April 17th, 2017, 01:25 PM
[QUOTE=gftgy;684598]You're really not being fair to me here, saying that I should have acted in a very specific manner to achieve a very specific result through a very specific set of circumstances where any number of things can (and did) go wrong.[/QUOTE]
While I get your point, it would be a stretch to say that giving a role and last will while on defense is some sort of very specific defense.
Originally Posted by
gftgy
You're really not being fair to me here, saying that I should have acted in a very specific manner to achieve a very specific result through a very specific set of circumstances where any number of things can (and did) go wrong.
While I get your point, it would be a stretch to say that giving a role and last will while on defense is some sort of very specific defense.
April 17th, 2017, 12:49 AM
[QUOTE=gftgy;684591]If I reveal as a doctor, the other two protective roles will be doubtful, and if either speak up that they themselves are protective roles, I am certainly doomed. Furthermore, as far as I know, a Judge is fairly likely as there have been no kills from the evil, no audits, and cult is incredibly unlikely, potentially resulting my myself being courted as soon as I reveal as town. Furthermore, even if I survive my trial, I can expect to be promptly murdered at night after revealing as a doctor.[/QUOTE]
I operate on the basis that the role and last will should be the FIRST thing somebody offers when they are voted up. Your reasons for not providing it are stretches at best.
To your first point, if only one prot spoke up, you can claim second prot. If two prots speak up, you can claim town random.
To your second point, surviving trial and getting killed at night is MUCH better then getting lynched, and somebody else getting killed at night.
Furthermore, it was clear there was a split between you and 8. Clearly either the evils were driving attention away from themselves by lynching the demon, or the evils were trying to protect their fellow mafia (8). If you were to claim doc and get voted innocent, I as a lookout would have a good chance of finding a killer if I was to watch you the following night. As such, I would likely have voted innocent.
Basically, by not giving your role and LW you made me sure that it was the evils trying to waste the town's time by lynching the demon.
EDIT: [QUOTE=gftgy;684591]If [COLOR="#800080"]coffeeclubbr[/COLOR] had voted innocent with the rest of the (present) [COLOR="#00FF00"]town[/COLOR], I would have been saved, and the town potentially victorious. [COLOR="#FFD700"]Considering that theirs was literally the only deciding vote, as all other evils were naturally voting guilty, this report is tainted by a clear conflict of interest.[/COLOR][/QUOTE]
This logic is somewhat in reverse. The lack of a "normal" defense while you were on trial ultimately lead me to vote guilty, so any conflict-of-interest (which I don't believe there is as the report is independently reviewed) would be created by your actions.
Originally Posted by
gftgy
If I reveal as a doctor, the other two protective roles will be doubtful, and if either speak up that they themselves are protective roles, I am certainly doomed. Furthermore, as far as I know, a Judge is fairly likely as there have been no kills from the evil, no audits, and cult is incredibly unlikely, potentially resulting my myself being courted as soon as I reveal as town. Furthermore, even if I survive my trial, I can expect to be promptly murdered at night after revealing as a doctor.
I operate on the basis that the role and last will should be the FIRST thing somebody offers when they are voted up. Your reasons for not providing it are stretches at best.
To your first point, if only one prot spoke up, you can claim second prot. If two prots speak up, you can claim town random.
To your second point, surviving trial and getting killed at night is MUCH better then getting lynched, and somebody else getting killed at night.
Furthermore, it was clear there was a split between you and 8. Clearly either the evils were driving attention away from themselves by lynching the demon, or the evils were trying to protect their fellow mafia (. If you were to claim doc and get voted innocent, I as a lookout would have a good chance of finding a killer if I was to watch you the following night. As such, I would likely have voted innocent.
Basically, by not giving your role and LW you made me sure that it was the evils trying to waste the town's time by lynching the demon.
