Player Notes

[Victoria]

This is a thread for storing our notes on other players. I look forward to this day, as it should be the most informative Day 1 of all time...

[Mr. Hat]

Here are my notes so far:


Gerald
- is either stupid or playing stupid (figure out his forum account to see if he's playing

stupid or not)
- Wants to be mayor
- Has a few typos (that I think are on purpose)
- Seen things no man has seen (lookout claim?)
- Member of lots of groups (could someone who knows more about West Side Story think about

who has been in lots of groups and what role FT would give that character?)
-Work in a shop (smith or something?)
- Wants people to read between the lines of his second post
- Thinks that Jimmy is stupid
- Will step out of the race if people don't change their minds on this
- Semi steps out of the mayor race
- Is stupid about his nomination location

Ned
- Is semi-scum baiting and asks "who wants to be mayor?"
- Nominates McDaniels when McDanieals didn;t really want it
- Changes settings (perhaps he is one of the people who prefer to see 50 posts per page)
- "nominates" Gerald with someone with an "idea" (I use the quotes because idk if it counted)
- wants to nominate someone who posts with substance
- Is glad that he has two nominations

Mcdaniels
- semi troll post to fade out of teh spotlight of posting in the first page
-Thinks False is to blame for him/her not getting the first post in
- Suggests (without subtlety) that stan is voting up one of his/her mafia teammate
- Is semi trolled by Timmy's semi troll scum hunting then semi trolls Timmy by using French
- Semi troll post and Nominates Tweek Tweak
- Claims to be able to help the town
- only other worthy candidate is Tweek Tweak
- "I can scum hunt. I'm not arrogant"
- Implies that someone will kill Tweek Tweek
- Claims that Butters isn't the better choice over McDaniels
- "Butters is scum"

Timmy (keeping notes on us so that if we're ever asked to give our notes we don't have to

scramble to write something up fast that could end in disaster)
-Troll post to not seem out of the spotlight
-Troll nomination to "help out" the new, stupid kid
- doesn't think he's good enough to be mayor (possible clue into his role? citizen maybe)
- Semi Troll scum hunts through the use of spanish
- Changes his nomination to Kyle because kyle is a jew
- Thinks that Butters is Luna
- Wants to know what qualities a good mayor should have
1 Intelligence
2 Citizen
3 or a PR (thinks that there should be a protection role)
- suggests to check the mayor on night 2
- Agrees with Big Gay Al that the forum identity should matter
- Says that COM accounts matter because the player needs to have proven to be a good player
- Learn a lot from who wants to be mayor and who doesn't
- Read/knows the rules

Kyle
- is a jew
- semi troll post
- wants to be mayor but only gives the reason that he is a jew as good enough
- Is really trying to get mayor through being a jew
- Wants to be mayor
- Wants jimmy's nomination
- Replies to Liane's concerns about no doc/bg saying that other people would be of more

interest to the mafia
- Nominates Butters for no reason other than someone else did
- Still is using the "I'm a jew, vote me!" way of getting elected
- tries to play the stupid kid (but he's a jew and jews are smart :P)
- Still trying the stupid kid by saying the Gerald uses big words
- Says he would be a good mayor, because he is "straight-forward"
- will say "you bastards" if someone kills Kenny
- Uses troll logic to say that Jimmy is mafia
- Uses South Park to "prove" that he's not in the mafia
- Answers for FT about lynching on day 1

Stan
- needs to proof read his post (personal belief is that he is doing that on purpose)
- Wants us to elect citizens and have them suicide (not good for town imo)
- Warns people not to get him angry
- Trolls about being in scientology with cartman, Kenny, and Kyle and wanting their

ventrilloquist double elected
- Wants a PR to "proof" itself
- Random reasons to nominate someone don't make sense but people still use them
- Still wants someone to reveal their role
- sees no problem with this
- after responses he asks a citizen to claim
- thinks that it is a 1/3 chance of nominating scum to mayor (he forgets that this isn't a

game of numbers, but a game of deception)
- reminds people that there could be a ventrilloquist
- Says that Chef and Shelley aren't adding to the discussion
- Says that one team has a ventrilloquist from Clyde's list of players
- Is worried that the smurf might be elected
- Nominates Craig
- Says that people will be repelled by Tweek Tweak's arrogance

