Search Results - SC2 Mafia
Register

Search:

Type: Posts; User: DJarJar

Page 1 of 40 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.14 seconds.

  1. Replies
    3
    Views
    34

    {Approved} ►►Re: max: 1-S2-1-6159784◄◄

    restored
  2. Replies
    0
    Views
    27

    {Unsolved} ►►1 v 1 auditor and citizen, no winner declared◄◄

    1 v 1 auditor and citizen which should result in auditor solo win.

    For some reason game just says "we cannot reach a consensus today" rather than declaring auditor the winner

    I use lightning on the citizen to give auditor his win.Name: auditor doesn't win.SC2Replay
Views: 0
Size: 271.4 KB
  3. Forum:Mafia Discussion

    Thread:SC2Mafia MVP Contest: 2021 Edition

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    8
    Views
    3,263

    Sticky: ►►Re: SC2Mafia MVP Contest: 2021 Edition◄◄

    Sorry for the extremely long delay, but judging is finally over!

    Varcron (1-S2-1-1208407) has been declared the winner of the 2021 contest, for the replay submitted by Lag of a disguiser making excellent plays and winning despite difficult odds. As he already won before he will just receive 2500 points and another copy of the forum badge.

    As the nominator, lag will also receive 500 points.

    theoneceko (1-S2-1-8585442) was the runner-up, for the replay of a vigilante carrying the town. He will receive 500 points.


    @Varcron @Lag @theoneceko
    Please contact me to organize a time in-game to receive your rewards.
    Congratulations!


    Thanks to all who participated!


    If you are jealous of them, make sure to submit some entries into the 2022 MVP contest thread!


    edit: added varcron points 5/16
  4. Forum:General Discussion

    Thread:starcraft 2 mafia

    Thread Author:oops_ur_dead

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    14
    Views
    132

    ►►Re: starcraft 2 mafia◄◄

    no what's that?
  5. Forum:Mafia Bug Reports

    Thread:I can't prefer

    Thread Author:Etienne

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    2
    Views
    156

    [Setup] ►►Re: I can't prefer◄◄

    can you provide a replay of a game with you at 20k points and trying to type -prefer?

    https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showt...pload-a-replay
  6. Replies
    0
    Views
    59

    {Unsolved} ►►Game doesn't register gameover after a bonker conversion◄◄

    Bonker chaos mode save.

    In this game the bonker converts the SK to amnesiac n3 resulting in 3 mafia, 1 amnesiac, 1 auditor, 1 bonker, and 1 town alive. This should cause an instant win for all of the non-town but instead the day plays out resulting in 1 player getting pointlessly lynched. (bug is that bonker conversion seems to occur after checking for gameover?)


    Additionally as a separate bug, players seem to get the "you got bonked" message twice whenever bonked which is confusing when trying to determine exactly what happened last night.

    Name: -Mafia- (88).SC2Replay
Views: 0
Size: 295.0 KB
  7. Replies
    1
    Views
    101

    ►►iceepirate: 1-S2-1-3595439◄◄

    1-S2-1-3595439's highest points in database from: 2018-11-12-114346, highest wins from: 2018-03-09-134841, highest games from: 2018-03-09-134841, and combined achievements.
    Approved for: 27323 points, 124 wins, and 305 games played.
    To complete your restore you'll need to meet up with an admin in-game. Your best bet is to use the @point restore tag on our discord until you find one.
  8. Forum:Punished Players & Appeals

    Thread:Rachyl: 1-S2-1-4370710

    Thread Author:Omegasaur

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    3
    Views
    1,091

    {Ban List} ►►Re: Rachyl: 1-S2-1-4370710◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Arrow View Post
    1-S2-1-4370710: Permaban
    @Arrow
    this id is playing again rn
  9. Forum:Mafia Discussion

    Thread:Rachyl's unbanning Thread

    Thread Author:RachylReborn

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    5
    Views
    399

    ►►Re: Rachyl's unbanning Thread◄◄

    thanks for letting us know
  10. Replies
    52
    Views
    1,495

    ►►Re: 24/7 Wolf Chat vs Night-Only Wolf Chat◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by OzyWho View Post
    Yah I myself have left SC2Mafia and Skwirl discords and not really joining any games anymore.
    Similarly, I came to FM from the mod for MM, Oberon came here for Distorted, lots of older players came for SuperJack.

