Stump is not town?

[Sraw]

We had a setup in which there were 3 random any's which were exclude town/mafia (any neutral role). One of them spawned as a stump (Did not get converted after), confusing the mayor since it made him think he was the only town member left when I was town.

first bug: why does random any exclude town spawn as stump?

second bug: why is stump still not listed as a preset-able role?
If stump is never going to be a preset-able role, it shouldn't have a win associated with it at all.
(I Never seem to get mason leader ever and no one seems to want to play cult vs mason, so I am short so few roles and if this prevents me from getting all roles, it will vex me greatly)

[Deantwo]

a replay would help a lot

other then that... if one of the players was on the Stump-list... i guess it would first give that player a random role like normal... and then turn him into an Stump?

i could be wrong... and hopefully am... but that would meam Stump-listed players could even become mafia or other evils... and then become Stump? there by removing an evil from the game?

[Mugy]

http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Stump

Should hold most of the answers to your questions :)

[Deantwo]

http://wiki.sc2mafia.com/en/index.php/Stump

Should hold most of the answers to your questions :)

it doesn't answer my questions... but yeah OP's question yes

as far as i understand from OP's question... he thought Stump could roll from a Town random...
the answer to that is no... Stump does not roll from any randoms at all

Edit: ooh didn't see OP's second question...
but to answer that... Stump is a punishment role... you can't become a Stump unless a moderator makes you into one (or you are on the Stump-list)... also... there is no "Stump win"