S-FM Matrix 2.0

[Unknown1234]

Welcome to S-FM Matrix 2.0. I wish you all luck, and if you have any questions ask me or your mentors.

Setup questions should be asked in green, with or without a @ ping with my account name.

51% of the votes are needed on someone in order for there to be a lynch.

Order of Operation (OoO):
1.) Consort Roleblock
2.) Mafia Night Kill
3.) Doctor Healing
4.) Sheriff Check

Win Conditions:
Town: Eliminate the Mafia and have one town member survive until the end of the game.
Mafia: Gain 50% of the votes.

Mechanics:
Lynches set to 51%.
Once someone reaches 51% of the votes, the player is lynched and the day ends.
Days are 48 hours, nights are 24 hours.
Last Wills are allowed. (Granted you send it to me before day/night ends)
Death Notes are not allowed.
Mafia have a night chat.
No Suicide.
Citizens do not win ties.

Rules:
No out of game communication.
Do not quote Private messages.
No off site links
English only.
No passworded spoilers.
No Editing posts.
No excessive personal attacks.
No threatened or fake game-throwing.
Have fun.

Citizen:

You had previously believed you were a Mayor. It was only until you stopped dreaming that you discovered your real role: A Citizen!


You have no special abilities other then to vote.

Doctor:


Target one player at night, saving them from death.

-You and your target will not know if they were attacked.

Sheriff:


Target one person at night, learning their alignment.

Result: Town or Mafia.

Consort:


Target one person at night, preventing them from completing their night action.

-Your target will not know they are roleblocked.

-You cannot perform the night kill and roleblock in the same night.

-You share a night chat and night kill with the Mafioso.

Mafioso:


-You share a night chat and night kill with the Consort.

Living Players:
Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill
Funce
Never Unlucky
XDarkDragonDX
Spruance
Chapdat
Eggy

Dead Players: N/A

Roles List:
Sheriff
Doctor
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Consort
Mafioso

On that note:
5

Time until day's end:
http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?iso=20160802T1411&p0=250&msg=Time+Until+Day%27s+end.&font=cursive

[Spruance]

First :D

Funce

[Never Unlucky]

"No Editing posts.
No excessive editing posts."

Legit.

[Spruance]

Do we know how many mafia there are?

[Unknown1234]

"No Editing posts.
No excessive editing posts."

Legit.

Sorry, meant to write no excessive personal attacks. Will edit now.

[Never Unlucky]

No one expects the Spanish inquisition.

XDarkDragonDX

[Unknown1234]

Do we know how many mafia there are?

Sorry about that, Fixed!

[Eggy]

[Vote]BigBallsMcGG

[Eggy]

BigBallsMcGG lets see how big your balls really are

[XDarkDragonDX]

Never Unlucky, why you defend Spruance?

[Never Unlucky]

Do we know how many mafia there are?

I liked that you asked this question. Mafia already know who their teammates are, I highly doubt they'd have asked this.

Early town-read on Spruance.

Spruance, what are your thoughts on the consort role?

[Never Unlucky]

Never Unlucky, why you defend Spruance?

Tell me how I'm defending Spruance, sir. I can't see where your coming from.

[Spruance]

I liked that you asked this question. Mafia already know who their teammates are, I highly doubt they'd have asked this.

Early town-read on Spruance.

Spruance, what are your thoughts on the consort role?

Well mafia is likely to want to kill whoever they suspect to be doctor or sheriff and it is unlikely that they will have two strong suspects so the consort shouldn't be much of an issue as long as there are 5 citizens alive.

[XDarkDragonDX]

Townies listen,

We should look at the people who votes up, because if someone is lynched, the night starts and thats what the mafia want.

[XDarkDragonDX]

Tell me how I'm defending Spruance, sir. I can't see where your coming from.

I typed -vote Spruance but it didn't appear ugh.

[Never Unlucky]

Townies listen,

We should look at the people who votes up, because if someone is lynched, the night starts and thats what the mafia want.

So you're saying that town doesn't want to lynch to end the day? Explain.


I typed -vote Spruance but it didn't appear ugh.

PLAYER NAME.

[Never Unlucky]

I typed -vote Spruance but it didn't appear ugh.

PLAYER NAME [/Vote ] Minus the "space between the bracket and "vote".

[Vote]XDarkDragonDX

[XDarkDragonDX]

So you're saying that town doesn't want to lynch to end the day? Explain.



PLAYER NAME.

No, I said that the mafia want to Lynch so the night begins and thats what the mafia wants.

[Never Unlucky]

No, I said that the mafia want to Lynch so the night begins and thats what the mafia wants.

What does the town want then? Wouldn't they want to lynch who they think is scum too?

[XDarkDragonDX]

What does the town want then? Wouldn't they want to lynch who they think is scum too?
At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies.

[Funce]

Hi everyone!!!
I look forward to playing with you all.

You wanna go?
Spruance

[XDarkDragonDX]

Also
Never Unlucky

[Never Unlucky]

At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies.

If this is your plan for day 1, you're lost. A townie should look to get what we call "reads" on other players and pressure who they think is scum. In this setup, town doesn't have a killing TPR, so lynches are the only way of eliminating the scum. We can't afford to wait until the scum "are too impatient to lynch", it just isn't going to come by itself. Besides, mafia have a night kill. They won't ever be impatient to lynch as they can result to their killing advantage. Town needs to be the proactive one to pressure the scum and have them slip.

What are your thoughts on this?

[Never Unlucky]

Hi everyone!!!
I look forward to playing with you all.

You wanna go?
Spruance
What does a person with 9 rep power and 454 posts do in a "Beginners' Game"?

[XDarkDragonDX]

If this is your plan for day 1, you're lost. A townie should look to get what we call "reads" on other players and pressure who they think is scum. In this setup, town doesn't have a killing TPR, so lynches are the only way of eliminating the scum. We can't afford to wait until the scum "are too impatient to lynch", it just isn't going to come by itself. Besides, mafia have a night kill. They won't ever be impatient to lynch as they can result to their killing advantage. Town needs to be the proactive one to pressure the scum and have them slip.

What are your thoughts on this?

Ok, if town starts to Lynch a random player and then the random player is the doctor?, Mafia will know who's the doctor, so it's so dumb to start voting without a lead.

[XDarkDragonDX]

What does a person with 9 rep power and 454 posts do in a "Beginners' Game"?
Defending Spruance again?

[Funce]

What does a person with 9 rep power and 454 posts do in a "Beginners' Game"?

Excuse you. I happen to like it here.

[Funce]

Anyhow. The DarkDragon is coming off a little fake to me.

[Never Unlucky]

Ok, if town starts to Lynch a random player and then the random player is the doctor?, Mafia will know who's the doctor, so it's so dumb to start voting without a lead.

First things first, this isn't mod mafia, there is no randoming. If you vote a player after the RVS, it's because they appear scummy in your eyes or because you want to pressure them. There is no "Trial" unlike mod mafia. When a player gets the amount of votes needed to be lynched, they are lynched immediately, day ends.

Second, if the doctor has enough votes to the point where he should role-claim, it's because he's slipped somewhere, he's said something scummy. It really isn't dumb voting for him in that case. If you're town, you shouldn't slip.

Third, this is Forum mafia. The game is based around dialogue, not night actions. There is a reason why days last 48 hours and nights 24 hours... We won't wait for a "lead" like you say. It may never come by, and we won't rely on RNG to win the game. We have to be proactive, and get to the scum ourselves.

Do you have a mentor?

[Never Unlucky]

Defending Spruance again?

Please explain how I'm defending Spruance.

Minotarr, I see you lurking in the thread. What are your thoughts on Dragon and me so far? How do you read us both?

[Never Unlucky]

Anyhow. The DarkDragon is coming off a little fake to me.

What don't you like about his posts?

What do you think of me?

[Funce]

Please explain how I'm defending Spruance.

Minotarr, I see you lurking in the thread. What are your thoughts on Dragon and me so far? How do you read us both?

Seems to me like you seemed to go after the people voting Spruance. That's why he said that. Took me a bit to get it.

[Funce]

What don't you like about his posts?

What do you think of me?

The tone of his posts feel off. They wording looks forced. Could be the non-native-speaking English though.

Can I hold off on talking about you?

[Never Unlucky]

Seems to me like you seemed to go after the people voting Spruance. That's why he said that. Took me a bit to get it.

I don't see how this could be true. I voted Dragon without him going after Spruance.

Also, why are you speaking on Dragon's behalf?

[Funce]

Ah Spain. That would explain it. I would like him to explain himself though.

[Funce]

I don't see how this could be true. I voted Dragon without him going after Spruance.

Also, why are you speaking on Dragon's behalf?

I voted Spruance. I have no idea what the first lot of defending Spruance was all about.
Dragon isn't here. I'd like to keep the ball rolling.

[Never Unlucky]

The tone of his posts feel off. They wording looks forced. Could be the non-native-speaking English though.

Can I hold off on talking about you?

Why wouldn't you want to talk about me right now? Is there something else you want to talk about?

[Funce]

What do you think about Dragon being aware of Spruance like that?
Do you think it's paranoia? Or just easy pickings.

[Funce]

Why wouldn't you want to talk about me right now? Is there something else you want to talk about?

I want to focus on dragon a bit more.
It's probably not healthy.

[Never Unlucky]

What do you think about Dragon being aware of Spruance like that?
Do you think it's paranoia? Or just easy pickings.

I do not think he is aware of Spruance specifically. I think he's making an attempt to scum-hunt by looking for potential signs of buddying.

Why did you suggest paranoia? Why would someone be paranoid this early into the game?

[XDarkDragonDX]

Ok, this game is so boring, Im not typing anymore, Im going afk if you want lynche me, If you Lynch me send me a pm or something.

