Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
I am pointing out a bad read. Bad reads can be made up or forced. Trying to figure that out with you.
No, I don't take much stock in day one reads, especially my own (excluding ceko currently, I'm 99% sure that I'm right with him)
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Varcron
Back on to the game instead of bickering over meta stuff.
Can Renegade justify his vote other than "someone told me to" or is that all you have?
I gave you my reasoning. It is a day 1 vote, didn't know I was prosecuting the OJ case. I've seen others with much weaker cases voting already.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Renegade
I gave you my reasoning. It is a day 1 vote, didn't know I was prosecuting the OJ case. I've seen others with much weaker cases voting already.
I was just curious if there was anything else to it.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Varcron
No, I don't take much stock in day one reads, especially my own (excluding ceko currently, I'm 99% sure that I'm right with him)
Fair.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Prefacing by saying, yes I did confirm my rolecard. I believed the game started today. My bad folks.
Not really my style in either alignment to go step-by-step and quote random shit just for a hot-take so I'll keep it brief. Feel free to ask me questions about whatever you like. I've read from page 7 up to now because, well -- I'm sure it was D1 garbage.
Also, I'm flattered so much attention has gone to my slot. For scum to gravitate the entire fucking game around my meta and Tales Of Yore is really gratifying.
Anyway out of the gates:
Noz_Bugz
theoneceko
Ganelon
BananaCucho
naz
Renegade
Varcron
SuperJack
aamirus
The top two have been for the most part, town in tone. This is even despite Noz only having 12 posts. In a huge contrast, Ceko @72 posts has been asking the right questions so far and it hasn't felt forced.
The next five are in some realm of chaotic bullshittery where they say "lets get Frinckles! no let's not get em!" back and forth. Like, there is no way the five of you seriously thought I wouldn't be informed to re-join or at worst have my slot replaced. I'm just trying to figure out if Ganelon was trying to white knight for me or if Naz/Banana are using the momentum of my train to spin it into another town member (and then whatever the fuck Varcron is doing.) There's definitely scum in there.
The last two are goofy because they both seem to be directly pushing for muh info lynches but contributed zero elsewhere. I don't know how towntelling it is to sarcastically chant Thunderdome! and do nothing at the same time. I don't know why SuperJack needs to make snippy remarks between his standard meta analysis spiel. I have thusly placed them as Cultists.
Anyway. those are the hottakes I've gotten after reading half of this game over the past 30 minutes. Feel free to question.
I agree (I don't know how helpful it is for me to say this lol)
noU!!!uWu
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Renegade
Three reasons dear Vracon.
Aamirus accuses my very simple defense of Gamelon as pocketing. I don't think definding someone saying that voting a truly afk player (unlike typical treko) is useless is worthy of this accusation.
Banana somehow strongly believes that Aamirus is town despite little information. I would like to explore this more.
I was told to jump on a train by at least two people.
But you just proved my point, by suggesting that voting a truly afk person is silly. We all know that's true. That was part of the whole point. Yet several things came out of it now:
1) Ganelon got overly defensive of frinckles. Frinckles was never in any real danger so it was odd to react this way. It did seem a bit white-knighty at first. However, I see this kind of behavior from ganelon and MM a lot so I don't think it ended up being very alignment indicative for ganelon.
2) The topic stayed glued on whether or not to lynch an afk person for way longer than it should have. I was trying to move to something else by asking ganelon to give his own train target, but oddly ganelon and banana both seemed to want to keep the topic of discussion on frinckles. Either or both of them could be scum that saw an opportunity to thunderdome and prevent the town from pursuing anybody else. It's also notable that neither was actually trying to push votes on the other. The votes were on frinckles and naz.
3) You popped in and state that ganelon is essentially the only rational person here for defending frinckles, since frinckles was afk. We all know turboing frinckles before he even posts once would be stupid. That was literally 90% of the back and forth between ganelon and banana. The only point of making that post I can see is to get ganelon to like you, and/or make it seem like you were contributing an opinion when it was really a useless thing to say from a town POV.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Renegade
Three reasons dear Vracon.
Aamirus accuses my very simple defense of Gamelon as pocketing. I don't think definding someone saying that voting a truly afk player (unlike typical treko) is useless is worthy of this accusation.
Banana somehow strongly believes that Aamirus is town despite little information. I would like to explore this more.
I was told to jump on a train by at least two people.
I forgot about that. Her attack on you was so weak that no one followed up on it LOL
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Varcron
No, I don't take much stock in day one reads, especially my own (excluding ceko currently, I'm 99% sure that I'm right with him)
UwU
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
"Like, there is no way the five of you seriously thought I wouldn't be informed to re-join or at worst have my slot replaced. I'm just trying to figure out if Ganelon was trying to white knight for me or if Naz/Banana are using the momentum of my train to spin it into another town member (and then whatever the fuck Varcron is doing.)"
1) I never once implied at all anywhere that my vote was on you for anything related to activity. Or stayed on you for activity. Grouping me into a "you 5 null slot" for that reason is insulting.
