SilentMadara 1-S2-1-5412838

[Tiffangel]

Account Name: SilentMadara
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5412838
In-Game Name: Orlando Bucciarati

Crimes Committed: Racism, trolling and toxic

Your Account Name: Tiffangel
Summary: He refused to claim after being voted and got super mad for getting lynched

[Arrow]

SC ID VERIFICATION
1-S2-1-5412838 is Correct.


Respective Hotkey:

1

Previous Offenses:

2x WL for Racism, and 6x WL before that for racism

Key Points:
Players in question:

SilentMadara - "Orlando Bucciarati" - DOCTOR - 9

Game:


Setup: A repick sees "Playwizdiots" who makes a SILENT NIGHT game.
Names: None.
Roles: None.
D1: 9 sets a LW of healing 8.
N1: Party time! 9 heals 8. He switches to 13. Kills: MAFIA.
D2: 2 (ENCHANTRESS) is dead. Carol was 5/4/8. 8 is put to trial. He claims CAROLER who doesn't understand how it works. He is released 9-3. (9 voted to convict). 5 to trial. Released 7-2 on a JESTER claim. 4 to trial. BODYGUARD claim gets Kira released 6-3. 9 voted again to convict. 9 to trial. He goes down 8-0 on a roleless defense, claiming he wasn't on the carol. But the caroler claimed he didn't give a carol...so somewhere there's a bunch of lies. In any case, he's down and flips DOCTOR. He does use a bit of strong language, including a slur, during trial.
N2: 9 is dead. Party time! Kills: VIGILANTE, VIGILANTE, MAFIA.
D3: 15 (CAROLER), 6 (WITCH) and 7 (PARTY HOST) are all dead. After deliberation and vote stalling between 1 and 5, the CONSTABLE reveals as 3 and kills 1. Flip is LOOKOUT. 4 to trial. He goes down on a BODUGUARD claim and flips GODFATHER. Calls out 11 and 13 as he dies. Neither is scum.
N3: Kills: VIGILANTE, VIGILANTE, MAFIA.
D4: 8 (MAFIOSO), 12 (CAPOREGIME), and 5 (VIGILANTE) are all dead. An AMNESIAC converts to a DOCTOR. This leaves 4 town opposing an ARSONIST. 10 to trial, released 3-1. 13 to trial, released, 3-0. 11 to trial, convicted 3-0. Flip is ARSONIST. Game ends with a TOWN win.

Was the game result altered?
Nah. He was doomed.

Player Offenses:

SLurs

Recommended Actions:

2x banlist

Additional Notes:
Thank you for the report!

[SilentM]

In game I'm banned for racism and griefing? But I've watched the replay and I did not grief or use racism. There is no obligation to give a role so not giving one isn't griefing and in this case it was even justified because I was not named in carol. Also where was the racism? Someone else used the N word claiming to be black and i only use it to address what he is saying. I have read the appeal instructions here and understand that if my appeal is found to be frivolous, staff may double my punishment.

-Silent

[Arrow]

Appeal noted, we'll get this handled.

[MrMostache]

In game I'm banned for racism and griefing? But I've watched the replay and I did not grief or use racism. There is no obligation to give a role so not giving one isn't griefing and in this case it was even justified because I was not named in carol. Also where was the racism? Someone else used the N word claiming to be black and i only use it to address what he is saying. I have read the appeal instructions here and understand that if my appeal is found to be frivolous, staff may double my punishment.

-Silent

The slur that you were punished for is "f*gs". It's not racist, but it's on our list of toxic offensive words.

[SilentM]

The slur that you were punished for is "f*gs". It's not racist, but it's on our list of toxic offensive words.

Ok I accept it is on the list, but 2x BL is extreme. The punishment should fit the crime. Especially taking into account I only used the word in anger and my previous two offenses happened over the course of what, 10 years?

Also imo people should not get BL unless they commit the offense while on a WL.

[MrMostache]

As long as you accept it, we can reduce it to a WL.
Arrow

[SilentM]

As long as you accept it, we can reduce it to a WL.
Arrow

I already did accept it is on your list of toxic words.
Also why did the guy who used the n word not get punished and I was banned when I'm not even on any watchlist.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-5412838 : 2x WL with time served. Appeal successful.