    After years and years of pondering on this question, your comment shines the truest of them all.
    ya and lag is fing awesome
  11. Replies
    5
    Views
    195

    [New Mechanic] ►►Re: Give disturbing the peace to all night speakers◄◄

    i appreciate the 2 of u jumping in well after the fact to dump on it some more after mostache's response was enough!

    the idea was to find a middle ground - in the old ways mafia couldn't talk at all - in the new ways mafia can talk as much as they want with no fear which is actually a MASSIVE buff when playing with strong teammates.

    What all 3 of you ignore is that i was suggesting adding the crime also to party host chats and mason chats - So for you to get caught as mafia by this there 1) has to actually be an investigator in the game which is already like 1 in 4 games, and 2) the mafia chat happens to be the only night chat in the game and 3) the invest actually picks to check you specifically

    It would be pretty rare that it would catch you as mafia for sure IMO. But w/e.
  12. Replies
    52
    Views
    1,495

    ►►Re: 24/7 Wolf Chat vs Night-Only Wolf Chat◄◄

    With “only night chat”, the strongest scum teams I was in just made up cues to secretly communicate during the day anyway.

    Like “I will @ everyone but the third person I @ is who I saw my target visit”

    At that point you might as well just give us a 24/7 scum chat.

    Also it’s way more new player friendly to have 24/7 scum chat. I feel like playing your first game ever and roleing scum with no ability to get advice is a fast ticket to somebody never signing again


    Also I feel like you presented the change the wrong way cuz it’s not like hosts are being forced to use it, it’s just changing the default setting
  13. Forum:News

    Thread:iso feature

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    16
    Views
    586

    ►►Re: iso feature◄◄

    it's kind of ugly but i added an iso list to the top of threads
  14. Replies
    52
    Views
    1,495

    ►►Re: 24/7 Wolf Chat vs Night-Only Wolf Chat◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Frinckles View Post
    1. There are currently X users browsing this thread can be useful to help angle-shoot if 24/7 wolf chat exists.
    this can be disabled and we actually did that before but I think people missed it and it has one big advantage - if you know someone else is online it encourages you to stay online too
    I think the agreed upon solution was to have the default for new members be that they are invisible (so it says a member is reading the chat but not their name)

    if the modern consensus is to just remove it then we can do that
  15. Forum:Punished Players & Appeals

    Thread:Lamp: 1-S2-1-12435349

    Thread Author:Reasoner

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    3
    Views
    257

    {Permanently Banned} ►►Re: Lamp: 1-S2-1-12435349◄◄

    1-S2-1-12453019
    "StrutJetstre#503"

    StrutJetstre#246
    1-S2-1-12479976

    are also his accounts
  16. Replies
    713
    Views
    14,679

    ►►Re: S-FM 341: American Flag Nightless◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by theoneceko View Post
    -daykill aamirus
    has to be re-enabled each day
  17. Replies
    713
    Views
    14,679

    ►►Re: S-FM 341: American Flag Nightless◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by oliverz144 View Post
    woohoo i can type! @aamirus copy the threadclosing code line from the hammer bot and add it intented to the daykill code, that should fix it easily
    martin is correct, i just opened the thread after doing that lol
  18. Replies
    713
    Views
    14,679

    ►►Re: S-FM 341: American Flag Nightless◄◄

    -daykill Stealthbomber16
  19. Forum:News

    Thread:iso feature

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    16
    Views
    586

    ►►Re: iso feature◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by OzyWho View Post
    This is awesome, thx!
    Also, I myself idk what most of those request thingies are supposed to be anymore
    ISO results now show in the order they were posted.
  20. Forum:General Discussion

    Thread:CPI

    Thread Author:Helz

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    41
    Views
    3,315

    ►►Re: CPI◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Lag View Post
    The original question was:



    My view on the accuracy of the CPI has not changed - I don't think it's "totally insane" nor do I think their calculations are "bullshit"

    Inflation has certainly continued to go up though, and that is also reflected in the CPI which sits at 7.9% for all urban consumers and 8.6% for urban workers - those are the highest inflation rates since the stagflation of the late 70's/early 80's. So I think the index is doing a pretty good job of capturing the severity of the current inflation. And those are just the February numbers, March numbers are scheduled to release tomorrow.


