NarNoO 1-S2-1-1240620 BSeV 1-S2-1-1098257 Tuco 1-S2-1-4457292

[Dose]

This is going to be a long one with multiple replays so bear with me. The first replay isn't "conclusive" but it's what originally caught my eye and they began to be more and more obvious throughout the night. The third Skyper Tuco does not come in until the third replay. I am sending this in one bundle in hopes we can just skip the watch list and automatically kick or banlist them.

Replay name: -Mafia- (56) gamethrowskype
Account Name: NarNoO
Account ID:1-S2-1-1240620
In-Game Name: Otello

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing/Preparty Cheating/ Skyping

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: Falsifies a Last Will clearing his party member BSeV (in game name tristan) of guilt. Refuses to vote unless his party member votes as well. Claims he was voting with mafia by voting with 7 at the end of the game when 7 claims GF and GF not possible. A player with his number of games played would know this for certain. Like I said, this one is flimsy but the falsified Last Will caught my eye when I watched the replay.

Account Name: BSeV
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1098257
In-Game Name: tristan

Crimes Committed: Preparty Cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: Not much evidence in this one aside from him NEVER targeting his teammate (NarNoO) even though he was town and BSeV was Serial Killer, and ALWAYS only voting with him.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Replay Name: -Mafia- (56) skypers again
Account Name: NarNoO
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1240620
In-Game Name:Veteran

Crimes Committed: PreParty Cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name:esoDrevO
Summary: This one is abundantly obvious that they are skyping from the get go. After NarNoO isn't jailed he immediately selects me every night (McRapey The Abstinence Clown) and waits until the mafia selects a target to kill and swaps me with them to try and make my mafia teammate kill me. BSeV (sam jones III) even says "NarNoO sends his regards" in mafia chat thinking that I would immediately die. This continues until BSeV (sam jones III) dies after being bussed by a 2nd Bus Driver.


Account Name: BSeV
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1098257
In-Game Name: sam jones III

Crimes Committed: PreParty Cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: He is mafia with me and it becomes abundantly clear that he is skyping with NarNoO telling him the mafia targets while trying to get me killed. He even says "NarNoO sends his regards" in mafia night chat right before the night ends and I am bussed. Luckily there were two bus drivers so his plans were foiled.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Replay Name: -Mafia- (56) cheatersskypers #3
Account Name: NarNoO
Account ID: 1-S2-1-124062
In-Game Name: Ugo Colombo

Crimes Committed: Preparty Cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name:esoDrevO
Summary: Obviously Skyping with his clan mates (BSeV and Tuco) again. This is further proven on N3 when the new Killer for Mafia was going to kill me (Zanebono DeVito) and he says "No don't. He's going to die." Meaning he knew his skype partner Tuco (Lorenzo) was going to shoot me that night. Luckily, the new Killer attacked Tuco (Lorenzo) on a whim and stopped the attempted gamethrow from the vigilante.

Account Name: Tuco
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4457292
In-Game Name: Lorenzo

Crimes Committed: Attempted Gamethrowing/ Preparty Cheating/ Skyping

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: Obvious Skyping with his clan mates (BSeV and NarNoO). He refuses to vote his clan mates although all of town wanted to vote him and then shoots the player implicating his clan mate as mafia. Skype is further proven when NarNoO (Ugo Columbo) says that Zanebono DeVito is going to die anyway and he shouldn't try to kill him. Proving he knew Tuco (Lorenzo) was going to attack and kill him.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Replay Name: -Mafia- (56) skypers#4
Account Name: BSeV
Account ID: 1-S2-1-109825
In-Game Name: Rick Ross

Crimes Committed: Skyping/Cheating/Gamethrowing

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: Executes the Jailor on N1 as a Jailor (This can be a common mistake so mildly excusable) He then immediately elects to jail Electric Feel after he PM'd the other skype partner Tuco (LUUUDA). Electric Feel claims BodyGuard and BSeV executes him saying "Regards from NarNoO". The three openly admit to cheating towards the end of the game.

Account Name: NarNoO
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1240620
In-Game Name: Boogieman

Crimes Committed: Preparty Cheating/Skyping/Gamethrowing

Your Account Name:esoDrevO
Summary: Openly admitting skyping in chat. Refers to skype teammates by first name in both chat and LW and tells him not to lynch. As soon as someone PMs him saying that they will kill him (The MotherFucker on Day 3) the three skypers immediately vote him and guilty. He also knew he was going to die via skype which is why he suddenly updates his LW the night of his death after not updating his LW the entire game.

Account Name: Tuco
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4457292
In-Game Name: LUUUDA

Crimes Committed: PreParty Cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name:esoDrevO
Summary: Openly admits to cheating via skype on Day 4.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Replay Name: -Mafia- (56) skypers #5
Account Name: BSeV
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1098257
In-Game Name: Say Aah

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing/Preparty Cheating

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: With three players total left (Say Aah the Sheriff, AIDS the investigator, and MESSIIIIIII the SK) He votes for and lynches 6 after investigating him the night before and knowing for a fact he isn't the Serial Killer. After game end they spam "GLSN" (their clan name) in the chat and further proving the gamethrow.

Account Name: Tuco
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4457292
In-Game Name: MESSIIIIIII

Crimes Committed: Preparty cheating/Skyping

Your Account Name: esoDrevO
Summary: Purposely doesn't kill his skype partner (Say Aah) at the end of the game knowing he will vote with him. Say Aah then lynches his town teammate knowing he is innocent, having investigating him the night before and giving Tuco the SK win. They also say GLSN in the chat further proving cheating.