[Never Unlucky]

I voted Spruance. I have no idea what the first lot of defending Spruance was all about.
Dragon isn't here. I'd like to keep the ball rolling.


I want to focus on dragon a bit more.
It's probably not healthy.
Legit.

Giving your thoughts on me doesn't stop you from "focusing" on dragon. Besides, you weren't doing anything to pressure Dragon, so I don't know where the "focus on Dragon" is coming from.

Please explain.

[Chapdat]

-Vote XDarkDragonDX

[Minotarr]

Please explain how I'm defending Spruance.

Minotarr, I see you lurking in the thread. What are your thoughts on Dragon and me so far? How do you read us both?

I personally am unsure of how this game works so sorry if I mess up xD.

Thoughts on Never Unlucky: I get a slight scum-read on you personally NeverUnlucky. Although you did bring up a fair point against DarkDragon. When DarkDragon said: "At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies."

I do not believe that someone not voting day 1 means that they're scum but it means that they probably don't know how to or that they don't have enough of a lead on someone to actually give a valid reason on why they're voting. (btw I don't know how until you typed it out).

Although, DarkDragon did bring up a good point you seem to kind of be defending Spruance a little whenever someone decides to vote him up.

"I liked that you asked this question. Mafia already know who their teammates are, I highly doubt they'd have asked this.

Early town-read on Spruance.

Spruance, what are your thoughts on the consort role?"

You seem to be covering for him and trying to make him look like a member of the town.

Thoughts on DarkDragon: I am unsure of what DarkDragon is I have not come to a decision on whether or not I think he is mafia or town yet, I think that he's brought up a point that wasn't really that valid in my opinion.

For example when he said, "At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies."

This point doesn't really make much sense since the mafia would want to get a lynch on the first day since they want to get as many people out of the way as possible.

DarkDragon does bring up a fair point about you NeverUnlucky on how you're defending Spruance whenever someone decides to put a vote on him.

[Never Unlucky]

-Vote XDarkDragonDX

A) You didn't vote correctly. [Vote ] PLAYER NAME[/Vote ] is the way to vote.

B) Why are you voting Dragon without adding anything?

Do you have any thoughts on anything that was said?

[Never Unlucky]

I personally am unsure of how this game works so sorry if I mess up xD.

Thoughts on Never Unlucky: I get a slight scum-read on you personally NeverUnlucky. Although you did bring up a fair point against DarkDragon. When DarkDragon said: "At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies."

I do not believe that someone not voting day 1 means that they're scum but it means that they probably don't know how to or that they don't have enough of a lead on someone to actually give a valid reason on why they're voting. (btw I don't know how until you typed it out).

Although, DarkDragon did bring up a good point you seem to kind of be defending Spruance a little whenever someone decides to vote him up.

"I liked that you asked this question. Mafia already know who their teammates are, I highly doubt they'd have asked this.

Early town-read on Spruance.

Spruance, what are your thoughts on the consort role?"

You seem to be covering for him and trying to make him look like a member of the town.

Thoughts on DarkDragon: I am unsure of what DarkDragon is I have not come to a decision on whether or not I think he is mafia or town yet, I think that he's brought up a point that wasn't really that valid in my opinion.

For example when he said, "At the first day we should see who is impatient to lynch and he might be scum, Also it's first day, the mafia knows who is his teammate, but town didn't know who is mafia or other townies."

This point doesn't really make much sense since the mafia would want to get a lynch on the first day since they want to get as many people out of the way as possible.

DarkDragon does bring up a fair point about you NeverUnlucky on how you're defending Spruance whenever someone decides to put a vote on him.

tl;dr : NeverUnlucky makes good points, but defends Spruance.

Why do you interpret my question to Spruance as buddying? Why don't you do the same for my questions to you, Chapdat, Funce and Dragon? What is the difference between those?

How did I defend Spruance of Dragon? Is pressuring player X who voted player Y = defending player Y? Where did Dragon vote Spruance?

How was my reply to Funce's first post attacking Funce/defending SPruance rather than starting a conversation?

[Unknown1234]

Mesk514 is replacing XDarkDragonDX effective immediately.
Mesk514

[Mesk514]

YAH MOTHER FUCKERS, effective immediately i'm running this bitch

[Mesk514]

seriously tho

Funce

I disagree with what Funce was saying about Dragon seeming like he was forcing what he was saying.
I think what he said generally comes from a noob perspective.

Minotarr can you elaborate on why you think he point was no valid? Setup speculation is something that can be valuable in a game like this, also pointing out things for the greater good of town is very pro town thing to do

Just a heads up my friends, in case you don't know... I am Mesk, a law abiding civilian who always pays there taxes on time.

[Never Unlucky]

YAH MOTHER FUCKERS, effective immediately i'm running this bitch

Mesk! <3

What's going through your mind regarding this game?

[Mesk514]

Anyhow. The DarkDragon is coming off a little fake to me.

i very much dislike any statement that doesn't come with an explanation.

[Mesk514]

right now i have a town noob lean on minotarr. I agree with what he's saying about you (NU) trying to cover up certain things for Spruance...

Spruance has come out strong with his setup speculation, when has Spruance ever came out strong with anything?


Again, Funce made a statement with no explanation... The only game I've played with Funce he was scum and he did something to a similar effect.

[Funce]

Ugh. Mesk.

Fine. Such a lack of imagination.

[Mesk514]

Ugh. Mesk.

Fine. Such a lack of imagination.

me? lack of imagination....?

I imagine us in bed together and I being super bored.

give me ideas that would make me think otherwise.


let me see you spice up this game.

[Minotarr]

seriously tho

Funce

I disagree with what Funce was saying about Dragon seeming like he was forcing what he was saying.
I think what he said generally comes from a noob perspective.

Minotarr can you elaborate on why you think he point was no valid? Setup speculation is something that can be valuable in a game like this, also pointing out things for the greater good of town is very pro town thing to do

Just a heads up my friends, in case you don't know... I am Mesk, a law abiding civilian who always pays there taxes on time.

I thought that the point wasn't valid because it doesn't really make much sense to me how someone who doesn't choose to vote is possibly mafia since the mafia would want to get rid of as many people as possible in the shortest amount of time.

[Mesk514]

-Vote XDarkDragonDX

also.. hello friend, welcome to my town... How are you? Care to join in the conversation?

[Mesk514]

I thought that the point wasn't valid because it doesn't really make much sense to me how someone who doesn't choose to vote is possibly mafia since the mafia would want to get rid of as many people as possible in the shortest amount of time.

hmm, perhaps i misunderstood what he was saying then... I think he was getting to the point that scum may be less reluctant to throw a vote anywhere as throwing a vote anywhere can be perceived as a scum thing and thats something scum would want to avoid.

It's called WIFORM (Wine In Front Of Me)

[Mesk514]

dammit, try to teach people things and i can't even get it right...

it's called WIFOM***

[Never Unlucky]

I thought that the point wasn't valid because it doesn't really make much sense to me how someone who doesn't choose to vote is possibly mafia since the mafia would want to get rid of as many people as possible in the shortest amount of time.

You've only been posting when you've been pinged by me or the Mesk. You are showing a lack of initiative, and it could be a scum tell.
me? lack of imagination....?

I imagine us in bed together and I being super bored.

give me ideas that would make me think otherwise.


let me see you spice up this game.

+2 rep. Your posts are gold.

[Mesk514]

You've only been posting when you've been pinged by me or the Mesk. You are showing a lack of initiative, and it could be a scum tell.

+2 rep. Your posts are gold.

oh shit... +2 rep... that's a step up from the +1 you gave me earlier...

[Never Unlucky]

oh shit... +2 rep... that's a step up from the +1 you gave me earlier...

Oi, I'd give you +10 if I could, but I'm still a pleb. How do you read me?

[Minotarr]

hmm, perhaps i misunderstood what he was saying then... I think he was getting to the point that scum may be less reluctant to throw a vote anywhere as throwing a vote anywhere can be perceived as a scum thing and thats something scum would want to avoid.

It's called WIFORM (Wine In Front Of Me)

This actually clears things up a little bit for me. It would be true that mafia would be more reluctant to throw a vote out since it will draw more attention to them in this beginner game which so far operates very differently from the mod in SC2 I guess the mafia would be trying to fly under the radar so they aren't as pressured as the people who are voting each other to get reads on one another.

[Mesk514]

Oi, I'd give you +10 if I could, but I'm still a pleb. How do you read me?

I already told you where I have you... You smell fishier than a Quebecois hoe on St-Jean Baptist. But that's because you're seemingly helping Spruance for no reason that I can come up with... unless you hard town read him for his 2 posts....

other than that I'm genuinely surprised you've seemed to step up your game. This is the beginners game, all about having fun and time to shine :D

[Mesk514]

This actually clears things up a little bit for me. It would be true that mafia would be more reluctant to throw a vote out since it will draw more attention to them in this beginner game which so far operates very differently from the mod in SC2 I guess the mafia would be trying to fly under the radar so they aren't as pressured as the people who are voting each other to get reads on one another.

Forum Mafia, while different from the mod has much less trolls and actually tests your ability to scum read. There are actually somethings you can pick up from playing Forum Mafia and apply to the mod, but because the mod is so trolly, theres not much you can take from the mod and apply here.

[Minotarr]

You've only been posting when you've been pinged by me or the Mesk. You are showing a lack of initiative, and it could be a scum tell.

I understand why you would think this is a scum tell because I am only replying when people are pinging me (good point btw). The reason that I am only replying when people are pinging me is because I don't understand this game works still and am just getting a feel for it by watching how others communicate and play. In the future I will be trying to be more involved in the conversation and getting out there more.

