of there being a jailor.

What you did: Recruited both citizens and found the GF by disproving his cit claim when you tried to recruit him. While that was well-played, it didn't change the outcome of the game nearly as much as Chane's prevented conversions did.

Consider the above an "Honorable Mentions" award :P

[clementine]

Player's choice:
-vote CmG for siding with the town and exposing AppleyNO as a cultist. :]

[AppleyNO]

My god this game.

Just no.

Good Game everyone. I see Chane gets his 3rd or 4th MVP, Good Job dude!

[Roflcopter]

I considered adding you in to the WIFOMville award. But you didn't really do any lying about your role as the others did. You just withheld the knowledge of there being a jailor.

What you did: Recruited both citizens and found the GF by disproving his cit claim when you tried to recruit him. While that was well-played, it didn't change the outcome of the game nearly as much as Chane's prevented conversions did.

Consider the above an "Honorable Mentions" award :P

I could get the "Straight up mason leader" award!

[AppleyNO]

Or


-Vote Rolfcopter

[Damus_Graves]

[Fatalis]

1st recruit- Prevented by Chane
3rd recruit- Clem is immune to recruits
4th recruit- Prevented by Chane

Even the only succesful recruit was targeted by Chane, if the mafia hadn't attacked appleyno Chane would have prevented it again. GG WP though, time to put in a new sig!

[Fatalis]

-vote CmG For trying to help scum

[BorkBot]

Lol, those night chats were all so dead!

Mafia inactive + all lynched one by one, masons and cultists getting jailed the first nights they actually had 2 members

I don't know who to vote for player's choice

Chane was obviously the best player in this game though, hands down. His WIFOM was correct and easy to read, while just deterring scum just enough. He made the right reads in day chat while laying low and looking like a sheep, and had great night actions too. But he already got MVP so I can't vote him.

Roflcopter's night actions were good, but he was confused in day chat and didn't do much in terms of analysis and town leadership. If it wasn't for Glip extending day 1, his unvoting on Jr4life24 could've been fatal. Not much coordination in their night chat either, even when multiple players were present.

Clementine's WIFOM worked for her role, but in a small game like this it could have resulted in our doom if we had been competing for that town investigative slot any longer. In the end her jailing me and dropping some hints (intentional or by accident, I'm not sure) helped me fill in the last few blank townie slots on the starting roles list with only CmG and Fatalis as interchangeable benign/evil neutral. So her play definitely helped our win in the end because I knew which people had to be mafia without even checking them and people like Chane would fuel my trains because they guessed I was probably a sheriff. Her false claim also resulted in a failed culting because she was immune. I don't know if she did what she did for the right reasons (I actually think she didn't), but it worked..

So I'll vote Clementine

[Fatalis]

Lol, those night chats were all so dead!

Mafia inactive + all lynched one by one, masons and cultists getting jailed the first nights they actually had 2 members

I don't know who to vote for player's choice

Chane was obviously the best player in this game though, hands down. His WIFOM was correct and easy to read, while just deterring scum just enough. He made the right reads in day chat while laying low and looking like a sheep, and had great night actions too. But he already got MVP so I can't vote him.

Roflcopter's night actions were good, but he was confused in day chat and didn't do much in terms of analysis and town leadership. If it wasn't for Glip extending day 1, his unvoting on Jr4life24 could've been fatal. Not much coordination in their night chat either, even when multiple players were present.

Clementine's WIFOM worked for her role, but in a small game like this it could have resulted in our doom if we had been competing for that town investigative slot any longer. In the end her jailing me and dropping some hints (intentional or by accident, I'm not sure) helped me fill in the last few blank townie slots on the starting roles list with only CmG and Fatalis as interchangeable benign/evil neutral. So her play definitely helped our win in the end because I knew which people had to be mafia without even checking them and people like Chane would fuel my trains because they guessed I was probably a sheriff. Her false claim also resulted in a failed culting because she was immune. I don't know if she did what she did for the right reasons (I actually think she didn't), but it worked..

So I'll vote Clementine

Yeah, Clem was the best town player next to Chane. Clem was very active in the day chat and figured out some scum.

It's super difficult to actually beat a Mason leader who had 2 members by day 3, I kinda blame Mafia for not trying enough. Jr4life was an obvious scum, I felt like Ezpo and Dust can have survive at least 1 more night, but Ezpo revealed his role unnecessarily and Dust didn't try that hard

[BorkBot]

Espozito tried to WIFOM jester, but it wasn't possible with CmG and you taking up the neutral slots

And his response to the Jr4life24 lynch was fishy as heck.

[Apocist]

Gotta say, I wasn't very active in this one. I felt so disconnected.

[Chane]

I must say I didn't expect MVP, I didn't get any notifications that I stopped cultist convertion but I find it funny that without appleyNO's rule bending I hit the cult every time.

I followed my gut and thought I was doing horribly because I got no results :P

-vote borkbot for taking town leader slot and amusing me with his wifom. a tad bit to cocky though.

and Fatalis, sr bro :P

[Glip]

I'ma close this so BorkBot can go ahead and clean up the ongoing games.

If anyone still wants to vote for a Player's Choice, you can PM me your vote. Otherwise, there will be no winner.

In the event someone actually does win the Player's Choice award, I will pm them the award.