{Watch List} 1-S2-1-3465106, 1-S2-1-1344628, 1-S2-1-1142353, 1-S2-1-3897459, 1-S2-1-1902589 [Archive]

Nuudules

July 3rd, 2013, 11:10 PM

Account Name: Jake
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3465106
In-game Name: Green Lantern (#3 Teal)
Crime Committed -> Skyping\Cheating.

Account Name: FightingGoat
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1142353
In-game Name: PadMckenzie (#1 Red)
Crime Committed -> Skyping\Cheating.

Account Name: Mike
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1344628
In-game Name: Guido the Sharp (#7 Green)
Crime Committed -> Skyping\Cheating.

Account Name: Herty 1-S2-1-3897459
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3465106
In-game Name: [Superman] (#8 Light Pink)
Crime Committed -> Skyping\Cheating.

Account Name: Diebold
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1902589
In-game Name: Don Mattrick (#2 Blue)
Crime Committed -> Skyping\Cheating.

My Account Name: Nuudules (#13 Light Green)

My Summary:

N1, Mafia kills exe, (7), teal visits 5, NS.
No lynch
N2 10 dies, all non clan mates are accounted for as town via skype.
D3 Does NOT visit anyone, accuses 13 (me consig), 11 (disguiser), and 9 (GF) as mafia.

Sheriff cannot detect GF, so I already knew that was shady. Looked back at replay, 3 doesn't visit me at all. I get lynched, 4 guilty, 3 Innocent, Both mafia, and 6 who is not part of clan vote me innocent, 3 people who are part of the clan vote me guilty, 5 who is not part of clan vote me guilty, 8 abstains.

TLDR:
No way 3 could figure out all three of us are mafia, and then call out all three of on day 3. Shady as fuck, and he only investigates 1 person. 0 possibility of him being legit.

Mugy

August 4th, 2013, 01:54 AM

SC ID VERIFICATION
Account Name: Jake
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3465106 is correct.
Account Name: Mike
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1344628 is correct.
Account Name: FightingGoat
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1142353 is correct.
Account Name: Herty
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3465106 is incorrect.
Corrected: 1-S2-1-3897459
Account Name: Diebold
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1902589 is correct.

Respective Hot-key(s)
Jake: 1
Mike: 2
FightingGoat: 3
Herty: 4
Diebold: 5

Review
Summary of Game

http://i.imgur.com/pC1MIDI.png

Night One:
Jake checks 5, returns ns.
Mike is killed by mafia.
FightingGoat heals Jake.
Herty watches jake, sees FightingGoat and Diebold visit him.
Diebold heals Jake.
Player 10 the sheriff checks 13, returns mafia.

Day Two:
FightingGoat and Herty both vote 5 as soon as voting begins, followed by the consigliere after a short while.
After an extraordinary period of silence, everyone unvotes. FightingGoat proceeds to then vote 10.
Day is then skipped.

Night Two:
Jake does nothing that night.
FightingGoat heals Herty.
Herty chooses to watch 9, then chooses to watch 11, he sees that noone visited.
Diebold heals Jake.
Player 10 dies to mafia.

Day Three:
Night Chat:
Player 10 exclaims that he forgot to change his lw to say that 13 is mafia. Mike is active in the dead chat with him.

Live Chat:
Jake asks 11, 13, 6, 8, 9 for their roles. 11, 13 and 9 are the mafia.
Jake proceeds to say that 13 is mafia and votes him.
13, 8, 9 vote 3. FightingGoat, Herty and Diebold proceed to vote 13.
13 as consig, pulls his read on 8 out as evidence when he is voted to trial. He correctly calls out 8 as lookout/detective/agent. 8(Herty) says nothing and abstains.
13 is executed, at the execution, jake claims that 9 and 11 are mafia.

Night Three:
Jake checks noone.
FightingGoat heals Herty, FightingGoat dies that night
Herty watches 5, sees that noone visited. Is attacked and healed.
Diebold heals Jake.

Day Four:
Jake starts the day by stating that 9 and 11 are mafia.
Gino the Marshall reveal, both 9 and 11 are lynched.
Day is then skipped. Town wins

Conclusions
It is 100% clear that these five were communicating out-side of the game.
They co-ordinated their night actions together and worked together during the day to manipulate sheep lynchers.
Jake was able to get a good idea of who the mafia were by night 2, as evidenced by the fact the lookout switched targets between two mafia on that night. The clan must have got info from Mike in the dead chat, where the dead sheriff says that 13 is mafia. 13 is lynched that same day. Weirdly though, they seem to already know that 9 and 11 are mafia before the lynch goes off. Jake accused 6 in addition to the mafia members. This leads me to believe that they were indeed skyping, and that their final conclusion on who the mafia are was based on the fact 9 and 11 voted innocent, but 6 also voted innocent.

Either way, I can conclude with 100% certainty that there was out-of-game communication between the 5 offenders, and that they used it to their advantage.
Players Added to Report
None.

Game Result
The town won the game by a landslide after starting heavily disadvantaged due to leavers.

Previous Offenses
None.

Verdict(s)
Jake:
1xCheating.
Mike:
1xCheating.
fightingghost:
1xCheating.
Herty:
1xCheating.
Diebold:
1xCheating.

Forum Classification

Approved.

Recommended Action
Watch-list according to punishment guidelines; but since they're a massive group, perhaps their punishments/any future punishments should be more severe.

Thank You for the report.