[Never Unlucky]

This actually clears things up a little bit for me. It would be true that mafia would be more reluctant to throw a vote out since it will draw more attention to them in this beginner game which so far operates very differently from the mod in SC2 I guess the mafia would be trying to fly under the radar so they aren't as pressured as the people who are voting each other to get reads on one another.

Scum sometimes lurk, sometimes don't. Some townies lie low too, so you can never tell someone's alignment from their activity.

That's exactly my point. We have to ping the ones who are lurking and pressure them to get reads on them too.

[Minotarr]

Scum sometimes lurk, sometimes don't. Some townies lie low too, so you can never tell someone's alignment from their activity.

That's exactly my point. We have to ping the ones who are lurking and pressure them to get reads on them too.

Well if that's the case then JamesChurchill

[Never Unlucky]

I already told you where I have you... You smell fishier than a Quebecois hoe on St-Jean Baptist. But that's because you're seemingly helping Spruance for no reason that I can come up with... unless you hard town read him for his 2 posts....

other than that I'm genuinely surprised you've seemed to step up your game. This is the beginners game, all about having fun and time to shine :D

"Hard town-read" is an overstatement. I think that his second post about setup is a question a townie would've ask. I doubt a mafia would've asked it. This is where my read comes from.

Yes, I've received some tips and tricks from Calix. I'm making steps towards being a town leader :D

Now, it'd be nice to see YOU step up your game.

[Mesk514]

Scum sometimes lurk, sometimes don't. Some townies lie low too, so you can never tell someone's alignment from their activity.

That's exactly my point. We have to ping the ones who are lurking and pressure them to get reads on them too.

You know never unlucky, i town read Minotarr for his town noobness. He reminds me of myself in my first game. i actually argued that for a beginners game a day 1 may be better to be skipped as opposed to everyone sheeping and placing an uneducated vote. I think since this is not my first game town has a better chance of not making an uneducated lynch.

I'm also curious as to where my buddy Eggy is?

Eggy where you at?


Chapdat
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill

[Never Unlucky]

I understand why you would think this is a scum tell because I am only replying when people are pinging me (good point btw). The reason that I am only replying when people are pinging me is because I don't understand this game works still and am just getting a feel for it by watching how others communicate and play. In the future I will be trying to be more involved in the conversation and getting out there more.
It's okay, buddy. I've been there. You'll slowly pick up the game mechanics and find the game much more enjoyable than mod mafia. Just give it some time.

I saw you were reading Island Conflict yesterday. Were you just trying to get a feel for the game? What do you think of Forum mafia so far?

You're a mod player? What's your Bnet name? I don't recall seeing a Minotarr... (I play in the NA realm)

Well if that's the case then JamesChurchill

"Here's a pressure vote" won't pressure anyone.

[Mesk514]

"Here's a pressure vote" won't pressure anyone.

what are you getting at buddy?

[Never Unlucky]

You know never unlucky, i town read Minotarr for his town noobness. He reminds me of myself in my first game. i actually argued that for a beginners game a day 1 may be better to be skipped as opposed to everyone sheeping and placing an uneducated vote. I think since this is not my first game town has a better chance of not making an uneducated lynch.

I'm also curious as to where my buddy Eggy is?

Eggy where you at?


Chapdat
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill

I have the same read on him though it's much more nuanced than just "noob town". He needs people to ping him for him to contribute, he sheeped Dragon's point of me "defending Spruance" (YOU DID TOO MESK, SHAME ON YOU) and I can see some scum-motivation behind him bringing up the Spruance defense point against me and painting me as scum by doing so.

I'm liking what I see of his personality too (Not game related, but better be said than kept for myself). He sounds cute, don't you think?

[Never Unlucky]

what are you getting at buddy?

I'm just telling Minotarr that the manner of delivery of his vote won't have any effect on Unknown's brother. In the context of his post, he's saying "Here's a pressure vote" rather than "I want to hear more from you, what are your thoughts on X?"

Call me out for coaching, I'm just trying to help a friendly noob in need.

[Mesk514]

He sounds cute, don't you think?

I'm sorry I'm taken, I don't really like to use SC2Mafia as my personal dating site... unless Duck comes back with a proposal, but that's off topic... anyways


regards to me sheeping with the opinion that you're defending Spruance, that's not really sheeping that's more agreeing with the obvious.

[Mesk514]

I'm just telling Minotarr that the manner of delivery of his vote won't have any effect on Unknown's brother. In the context of his post, he's saying "Here's a pressure vote" rather than "I want to hear more from you, what are your thoughts on X?"

Call me out for coaching, I'm just trying to help a friendly noob in need.

My initial thought isn't that you're trying to coach someone, more befriend someone....

[Minotarr]

It's okay, buddy. I've been there. You'll slowly pick up the game mechanics and find the game much more enjoyable than mod mafia. Just give it some time.

I saw you were reading Island Conflict yesterday. Were you just trying to get a feel for the game? What do you think of Forum mafia so far?

You're a mod player? What's your Bnet name? I don't recall seeing a Minotarr... (I play in the NA realm)


"Here's a pressure vote" won't pressure anyone.

Yes I am a mod player, I also was reading the Island Conflict yesterday because the game interested me and because Unknown1234 the host of this game told me that this was a lot of fun and yes I was getting a feel for it and it's pretty interesting.

I personally think this is a great community that'll take off when more mod players hear about it. I think that the forum mafia is a lot more complicated than I thought it would be and that hosting would be a lot of fun to do.

ALSO BRB I'M HUNGRY.

[Mesk514]

ALSO BRB I'M HUNGRY.

okay, when you come back... what do you think of NeverUnlucky trying to befriend you?

[Never Unlucky]

My initial thought isn't that you're trying to coach someone, more befriend someone....

I want to befriend him, yes, and I don't think it's game-related. (You and Eggy do similar things every game) You're insinuating that I want Minotarr to take my side (Town side) by befriending him, but it's not the case. I can see where you're coming from though.

[BigBallsMcGG]

[vote] Eggy You think you can face me? Me sa on vacation I sa back now.

[BigBallsMcGG]

How da fack do I vote jeebus christ I forget things

[Mesk514]

I want to befriend him, yes, and I don't think it's game-related. (You and Eggy do similar things every game) You're insinuating that I want Minotarr to take my side (Town side) by befriending him, but it's not the case. I can see where you're coming from though.

My comment wasn't an attack, more of trying to show the noob certain things to look out for. You say you're on Towns side but if you were to flip scum, this would be something he would want to look out for no?

As I understand your point, i hope you understand where I am coming from

[Never Unlucky]

How da fack do I vote jeebus christ I forget things

[Vote] PLAYER NAME [/Vote ] (I've said this 3x now..)

Is that all you have to say? Stuff has happened between the time Eggy voted you and now.

[Never Unlucky]

My comment wasn't an attack, more of trying to show the noob certain things to look out for. You say you're on Towns side but if you were to flip scum, this would be something he would want to look out for no?

As I understand your point, i hope you understand where I am coming from

Of course I understand, I don't have an extra chromosome like you say I have : )

[BigBallsMcGG]

Eggy Never Unlucky I thank you and I didn't think much of what everyone said. I shall go back and check

[Mesk514]

Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill
Funce
Never Unlucky
XDarkDragonDX
Spruance
Chapdat
Eggy




sup bitches

[BigBallsMcGG]

Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill
Funce
Never Unlucky
XDarkDragonDX
Spruance
Chapdat
Eggy




sup bitches

What an asshole amirite.

[Never Unlucky]

Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
JamesChurchill
Funce
Never Unlucky
XDarkDragonDX
Spruance
Chapdat
Eggy




sup bitches

How is this GIF representative of this community?

What did you think of Chapdat's vote?

[Mesk514]

What an asshole amirite.

me? asshole? never

more into foreplay first....

[Mesk514]

How is this GIF representative of this community?

What did you think of Chapdat's vote?

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL, half the males in this community are either Virgins because they have no social skills or they're literally intimidated by the presence of a woman... true story... don't understand why thats relevant tho


also, chapdats vote was random no? if it wasn't it warrants an explanation

[Never Unlucky]

LOLOLOLOLOLOLOL, half the males in this community are either Virgins because they have no social skills or they're literally intimidated by the presence of a woman... true story... don't understand why thats relevant tho


also, chapdats vote was random no? if it wasn't it warrants an explanation

There's more than just Unknown in this community, Mesk...

It might've been random, but it was casted in the context of me questioning Dragon, so I'm not sure. Chapdat, please clarify your vote.

Minotarr, you must've been REALLY hungry, eh?

[Minotarr]

okay, when you come back... what do you think of NeverUnlucky trying to befriend you?

I don't really think to much of NU trying to befriend me, I think that NU is trying to establish a friendship outside of the forum (maybe, maybe not) but I have taken notice of the friendship that is trying to be made here but rest assured I'm still keeping my eyes open. I'm looking for tell's that could possibly lead me to suspect there is scum among us.

Also, JamesChurchill what do you think so far about what has been going on in the game so far?

[Mesk514]

There's more than just Unknown in this community, Mesk...


your right, theres Gyrlander as well...

[Minotarr]

Chapdat I think we're all wondering the meaning behind your vote and all would like more clarification behind your vote because there is no reason you put forth for voting up Dragon.

[Mesk514]

I don't really think to much of NU trying to befriend me, I think that NU is trying to establish a friendship outside of the forum (maybe, maybe not) but I have taken notice of the friendship that is trying to be made here but rest assured I'm still keeping my eyes open. I'm looking for tell's that could possibly lead me to suspect there is scum among us.

Also, JamesChurchill what do you think so far about what has been going on in the game so far?

okay and what about Funce, he seems to have made a comment with no explanation than disappeared...

[Never Unlucky]

Unknown1234 You might want to remove Dragon's vote from my ass.

Chapdat

[Minotarr]

okay and what about Funce, he seems to have made a comment with no explanation than disappeared...