Jason
-seems to not want people to analyze a troll post so he gives a semi troll post that's

actually a troll post
-Troll scum hunting
- Wouldn't mind being mayor
- Tries to get people to stop nominating him by mispelling "ignorant"
- Says that Jimmy is scummy
- Thinks Gerald gave a good speech
- Fixes his nomination
- still plays the stupid kid
- Uses a word that no idiot would correctly use (hackneyed)
- Semi troll scum hunts Butters against Prof Chaos
- Proof reads Gerald's second speech
- After a "closer look" he decides that Gerald is stupid
- Stupid speech
- Implies that Jimmy is tunnel-vision'ing Jason
- Doesn't like that south park is messing with the game (sort of)
- ignores theme and nominates Mr. Hat

Big Gay Al
- Wants someone to reveal his/her identity so that he will nominate that person
- Says that the mafia could be voting their buddies up with "theatrics"
- Wants some real reasons to nominate someone
- Wants someone to reveal their forum identity
- Asks Clyde to stop rabble rousing and come up with a plan
- Is wary about role claims that can't be proven

Sharon
- Wonders about the benefits of mayor in a troll post
- Nominates Butters to get Butters to "man up"

Shelley
-Troll post
- Troll post with a no-reason nomination
- Says that no one is informed on day 1 (you could say that about US voting any day)
- Troll post
- Says that only AFTER the fact can anything be learned from day 1
- Agrees with Stan that a role that can "proof" itself would be good for mayor
- Still thinks that people are uninformed about choices
- has an execption to that: mob
- Will random nominate and random vote because the numbers are on his/her side
- Says that there will be flaws in any method we use to elect the mayor

Sheila
- Trolling
- Trolling
- Nominates Big Gay Al
- Trolls
- Unnominates Big Gay Al
- More trolling

Liane
- Trolls with the "$" sign
- Warns about random nominations being almost the same as random lynches
- Thinks there is little point to a mayor without doctors/bodyguards
- Is trolled by Sheila
- Agrees with Clyde that Gerald is stupid
- Wants a mayor that everyone can trust
- Distrusts random nominators
- THinks that Clyde is smart, nominates him
- Suggests that someone will kill Kenny by night 2
- Implies that he nominated the lesser of the evils (too much RPing)
- seems to want to lynch someone on day 1
- Thinks that Clyde is smart
- Thinks that Bebe is trolling
- Reposts Mr. Hat's suggestion for Mayor candidates as it's a good idea (ahem)

Jimmy
- Greets us in german
- says that his nomination is an honor (he is european, he spelled it "honour")
- semi troll scum hunts against Jason
- Uses a south park reference for scum hunting
- Nominates Butters because of Prof Chaos
- "Misreads" Geralds comments about him (Jimmy)
- Places suspicion on player with long, thought-out speeches
- Doesn't like how sheila is using the garbled type
- Is thinking of ways to find the smurf
- Claims that the orange text isn't good

Butters
- Wants to nominate someone but would be grounded if he did (Hmm)
- barely claims investigator
- Is alright with being Mayor
- Plays on Prof. Chaos by saying that "where I go, destruction will follow"
- Nominates Jimmy
- Doesn't know what hackneyed is
- Troll "I want mayor" post
- Plays on the Prof Chaos thing again

Jimbo
- Jimbo plays dumb
- Jimbo semi claims bus driver (IDK whether to believe this or not)
- Jimbo wants to wait for someone else to come along (mafia bud?)
- Jimbo does not like Gerald because violence is good
- "Nominates" Jimmy because "name is nice"
- Corrects nomination fail
- More on the bus thing
- Jimbo stares at Mrs. Claridge (lol)
- Jimbo nominates Butters because Butters is hero and hero is good

