DivineKiller: 1-S2-1-3439362, DivineEvil: 1-S2-1-1557527, DivineSparta: 1-S2-1-4777384

[MrHouse]

DivineKiller: 1-S2-1-629521, DivineEvil: 1-S2-1-1557527, Dork: 1-S2-1-3751608, DivineSparta 1-S2-1-4777384

Account Name: DivineKiller
Account ID: 1-S2-1-629521
In-Game Name: CaSino Saruman King

Account Name: DivineEvil
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1557527
In-Game Name: Gandalf the Lyncher

Account Name: Dork
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3751608
In-Game Name: Confirmed Dork

Account Name: DivineSparta
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4777384
In-Game Name: Gimli

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing (DivineKiller/Dork), possibly Skyping (All)

Your Account Name:MrHouse
Summary: I found a lead initially by roleblocking 6 on D1 (and got notification that it was unsuccessful). On the strength of that lead I led the charge against 6. Despite mounting evidence on the following days from a second escort (4), and a kill attempt by a vigilante (1), 11 (DivineKiller) refused to vote up 6 even as the auditor (10) did so as well.

On day 5, Dork also claims "we've had a majority since D3". Mafia had 3 people in it on day 3, to 6 town and 3 neutrals. That's not a majority without extra help, and on several votes 11 (DivineKiller) would have made the difference between a lynch and a pardon. Given the use of sharedclan tags by DivineKiller, DivineSparta, and DivineEvil, its not a stretch to imagine out of game communication occured here between these individuals and dork. Especially given 11's rather peculiar voting pattern and the willingness of Dork to "give [DivineSparta] the win" on day 6.

22464

[Mesk514]

SC ID VERIFICATION
DivineEvil - Correct: 1-S2-1-1557527
DivineKiller - Incorrect: 1-S2-1-629521 - Correct: 1-S2-1-3439362
DivineSparta - Correct: 1-S2-1-4777384
Dork - Correct: 1-S2-1-3751608

Respective Hotkeys
DivineEvil: 1
DivineKiller: 4
DivineSparta: 5
Dork: CTRL + 4

Was the Game Result altered?
game was unfair as multiple slots were run by the same person

Summary
DivineEvil(#2) roles Blackmailer - listed as new - under 15 games played
DivineKiller(#11) roles Veteran - under 15 games played
DivineSparta(#9) roles Arsonist - listed as new - under 15 games played
Dork(#6) roles Godfather - over 100 games played

Night 1:
#2 goes to blackmail #7 (role blocked)
#11 does nothing
#9 goes to douse #13
#6 goes to kill #3 (role block averted)

Day 2:
No lynch occurs

Night 2:
#2 goes to blackmail #7 (audited to Mafioso)
#11 stays on alert (kills no one)
*#9 receives multiple afk warnings*
#9 goes to douse #5 (role blocked and douses #4)
#6 goes to kill #12 (attacked but survived)

Day 3:
No Lynch occurs however #6 is being heavily pushed.

Night 3:
#2 goes to kill #7
*#11 receives multiple afk warnings*
#11 does nothing
#9 goes to douse #15
#6 does nothing (role block averted)

Day 4:
No lynch occurs

Night 4:
#2 does nothing
*#11 receives AFK warnings*
#11 stays on alert
#9 burns everyone doused (attacked but survived)
#6 goes to kill #10

Day 5:
#1 is lynched

Night 5:
#2 goes to kill #11
*#11 receives an AFK warning*
#11 goes on alert (kills #2)
#9 douses #8

Day 6:
#8 is lynched

Game ends with Arsonist win

Upon further review I do not think the Godfather (Dork#6) had anything to do with the coordinated slots, the only thing I would say on his part that was wrong was not fighting for his win at the end. However at this point the game was most certainly slanted.

On Night 5, originally #8 was supposed to be killed, when that was seen to not be happening, immediately after #11 was chosen for death #11 went on alert and #9 went to douse #8. This to me is an obvious example of coordination. None of these three voted with each other or at all for that matter until the end when it was needed.

DivineEvil seems to be a main account and the others seem to be smurfs.



Previous Offenses
DivineEvil:
(3 reports before 2014, all for cheating)
- Cheating (x3 KV) (http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/26990-(DivineEvil-1-S2-1-1557527)DivineSparta-1-S2-1-4777384-UltraGunner-1-S2-1-5518469?highlight=1-S2-1-1557527)

DivineKiller:
- None

DivineSparta:
- Cheating (x3 WL) (http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/26990-(DivineEvil-1-S2-1-1557527)DivineSparta-1-S2-1-4777384-UltraGunner-1-S2-1-5518469?highlight=1-S2-1-1557527)

Dork:
- None


Player Offenses
DivineEvil: Cheating
DivineKiller: Cheating & Smurf Account
DivineSparta: Cheating & Smurf Account
Dork: None

Recommended Action
DivineEvil: x2 BL *to be taken seriously if more accounts are made to cheat*
DivineKiller: PermaBan
DivineSparta: PermaBan
Dork: Ignored

Additional Notes
Thank you for your effort in trying to keep the game clean!

[MrHouse]

Thanks Mesk.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-1557527: 2x Banlist
1-S2-1-3439362: 2x banlist
1-S2-1-4777384: 2x banlist

[SonnyKay]

Told you i didnt cheat. Now get off my nuts in game please.