Very true, where did Funce go? Just voted against Spruance giving no reason behind it from what I can see.

Funce Do you mind explaining why you voted Spruance other than Spruance voting against you?

[Never Unlucky]

Eggy Never Unlucky I thank you and I didn't think much of what everyone said. I shall go back and check

Perhaps you want to share your reads with the town?

[BigBallsMcGG]

Perhaps you want to share your reads with the town?

My reads what do u mean what

[XDarkDragonDX]

unvote

[Never Unlucky]

Very true, where did Funce go? Just voted against Spruance giving no reason behind it from what I can see.

Funce Do you mind explaining why you voted Spruance other than Spruance voting against you?

His/her vote is not the suspicious part. All FM games start with a random vote stage, it is normal for Funce to vote Spruance this early on. The suspicious parts of his/her play so far is that he/she talked on Dragon's behalf and disappeared without answering my last questions (Could be due to RL, who knows).

Minotarr Why do you point out Funce's vote on Spruance but not Balls' vote on Eggy?

[Never Unlucky]

My reads what do u mean what

Reads are how you perceive other players based on what they say and how they act. In this setup you can town/null/scum-read others. Provide your reads so far with a bit of explanation for each read you make, please.

[Mesk514]

Reads are how you perceive other players based on what they say and how they act. In this setup you can town/null/scum-read others. Provide your reads so far with a bit of explanation for each read you make, please.

this should be for anyone BY THE WAY. If you place a vote on someone or would just in general like to point things out, its always best to give a read to support your evidence.

[Minotarr]

His/her vote is not the suspicious part. All FM games start with a random vote stage, it is normal for Funce to vote Spruance this early on. The suspicious parts of his/her play so far is that he/she talked on Dragon's behalf and disappeared without answering my last questions (Could be due to RL, who knows).

Minotarr Why do you point out Funce's vote on Spruance but not Balls' vote on Eggy?

I forgot to ask Bigballs tbh and I was not aware with the random vote stage.

BigBallsMcGG Why did you vote against Eggy?

Sorry didn't realize mesk replaced dragon whoops not paying close attention xD.

[Mesk514]

I forgot to ask Bigballs tbh and I was not aware with the random vote stage.

BigBallsMcGG Why did you vote against Eggy?

Also, XDarkDragonDX what do you think of how the game has progressed so far?

DarkDragon is no longer in the game, I have replaced him.

[Mesk514]

DarkDragon is no longer in the game, I have replaced him.

just so you know, it's forbidden to edit your posts during a game... you're knew so i'm sure all is forgiven, but just a heads up :)

[Never Unlucky]

just so you know, it's forbidden to edit your posts during a game... you're knew so i'm sure all is forgiven, but just a heads up :)

RIP Minotarr, you're getting modkilled anytime in the next 5 minutes.

[Minotarr]

RIP Minotarr, you're getting modkilled anytime in the next 5 minutes.

Oh, well I'm sorry everyone didn't mean to get myself killed first day lol my bad I'm such a noob.

[Unknown1234]

Oh, well I'm sorry everyone didn't mean to get myself killed first day lol my bad I'm such a noob.

Given that I have seen the original message and no harm was done, I will allow it this time. Please be mindful and make sure to read the rules =)

[Minotarr]

Given that I have seen the original message and no harm was done, I will allow it this time. Please be mindful and make sure to read the rules =)

Yeah I'll go back and read them again. Sorry for the mess up :L.

[Mesk514]

Yeah I'll go back and read them again. Sorry for the mess up :L.

it's okay dude, i did it my first game too... i even got an infraction for it... just be mindful next time...

[Minotarr]

it's okay dude, i did it my first game too... i even got an infraction for it... just be mindful next time...

Yeah I'll make sure to do that in future games lol.

[BigBallsMcGG]

His/her vote is not the suspicious part. All FM games start with a random vote stage, it is normal for Funce to vote Spruance this early on. The suspicious parts of his/her play so far is that he/she talked on Dragon's behalf and disappeared without answering my last questions (Could be due to RL, who knows).

Minotarr Why do you point out Funce's vote on Spruance but not Balls' vote on Eggy?

Dat asshole voted me up u cuck

[Never Unlucky]

Spruance
Minotarr
DarkDragon/Mesk
Funce
Chapdat
Unknown bro
Eggy
Balls

Scum-read / Null-read / Town-read

Here's where I'm standing at so far. That's kind of what I want to see when I ask for reads. Normally each read should be followed by an explanation, but I've already expressed my opinion on most of my reads in separate posts, so I'll take the lazy route.

Balls, Mino and Mesk, what would be your reads list like?

[Mesk514]

Dat asshole voted me up u cuck


ok since BigBallsMcGG here is gonna wear his anus on his face we should just ignore the fact that he voted Eggy because Eggy voted him...


is there anything you'd like to add besides the obvious I'm a bitch and you don't wear your anus on your face?

[Mesk514]

Spruance
Minotarr
DarkDragon/Mesk
Funce
Chapdat
Unknown bro
Eggy
Balls

Scum-read / Null-read / Town-read

Here's where I'm standing at so far. That's kind of what I want to see when I ask for reads. Normally each read should be followed by an explanation, but I've already expressed my opinion on most of my reads in separate posts, so I'll take the lazy route.

Balls, Mino and Mesk, what would be your reads list like?

Do you read me as scum because of Dragon?Me? a mix? I thought we were hitting it off pretty well actually...i'll get to my list in a moment.

[Never Unlucky]

Do you read me as scum because of Dragon?Me? a mix? I thought we were hitting it off pretty well actually...i'll get to my list in a moment.

I read you as null, but I lean-scum read Dragon because of his weird setup spec posts.

[Never Unlucky]

Mesk, you're not really trying to scum-hunt... heck, Mino is doing a better job at that than you. Nothing you've said pinged weird/scummy to me, so I have you as null for the moment.

[Minotarr]

Spruance
NeverUnlucky
Balls
Chapdat
Mesk
Funce
JamesChurchill
Eggy

I think Spruance is more town since he hasn't shown any signs thus far of being scummy but this could change further towards the end of the day.

I think NeverUnlucky is town because they've been putting some really good pushes on people including myself although NU did attempt to befriend this is what I am thinking at the moment.

I think Balls is leaning more towards mafia because he just flat out voted against eggy kind of aggravated towards the attention thrown to him.

I think Chapdat is null for now since he hasn't said much just voted.

I am still not sure about Mesk but the previous messages make me a bit confused or suspicious that Dragon sent.

Funce I am also not sure about but they just kind of up and left but I'm sure it must've been an RL problem that caused them to disappear so I have insufficient evidence to decide.

JamesChurchill,Eggy I don't have enough info to make a decision on whether they're town or mafia yet.

[Minotarr]

This is what my thoughts are at this moment in time although they could change towards the end of the first day.

[Mesk514]

okay, first of all i'm very blitzed right now so i apologize for any mistakes or miscommunication errors

Minotarr right now is my only hard town read. I see a lot of his questions and beginner ways coming from genuine new town.

Never Unlucky bothers me because he tried to befriend Minotarr and although thats not a bad thing could have alternative motives. I'm also rather confused as to why he has me marked as scum. He told me to step my game up and since i've seen he's done that i'm willing to do the same. I could go ranting on about how it's basic nature that i'm always town but i won't until I get super frustrated because at this moment I have high hopes for this game . Never Unlucky coming to Spruance defence isn't what bothers me. It's his explanation of "a scum wouldn't ask that question" that bothers me. While I can agree it was Spruance's first post, sometimes setup speculation is a scum way of directing the way the conversation starts.

With Spruance, he may have RL issues to attend to but I would have liked a follow up to his setup speculation. It's one thing to make a comment and then make an elaborate point about it, but I see Spruance's comment to more be stating out the obvious, which to me is what a scum member would do. I also think his comment was a little too "smart" to come from Spruance. He definitely hasn't started this game like he has every other. Then again he could be stepping his game up like us NU?

Funce came, challenged Spruance and then voted Dragon. Albeit that Dragon did come off as scummy (I was reading the thread from the beginning) I actually know that that was town emotion pouring out of his Spanish pours. So what I would like from Funce is an explanation, because there should be no reason for anyone to not have a reasoning to back up there claims.

Mr.Balls and Eggy i think should just dual it out.

Chapdat came in with just a vote, I'm inclined to believe that was their RVS vote seeing as that's all they've said... If they would like to counter this statement by saying that it wasn't a RVS vote, i think we all deserve an explanation


everyone else has pretty much been AFK, no?

I don't give full list reads like never unlucky just did this early into the game, especially when so many people have been AFK. However i think it's clear i'm looking closely at Spruance at the moment, and definitely how Never Unlucky forms his relationships with people.

[BigBallsMcGG]

okay, first of all i'm very blitzed right now so i apologize for any mistakes or miscommunication errors

Minotarr right now is my only hard town read. I see a lot of his questions and beginner ways coming from genuine new town.

Never Unlucky bothers me because he tried to befriend Minotarr and although thats not a bad thing could have alternative motives. I'm also rather confused as to why he has me marked as scum. He told me to step my game up and since i've seen he's done that i'm willing to do the same. I could go ranting on about how it's basic nature that i'm always town but i won't until I get super frustrated because at this moment I have high hopes for this game . Never Unlucky coming to Spruance defence isn't what bothers me. It's his explanation of "a scum wouldn't ask that question" that bothers me. While I can agree it was Spruance's first post, sometimes setup speculation is a scum way of directing the way the conversation starts.

With Spruance, he may have RL issues to attend to but I would have liked a follow up to his setup speculation. It's one thing to make a comment and then make an elaborate point about it, but I see Spruance's comment to more be stating out the obvious, which to me is what a scum member would do. I also think his comment was a little too "smart" to come from Spruance. He definitely hasn't started this game like he has every other. Then again he could be stepping his game up like us NU?