Clyde
- Calls Gerald out for his seeming stupidity
- Says that Gerald would not make a good mayor
- Doesn't need to think because he is cute (right...)
-Implies that he would make a good leader with a troll reason
- Points out that people aren't following FT's wants by not putting in their nominations in

their signatures
-Says that he will rid the city of crime by using an alter ego
- Random nominates Craig (are we sure its random?)
- Thinks that Gerald doesn't like cripples
- "agrees" with whatever Kenny said
- Says that when someone gives a good reason then the nominations will flood in
- Says he's lucky that he got a "sane" character
- Wants to be helpful with the tally
- Doesn't think that COM accounts would be good to reveal (NEW KID!)
- Thinks they add bias
- "If I were a mod/respected member and I got GF, I would go for mayor"
- Misread the rules (definitely a new kid)
- Is waiting for a role claim
- Says that someone with more experience would be a better Mayor than he would (ahem, that's

what he was arguing against lol)
- Wants a role claim for information (if its a lie or what not)
- Says his nomination of Craig was a joke
- Wants Randy to keep trolling
- Blames the theme for the randomness that goes about
- Says that using Bebe's plan is like cheating
- Nominates Tweek Tweak

Terrance
- Semi trolls about Philip's troll post about "aboot"
- Thinks that Jason is the least creepy of the people with Avatars
- "Nominates" Jason

Kenny
- Troll first post
- doesn't want people to kill Kenny for a joke
- Troll posts after that (mmmf etc.)
- Says that there is no set protection role so that revealing a PR would not be a good idea

Mrs. Claridge
- Doesn't want to be in the spotlight
- Acts shy (I think s/he is acting about this. Could be one of the vet players who likes to

do this)
- More on the shy thing
- The shyness gets on my nerves
- Still on the shy thing
- Puts it out there that she wants to be mayor
- nominates Kenny
- Thinks that Bebe is opps_ur_dead (I agree)
- Thinks that Tweek Tweak is JackofSpades (either jack or claw)
- Unvotes Kenny
- Nominates Tweek Tweak

Victoria
- Troll post

Mr. Hat (could you guys analyze my posts for me?)

Sharon
- Wants good rhetoric from Stan (I think he means grammar)
- Asks, trollingly, if Stan is mafia
- Supports Butters

Randy
- Troll post about Stan and Shelly being "grounded"
- Uses them reasons for him wanting to be mayor

Bebe
- Has a plan that would break the game
- Says the rules don't say that you can't do that

Tweek Tweak
- Claims to be the best player
- Says that Wendy Testaburger was on the FM page during the night
- uses a semi parable
- Arrogant bastard
- Wants more votes
- claims he can use the information from his role as well as scum hunting
- Claims that he is the best player here
- He won't reveal his scum hunting skills
- Says that "you WILL vote for me"
- Agrees with Clyde that Gerald is stupid
- Nominates someone who he thinks won't be a candidate (Ned)
- Claims that he is not JackofSpades
- Implies that he is the best choice for Mayor
- Claims he knows what Barbrady is doing
- Says that if you aren't the best then you shouldn't apply for mayor

Chef
- agrees with Mr. Hat that Stan should proof read
- Nominates Mr. Hat because "he is a classy mofo" (damn right)
- States that Stan isn't helping because Stan hasn't nominated anyone yet
- and random is in the eye of the beholder
- Thinks that waiting for a PR to reveal is a "recipe for disaster"
- Says that Stan is not a good judge of ideas
- Troll application for mayor

Craig
- blames the theme for the madness
- nominates Butters
- Thinks that the nominations are random and based off of names
- Thinks that 2 players max will get nominated
- "Tweek Tweak makes me run away from him"

Barbrady
- Says that voting on day 1 is hard
- needs to decide who to nominate (leaning towards tweek tweak)
- Is repelled by Tweek Tweak's arrogance
- Nominates Butters

Towelie
- Wants to get elected
- Promises free towels (!)

Ike
- Claims he stays in a hotel in his troll post
- Troll post about retardz and genius rite?

Garrison
- WTF is this troll post? Mr. Slave and me would be very happy if you nominate us
- Wants to be elected

Philip
- Troll post
- Nominates Butters
- Uses the "$"
- Unnominates Butters
- Nominates Clyde

[Victoria]

Gerald
-Asks if anyone else thinks I'm scummy

Myself
-As far as I can tell, I've acted no scummier than anyone else today (correct me if I'm wrong)

Conclusion: Gerald might be the Shark's lover

[Timmy]

Yeah, but why would he focus on you? I have my own suspicions about who the lover is, and it's not him...

[Victoria]

Yeah it's probably not him, but I can't help but remember when Jack threw Shinra under the bus
in FM VII.... I shall not forget.

[Timmy]

By the way, lover, you should tell your partner to be a little less obvious. His last post confirmed my suspicion about who he is.

