A Contest

[FM Basil Hawkins]

It seems like all the scum has been revealed by now except the ventriloquist. Lets have a contest to guess who he is (contest ends if the vent reveals himself in chat). I'll give +rep after the FM ends to anyone who can help me figure out his identity.

My guess is that Bonney is vented due to the lack of articles, but I'm not sure who the vent would be... What do you think?

Dracule, can you confirm if anyone gets it correct? =)

[FM Soul King Brook]

i merely have time, so i can't read the day chat, will do that later
anyway, it's good that the doctor is still alive and also that a marine died, now the remaining one will probably side with town, since pirates are still 2. and then doc can heal him
i'm also glad they killed such a lurker citizen who was suspicious anyway. dumb move if you ask me

but on the other hand, doc failed to heal so now we need the vote of the exe/jester. damn what it be cool if i was that neutral, i would kill a pirate/cp9, just for fun :D chances to win seem equal anyway for him

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Sure, I'll confirm if someone guesses correctly.

[FM Soul King Brook]

pls someone, hammer him... ANYONE...

i really hate that jester by now... looks like he is a real evil man ;( not siding with the good and innocent people
but pressuring him with the whole town suiciding might work^^ they just have to pick it up from jimbei

[FM Soul King Brook]

yes good job buggy!

[FM Soul King Brook]

my guess is:
drake x - vented
blackbeard - janitor
buggy - vent


edit: mixed them up. now it should be correct. the others should be clear

[FM Soul King Brook]

First Mate, why is it no more possible to see the votes after a lynch since a few days ago?

[FM Ferengi]

I don't know, once auto-lock sets down, players can no longer see the vote tally. But here is the list of people who voted against Crocodile:

Cat Thief Nami
Straw Hat Luffy
Jewelry Bonney
Jimbei
Tony Tony Chopper
Fire Fist Ace
Gecko Moria
Buggy the Clown

[FM Capone Bege]

Vent is Gecko Moria
Krieg's "He HAS been posting" is my clue

[FM Soul King Brook]

drake x: vented, because he said nothing while everyone else did. unless blackbeard, who is most likely the janitor. buggy might actually be a vent, because he accused himself with big mom's account, which was likely to be counter claimed. he wanted to clear buggy from being cp9 i think. anyway i'm not so sure, might aswell be that buggy is vented and one of the other 2 is vent

[FM Soul King Brook]

Vent is Gecko Moria
Krieg's "He HAS been posting" is my clue

then the marines would have lied

[FM Capone Bege]

Marines dont have to tell Town anything about CP9, esp since they're the dominant faction

[FM Soul King Brook]

yes i don't exclude it but i don't think it's very likely

[FM Basil Hawkins]

I think the vent is Gecko Moria even though he voted on the pirate captain.

[FM Crocodile]

I think the vent is the only cleaned person ^.^

[FM Donquixote Doflamingo]

I think the vent is the only cleaned person ^.^

I think this is very possible. It would explain why town still has control over the votes

[FM Capone Bege]

:o hmm it's actually starting to make sense

Big Mom fos'd Gecko Moriah on D2 so Gecko might be clean

[FM Crocodile]

I don't know, once auto-lock sets down, players can no longer see the vote tally. But here is the list of people who voted against Crocodile:

Cat Thief Nami
Straw Hat Luffy
Jewelry Bonney
Jimbei
Tony Tony Chopper
Fire Fist Ace
Gecko Moria
Buggy the Clown

At the request of SFM hosts, there is a reset vote count in the post.

[FM Basil Hawkins]

:o hmm it's actually starting to make sense

Big Mom fos'd Gecko Moriah on D2 so Gecko might be clean

Big Mom tried to lynch me on D2. Just saying.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

At the request of SFM hosts, there is a reset vote count in the post.

Offtopic, but;

Just out of interest, were you doused? I misread my role card, thinking that I needed to be the last one alive to win like in SC2Mafia, so I doused everyone I thought was a killing role ^_^ herpaderp! Was just wondering if you got doused or if you were switched o.O

Night actions:

1: -douse FM Eustass Kidd (dead, rebel leader)
2: -douse FM Crocodile (claims veteran?)
3: -douse FM Buggy the Clown
4: -douse FM Jewelry Bonney (journalist?) (bus driver switch I think...)

[FM Ferengi]

At the request of SFM hosts, there is a reset vote count in the post.

Really? How they can do that?

[FM Ferengi]

By the way, Crocodile, your remaining Pirate's real name is Fatalis. But I have not received night action from him yet (even though his target is quite obvious). Is it ok if I give you access to his day account?

EDIT: Nevermind that, he is simply short of time and does not always have the time to post.