    As far as the topic of "has my view on inflation changed?"



    Yes and no. Yes since inflation is empirically higher now, so of course my view on the current rate has changed.

    But no because it's not a particularly surprising outcome given that the Fed had explicitly warned about that possibility as I mentioned in my previous post.



    And going back to the original question - No, the Federal Reserve and US Bureau of Labor Statistics are still not "totally insane" nor are they "bullshit"
    i got a 2017 toyota corolla like a week before lockdowns started in the US. For about 12k and it's now worth about 18k. Obviously anecdotal experience but it's still kind of shocking. If that 7% feels high to anybody i mean... the us government will happily give you 7% interest on a 10k bond for at least the next 6 months https://www.treasurydirect.gov/indiv...res_ibonds.htm - although i wager if you wait til may to buy it, it'll be closer to 8%
  21. Forum:News

    Thread:iso feature

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    16
    Views
    586

    ►►Re: iso feature◄◄

    Also if someone would like it to look prettier you’re welcome to copy the checkbox next to it and make a similar size image or some css whatever and send it to me
  22. Forum:News

    Thread:iso feature

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    16
    Views
    586

    ►►Re: iso feature◄◄

    @OzyWho

    from ozy: "Auto expand, reverse ISO, multi ISO, vote ISO, reply, +multi quote button, hide forum thread info, distinguish posts, ISO shortcut from thread directly."

    ozy i did one of your requests are you proud of me
  23. Forum:News

    Thread:iso feature

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    16
    Views
    586

    ►►iso feature◄◄

    There's now an iso button in the top right of each post for you fm people


    edit: it does absolutely nothing new but now you don't have to go through the infuriating process of clicking out of the thread, clicking the number of posts, then desperately trying to scroll all the way to the right of the name you wanted to iso in that ugly little popup window
  24. Forum:News

    Thread:Daykill feature for fm

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    6
    Views
    267

    ►►Re: Daykill feature for fm◄◄

    if it's an anonymous day kill you could make a 2nd forum account to do it, else w/e
  25. Forum:News

    Thread:Daykill feature for fm

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    6
    Views
    267

    ►►Re: Daykill feature for fm◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by OzyWho View Post
    I think American Flag was the first setup that had day kills end the days. Feature is nice to have, just I expect most to have forgotten about it before the next time arises that it'll be needed - that remembering will be a fun moment.
    it doesn't have to officially end the "FM day" but it just immediately closes the thread when you want to do your day kill which seems normal? Now you don't have to hope for host to be online to do your day kill either?
  26. Forum:News

    Thread:Daykill feature for fm

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    6
    Views
    267

    ►►Re: Daykill feature for fm◄◄

    If the host enables this and then you use it to close the thread when you’re not supposed to (you don’t have a day kill power) then you will face infractions. So please don’t.
  27. Forum:News

    Thread:Daykill feature for fm

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    6
    Views
    267

    ►►Daykill feature for fm◄◄

    There is now daykill functionality for FM.

    The host/OP of the thread must first enter [ enabledaykills][/enabledaykills]

    Then anybody in the thread can do [ daykill]username[/daykill]

    It will immediately close the thread so nobody will post after the kill.
    It also @ mentions the username you entered so they get a notification and hopefully realize not to post anymore in future days

    The enable day kills bbcode must be done anytime votes are reset (e.g. whenever day ends)
  28. Replies
    2
    Views
    191

    ►►Re: Points/ achievement restore◄◄

    archiving from lack of response
  29. Replies
    8
    Views
    290
  30. Replies
    8
    Views
    290

    ►►Re: Bank problems: afk - 1-S2-1-3151647◄◄

    still can't tell what could be causing the bug.

    anyway for your point restore you need to delete the mbank13 as euna said - then you should stop getting the "bank invalid stats won't be saved / X is a hacker!" messages and you'll be at 0 points.