EDIT:
Originally Posted by
gftgy
If coffeeclubbr had voted innocent with the rest of the (present) town, I would have been saved, and the town potentially victorious. Considering that theirs was literally the only deciding vote, as all other evils were naturally voting guilty, this report is tainted by a clear conflict of interest.
This logic is somewhat in reverse. The lack of a "normal" defense while you were on trial ultimately lead me to vote guilty, so any conflict-of-interest (which I don't believe there is as the report is independently reviewed) would be created by your actions.
April 17th, 2017, 12:26 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] OmegaWeapon
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-3010347
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Zanebono Lombardi
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Revealed as mayor day 6 and left
Account Name: OmegaWeapon
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3010347
In-Game Name: Zanebono Lombardi
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Revealed as mayor day 6 and left
April 16th, 2017, 02:09 AM
[QUOTE=Helz;684484]As for the standard prefer chances it basically very strongly increases your chances of getting the preferred role 'if' that role is rolled by the setup. It does nothing to increase the chances of that role being in the game so the exact chances of it working it kind of tough to calculate. Its based off each setup and things get much more complicated when more than 1 person prefers the same role.[/QUOTE]
Well, does prefer give extra weight to the player that prefers that role? Or is it more complex?
Originally Posted by
Helz
As for the standard prefer chances it basically very strongly increases your chances of getting the preferred role 'if' that role is rolled by the setup. It does nothing to increase the chances of that role being in the game so the exact chances of it working it kind of tough to calculate. Its based off each setup and things get much more complicated when more than 1 person prefers the same role.
Well, does prefer give extra weight to the player that prefers that role? Or is it more complex?
April 16th, 2017, 01:49 AM
[QUOTE=Helz;684485]I am not sure what you are reporting here. Yes different roles get different messages. It is intended.[/QUOTE]
This is in reference to the role cards at the top of the screen. The same action is worded differently. It's not important at all, per the "Not a Bug" tag, but it is strange.
Originally Posted by
Helz
I am not sure what you are reporting here. Yes different roles get different messages. It is intended.
This is in reference to the role cards at the top of the screen. The same action is worded differently. It's not important at all, per the "Not a Bug" tag, but it is strange.
April 15th, 2017, 11:45 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] DINK
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-436506
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Lequan "Oneshot" McDonald
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] DINK Rolls judge in slot 12
6 (DH) goes on trial, falsely claims jailor, claiming to have jailed DINK. 6 is voted innocent by the town, including DINK.
DINK then courts and kills 6, who flips DH.
DINK commits suicide the following night.
DINK knew that 6 was not town (fake lw mentioning him) and commits suicide after courting him, making this a clear game-throw.
Account Name: DINK
Account ID: 1-S2-1-436506
In-Game Name: Lequan "Oneshot" McDonald
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: DINK Rolls judge in slot 12
6 (DH) goes on trial, falsely claims jailor, claiming to have jailed DINK. 6 is voted innocent by the town, including DINK.
DINK then courts and kills 6, who flips DH.
DINK commits suicide the following night.
DINK knew that 6 was not town (fake lw mentioning him) and commits suicide after courting him, making this a clear game-throw.
April 15th, 2017, 11:05 PM
[QUOTE=Cryptonic;684310]it's not a 100% guarantee you'll get the role you prefer.[/QUOTE]
How likely is it/how much does it boost your chances?
Originally Posted by
Cryptonic
it's not a 100% guarantee you'll get the role you prefer.
How likely is it/how much does it boost your chances?
April 15th, 2017, 10:58 PM
Doctor: "PROTECT one person each night from death"
Witch Doctor: "SAVE one person each night from death" OR "SAVE a member of the cult each night from death"
One of these is not like the others, and I believe they all prevent one attack.
Doctor: "PROTECT one person each night from death"
Witch Doctor: "SAVE one person each night from death" OR "SAVE a member of the cult each night from death"
One of these is not like the others, and I believe they all prevent one attack.
