-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
LuckyDucky
Mannnnn, you literally create the most exquisite scenarios, then go through in depth the way things would and wouldn't be if things were A or B, then I start getting confused and you wind right back up on some alternate point that it seems like you weren't even trying to make in the first place. MIND YOU this is all without even a player being killed on day one. We know nothing about nothing. Now I have you tell me that your intelligence isn't capable of manipulating me in a way that makes total sense because I think I've been pretty transparent. And I feel you've been trying to manipulate me all game, which you've admitted that you have tried to influence me. =====> Ducky thinks Joey is SK. I will claim that he's the SK to get ducky to trust me. I'm actually SK. That doesn't seem complex it seems pretty basic to me. You know I won't lynch the killer. HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM QUACK QUACKITY QUACK QUACK
bro you're killing me
I'm in fucking hysterics here
Let's just wait and see what Joey says when he gets back.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
I need a cocktail, jesus christ people who play this regularly must be alcoholics
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
being fucking lynched?
bro you don't deserve to go through this right after work you should crack open a pint and chill
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
bro you don't deserve to go through this right after work you should crack open a pint and chill
im gonna go do that
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
It's really bothering me though who the fuck would kill Michael lol
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Oh. I think I know what's happening. Ok
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
It's really bothering me though who the fuck would kill Michael lol
Me
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
Me
Aren't you glad neither of us are SK. We're almost, almost on the same team for sure.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Sounds like buddying to me. If I didn't know who the sk is I'd probably vote you both
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kenny
Sounds like buddying to me. If I didn't know who the sk is I'd probably vote you both
Yeah, I feel bad for your severe lack of understanding. We're not on a scum team ever.
Besides, you should be doing other stuff.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kenny
Sounds like buddying to me. If I didn't know who the sk is I'd probably vote you both
lol
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
I still havent been able to catch up
At a chocolate party
Be back later
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
My gut really says rn you are agent and pringles is mafia
Was this a shitpost?
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Yeah, I feel bad for your severe lack of understanding. We're not on a scum team ever.
Besides, you should be doing other stuff.
You've been definitely ignoring banana at times today. I can totally see you two being scum, assuming yzb retracts his claim later
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Yeah, I feel bad for your severe lack of understanding. We're not on a scum team ever.
Besides, you should be doing other stuff.
What other stuff anyway? Talk about it. I don't know you mean here
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kenny
You've been definitely ignoring banana at times today. I can totally see you two being scum, assuming yzb retracts his claim later
lol
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Genuine question, is yzb a man? I don't wanna fuck this up
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
LuckyDucky
I need a cocktail, jesus christ people who play this regularly must be alcoholics
Confirmed
Its self abuse
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kenny
You've been definitely ignoring banana at times today. I can totally see you two being scum, assuming yzb retracts his claim later
Well, mostly because our interaction result in a spiral of shit conducive to not ever solving the game. We had two AFK's (at minimum) and whatever the fuck Duck/Joey were doing, ironically enough.
We've definitely talked enough throughout the game for a clear read to be made.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Well, mostly because our interaction result in a spiral of shit conducive to not ever solving the game. We had two AFK's (at minimum) and whatever the fuck Duck/Joey were doing, ironically enough.
We've definitely talked enough throughout the game for a clear read to be made.
And because you think that, it's now fine for you to stop trying to act towny, am I correct in believing that?
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
That's how your post reads to me
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
"lol" doesn't help in progressing the game either. Makes one believe you'd like the current gamestate
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Kenny
"lol" doesn't help in progressing the game either. Makes one believe you'd like the current gamestate
I dont think any rational town likes the current gamestate. It's mostly kylo barring shenanigans.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Wew those drinks made me feel better
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
I don't think it's necessary to play any more mind games at this point to weed out scums, though I appreciate the sentiment.
I'd rather we maintain order and focus on just using the info we have to win this game. We've got 2/3 scums and it'll be ez asf.
If you do this again you're going to take major minus points, given you were annoyed at me for "stirring paranoia about Joey" yesterday (even tho I was fucking right)
I don't like this
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
I corrected my mistake. They said ducky.
Man I missed like half of what went down earlier lol. I get it all now
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
Let’s cut to the chase.
I am your [COLOR=][BOLD]F.B.I. Agent[/BOLD][/COLOR]
I checked Joey last night. He is [COLOR=][BOLD]NOT THE SERIAL KILLER[/BOLD][/COLOR]
I have ranked players on their towniness and made a makeshift lynch order. Feel free to give input, obviously.
(Tier A) Gyrlander – Gyrlander has shown an incredible degree of conviction regarding his reads, making it very difficult to imagine him as the Serial Killer. Furthermore, the exact configuration of his reads makes it difficult to imagine what mafia team he could even plausibly fit into. For example, if he were with BC, it would be very risky to maintain a hard townread on BC for so long when it looked very likely for a long while BC would be lynched. If his intention was backing BC, there would be no reason to townread me and Frinckles so hard. He’s also kept thick red reads on the newbies for effectively the entire game.
(Tier A) JoeyDX – Confirmed to not be the Serial Killer. I think we can also reasonably bet on him not being mafia, given how sincerely he seemed to believe in his (admittedly absurd) Frinckles/Banana team for 10 minutes. Even supposing he were were mafia, it’s difficult to imagine who his team member might be, given his interactions. The most plausible might be Kenny, and even that is very tenuous.
(Tier B) Bananacucho – Given the game, I feel less confident about my ability to give an objective read on this slot. A good portion of it is just based on my gut and feelings at this point. He certainly gives off the aura of an initially apathetic then eventually frustrated town, which he can probably fake, and he certainly has had a lot of “towny reactions”, which he could probably also fake. However, I’ll just say fuck it and trust the judgement of the other towns on this, both alive and deceased.