    Then you're approved for a restore to 61958 points, 457 wins, 1201 games played + achievements.
    Name: afk.png
Views: 5
Size: 108.9 KB

    To complete the restore you need to meet up with an admin in-game. The easiest way to find one is use the @point restore tag on our discord server, which you can find a link to on the sidebar of homepage.
  31. Replies
    15
    Views
    595

    ►►Re: Account Name: Anhionring◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Euna View Post
    I've attached replay 797.


    Anyways, do I need to delete my Sc2maf bank file (the one with 0 points) before having the admin add my points? Will my account continue to be labeled as a hacker? Thanks in advance.
    Yea you need to delete that bank and then the game should make a new one with 0 points next time you play and you’ll stop being called a hacker.
  32. Replies
    15
    Views
    595

    ►►Re: Account Name: Anhionring◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Euna View Post
    @aamirus

    I get this message while trying to open the attachments you sent: "Invalid Attachment specified. If you followed a valid link, please notify the administrator"


    Please reference below for which replay is which

    Replay from the picture of my points, which is the same game before I got the error: -Mafia- (79.SC2Replay (148.1 KB) [-Mafia- 798]]
    Replay from the first time it says "Please report Anhonring!": -Mafia- (799).SC2Replay (126.9 KB)

    From my perspective, I see "WARNING -YOUR BANK IS INVALID! NO STATS WILL BE SAVED! If this persists, delete 'MBank13.SC2Bank'!"

    During downtime, I sometimes play mafia on my work pc, which has a different bank file on there with like 3-4k points accumulated. Not sure if that messes with anything. I've been playing on my work PC and then switching back to my gaming PC for a couple months and nothing has happened until now.


    One more thing, I found another MBank13.SC2Bank (8.0 KB) file under this path: https://gyazo.com/b751302c9285c533cb8dbee0e065bba9
    Is this the one with 38k points? I don't understand why there are different bank files other than they were made from when I reset my drives or used new ones.

    Thank you for your assistance, it is much appreciated. Please let me know if you need anything else.

    The work computer explains the first bank you uploaded as it had just under 4k points. I think that file is fine and unrelated.

    Both the file paths you showed in the images seem to be the same to me? But the 1st bank seems to be from your work computer and this 2nd bank is the one that's getting you called a bank hacker by the game.

    This 2nd bank you've uploaded is definitely broken. It has 0 points and 0 games played but some wins and all the achievements that you're supposed to have.

    It looks like whatever happened at the start of the 798 replay where the game was bouncing back and forth between your save slot and chaos mode nuked your bank. For bug-fixing it might be helpful if you can get the replay from right before this one (so 797), so we can see what had most recently changed in your bank.





    Sorry the pictures didn't work before they're just pictures of your points and achievements so any admin can process your point restore for you. I'll repost - Name: anhionring2.png
Views: 5
Size: 18.7 KB Name: anhionring.png
Views: 7
Size: 59.5 KB
    So to complete your point restore you just need to meet up with an admin in sc2. The best bet to find one is to use the @point restore tag in the discord (link to discord on sidebar of homepage).
  33. Replies
    15
    Views
    595

    ►►Re: Account Name: Anhionring◄◄

    yea so somehow that file has much lower stats than what you had in the replay from right before. I'm not sure what happened to cause this. Would you mind uploading the replays for the pictures you shared in the original post? Like say the replay from right before you got the error message, the replay where the error message happened, and the 1st replay with Anhionring is a hacker message appearing? It would help us try to figure out what happened.


    Also, you can delete that bank file from your computer and we can do a point restore for you. Approved for these stats:
    Name: 
Views: 
Size: 0.0 KB
    Name: 
Views: 
Size: 0.0 KB
  34. Replies
    15
    Views
    595

    ►►Re: Account Name: Anhionring◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by Euna View Post
    Account Name: Anhionring
    Account ID: 1-S2-1-8107290
    Your Server: North America
    Approximate Points: 38680


    Image of my points: https://gyazo.com/d4cee6ebb6809c5d2cc5de1e2a6663ec

    Hello? Why do I get this error?: https://gyazo.com/9bb8dabcdcf5f50ef93dc2ca9fb5eda2
    AND WHAT IS THIS?: https://gyazo.com/b1dd20131d71df791f8ebdd6c5336739

    "Anhionring is a known hacker...NO STATS WILL BE SAVED"...WHAT? I honestly thought Frinckles was trolling me because, on Day 1, he said "I'll show you a real bug tonight" after I said something like "developers should fix the hosting bugs and stop gaslighting players" . For some context, when I was trying to host, it didn't let me select my save and bugged out by rapidly switching between a bunch of saves (this is not the first time it happened to me), and Frinckles memed about me having a macro, when I had NOTHING. I SWEAR ON MY DOG.