April 12th, 2017, 01:56 AM
[QUOTE=MrCarl;682769]Lol Coffeeclubbr you little bitch. He messages me in game and tells me I'm banned. Removing you from every lobby I host now.[/QUOTE]
Can confirm that Carl here is salty about his 4 day ban, and is kicking.
Originally Posted by
MrCarl
Lol Coffeeclubbr you little bitch. He messages me in game and tells me I'm banned. Removing you from every lobby I host now.
Can confirm that Carl here is salty about his 4 day ban, and is kicking.
April 10th, 2017, 10:14 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] gftgy
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-564449
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Ercole Rizzo
[B]Account Name:[/B] Human
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-7818686
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Michelagelo Pesci
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Griefing/Reactionary Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubbr
[B]Summary:[/B] Tried to get the diablo killed, and offered no defense when trialed themselves.
A few more people could be added but evidence isn't as definitive (no trial)
Account Name: gftgy
Account ID: 1-S2-1-564449
In-Game Name: Ercole Rizzo
Account Name: Human
Account ID: 1-S2-1-7818686
In-Game Name: Michelagelo Pesci
Crimes Committed: Griefing/Reactionary Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubbr
Summary: Tried to get the diablo killed, and offered no defense when trialed themselves.
A few more people could be added but evidence isn't as definitive (no trial)
April 9th, 2017, 12:53 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Shadow
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-4753842
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Kris
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Reactionary Gamethrowing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Shadow Rolls disguiser, things start to look bad for mafia and he leaves. The next day the godfather gets lynch by 4 to 3, so outcome was significantly changed.
Account Name: Shadow
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4753842
In-Game Name: Kris
Crimes Committed: Reactionary Gamethrowing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Shadow Rolls disguiser, things start to look bad for mafia and he leaves. The next day the godfather gets lynch by 4 to 3, so outcome was significantly changed.
April 8th, 2017, 06:05 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] MASLOW
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-4363834
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] SupremeTrump
[B]Account Name:[/B] SnakeMan
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-1877641
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] trump wall
[B]Account Name:[/B] Puffball
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-653670
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] John F. Kennedy
[B]Account Name:[/B] hanniau
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-2456188
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Ronald Reagan
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Skyping, Intentional Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Most obvious skyping I've ever seen
Account Name: MASLOW
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4363834
In-Game Name: SupremeTrump
Account Name: SnakeMan
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1877641
In-Game Name: trump wall
Account Name: Puffball
Account ID: 1-S2-1-653670
In-Game Name: John F. Kennedy
Account Name: hanniau
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2456188
In-Game Name: Ronald Reagan
Crimes Committed: Skyping, Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Most obvious skyping I've ever seen
April 8th, 2017, 02:23 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Hank
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-8552852
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Nino Marino
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Gamethrowing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Rolled Jailor, executed a Lookout night 1 and a Crier night 2, before suiciding.
Nothing too bad, but before the game started he said he would throw.
Account Name: Hank
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8552852
In-Game Name: Nino Marino
Crimes Committed: Intentional Gamethrowing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Rolled Jailor, executed a Lookout night 1 and a Crier night 2, before suiciding.
Nothing too bad, but before the game started he said he would throw.
April 7th, 2017, 08:47 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] MrChow
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-1168040
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Sergio De Niro
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Game-throwing
[B]Account Name:[/B] Zanzibar
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-3188147
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Rewind and Reeeelax
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Role-Quitting
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Zanzibar rolls Crier, insta leaves.
MrChow rolls Judge, calls court day one, save doesn't allow trials day one so nobody lynched.
Day 2 the Mayor reveals, multiple people go on trial and are voted innocent. MrChow Votes guilty for each one. Jester isn't possible.
MrChow gets on stand and gives no defense. Is voted guilty
I know that Judge has no faction and all, but MrChow was clearly not trying to win.