Funce came, challenged Spruance and then voted Dragon. Albeit that Dragon did come off as scummy (I was reading the thread from the beginning) I actually know that that was town emotion pouring out of his Spanish pours. So what I would like from Funce is an explanation, because there should be no reason for anyone to not have a reasoning to back up there claims.

Mr.Balls and Eggy i think should just dual it out.

Chapdat came in with just a vote, I'm inclined to believe that was their RVS vote seeing as that's all they've said... If they would like to counter this statement by saying that it wasn't a RVS vote, i think we all deserve an explanation


everyone else has pretty much been AFK, no?

I don't give full list reads like never unlucky just did this early into the game, especially when so many people have been AFK. However i think it's clear i'm looking closely at Spruance at the moment, and definitely how Never Unlucky forms his relationships with people.

I am not scum I just voted Mr. Eggy because he started the vote up against me my vote is meaningless and having nothing to say for it I do not mean to start any stuff.

[Mesk514]

I am not scum I just voted Mr. Eggy because he started the vote up against me my vote is meaningless and having nothing to say for it I do not mean to start any stuff.

hence why i said, i'll let you two battle it out... -.-

[BigBallsMcGG]

I think Never Unlucky and Eggy are possible scum and I think that Minotarr is Town and I think that Mesk could be scum just by how she is trying to make everyone think that she is with the town when she secretly could be the scum.

[Never Unlucky]

This is what my thoughts are at this moment in time although they could change towards the end of the first day.
No need to marginalize your reads, they look great to me. You're doing much better than I did in my first time so far. : )

okay, first of all i'm very blitzed right now so i apologize for any mistakes or miscommunication errors

Minotarr right now is my only hard town read. I see a lot of his questions and beginner ways coming from genuine new town.

Never Unlucky bothers me because he tried to befriend Minotarr and although thats not a bad thing could have alternative motives. I'm also rather confused as to why he has me marked as scum. He told me to step my game up and since i've seen he's done that i'm willing to do the same. I could go ranting on about how it's basic nature that i'm always town but i won't until I get super frustrated because at this moment I have high hopes for this game . Never Unlucky coming to Spruance defence isn't what bothers me. It's his explanation of "a scum wouldn't ask that question" that bothers me. While I can agree it was Spruance's first post, sometimes setup speculation is a scum way of directing the way the conversation starts.

With Spruance, he may have RL issues to attend to but I would have liked a follow up to his setup speculation. It's one thing to make a comment and then make an elaborate point about it, but I see Spruance's comment to more be stating out the obvious, which to me is what a scum member would do. I also think his comment was a little too "smart" to come from Spruance. He definitely hasn't started this game like he has every other. Then again he could be stepping his game up like us NU?

Funce came, challenged Spruance and then voted Dragon. Albeit that Dragon did come off as scummy (I was reading the thread from the beginning) I actually know that that was town emotion pouring out of his Spanish pours. So what I would like from Funce is an explanation, because there should be no reason for anyone to not have a reasoning to back up there claims.

Mr.Balls and Eggy i think should just dual it out.

Chapdat came in with just a vote, I'm inclined to believe that was their RVS vote seeing as that's all they've said... If they would like to counter this statement by saying that it wasn't a RVS vote, i think we all deserve an explanation


everyone else has pretty much been AFK, no?

I don't give full list reads like never unlucky just did this early into the game, especially when so many people have been AFK. However i think it's clear i'm looking closely at Spruance at the moment, and definitely how Never Unlucky forms his relationships with people.
I don't have you marked as scum. I had Dark Dragon as lean scum because of the weirdness of his posts, but I have you as null for reasons I detailed in my latest post.

Funce did not vote Dragon, he/she voted SPruance.

I can't agree that stating the obvious is a scum tell. Minotarr has done just that a couple times for instance, and he's a hard town-read for both of us. (And lmfao at the low af hopes you have for Spruance)

I'm glad you're stepping up your game too. It's much better than that post you made in IC.

[Never Unlucky]

I think Never Unlucky and Eggy are possible scum and I think that Minotarr is Town and I think that Mesk could be scum just by how she is trying to make everyone think that she is with the town when she secretly could be the scum.

Where is this coming from? I've had 0 interaction with Eggy, how are you already pairing me up with him? Why are you reading me as scum?

Mesk isn't trying to make everyone think she is town as much as usual too.

[BigBallsMcGG]

Where is this coming from? I've had 0 interaction with Eggy, how are you already pairing me up with him? Why are you reading me as scum?

Mesk isn't trying to make everyone think she is town as much as usual too.

You ask too many damn questions.lol

[Mesk514]

Mesk could be scum just by how she is trying to make everyone think that she is with the town when she secretly could be the scum.

Eh NU, look at this noob.... he's trying to argue the facts of life, I loooooove it.

[Minotarr]

You ask too many damn questions.lol

I think you should just take all the questions and just kind of pair them up with each other to make 1 question seem like 1 for example. Where is this coming from and why are you reading me as scum can be put into one sentence. Just explain why you think NU and Eggy are in your eyes mafia/scum. And finally just justify your reasoning on why you think Musk is trying to make everyone her friend. And for these short questions you can reply with short answers for example when I posted my big text block I overthought and it worked against me.

[Mesk514]

I posted my big text block I overthought and it worked against me.

i don't think it worked against you tbh, there has definitely been 100000x worse

[Minotarr]

i don't think it worked against you tbh, there has definitely been 100000x worse

I'm happy you think that. But I what that I took away from is it that the bigger the text block the more questions asked and the more confusing it gets to answer as a result.

[Minotarr]

BigBallsMcGG what are your thoughts/reads at the moment I see you're lurking at the moment and I'm wondering what your thoughts are on everyone's reads.

[Mesk514]

I'm happy you think that. But I what that I took away from is it that the bigger the text block the more questions asked and the more confusing it gets to answer as a result.

well it's not the length of the text block as long posts =/= town, it's the content of the text.

This is day 1, people asking questions is like the only way of gathering information

[BigBallsMcGG]

BigBallsMcGG what are your thoughts/reads at the moment I see you're lurking at the moment and I'm wondering what your thoughts are on everyone's reads.

Idk I dont really have an opinion.

[Minotarr]

Idk I dont really have an opinion.

BigBallsMcGG Who sticks out to you or bothers you with some of the actions they're doing? Then explain why.

[BigBallsMcGG]

BigBallsMcGG Who sticks out to you or bothers you with some of the actions they're doing? Then explain why.

I feel like mesk is scummy but apparently i'm wrong on that one supposedly. I already explained why but im noob af so I'd rather not explain

[Mesk514]

I feel like mesk is scummy but apparently i'm wrong on that one supposedly. I already explained why but im noob af so I'd rather not explain

you are wrong
its is rather possible both scum haven't spoken yet btw

[BigBallsMcGG]

you are wrong
its is rather possible both scum haven't spoken yet btw

Probably true. A lot of people haven't said shit.

[Never Unlucky]

Eh NU, look at this noob.... he's trying to argue the facts of life, I loooooove it.

lma0. Golden rule of forum mafia: Mesk is always town.
I feel like mesk is scummy but apparently i'm wrong on that one supposedly. I already explained why but im noob af so I'd rather not explain

You also mentionned me being scum. Why?

Don't be scared to explain, this is the Beginners' game. Half of the players haven't even played a game before. Not explaining your thoughts makes you look scummy. Also, no one said you were wrong about your read on Mesk. And it's a "READ". It's perfectly ok not to have good reads, especially on day 1.

[Mesk514]

no one said you were wrong about your read on Mesk.

well i did, but NeverUnlucky brings a valid point.

[Mesk514]

sooo uh

any questions?

comments?

concerns?

[Never Unlucky]

sooo uh

any questions?

comments?

concerns?

Mesk, the type of person to play the Beginners' game twice.

[Mesk514]

Mesk, the type of person to play the Beginners' game twice.

fuck yeah, my beginners game play was by far my best.

[Never Unlucky]

JamesChurchill
Chapdat
Eggy
Funce

[Minotarr]

Sigh. I really wish they'd get on I'd love to hear their opinions on everything that's been going on so far.

[Never Unlucky]

We're heading towards a policy lynch if they don't show up.

[Minotarr]

Policy lynch what's that?

[Minotarr]

Unknown1234 what is a policy lynch?

[Unknown1234]

Unknown1234 what is a policy lynch?

Policy Lynch is basically to kill someone purely based on either the lack of help they have provided or simply because they are just not playing.

[Minotarr]

Policy Lynch is basically to kill someone purely based on either the lack of help they have provided or simply because they are just not playing.



@Unknown1234 thanks for clarifying that.

[Never Unlucky]

@Unknown1234 thanks for clarifying that.

I guess I'll ask you if you support the idea of a policy lynch in this situation and who you would like to see policy lynched.

[Minotarr]

I guess I'll ask you if you support the idea of a policy lynch in this situation and who you would like to see policy lynched.

The only person right now that I believe should be policy lynched is JamesChurchill because he hasn't been active in the thread at all.

Although, you could argue Chapdat since he just kind of appeared voted then left.

Eggy and Funce did this as well, but I feel as though they may have had RL problems but these two are still open for a policy lynch if I had to put it in a list it would look like this.

Should be policy lynched -> should not be policy lynched
JamesChurchill
Chapdat

Eggy
Balls
Funce
Spruance
Mesk
NU
Minotarr

This list is in no particular order other than who I think should be lynched vs who should not be lynched.

[Never Unlucky]

The only person right now that I believe should be policy lynched is JamesChurchill because he hasn't been active in the thread at all.

Although, you could argue Chapdat since he just kind of appeared voted then left.