    I'm playing on a drive with previous sc2 installations, not sure if that messes with anything. I never had this issue before.

    I WANT MY COLORED NAME, -PREFER, AND -BLACKLIST BACK..THAT'S LIKE 80% OF THE GAME.
    @Euna

    Somehow your bank file become corrupt. If you could post it here that might be helpful to find out what happened. The "x is a bank hacker" message will just automatically appear if the bank file is invalid.

    Please see here for instructions on where to find the file:
    https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showt...your-bank-file

    Anyway, to fix the problem you'll have to delete the corrupted bank file (this will fix the "X is a bank hacker" message). And then we can do a point restore for you.
  35. Replies
    6
    Views
    265

    ►►Re: In-Game Discord Link Does Not Work◄◄

    ok @Frinckles

    I made this invite and set it to never expire
    https://discord.gg/6h8e6h8e9T
  36. Replies
    3
    Views
    182

    ►►Re: PSA: How to look up Player Handles (IDs)◄◄

    to me "handle" sounds more like a chosen username than a numerical id
  37. Replies
    6
    Views
    265

    ►►Re: In-Game Discord Link Does Not Work◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by ChannelMiner View Post
    It's expired chief.
    that's interesting so the sidebar widget has some code to keep generating a new invite link when the old one expires
  38. Replies
    4
    Views
    187

    [Role Change] ►►Re: Street Racer Should Have Speeding Crime◄◄

    in the nights he is racing, wouldn't the invest get no feedback at all rather than "no crimes"? That lack of feedback basically confirms it.
  39. Forum:Mafia Discussion

    Thread:Mafia 2.0

    Thread Author:theoneceko

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    5
    Views
    690

    ►►Re: Mafia 2.0◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by OzyWho View Post
    “Yes” and “No.”
    @aamirus how did you get them not-vertical quotation marks?
    idk i guess my iphone does that
  40. Replies
    4
    Views
    168

    ►►Re: Bank Problems BrockSamson 1-S2-2-542260◄◄

    approved 156,145 points, 3344 wins, 5952 games played + achievements

    Name: brock3.png
Views: 5
Size: 140.1 KB
  41. Replies
    4
    Views
    168

    ►►Re: Bank Problems BrockSamson 1-S2-2-542260◄◄

    this is definitely not the right bank file. It's got all kinds of weird shit going on in it. I'm not sure how you lost your original bank file but you should delete this and we can do a point restore for you

    it has fields i've never seen before, a different bnet id "3-S2-1-4255131", negative points...

    So yea idk how you got that but just delete it.
  42. Forum:Mafia Discussion

    Thread:Mafia 2.0

    Thread Author:theoneceko

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    5
    Views
    690

    ►►Re: Mafia 2.0◄◄

    “Yes” or “No.”
  43. Replies
    2
    Views
    702

    ►►Re: Why I Started Playing Sc2 Mafia◄◄

    Seems like among us completely killed off parasite yea
  44. Replies
    2
    Views
    137

    ►►Re: Actress Not Getting Information?◄◄

    i'm not super well-versed in the newer mechanics but generally this would happen if, for example, a witch or bus driver redirected your target so that your action ends up doing nothing

    - your best bet is to check the replay from all players POV and see what they did
  45. Replies
    1
    Views
    116

    [Mechanics] ►►actress becomes mafioso but then still flips as her acted role◄◄

    The actress selects the constable on n1. The actress then turns into mafioso after 1 mafia dies n1 and the gf dies to constable d2. However when the mafioso (actress) later dies they still flip constable.