Account Name: MrChow
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1168040
In-Game Name: Sergio De Niro
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-throwing
Account Name: Zanzibar
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3188147
In-Game Name: Rewind and Reeeelax
Crimes Committed: Role-Quitting
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Zanzibar rolls Crier, insta leaves.
MrChow rolls Judge, calls court day one, save doesn't allow trials day one so nobody lynched.
Day 2 the Mayor reveals, multiple people go on trial and are voted innocent. MrChow Votes guilty for each one. Jester isn't possible.
MrChow gets on stand and gives no defense. Is voted guilty
I know that Judge has no faction and all, but MrChow was clearly not trying to win.
April 1st, 2017, 10:13 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Carl
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-7802658
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Excretioner
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubbr
[B]Summary:[/B] Is bodyguard, tries to get #3 (Sheriff) killed by claiming detective. Very obvious game throwing.
Account Name: Carl
Account ID: 1-S2-1-7802658
In-Game Name: Excretioner
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubbr
Summary: Is bodyguard, tries to get #3 (Sheriff) killed by claiming detective. Very obvious game throwing.
March 28th, 2017, 12:39 AM
[QUOTE=Helz;667629]I will dig into it[/QUOTE]
Time to get out of the hole mate :)
Originally Posted by
Helz
I will dig into it
Time to get out of the hole mate
March 22nd, 2017, 02:33 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Teal
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-5097841
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] im pissed
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Intentional Game-Throwing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Teal is judge, and openly says the save is shit. Day 5 courts the arsonist (which is fine). On the last night (Night 6) he says he will die tomorrow, and fails to lynch in time (through second court). While nothing is provable here, it seems like Teal wanted the town to win, as he didn't like the save, killed his ally and admitted defeat when he was likely to win.
Account Name: Teal
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5097841
In-Game Name: im pissed
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Teal is judge, and openly says the save is shit. Day 5 courts the arsonist (which is fine). On the last night (Night 6) he says he will die tomorrow, and fails to lynch in time (through second court). While nothing is provable here, it seems like Teal wanted the town to win, as he didn't like the save, killed his ally and admitted defeat when he was likely to win.
March 19th, 2017, 01:37 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Agrave
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-6562611
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] [Irrelevant]
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Griefing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Stump and Scumbag Save
Account Name: Agrave
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6562611
In-Game Name: [Irrelevant]
Crimes Committed: Griefing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Stump and Scumbag Save
March 18th, 2017, 06:49 PM
[B]Account Name:[/B] AmazingJohn
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-8595469
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Giovanni Fondra
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Role Hacking, Bank Hacking
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Reveals all roles in last will. Obviously hacked bank. Likely a smurf.
Account Name: AmazingJohn
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8595469
In-Game Name: Giovanni Fondra
Crimes Committed: Role Hacking, Bank Hacking
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Reveals all roles in last will. Obviously hacked bank. Likely a smurf.
March 11th, 2017, 01:21 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Silentfreak
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-813045
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Micahthefaggot
[B]Account Name:[/B] FireFlareX
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-5425884
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] Salvatore
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Skyping
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] They admitted to it at end.
Account Name: Silentfreak
Account ID: 1-S2-1-813045
In-Game Name: Micahthefaggot
Account Name: FireFlareX
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5425884
In-Game Name: Salvatore
Crimes Committed: Skyping
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: They admitted to it at end.
February 26th, 2017, 01:06 AM
From the wikia:
Fail to kill night-immune players four times in one game.
I got this achievement as a vigilante with only 3 shots.
From the wikia:
Fail to kill night-immune players four times in one game.
I got this achievement as a vigilante with only 3 shots.
February 25th, 2017, 02:25 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] THROWER
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-8566456
[B]In-Game Name:[/B] RADICAL AIDS
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Bank Hacking
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Over 900 games played and 0 victories. Most obvious bank hack ever?
Account Name: THROWER
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8566456
In-Game Name: RADICAL AIDS
Crimes Committed: Bank Hacking
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Over 900 games played and 0 victories. Most obvious bank hack ever?