Eggy and Funce did this as well, but I feel as though they may have had RL problems but these two are still open for a policy lynch if I had to put it in a list it would look like this.

Should be policy lynched -> should not be policy lynched
JamesChurchill
Chapdat

Eggy
Balls
Funce
Spruance
Mesk
NU
Minotarr

This list is in no particular order other than who I think should be lynched vs who should not be lynched.

Interesting. I had Balls as my #1 target because he said himself that he thought "nothing" of what was said in 7 pages. Do we want that kind of guy alive in a MYLO/LYLO situation? No, we do not. He is the kind of player that can sheep the scum easily because he is not opinionated. Plus, he's been lurking a lot on the thread and not posting much. Add to that the fact that he seems immature by his "u cuck"/"u idiot" comments...

Balls is a prime candidate for a policy lynch.

[Minotarr]

Interesting. I had Balls as my #1 target because he said himself that he thought "nothing" of what was said in 7 pages. Do we want that kind of guy alive in a MYLO/LYLO situation? No, we do not. He is the kind of player that can sheep the scum easily because he is not opinionated. Plus, he's been lurking a lot on the thread and not posting much. Add to that the fact that he seems immature by his "u cuck"/"u idiot" comments...

Balls is a prime candidate for a policy lynch.

I agree with you on everything you're saying and I would policy lynch the only reason I'm refraining from voting against him is because he just got back from vacation and the fact that he is my brother. I feel that he can put more effort into this game because he is a pretty good mod player when he's not tired. If my brother does choose not to participate I will definitely consider him as a prime policy lynch target.

[BigBallsMcGG]

Interesting. I had Balls as my #1 target because he said himself that he thought "nothing" of what was said in 7 pages. Do we want that kind of guy alive in a MYLO/LYLO situation? No, we do not. He is the kind of player that can sheep the scum easily because he is not opinionated. Plus, he's been lurking a lot on the thread and not posting much. Add to that the fact that he seems immature by his "u cuck"/"u idiot" comments...

Balls is a prime candidate for a policy lynch.

I don't know what to say and frankly i'm kind've tired so I'm not gonna say much right now maybe later.

[Never Unlucky]

Eggy

He's active on other threads and ignores this one. Scummy AF.

[Minotarr]

He's active on other threads and ignores this one. Scummy AF.

Could you point me in the direction of one of the threads Eggy is on?

[Minotarr]

Never mind I found it.

[Funce]

I apologize for my absence. Yesterday was my not-free day. Allow me to read up on the day's events.

[Funce]

Okay. Seems like I have some explaining to do.

In regards to talking for dragon. I was attempting to point out things which I saw.
The shade, I used because I was really not sure on one of my reads. It was the only thing I could think of that I could use.

[Never Unlucky]

Okay. Seems like I have some explaining to do.

In regards to talking for dragon. I was attempting to point out things which I saw.
The shade, I used because I was really not sure on one of my reads. It was the only thing I could think of that I could use.

What shade are you referring to?

Who do you think we should PL?

[Funce]

Yeah I believe that's everything people required.
Also, my vote on Spruance was an OMGUS(Omg you suck)
Meaning I voted him for no other than he voted me.

[Funce]

What shade are you referring to?

Who do you think we should PL?

I shaded dragon by slightly exaggerating a point that was irrelevant at the time. His tone.

Why is PL being discussed?
Do we not have... Ohhh no public enemy number 1.
Okay. I don't support policy lynches, although it's better than getting a no lynch.
Nothing can be made from a policy lynch.

[Never Unlucky]

I shaded dragon by slightly exaggerating a point that was irrelevant at the time. His tone.

Why is PL being discussed?
Do we not have... Ohhh no public enemy number 1.
Okay. I don't support policy lynches, although it's better than getting a no lynch.
Nothing can be made from a policy lynch.
I brought up PL because Mino, Mesk and I have no strong scum-read and 4 of the slots have been inactive so it's hard/impossible to get a read on them. A conventional lynch in unlikely to happen in this context. A PL on an inactive player won't kill off any interaction anyways.

If you don't support a PL, you should create a reads list.

[Minotarr]

Funce do you have any thoughts on the reads that NU, Mesk and I posted?

[Funce]

Minotarr right now is my only hard town read. I see a lot of his questions and beginner ways coming from genuine new town.

Never Unlucky bothers me because he tried to befriend Minotarr and although thats not a bad thing could have alternative motives. I'm also rather confused as to why he has me marked as scum. He told me to step my game up and since i've seen he's done that i'm willing to do the same. I could go ranting on about how it's basic nature that i'm always town but i won't until I get super frustrated because at this moment I have high hopes for this game . Never Unlucky coming to Spruance defence isn't what bothers me. It's his explanation of "a scum wouldn't ask that question" that bothers me. While I can agree it was Spruance's first post, sometimes setup speculation is a scum way of directing the way the conversation starts.

This is literally the state of my reads. I kinda wanted to scumread Mino. However that became impossible upon further inspection. However that one post described in Mesks post sounded incredibly scummy to me and I'm glad I wasn't the only one. This is the read I was unsure about.

[Funce]

I've been hard scumreading never unlucky for the whole game. Which is why I avoided talking about you, never unlucky. Cause I knew I'd only be able to say it once.
I also had an aversion to lynching an active player.

[Never Unlucky]

This is literally the state of my reads. I kinda wanted to scumread Mino. However that became impossible upon further inspection. However that one post described in Mesks post sounded incredibly scummy to me and I'm glad I wasn't the only one. This is the read I was unsure about.

You wanted to scum-read Mino?

Town can't decide how they read others. They read others naturally through gut, tone, feel, action and motivation. They can't make up a read.

Explain yourself, your post pinged scumminess to me.

[Funce]

You wanted to scum-read Mino?

Town can't decide how they read others. They read others naturally through gut, tone, feel, action and motivation. They can't make up a read.

Explain yourself, your post pinged scumminess to me.

Wanted as in by glancing over got a somewhat scummy feel. That and he was conveniently being town read by everyone.

[Never Unlucky]

I've been hard scumreading never unlucky for the whole game. Which is why I avoided talking about you, never unlucky. Cause I knew I'd only be able to say it once.
I also had an aversion to lynching an active player.

You're expected to have an explanation when you "hard scum-read" someone else. All you've provided on my case is Mesk's post, and Mesk doesn't even scum-read me...
Are you painting me as scum?

You scum-read me, so you avoided confronting me/talking about me? WAIT WHAT?!
If you're town you should talk about your scum-reads the most to guide the town into lynching who you think is scum, not keep your reads for yourself. That is what a scum would do not to draw attention on his slot. Scummy AF.

[Never Unlucky]

Wanted as in by glancing over got a somewhat scummy feel. That and he was conveniently being town read by everyone.

Explain how he gave you a scummy feel.

"Conveniently being town-read by everyone"
Let's see who said they town-read Mino. Mesk, Balls (implicitly) and me. 3 players. Is he really being town-read by everyone? Scum tend to mischaracterize/overstate and that is what you're doing right now.
Being town-read by "everyone" makes you "want to scum-read" him? What the actual fuck.

[Never Unlucky]

Minotarr I see you lurking. What are your current thoughts on my interaction with Funce? Did your reads on us both change?

[Minotarr]

Funce I'm curious for your reasoning behind why you scum read me could you please explain to me why?

[Minotarr]

Minotarr I see you lurking. What are your current thoughts on my interaction with Funce? Did your reads on us both change?

My reads so far have not changed and I'm curious to hear why Funce scum read me and hard scum reads you.

[Minotarr]

@NeverUnlucky I see that Eggy and Spruance are both posting in another thread. Earlier you mentioned that you thought Eggy was scummy for doing this. What are your thoughts on Spruance posting? Have your reads changed at all?

[Spruance]

@NeverUnlucky I see that Eggy and Spruance are both posting in another thread. Earlier you mentioned that you thought Eggy was scummy for doing this. What are your thoughts on Spruance posting? Have your reads changed at all?

idk that thread is more pressing than this one.

[Never Unlucky]

@NeverUnlucky I see that Eggy and Spruance are both posting in another thread. Earlier you mentioned that you thought Eggy was scummy for doing this. What are your thoughts on Spruance posting? Have your reads changed at all?

There's a space between Never and Unlucky btw. Keep that in mind next time you ping/vote me. : )

Yes, I thought that Eggy was scummy for doing this. I don't necessarily think that he's scum though. I still read him as null as he's only posted once.

Same goes for Spruance. I'd be more inclined to lean-town-read him now.

Yes, I now lean-scum-read Funce. Her reasoning for scum-reading me and you is lacking and some of her posts/actions ping scumminess like I have highlighted. That's the big picture of my read on her.

[Minotarr]

There's a space between Never and Unlucky btw. Keep that in mind next time you ping/vote me. : )

Yes, I thought that Eggy was scummy for doing this. I don't necessarily think that he's scum though. I still read him as null as he's only posted once.

Same goes for Spruance. I'd be more inclined to lean-town-read him now.

Yes, I now lean-scum-read Funce. Her reasoning for scum-reading me and you is lacking and some of her posts/actions ping scumminess like I have highlighted. That's the big picture of my read on her.

I agree Funce's scum reads on you and I are lacking.

I'm keeping Funce as null still since I don't think I've seen enough from them.



BigBallsMcGG I see you lurking bro.

[Never Unlucky]

I know there's 22 hours left to the day, but I think that we should start voting now as there seems to be activity mostly from 2 PM to 10 PM EST (Writing this post at ~5PM). If we do not start now, I'm afraid the day will end in a no-lynch.

I propose Eggy/Chapdat and possibly Balls (He said he'll put in more effort later, so maybe not him). I know Mino proposed JamesChurchill too, but the host told me that he'd be dealt with if he doesn't post at all.