Don't worry, though. I don't think that it's in our best interest to kill you guys. I still like the plan of coordinating through you.

[Victoria]

My speculations so far...

Cartman: Ghost?
McDaniel: Jets (not lover)

I see what post you were talking about Timmy... It is a bit lazy on his part...

[Victoria]

Also, it's worth noting that Jimbo also guessed it before the massive slip up post...

[Timmy]

Yeah, I'm not quite sure what to make of Jimbo. He does some obviously dumb things, but then some of his posts are quite perceptive.

[Victoria]

Jimbo obviously isn't mafia, and he's demonstrated that he's a threat to us if we're not careful: I say we take him out ASAP. I doubt that he'll be getting doctor heals with a newly elected mayor, so I think we could get him tonight.

[Timmy]

That sounds pretty good to me, for now. What makes you think that McDaniel is a Jet?

[Victoria]

She is too.... agreeable (not counting Cartman). In my eyes, she's just siding with the majority and playing the part. Also, I didn't really see her as a strong town leader, yet she's been supported throughout this day. I dunno why, but I just have a 'feeling' about her that is kind of hard to explain. Of course, if she is a Jet, I'll see to it that she's nominated and elected...

[Mr. Hat]

So from my notes so far and my impressions of some of the players so far I have compiled a list of good kill targets for night 2.

Kyle - very scummy and I think he's in the Jets. Also a Jew.

Stan - Asking for a PR to reveal is not town play imho. That is why I think he is scum and possibly a Jet

Clyde - I don't see why people see him as trustworthy. He has a few slip ups that definitely pin him as mafia.

Chef - If we should kill a non-scummy player then Chef would be a good choice. He is observant (I AM a classy mofo) and he has a few gems of wisdom.

Gerald - He could very well be the Jets lover for the reasons that Victoria brought up. I think that Gerald played stupid in the begining for a reason because now he's not as stupid.

Concerns? Suggestions for kills?

[Timmy]

The question is: do we want to target town, or do we want to target potential mafia?

[Mr. Hat]

And what type of death note do we want? If we have one at all? Do we want it LiKE thIs? Do we want it to be regular type with a typo or two mixed in (to frame someone)?

I'm thinking we have a typo or two mixed in. My personal opinion but I like how that goes. (Rumpel for SK and Auckmid for Tiberius)

[Victoria]

So from my notes so far and my impressions of some of the players so far I have compiled a list of good kill targets for night 2.

Kyle - very scummy and I think he's in the Jets. Also a Jew.

Stan - Asking for a PR to reveal is not town play imho. That is why I think he is scum and possibly a Jet

Clyde - I don't see why people see him as trustworthy. He has a few slip ups that definitely pin him as mafia.

Chef - If we should kill a non-scummy player then Chef would be a good choice. He is observant (I AM a classy mofo) and he has a few gems of wisdom.

Gerald - He could very well be the Jets lover for the reasons that Victoria brought up. I think that Gerald played stupid in the begining for a reason because now he's not as stupid.

Concerns? Suggestions for kills?

Hmm.... I mostly agree with this list. However, did you ever get the chance to see Chef's slip-up? Check reply #531 (I do believe that Timmy and I were talking about the same post, but I suppose it never hurts to check). Also, I don't think that Gerald is a lover at all: I was suspicious and paranoid before because of his unprovoked attack on me, but he's added Kyle to that list and, since Kyle isn't part of the Sharks, he would have to be part of the Jets and that would be grounds for a modkill.

As for kills, I want to target townies. The way I see it, we could target the Jets, but that may come back to bite us if either the Lover or the Mafia event is triggered.... the town shall always be our enemy, but the Jets probably won't be (especially since FalseTruth's new rule makes it so that the most 'idealistic' way for mafia to merge is through the Lover event, where only the Lovers are guaranteed to lose). I think that Jimbo is still a good target, and we should obviously stay away from the mayor (I think it's actually in our best interests to leave the pardoner alone). The way I see it, if we can take out the logical ones, the town will descend into decay...

As for death notes, I'm up for whatever.....

I have no idea what Garrison is up to, but I don't like how Jason posted in day chat but didn't check in here (especially since he implied an extended leave of absence, possibly during elections which would get him modkilled). We have this chat during the day, and all of us need to be taking advantage of it.