(2656215, 34776688)2221323, 403696, 1101521, 1025036 | 2794557, 4932015 | 1119776, 528687

[UltimaNecros]

Account Name: Ratler
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2656215
In-Game Name: jailor

Account Name: mrsweetwood
Account ID: 1-S2-1-34776688
In-Game Name: coca cola

Crimes Committed: Skyping

Your Account Name: UltimaNecros
Summary: I was outed as an arsonist by a crier during night 2 and lynched day 3, there had been no PM's at all during day 2 so ii assumed that the crier was skyping with a sherrif to be able to know i was the arsonist and that there was an arsonist in game. i went through the replay and found that the sherrif who investigated me and the crier who called me out also had the same clan tag in the replay and were lined up in order on the inital list so they joined together. I believe the actual chance that a crier random shouted and called me an arsonist the night after i was investigated by a sherrif who happened to share a clan tag and joined the lobby along with said crier is near impossible.

13067

[Mugy]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Account Name: mrsweetwood
Account ID: 1-S2-1-34776688 is incorrect.
Corrected: 1-S2-1-3476688
Account Name: Ratler
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2656215 is correct.


Respective Hot-key(s)
mrsweetwood: Ctrl-5
Ratler: Ctrl-6

Review

Summary of Game

13835

mrssweetwood and Ratler are in the same clan [Hiet]
ButterManuel, ButterMyDeek, ButterDragon, ZCurve are in the same clan
Levethian and Unoriginal are in the same clan [YACHT]

Day One:
Some people pming for no apparent reason.
Levethian whispers Unoriginal.
ZCurve whispers to ButterMyDeek.


Night One:
Koala seems to recognise who ButterMyDeek is.
ButterMyDeek tries to disguise as ZCurve. It fails.
ButterManuel tries to kill 11.
ZCurve vests as survivor and gets attacked.
ButterDragon does not check anyone despite being active.

Levethian heals Unoriginal.
Unoriginal watches himself. He sees that 3(Levethian) visits him.

mrsweetwood checks 7, turns up as arsonist.
Ratler just spams at night as the crier.

Day Two:
ZCurve claims that he was attacked.
ButterMyDeek claims that huskystarcraft(ZCurve) is Mafia.

HuskyStarcraft(ZCurve) votes Husky(ButterMyDeek).
Levethian votes HuskyStarcraft(ZCurve).
Player 7 votes Husky.
player 5(ButterManuel) votes Husky.
Unoriginal, ButterManuel(changes vote), player 8, player 10, player 4, ButterDragon, player 12 votes Huskystarcraft(ZCurve).

HuskyStarcraft claims survivor, and that he used a vest. He also says to get 1(ButterMyDeek).
10, 8, ButterMyDeek, Unoriginal, 2 and Levethian votes guity.

ZCurve's lw says to get 1, because he's a dick. Evidence that they know each other.

Night Two:
2 checks 13, comes up as sheriff.
ButterMyDeek disguises as 7, gets roleblocked, is killed by the sk.
ButterManuel attacks 8
ButterDragon proceeds to do nothing.

Levethian heals Unoriginal.
Unoriginal watches 3.

mrsweetwood checks 1, comes up as mafia.
Ratler says that "I HEARD OM A BIRD 7 IS ARSONIST"

Day Three:
ButterDragon types -suicide.
Levethian pms Unoriginal asking for his role, Unoriginal replies that he is a lookout.

mrsweetwood, 10, Ratler, Unoriginal, Levethian and 2 vote up 7.
7 claims that he is an investigator, and uses his claims from the previous day that 1 was evil to back himself up.

Levethian and Unoriginal votes inno.
2, ButterManuel, 10, Ratler, mrsweetwood vote guilty.

Night Three:
2 tells the godfather that 13 is sheriff, and asks him to kill him.
2 checks 14, comes up as crier.
ButterDragon doesn't do anything again, proceeds to add more to his troll will saying that he can't deal with life.