[Minotarr]

I know there's 22 hours left to the day, but I think that we should start voting now as there seems to be activity mostly from 2 PM to 10 PM EST (Writing this post at ~5PM). If we do not start now, I'm afraid the day will end in a no-lynch.

I propose Eggy/Chapdat and possibly Balls (He said he'll put in more effort later, so maybe not him). I know Mino proposed JamesChurchill too, but the host told me that he'd be dealt with if he doesn't post at all.

I agree we should start voting now. I will not be here tomorrow at all so I'll miss the end of day chats. I'll make sure to deal with Balls.

[BigBallsMcGG]

I feel like we should vote chapdat, eggy or James even though I am very suspicious and sketchy I think u guys should go for the people who haven't really said anything besides either voting someone then leaving. I'm talking about when Eggy voted for me to die. Sorry that i've been out of it I don't exactly know if I should type what I want to type but I will try and provide info you guys could use later today or another time today.

[BigBallsMcGG]

I'm gonna be off for a while now so I won't be responding if you guys ask me anything or stuff like that. I'll check up with the convos later.

[Never Unlucky]

Actually, Funce has already got two votes. She's not a hard scum-read for me, but she is my strongest one. She gets my vote.

Funce

[Minotarr]

Actually, Funce has already got two votes. She's not a hard scum-read for me, but she is my strongest one. She gets my vote.

Funce

I thought you wanted to do a policy vote today?

[Minotarr]

What changed that?

[Never Unlucky]

I thought you wanted to do a policy vote today?

We would need at least 5 active players which may not happen by the EoD and we would need those 5 players to agree to vote Eggy/Chapdat. It's not inconceivable that we can all agree on a lynch, but I do not think we will. Plus Funce has expressed that she doesn't support PLs.

Funce has 3 votes already. She's my strongest scum-read at the moment.

[BigBallsMcGG]

Funce I guess we are voting Funce that's alright in my book

[Minotarr]

Funce I guess we are voting Funce that's alright in my book

It bothers me that you were so quick to jump on the vote train against Funce because you haven't given any reasons why you think she deserves to be lynched this makes me think you're scum.

[Minotarr]

BigBallsMcGG

I'm voting balls because his reads are weak and they give us excuses why he's not posting for example he's too tired or he's going to be offline. I think that him jumping so quickly to vote against Funce is very scummy this is why my vote goes to Balls.

[Never Unlucky]

No reason to be at L-1 right now. Mino is right, Balls' move was pretty scummy given he didn't explain his vote. Is he only sheeping me? THE ONE HE SCUM-READS? That makes no sense.

Funce You might want to role claim given you're at L-1 with my vote.

[Mesk514]

No reason to be at L-1 right now. Mino is right, Balls' move was pretty scummy given he didn't explain his vote. Is he only sheeping me? THE ONE HE SCUM-READS? That makes no sense.

Funce You might want to role claim given you're at L-1 with my vote.

Unvote

let me read over the new stuff since last night

[Mesk514]

lololol I left for quite a bit and yet theres still no action....

damn

[Never Unlucky]

lololol I left for quite a bit and yet theres still no action....

damn

What are your thoughts on what you've just read?

Who do you want lynched?

What color is your hair? o.o

[Funce]

I town read you Minotarr. Like Mesk, I think your post comes from a new townie rather than a deceptive scum.

Unlucky on the other hand still holds my attention.

[Funce]

And I am allowed to not want to lynch one of the few people pushing discussion. Scum or not. Discussion is healthy.

[Never Unlucky]

I town read you Minotarr. Like Mesk, I think your post comes from a new townie rather than a deceptive scum.

Unlucky on the other hand still holds my attention.

You went from "hard scum-read" to "holds my attention". Why the suddent change?

[Never Unlucky]

~2hours and 30 minutes left to the day.

Funce

Only 5 of the 9 players really showed up. With 5 votes needed to lynch and with those numbers, it's practically impossible for town to kill the scum. Activity's only going to go downhill too, as scum will kill one of us every night (probably targeting the most active players too.).

[Minotarr]

Funce
Mesk514
JamesChurchill
Eggy
Spruance
BigBallsMcGG
Chapdat

It's really close to EOD we need to make a decision here.

[Minotarr]

My vote stills lies with Balls since I feel that he's scum for lack of participation and whenever he is here he lurks or doesn't respond to questions coming up with excuses.

[Minotarr]

My reads haven't changed on anyone other than balls and Funce.

I feel Funce is scummy since she hasn't really been pushing conversation just kind of sitting back trying to let things play out. If by the EOD Funce is at L1 I will change my vote to her.

I feel balls is showing lack of effort not even trying to discuss anything coming up with excuses and the vote against funce was very scummy since he didn't even give reasoning or thought behind his vote.

[Minotarr]

Funce you might want to speak up and defend yourself before EOD.

[Minotarr]

BigBallsMcGG you too.

[Minotarr]

Never Unlucky you've been sitting there and I'm getting bored of talking to no one so what are your thoughts on my reads and have your reads changed at all?

[Never Unlucky]

Never Unlucky you've been sitting there and I'm getting bored of talking to no one so what are your thoughts on my reads and have your reads changed at all?

No, my reads have not changed. As for you reads, I think they're great. They're basically the same as mine, but I don't think you've sheeped my reads because you've briefly explained every one of your reads while I haven't.

[Minotarr]

Mesk514 thoughts?

[Mesk514]

sorry my friends, I was having some problems yesterday... sup homie Gs

[Mesk514]

I laugh at this game because host's own brother isn't even playing :P

[Mesk514]

for the sake of day 1

Funce

Hopefully host gets this game together before day 2.

[Minotarr]

Funce could you pop your head in and say a few words before I make a decision?

[Minotarr]

Funce nothing at all?

[Never Unlucky]

15 minutes left to the day.

[Minotarr]

Funce

Seeing as Funce's reads don't seem to be explained and is not showing up to explain them whether it be because of RL problems or not I'm voting against her since she is my second biggest scum read.

[The Godfather]

Funce has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!


Funce ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/member.php/6381') (5 [L-0]): Spruance ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=631485'), Never Unlucky ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=632050'), Mesk514 ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=632071'), Minotarr ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=632078'), BigBallsMcGG ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=631902')
BigBallsMcGG ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/member.php/28453') (1 [L-4]): Eggy ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=631495')
Spruance ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/member.php/27577') (1 [L-4]): Funce ('http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php?p=631521')

[Unknown1234]

Night One:

After a long day spent hunting for the mafia, the town struggled to succeed, ending up lynching their town leader.

Funce was lynched. They were a Sheriff.

AnassRhamur will be replacing JamesChurchill.

Living Players:
Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
Never Unlucky
Spruance
Chapdat
Eggy
AnassRhamur

Dead Players:
Funce: Lynched Day 1. Sheriff.

Roles List:
Doctor
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Consort
Mafioso


Night ends at this time: http://www.timeanddate.com/countdown/generic?p0=250&iso=20160803T1430

Night Actions must be submitted 1 hour before deadline.

[Unknown1234]

Day Two:

It was only until the Sheriff had fallen that the town realized they were in trouble. One by one the town was falling, they knew they had to act fast.

Spruance's lifeless body was found on the ground. They determined he was a Citizen.

Living Players:
Minotarr
BigBallsMcGG
Never Unlucky
Mesk514
Chapdat
Eggy
AnassRhamur

Dead Players:
Funce: Lynched Day 1. Sheriff.
Spruance: Killed Night 1. Citizen.

Roles List:
Doctor
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Consort
Mafioso


4

Day ends at this time:
02:00:00:00

[Never Unlucky]

I think Never Unlucky and Eggy are possible scum and I think that Minotarr is Town and I think that Mesk could be scum just by how she is trying to make everyone think that she is with the town when she secretly could be the scum.
Very strange that Balls said he scum-read me then sheeped my vote onto Funce.

Funce I guess we are voting Funce that's alright in my book

He's also the only one who had voted Spruance and he admitted it was a OMGUS vote.

[Mesk514]

RIP Spruance, da fuuuqqqq


ermmmm I think i would like to look at the people that haven't spoken yet...


Eggy
Chapdat

oh my friend AnassRhamur hello <3

[Never Unlucky]

RIP Spruance, da fuuuqqqq


ermmmm I think i would like to look at the people that haven't spoken yet...


Eggy
Chapdat

oh my friend AnassRhamur hello <3

Yo, yo, yo, Mesk, what analysis do you make of Spruance's death?

+2 rep for a satisfying answer.

[Eggy]

Hey sorry guys had a busy few days ill be on for a while feel free to ask me anything you like. Ill will make a reads list shortly.

[Never Unlucky]

Eggy

[Eggy]

me? lack of imagination....?

I imagine us in bed together and I being super bored.

give me ideas that would make me think otherwise.


let me see you spice up this game.

Lol this made my day :p

[Eggy]

Eggy

Based off my first post ouch im hurt. Care to explain?

[Eggy]

I hate seeing votes all alone like that. They need atleast a sentance to accompany them or else they get lonely. Are you saying you dont have a stronger scum read so far or is this a pressure vote of some sort.

[Never Unlucky]

Based off my first post ouch im hurt. Care to explain?
I'd like you to give me your thoughts on Spruance's death as well as post that reads list you talked about.

[Never Unlucky]

I hate seeing votes all alone like that. They need atleast a sentance to accompany them or else they get lonely. Are you saying you dont have a stronger scum read so far or is this a pressure vote of some sort.

It's neither. I have a case on you which I'll provide later.

[Eggy]

"Hard town-read" is an overstatement. I think that his second post about setup is a question a townie would've ask. I doubt a mafia would've asked it. This is where my read comes from.

Yes, I've received some tips and tricks from Calix. I'm making steps towards being a town leader :D

Now, it'd be nice to see YOU step up your game.