(Tier C) LuckyDucky – There is a lot of precedent for smurf accounts and COMs pretending to be newbies who do not believe in the foundations of scumhunting. That said, talking to him gave me the impression he probably doesn’t fall into this camp. It felt like he went to great lengths to try and make me see his perspective with the movie analogy.
Regardless, he is in my view the most likely candidate for serial killer after Michael and Kenny. His guess that Frinckles would not be a night hit was very suspicious, given he’s read the game and should be aware Frinckles is townread by effectively everyone, even if Frinckles is quite abrasive. A lot of his play, from accusing Joey of being SK to proposing the weird SK strategy could be interpreted as someone doing a bad job of distancing themselves from being SK.
(Tier D) Michael34 – Not much to say
(Tier D) Aamirus/Kenny – Not much to say
If we follow a lynching order like Michael -> Kenny -> Lucky -> BC, the only plausible scenario I can see where we lose is if BC and Duck are both scum (but not mafia together). That said, if we’ve got a day we may as well make the most of it. I imagine Kenny and Michael had defences planned and we may as well give them 24 hours to make those cases, at the very least.
Am I blind or are you leaving Pringles off
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
Am I blind or are you leaving Pringles off
Let me test your skills of rereading
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Sorry that I couldnt come back befofre EoD. I'm actually a bit I'll and went to sleep ASAP. Once I get up from my bed I'll assess the current situation but so far yzb IS FBI agent and Joey SK.
Kenny hasnt been convincing at all, aware that he's a liar.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Frinckles
Let me test your skills of rereading
I fell asleep last night doing it lol
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
But I assume that was yzbs last will
If lw is allowed this game
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
Weirder stuff has happened.
What's great tho is at this point I literally just need one person we can all agree is almost definitely town to take with me as my town core. I think Gyr and Frinckles do the job, choosing Gyr over Frinckles in a 2v1.
If you are proven to be agent, Gry+you is good
But we have to make sure it doesnt become 2v2 either
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
yeah. I was gonna write another post for if Joey is SK. The idea was if Frinckles died there'd probably be a lot of hysteria so I'd open day 2 with this "boom boom, this is what we're gonna do" and kinda restore morale lol. I wrote this one then couldn't be bothered to write the other scenario.
You were gonna reveal as agent even if you didnt get a guilty check? Why?
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
If you are proven to be agent, Gry+you is good
But we have to make sure it doesnt become 2v2 either
Kenny is almost certainly maf tho, so we only need a towncore of 2.
Also it's not a lw it was just something I wrote hypothetically for a different scenario where Frinckles was killed and Joey was not SK. I only posted it because I was asked for it.
I was shocked that Frinckles wasn't the night kill given how much power he has over the game. Even if you're SK and you have Frinckles' townread right now, eliminating that source of order has so many more benefits than killing a potential scapegoat for SK like michael
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
You were gonna reveal as agent even if you didnt get a guilty check? Why?
As the investigator I've gotta make sure I'm in a position where I'm not popular enough to be night killed but not disliked enough to be lynched. There was a major risk of failing on both of those fronts, especially if Frinckles got killed lol.
Also by revealing I presumably would have been able to take command of the game, bring order and line up the lynches optimally after my n2 death.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
I'm not even being sarcastic that SK read on Joey was basically play of the game. I borderline sheeped your judgement with my investigation XD
So
This right here is basically making my gut believe you more lol. You could be manipulating me, and if you're magia fakeclaiming this I dont understand the play but its so fucking mvp if it wins you the game lol
Ill vote to lynch Joey today
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
yzb25
As the investigator I've gotta make sure I'm in a position where I'm not popular enough to be night killed but not disliked enough to be lynched. There was a major risk of failing on both of those fronts, especially if Frinckles got killed lol.
Also by revealing I presumably would have been able to take command of the game, bring order and line up the lynches optimally after my n2 death.
Explain to me what you did day 1 to make yourself unpopular enough to not be night killed
Cause from pringles pov you were practically an untouchable jesus
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
I've checked and Joey doesn't appear to have discussed with Michael and actually kept him as a null read. We need to think clearly about this.
@JoeyDX
Please come here to tell us your point of view.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
@Kenny
Please tell us why the hell would you check the Duck.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
BananaCucho
Explain to me what you did day 1 to make yourself unpopular enough to not be night killed
Cause from pringles pov you were practically an untouchable jesus
I kinda tried to hang back a little and let Pringles be the main character for the night kill, but I admit I didn't excercise enough self-control in getting involved in fights lol.
Also, aside from Pringles I don't think anyone really hard-townread me. I think I did an okay job
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
LuckyDucky
I don't see any way that sprinkles can be town with the things that he posts I just can't.
Hes likely mafia
I know you wanna lynch mafia over sk but if we mislynch a town we lose if sk hits another town, and sk knows which one of yzb or kenny is agent, so he will
We have to lynch sk today
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
It's clear that if we don't do it correctly today the SK will kill a citizen, most likely me (as I seem to be the most Town read person). That would result in a 2 v 2 v 1 in which Town has basically no chance of winning.
I'm stating the obvious, but I want to order my thoughts and see that my life is at risk :o
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Fuck I was hoping I could convince Joey town wants to work with him and make him confess. I was gonna FPS so hard dammit lol
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Yeah it's basically obvious yzb is the real FBI. Kenny isn't putting any effort to this except for the claim because he knows they are screwed.
Also, what a coincidence that Kenny ALSO found the SK. I don't know, I consider it very unlikely.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
We can have Lucky as the third confirmed Town if Joey flips SK. It's inconceivable he would bus his team mate with a FBI claim.
-
Re: S-FM 294 (Ladder) : Undercover - Game Thread
Idk, this game is basically over for me.