    Maybe this is intended but it seems like after becoming mafioso they shouldn't flip as their previous acting target anymore.

    Name: mafioso shows as constable.SC2Replay
Views: 2
Size: 369.9 KB
  46. Forum:Mafia Bug Reports

    Thread:Mafia roles into any random slot

    Thread Author:DJarJar

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    0
    Views
    88

    [Setup] ►►Mafia roles into any random slot◄◄

    the setup is 8331 and the any random excludes mafia. Yet the game starts with 4 mafia.

    I assume based on existence of survivor, judge, and arson that the 4th mafia is taking the any random slot.


    Name: 4th mafia any random.SC2Replay
Views: 1
Size: 317.1 KB
  47. Forum:General Discussion

    Thread:Russia's economy: myth vs facts

    Thread Author:OzyWho

    Post Author:DJarJar

    Replies
    6
    Views
    301

    ►►Re: Russia's economy: myth vs facts◄◄

    Quote Originally Posted by OzyWho View Post
    The ruble regained 100% of its losses and sanctions don't work

    I'm very very VERY much not a economy person. Can someone tell me if I understood this correctly? Russia's economy is back on track? Can we "check it for ourselves" somehow?

    According to that article, everything I thought about Russia's economy is wrong.
    What are the myths and what are the facts? I hope someone who understands this better than me can tell me what is what!
    while the ruble's exchange rate went back to normal, reports from russia are that the price of goods has increased by about 40%. That is what i read yesterday anyway when people were circulating this.

    So the currency SHOULD be trading for much less since russians have to spend more to buy the same items. But the russian government and banks are manipulating the price by limiting supply and barring the average russian from converting their rubles to any other currency. I believe they closed the russian stock markets as well so people can't sell.

    I believe i read they were offering 20% interest at banks to incentivize people to deposit all their money - https://www.cnbc.com/2022/02/28/russ...ter-ruble.html

    Basically - just like a government can force inflation by simply printing more money, they also have ways to force de-inflation. But in both cases it's essentially stealing wealth from the people actually holding rubles - the citizens.
  48. Replies
    6
    Views
    265

    ►►Re: In-Game Discord Link Does Not Work◄◄

    @Frinckles

    i think this link from the sidebar doesn't expire? https://discord.com/invite/p95UY6x3
  49. Replies
    3
    Views
    188

    ►►Re: Why does Lookout have trespassing?◄◄

    You inspired me to make a suggestion thread lol

    I think it makes sense for lookout/det to have trespassing - it rewards mafia roles that also get trespassing for making a more difficult fake-claim than the lazy sheriff/doc claim.

    Also investigator is weaker than sheriff when it comes to detecting mafia or neut killers. So I would say part of what makes it viable is it can more easily self-confirm by correctly naming the crimes of others and also can sometimes confirm townies with its info.

    Another way to look at it is if you take off all the crimes except for the evil roles then invest basically becomes an OP giga sheriff
  50. Replies
    5
    Views
    195

    [New Mechanic] ►►Give disturbing the peace to all night speakers◄◄

    Iirc in 1.0 judge and crier could get the disturbing the peace crime if they spoke at night (and it wouldn’t show them with the crime until they spoke at least once at night).

    With the removal of spy listening to mafia chat and the addition of party host I think it could be interesting to give this crime to anybody who speaks at night. So mafia talking in their chat, anybody talking in party host chat, cult, masons, jailor and his victim.

    It provides a slight buff to investigator which has generally been considered a weak role as long as “detects exact role” is off. They may be able to immediately find a mafia player from it but this is still not as strong as the basic sheriff detection so I don’t think it’s too much.

    It slightly debuffs mafia as they’d now need to consider if it’s worth it to talk at night and pickup the crime. But it’s not a big risk as there would be a number of different viable fake-claims to explain why you have the crime, and investigators aren’t that frequent. So I don’t think it would silence mafia the way the old spy did.

    It also adds an interesting dynamic between investigator, party host, and any roles set immune to detection like godfather - the lack of disturbing the peace after a party would reveal that you’re a detection immune role, unless you can make some excuse for why you didn’t participate
Results 1 to 50 of 2000
Page 1 of 40 1 2 3 4