Levethian heals Unoriginal.
Unoriginal originally wants to watch Levethian, but then switches to himself.

mrsweetwood goes to check 9(Unoriginal), is role blocked and killed.
Ratler does general trolling with his crier abilities, telling 7 to suck his dick, etc.

Day Four:
Unoriginal pms Levethian asking why he's visiting him. Levethian replies that he is a doctor.

Levethian votes 5(gf) saying that he finds him suspicious.

Night Four:
2 goes to check 9, comes up as lookout.
ButterManuel targets 14.

Levethian heals Unoriginal. Levethian dies.
Unoriginal watches Levethian. Sees that 10 visited him.

Ratler says that "7s gay" in the night. He dies that night.

Day Five:
Unoriginal immediately informs the town that 10 visited 3.
2, ButterManuel and Unoriginal vote up 10.
10 claims doctor, not a very convincing defense.

Night Five:
2 checks 12, comes up as escort.
ButterManuel kills 9.

Unoriginal watches 5. He dies.

Day Six:
Two remaining mafia vote up 12.

Night Chat Highlights:
ButterMyDeek and Kryous both claim that they are on skype(not with each other), and that they aren't sharing info.

Ratler leaves the game near the start of Day 5.
Kryous, SinisterHD and mrsweetwood all leave the game at the same time. Kryous previously said that he was on skype.(Night Five)

Conclusions
It is utterly obvious that mrsweetwood and Ratler were using out-of-game communication to cheat.
The crier had information he shouldn't have had, but his friend had.

The BUTTER clan is a bit complicated.
They obviously know each other, but they don't seem to be directly sharing information.
ButterMyDeek even claimed that they were on skype, but weren't sharing info.
None of them(Except ButterDragon) seem to have any sort of trolly or sinister behavior during the time they were in the game.
There really isn't any evidence to suggest that they were directly sharing information such as roles, night results etc.

ButterDragon was kind-of griefing by not doing anything, and suiciding for no apparent reason.
ButterDragon's previous skyping conviction with another member of that isn't in this game makes me suspicious of the entire clan, but that's not enough evidence.

The YACHT clan seemed to know who each other were at the start of the game, but the lack of co-ordination in some of their night actions leads me to believe that names were the only thing they knew.
Though I do find the fact that the doctor healed one target throughout the whole game without question suspicious.

Kryous and sinisterHD are self-admitted skypers. They also leave the game at the same time.
Kryous dies early on, so there is not enough evidence of cheating.

[B]Players Added to Report
ButterManuel: 1-S2-1-2221323
ButterMyDeek: 1-S2-1-403696
ButterDragon: 1-S2-1-1101521
ZCurve: 1-S2-1-1025036

Kryous: 1-S2-1-2794557
sinisterHD: 1-S2-1-4932015

Levethian: 1-S2-1-1119776
Unoriginal: 1-S2-1-528687

Game Result
Mafia wins the game, was close.

Previous Offenses
ButterManuel: None
ButterMyDeek: None
ButterDragon: Previous skyping conviction along with another person http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/22737-ButterDragon-1-S2-1-1101521?highlight=1101521
Zcurve: None

Kryous: None
sinisterHD: None

Levethian: None
Unoriginal: None

mrsweetwood: None
Ratler: None

[B]Verdict(s)
ButterManuel:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold
ButterMyDeek:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold
ButterDragon:
1xGriefing.
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold
Zcurve:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold

Kryous:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold
sinisterHD:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold

Levethian:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold
Unoriginal:
1xPossible Cheating. On-Hold

mrsweetwood:
1xCheating.
Ratler:
1xCheating.


Forum Classification

Approved.

Recommended Action

Watch-List for:
mrsweetwood: 1-S2-1-3476688
Unoriginal: 1-S2-1-2656215


Thank You for reporting.

[fred]

Player Name: mrsweetwood
SC2 ID: 1-S2-1-3476688
Punishment: 2x Watchlisted

Player Name: Unoriginal
SC2 ID: 1-S2-1-2656215
Punishment: 2x Watchlisted