[Dose]

Anyone going to pick this one up

[Damus_Graves]

SC2 ID:
1-S2-1-1240620 is Correct - NarNoO
1-S2-1-1098257 is Correct - BSeV
1-S2-1-4457292 is Correct - Tuco

Before the Review:
Each of these players have the same clan tag and each of them are logged as next to each other on the player list.

Review #1:



Roles
Night Actions
Day Chat
Voting Arrangements
Vote Outcomes


NarNoO
Mayor
N1: Gets Jailed | Claims Doctor | Executed
N/A
N/A
9: Survivor
5: Witch
10: Kidnapper
6: Investigator


BSeV
Sheriff
N1: Lolipoper {NS}


N2: PedoBearLovesYou {NS}


N3: 8 then changed to 10 {Mafia} (Special Note: Begins writing his Last Will for changes, stops, targets someone other than 8 and resumes writing in his LW: N1 14 NS. N2 12 NS gf I believe. N3 8 )


N4: 6 {NS} (Updates last will to: N1 14 NS. N2 12 NS gf I believe. N3 8 mafia N4 6 )
Attacked and Bodyguarded
D1: Doesn't Speak


D2: Doesn't Speak


D3: Claims Sheriff and states 10 is Mafia



D4: Makes a show about not knowing who is who when he checked 6 the previous night and got NS. Claims its a coin flip. At the end he shouts GLSN
Does not vote {Guilties}


Votes for 5 {Guilties}

Votes for 10 {Guilties}


Votes for 6 {Abstains.}
9: Survivor
5: Witch
10: Kidnapper
6: Investigator


Tuco
Serial Killer
N1: Kill PedoBearLovesYou {Immune}


N2: Bob the Smoker {Doctor}


N3: 8 {Agent}


N4: Lolipoper {Doctor}
D1: Doesn't Speak


D2: Doesn't Speak


D3: Doesn't Speak


D4: Claims his accuser, who BSeV has checked and found NS, is SK. Claims Detective. At the end he shouts GLSN
Votes for 9 {Guilties}


Votes for 5 {Guilties}


Votes for 10 {Guilties}


Votes for 6 {Guilties}
9: Survivor
5: Witch
10: Kidnapper
6: Investigator




Review Conclusion #1:
While NarNoO dies early, and is thus unable to be judged for cheating in this review, his other clanmates are in clear communication and they know each others roles and identities. The final lock in this skyping desicion is on the final day when BSeV gets an NS on the person he votes to trial and allows him to be lynched which gives his teammate the win. When they both shout their clan tag it furthers the evidence of Skyping.


Review #2:



Roles
Night Actions
Day Chat
Voting Arrangements


NarNoO
Blackmailor
N1: 5 {Tuco}

N2: 8



N3: 8 then changes to 7 and claims that 8 is going to die tonight.

D1: Doesn't Speak

D2: Asks Jesus for Forgiveness and gets it.

D1: Votes 2 {Guilties} | Doesn't Vote


D2: Does not vote



D3: Silence as he gets hanged.



BSeV
Godfather
N1: 4 {Doctor}


N2: 1 changed to 3 {Veteran Alert Kills him}

D1: Doesn't Speak



Votes 2 {Innocent} | Votes 3





Tuco
Vigilante
N1: Spams trying to shoot somone

N2: 10 {Citizen}



N3: 8 {Detective}
Dies to Mafia

D1: Blackmailed



D2: Does not Speak
Doesn't Vote {Abstains} | Votes 3

Does not vite




Review conclusion #2:
These players once again show they are in some way communicating with each other outside of the game when NarNoO switches targets and says his original target was going to die tonight. It is sheer circumstance that caused the town to win against this skyping party.

Review #3:
Before the game begins they get called out for cheating and skyping and through their words there is an admittance to it. They claim that its only cheaating if roles are being told.




Roles
Night Actions
Day Chat
Voting Arrangements


NarNoO
Investigator
N1: 11 {Beguiler/Bodyguard}

N2: 13 {Jailor/Kidnapper}



N3: 2 {Citizen/Survivor/Amesniac}

D1: Says Jailor hate crimes are happening


D2: Claims the three people voting him are mafia and does not reveal his lead despite a jailor being dead.

D4: He says, when votes pile on Orange, don't lynch steven which suggests he knows who that player is. Orange is BSeV.
Once 9 laughs he replies to him to stfu james which also suggest he knows who 9 is as well.
This suggests out of game communication.
D1: Does not vote

D2: Votes Red {Guiltes}



BSeV
Jailor
N1: 7{Jailor}

N2: 10 {Bodyguard} {special Note: He tells his jailed victim "regards from narnoo" when he executes him}


N3: No Action

D1; Says nothing

D2: Says Nothing

D4: Nothing

D1: Does not vote


D2: Votes Red {Guilties}





Tuco
Agent
N1: 1 {3}

N2: No Action


N3: 5 {9}




D1: Laughs

D2: claims that Red is a cheater and that he has a million replays.

D4: Yells skype team unite.

D1: Does not Vote

D2: Votes Red {Gulties}, Troll votes Purple then cancels the vote.







Review Conclusion #3:
Based on their day chat, as well as the other replays provided these players are communicating outside of the game.

Previous Convictions:
Listed on Kickvote list previously.

Player Offenses:
Cheating, Skyping, Gamethrowing, Greifing.

Recommneded Punishments:
Banlist x4




Keeper Notes:
These accounts have been punished previously and with admittance to cheating. Their actions suggest a clear intent to ruin games for their amusement which leaves other players with a less than fun game experience. They have attempted to guise their cheating under the visage of trolling and have shown no remorse or sign of changing their ways from these replays.
Perma-Ban is suggested as these players have shown a clear wish to continue cheating in the game.

[fred]

5 times .. same group..skyping over and over?

Lets give a lengthy banlist on this one.

8x banlist