Lead town to defeat from what i've seen of calix lol

[Eggy]

I'd like you to give me your thoughts on Spruance's death as well as post that reads list you talked about.

In at like page 4 am reading through right now. Totally forgot about this game.

[Eggy]

It's neither. I have a case on you which I'll provide later.

Based on my one post or on my abscence? And later why because you are waiting for my reads list?

[Mesk514]

I'm busy dying my hair... i'll make a day 1 speculation very shortly... so far for the start of day 2 I would say that voting someone with out hearing what they have to say is very not "pro town"

[Eggy]

me? asshole? never

more into foreplay first....

Stop lying ur not into buttstuff, Unfortunately.

[Eggy]

How is this GIF representative of this community?

What did you think of Chapdat's vote?

Seemed to me because dragon asked to be lynched. Being a noob he might not realize that he was going to be replaced and decided to fallow his request and lynch him

[Never Unlucky]

Lead town to defeat from what i've seen of calix lol

Say what you want about Calix, she remains a smart player, you remain a shitty one. Want to talk about AI? Want to talk about Politico?

Calix can lead a whole town, you can't even lead Spruance.
Based on my one post or on my abscence? And later why because you are waiting for my reads list?

Based on both. Later because I need to hear more from you. That post alone doesn't make you scum.

[AnassRhamur]

Yes hello, where can i find hacks for this game?
Oh nvm found it. Spoiler alert: It's Minotarr and Eggy

[Never Unlucky]

Yes hello, where can i find hacks for this game?
Oh nvm found it. Spoiler alert: It's Minotarr and Eggy

TwelveYrOld, do your hacks tell you why these two would be the scum? Do they give an explanation?

[Eggy]

Eggy

He's active on other threads and ignores this one. Scummy AF.

Except I was scum in that game? And I was town in politico and I also was very inactive after islands started. I prefer playing as mafia than town. Is this what your case you were talking about is built off of?

[Eggy]

Say what you want about Calix, she remains a smart player, you remain a shitty one. Want to talk about AI? Want to talk about Politico?

Calix can lead a whole town, you can't even lead Spruance.

Based on both. Later because I need to hear more from you. That post alone doesn't make you scum.

So why is your vote on me? Do you not have better scum reads based off more than one post. Wow the game when I was afk the entire time and the game when I was distracted by another game and didnt want to play because ot was dead? Atleast I dont go around saying im town leader and then losing the game. From what I've seen calix is not as smart as you might think. Let me guess is she your mentor right now? Lol

[Eggy]

@NeverUnlucky I see that Eggy and Spruance are both posting in another thread. Earlier you mentioned that you thought Eggy was scummy for doing this. What are your thoughts on Spruance posting? Have your reads changed at all?

Another attempt at buddying looks like.

[Eggy]

idk that thread is more pressing than this one.

Exactly

[Eggy]

I feel like we should vote chapdat, eggy or James even though I am very suspicious and sketchy I think u guys should go for the people who haven't really said anything besides either voting someone then leaving. I'm talking about when Eggy voted for me to die. Sorry that i've been out of it I don't exactly know if I should type what I want to type but I will try and provide info you guys could use later today or another time today.

This pings me as quite scummy. Admitting he is scummy and suspicious but urging us to dismiss it in favor off people who have not been active so far? A reaction to his name comming up as a policy lynch? Strikes me as exactly what noob scum would say.

[Eggy]

Funce I guess we are voting Funce that's alright in my book

Sees someone other than himself is leading train and immediately jumps on that boat? This is definately a noob scum play.

[Never Unlucky]

Except I was scum in that game? And I was town in politico and I also was very inactive after islands started. I prefer playing as mafia than town. Is this what your case you were talking about is built off of?

That isn't an argument, nor is it a statement that makes any sense.

My case is not built around you being inactive. I'd have a case for 5 of the 9 players if this was what I built my arguments around. Nice try deflecting it on me like you did in IC.


So why is your vote on me? Do you not have better scum reads based off more than one post.Deflecting again. We're back in IC. You're trying to discredit my scum-read on you instead of giving your reads and contributing.

For the record, interrogative sentences usually end with a question mark.


Wow the game when I was afk the entire time and the game when I was distracted by another game and didnt want to play because ot was dead?You write unlogical and unreadable sentences like this one and you dare talk about Calix's intelligence?

Atleast I dont go around saying im town leader and then losing the game. From what I've seen calix is not as smart as you might think. Let me guess is she your mentor right now? Lol

Because you can't say that. You're the town idiot every single time you're town.

Good "guess", I said that Calix was my mentor day 1.

[Never Unlucky]

This pings me as quite scummy. Admitting he is scummy and suspicious but urging us to dismiss it in favor off people who have not been active so far? A reaction to his name comming up as a policy lynch? Strikes me as exactly what noob scum would say.
Good point.

Sees someone other than himself is leading train and immediately jumps on that boat? This is definately a noob scum play.
Good points, but...

You are drawing attention to BigBalls when you're in the spotlight right now. How is it different from Balls?

[Eggy]

That isn't an argument, nor is it a statement that makes any sense.

My case is not built around you being inactive. I'd have a case for 5 of the 9 players if this was what I built my arguments around. Nice try deflecting it on me like you did in IC.

Deflecting again. We're back in IC. You're trying to discredit my scum-read on you instead of giving your reads and contributing.

For the record, interrogative sentences usually end with a question mark.

You write unlogical and unreadable sentences like this one and you dare talk about Calix's intelligence?


Because you can't say that. You're the town idiot every single time you're town.

Good "guess", I said that Calix was my mentor day 1.

Except my first game ever on any forum where I lead the town to victory. Someone getting defensive. And do you not see my posting replies as I catch up? And you were town idiot in in islands aha, you or spruance.

[Eggy]

Good point.

Good points, but...

You are drawing attention to BigBalls when you're in the spotlight right now. How is it different from Balls?

Im not in the spot light you still havnt given me your case if you even have one. Im making reads now give me 5 minutes.

[Never Unlucky]

Another attempt at buddying looks like.

Asking questions to the only other active player =/= Buddying.

[Eggy]

That isn't an argument, nor is it a statement that makes any sense.

My case is not built around you being inactive. I'd have a case for 5 of the 9 players if this was what I built my arguments around. Nice try deflecting it on me like you did in IC.

Deflecting again. We're back in IC. You're trying to discredit my scum-read on you instead of giving your reads and contributing.

For the record, interrogative sentences usually end with a question mark.

You write unlogical and unreadable sentences like this one and you dare talk about Calix's intelligence?


Because you can't say that. You're the town idiot every single time you're town.

Good "guess", I said that Calix was my mentor day 1.

Oh and im not deflecting im saying that posting in one chat while being active in another is not AI

And the quality of my typing is mostly because I always play from my phone.

[Eggy]

Asking questions to the only other active player =/= Buddying.

Saying I was scummy for not posting and posting in another thread but then saying nothing when it was the townie you were trying to buddy?

[Never Unlucky]

Except my first game ever on any forum where I lead the town to victory. Someone getting defensive. And do you not see my posting replies as I catch up? And you were town idiot in in islands aha, you or spruance.
You didn't lead shit to victory.

You're deflecting again, claiming that I'm defensive instead of giving an appropriate reply.


No. I was right about you being scum, right about Kovath being scum, right about MattZed being scum, right about MiniZed being town. Very far from the town idiot you are (Politico, lol).

[Never Unlucky]

So why is your vote on me? Do you not have better scum reads based off more than one post.


Oh and im not deflecting im saying that posting in one chat while being active in another is not AI



So why is your vote on me? Do you not have better scum reads based off more than one post. This is fucking deflecting. I was not even referring to you typing in another thread.

[Eggy]

Read list:

scum:

Bigballs.

Plays exactly how I imigine noob scum to play trying to deflect attention of himself without providing anything to the thread or even attempting and given reads from what i've seen.

Neverunlucky. Seems to want to buddy spruance confirmed town and Mino(my strongest town read) in hopes of gaining their confidence I assume. Also seems to be taking advantage of the fact that most players are noobs and tries to steer it in any direction he wants. Scum reads who ever reads him as scum. Only doubt in my mind is that spruance got killed which would not be ideal if attempting to buddy. Unless a) his partner being a most likely a noob sibmitted his nightkill without reading night chat. Or he saw spruance as one of the more experienced and active players and decided to take him out.
If NU was town I strongly feel like he would have been NKd instead of spruance since he was way more active and was attempting to lead town.

Town

Mino
Obvious attempts and steering town in the right direction. Not wanting to lynch funce because he thought balls was scummier, only jumped on train at last possible second. Reads feel honnest and my gut says he is definately town.

Dragon/mesk
dragon pinged me as an extremely noob town with language comprehenssion issues(proabably citizen) because he seemed fed up with the lack of night action and was overwhelmed by the amount of reading to do(just my thoughts) he probably lost hope when he realized the only way he could impact the game was through telling people hes reads and so forth.

The others are null

Dont think I seen anything from chap or assramer(lol) I see if I missed anyone.

[Eggy]

You didn't lead shit to victory.

You're deflecting again, claiming that I'm defensive instead of giving an appropriate reply.


No. I was right about you being scum, right about Kovath being scum, right about MattZed being scum, right about MiniZed being town. Very far from the town idiot you are (Politico, lol).

Lol yet you still lost? And how did I not lead town to victory I identified the last 2 scum and convince my partner who to lynch with me, my reads were more or less perfect.

If you knew who was scum you should have convinced your town members to do something about it. Its okay tho I lost and you won dont be salty ;) and their is a big difference between not caring in the slightest and being an idiot. AI i was conpletely afk, politico thread was dead I didnt want to play anymore and neither did anyone else really lol.