February 16th, 2017, 02:14 AM
When the cult converts a witch, they do not turn into a witch doctor when that option is turned on.
When the cult converts a witch, they do not turn into a witch doctor when that option is turned on.
February 14th, 2017, 02:01 AM
Account Name: FinaLFaithdL
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6851966
In-Game Name: Roostergr
Crimes Committed: Griefing
Account Name: dOubleDizzy
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6352718
In-Game Name: Dante
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: FinaLFaithdL Rolls veteran in slot 15, and starts lynching people at random, making up reasons to do so. One dead, he admits he was just bored and guessing at random.
dOubleDizzy Rolls lookout in slot 2. Game goes down to two town + 1 witch. 2 leaves, ensuring the witch's win.
Account Name: FinaLFaithdL
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6851966
In-Game Name: Roostergr
Crimes Committed: Griefing
Account Name: dOubleDizzy
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6352718
In-Game Name: Dante
Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: FinaLFaithdL Rolls veteran in slot 15, and starts lynching people at random, making up reasons to do so. One dead, he admits he was just bored and guessing at random.
dOubleDizzy Rolls lookout in slot 2. Game goes down to two town + 1 witch. 2 leaves, ensuring the witch's win.
February 6th, 2017, 01:18 AM
[B]Account Name:[/B] Lankybird
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-3788240
[B]In-Game Name:[/B]
[B]Account Name:[/B] Mowgli
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-3551077
[B]In-Game Name:[/B]
[B]Crimes Committed:[/B] Griefing
[B]Your Account Name:[/B] coffeeclubber
[B]Summary:[/B] Lankybird rolls lookout in slot 4, Mowgli rolls investigator in slot 7
5 is silenced day 3 and spams votes to signal to town that he is silenced. He ends up on trial, where the only thing said is "I am blackmailed". Once defense is over, 4 says that he is lynching simply because 5 spammed so much, with 7 attempting to put him on trial because he is spamming. This is clear cut griefing, as these players didn't care about whether 5 was silenced or not, only that he was spamming. Furthermore, 5 stopped spamming votes once somebody acknowledged that he was silenced, which undermines the potential for jester bait.
Account Name: Lankybird
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3788240
In-Game Name:
Account Name: Mowgli
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3551077
In-Game Name:
Crimes Committed: Griefing
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: Lankybird rolls lookout in slot 4, Mowgli rolls investigator in slot 7
5 is silenced day 3 and spams votes to signal to town that he is silenced. He ends up on trial, where the only thing said is "I am blackmailed". Once defense is over, 4 says that he is lynching simply because 5 spammed so much, with 7 attempting to put him on trial because he is spamming. This is clear cut griefing, as these players didn't care about whether 5 was silenced or not, only that he was spamming. Furthermore, 5 stopped spamming votes once somebody acknowledged that he was silenced, which undermines the potential for jester bait.
February 3rd, 2017, 01:12 AM
[B]Account Name: Zairja[/B]
[B]Account ID:[/B] 1-S2-1-#8213012
[B]In-Game Name: Sansone Bianchi[/B]
[B]Crimes Committed: Lag Cheating[/B]
[B]Your Account Name: coffeeclubber[/B]
[B]Summary: 13 rolls lookout and is put on trial day 5. During the trial somebody lags out and 4 (Zairja) spams inno in lag chat. This likely didn't affect the outcome, but is clear and cut lag cheating.[/B]
Account Name: Zairja
Account ID: 1-S2-1-#8213012
In-Game Name: Sansone Bianchi
Crimes Committed: Lag Cheating
Your Account Name: coffeeclubber
Summary: 13 rolls lookout and is put on trial day 5. During the trial somebody lags out and 4 (Zairja) spams inno in lag chat. This likely didn't affect the outcome, but is clear and cut lag cheating.