Draw fails/Bugs?

[MoonAcE]

Hi Guys again...


i saw it now a few times that the "Draw System", if 2 maf vs 2 towns or 1maf vs 1 revealed mayor sometimes dumb is.


First Example(it happened 2 Days ago, i was revealed Mayor, Arso was left(he ignited all others the Night before day came), the game instantly said Arso won...but why? Mayor had 3 votes, Arso 1, means Mayor would have won the Majiority Vote.

Second Example(it happened 2 mins ago), i was Jailor with 1 Exec left and 1 Crier on Town side(means 2 Towns alive), vs GF and Consort, i Jailed the GF 3 days in a row, but couldnt kill because of Block from consort. After the 3 Days we came into this Anonymous Voting thing with Tie breaker...at end of day, Maf won? but why???. I mean Maf couldnt kill anymore, means Town should have won...am i wrong?

[cxx]

It's intended. You can refer to:

http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/index.php?title=Mechanics#Three_Days_of_Peace

[MoonAcE]

thx for this list, but still its rather...bad?

a revealed mayor should win a 1vs1 tie, since he has enough votes to trial/lynch some1
the 2vs2 i could understand somehow, however even there i think its not a good thing, if town manages it to block maf 3 days in a row, they hsould be above maf...but as i said, i couldt understand 2vs2

[Helios]

Well you shouldnt forget that it isnt that easy as maf to create a 2v2 situation at least it shouldnt be and i think its fair that they win ties then espacially since town can create many situations where maf cant kill anymore (2docs that heal eachother, jailor, (escort)).

[MoonAcE]

but its hard too for town sometimes to have a jailor alive in such a situation, maybe add specific win rules in a 2vs2, like if jailor is alive, town wins(since in most setups there is only 1 jailor, but 2-3 docs)

[Xentios]

but its hard too for town sometimes to have a jailor alive in such a situation, maybe add specific win rules in a 2vs2, like if jailor is alive, town wins(since in most setups there is only 1 jailor, but 2-3 docs)

Well you forgot that if town in in 2v2 that means town is losing.

For a normal 9-3-3 game where 9 town and 3 mafia you say 7 townie died for 1 mafia which left 2 maf and 2 town do you really think town should win in a draw?

[Xentios]

Can we change the topic admins? So Dr won't waste time reading this?

[louiswill]

2 maf Vs 2 town, arsonist wins? Sorry I do not get it, if arsonist is not in the role list.

[Helios]

2 maf Vs 2 town, arsonist wins? Sorry I do not get it, if arsonist is not in the role list.

His first example was 1 mayor vs arso, arso wins, he thought mayor would be better because mayor has more votes. Thought he count in ties as much as every other town role exept citizen.

[louiswill]

His first example was 1 mayor vs arso, arso wins, he thought mayor would be better because mayor has more votes. Thought he count in ties as much as every other town role exept citizen.

I see. Who wants to vote when there are only two people left? Criminals beat goo out of normal people on 1 vs 1, otherwise we don't need cops at all.