2) there was no "momentum" at all on you ever. I troll voted you. Nose troll voted you. Nothing else happened for a bit, eventually Ami voted you and then that was it. I stayed because I wanted to see how people reacted (you can see my interactions with Galeon over it). In the beginning I joked about chinese fire drilling or hammering you, but after Ami voted and through the interactions with Galeon I didnt push for more people to hop on your train or "pressure" an afk slot.
I guess mostly I'm just disappointed that through all that you've just grouped us all into "null" and thats it even though Ami voting you is essentially where the game "began"
Yeah, but Banana knows Pringles will come back and claim his role or my replacement would. I got Citizen. Hooray!
In the same vein, I know there was no real pressure on me. I checked the vote tallies before I began catching up and rolled my eyes at what bullshit I was about to sort through. I know how scum think. CFD over to some other slot after I start towntelling. It's a surefire way to try to pocket me and force a mis-lynch at the same time.
My point is, there are 3 scum in this game. Why is a cluster of 5 from a 30 minute read disappointing to you? You're the town scumleader right? Those are the fastest worthwhile takes I could fashion so do your part while I do mine. In my opinion the scummiest person in this game is intentionally at the bottom of my reads list.
-vote Aamirus
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Its REALLY weird seeing Treecko caught up with things lol
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
theoneceko
I'm revisiting this. Aami later wrote this vote off as sarcasm, but these three posts look semi-serious to me. Of course, she wouldn't tunnel SJ because I doubt anyone else see him as scum. I see this as scum!aami sowing distrust in someone I assume is townread by all.
She's talking out of both sides of her mouth....
This vote was to get a reaction, which she got from Ganelon. However, she hasn't pushed SuperJack, Ganelon, OR Frinckles. Her playstyle so far has been placing a vote, then stepping back.
Based on this interaction, I think aami was trying to improve MY opinion of her by a) calling me her top townread b) sowing distrust in Varcron, who also townreads me. Note how aami provided zero thoughts on anyone else, including BC.
Weak attack on Varcron. I thought he was joking when he made that comment.
your first 5 quotes are all obvious shitposts from the start of the game. the 6th quote "Fine then let's begin" is literally saying ok let's start actually playing.
Frinckles and superjack have both been awol since then.
I got what I wanted out of ganelon, and honestly, way more than I wanted.
I only placed 1 more vote, on naz, out of a desire to move the discussion on from ganelon and banana just going in circles, so the notion of dropping a vote and running away as a playstyle is faulty. Ganelon and banana were the only other ones on when I was trying to move to a different topic and neither seemed willing to cooperate, then I went to bed.
I don't need to improve your opinion of me because you already expressed a deep love for me
You can think he was joking, but he already replied in quite a lot of detail showing that he was not...
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Renegade
I gave you my reasoning. It is a day 1 vote, didn't know I was prosecuting the OJ case. I've seen others with much weaker cases voting already.
Are you saying that people who have weak cases against them are voting? Not sure what this sentence means.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Yeah, but Banana knows Pringles will come back and claim his role or my replacement would. I got Citizen. Hooray!
In the same vein, I know there was no real pressure on me. I checked the vote tallies before I began catching up and rolled my eyes at what bullshit I was about to sort through. I know how scum think.
CFD over to some other slot after I start towntelling. It's a surefire way to try to pocket me and force a mis-lynch at the same time.
My point is, there are 3 scum in this game. Why is a cluster of 5 from a 30 minute read disappointing to you? You're the town
scumleader right? Those are the fastest worthwhile takes I could fashion so do your part while I do mine. In my opinion the scummiest person in this game is intentionally at the bottom of my reads list.
-vote Aamirus
Not sure what CFD means, but this isnt even whats happening this game. Ami jumped off of you a long time ago, before you came back. You were only L-4 when you finally checked in lol. You rolled your eyes at 2 votes?
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
ceko's typing style makes me wanna die but is likely town so I can put up with it
Frinckles feels weird so I'd like to see more from them before i say one way or another on their alignment
Aamirus is >rand scum to me. Something isn't right there, need to zero in on it.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
@Ganelon
Ami is at L-2, come defend her like you did Pringles lol
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
btw
@Frinckles
If you'd like to know why I would post "shit's getting real; Thunderdome!", it's to encourage exactly the OPPOSITE. Because somebody about to thunderdome reading that should realize what's happening and catch themselves
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
@
Ganelon
Ami is at L-2, come defend her like you did Pringles lol
lol
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
Not sure what CFD means, but this isnt even whats happening this game. Ami jumped off of you a long time ago, before you came back. You were only L-4 when you finally checked in lol. You rolled your eyes at 2 votes?
Yes.
Re: S-FM 300: Black Flag Nightless [LADDER] GAME THREAD
Quote:
Originally Posted by
theoneceko
Are you saying that people who have weak cases against them are voting? Not sure what this sentence means.
Yes, I'm referring to the troll votes.