[FM Crocodile]

Really? How they can do that?

There was a problem where hosts couldn't open the threads again, since the required amount of votes was met. Oops added a resetvote BBcode tag in all FM GM lynch posts to stop this.

[FM Crocodile]

By the way, Crocodile, your remaining Pirate's real name is Fatalis. But I have not received night action from him yet (even though his target is quite obvious). Is it ok if I give you access to his day account?

EDIT: Nevermind that, he is simply short of time and does not always have the time to post.

I have faith in Fatalis, but I would play if I got the chance.

[FM Crocodile]

Offtopic, but;

Just out of interest, were you doused? I misread my role card, thinking that I needed to be the last one alive to win like in SC2Mafia, so I doused everyone I thought was a killing role ^_^ herpaderp! Was just wondering if you got doused or if you were switched o.O

Night actions:

1: -douse FM Eustass Kidd (dead, rebel leader)
2: -douse FM Crocodile (claims veteran?)
3: -douse FM Buggy the Clown
4: -douse FM Jewelry Bonney (journalist?) (bus driver switch I think...)

Yes, I did. My Vest was in danger!

[FM Basil Hawkins]

lol what if basil was the vent after all^^ it matches, don't you think so? caribou being suddenly released? noone claimed vented after? town always get one more vote than expected? and last but not least his contest about finding the vent^^

Gonna post this here since it was chronologically the first post in dead chat to mention this.
+ Rep is due to both Soul King Brook and Crocodile after the FM for figuring it out :P

[FM Soul King Brook]

yees^^ win + rep :D
anyway, bonney joking vented was kinda shocking since i was almost sure about this theory^^
nice try cp9 to reveal and try to convince the town they can't lynch^^ because they were obvious anyway
but i feel sorry for the marines, i wish he could survive and win with town. d9 they'd better lynch a pirate, that would save 1 person, nami in this case. but it wasn't clear who he was, probably blackbeard (unless cp9 lied)

[FM Soul King Brook]

ah and why didn't you witch the captain this night? he pretty much announced he's going to kill basil

[FM Whitebeard]

"All the scum will claim citizen! We should lynch all citizen claimers!"

Drug Dealer: "Imma escort"
Framer: "Imma bus driver"
Ventriloquist: "Imma doctor"
Witch: "Imma coroner"

[FM Soul King Brook]

that's probably because you have to claim a PR if there's a lynch train on you^^ or you get lynched
btw cyborg also hinted PR (vet)

[FM Whitebeard]

I think it's a stupid policy to lynch people for claiming citizen and let PR claims off the hook no matter how scummy they are / unable to prove themselves.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Were you really, Basil?
That would explain why the vent on me didn't go on.
It actually didn't work out too bad, but meh!

[FM Basil Hawkins]

ah and why didn't you witch the captain this night? he pretty much announced he's going to kill basil

My wallet actually was stolen so I was afk in day/night chat and requested replacement. Blame Dracule for that one! :P

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

My wallet actually was stolen so I was afk in day/night chat and requested replacement. Blame Dracule for that one! :P

Haha oh sheesh.
Hope you found your wallet!
Did Dracule end up controlling my account for the day or something?

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Yes, I did. My Vest was in danger!

Doesn't burning ignore invulnerability? =p I can only focus on what might have been... :c

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

My wallet actually was stolen so I was afk in day/night chat and requested replacement. Blame Dracule for that one! :P

I still blame Crocodile for not making his instructions clear. He was speaking as cp9, so I thought he was referring to us as pirates.


Haha oh sheesh.
Hope you found your wallet!
Did Dracule end up controlling my account for the day or something?

No. She just blames me for not witching Crocodile that night. I thought he was going to kill someone on the list he posted, so I thought I'd let him go for it and get the clean.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

So the CP9 is probably losing their last member, Sanji, today?

I still don't understand how this all happened. In my mind, this was a clear CP9 win.
Think it can be turned around?

[FM Soul King Brook]

it's a clear town win. i never stopped hoping^^

[FM Soul King Brook]

and i hope they don't let that jester win. he failed to chose the right side

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

can i know who boa hancock was? the person seems to have left already.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Don't be so sure yet.
What if Sanji isn't lynched today?

We don't know how the others will react.
Do we even know who the last pirate is?

[FM Don Krieg]

I tried to use a bit of WIFOM when Crocodile, who was not really suspected, decided to reveal himself as the Pirate Captain. I am a little bit frustrated about that since you should never get cocky, no matter how near victory is.. :/

We would've won even without the Ventriloquist, I'm sure, but with all these reveals it was hard and Pirates failing to kill twice in a row because they wanted the Marines gone.. come on. :/
Alright, alright, I haven't been a very good player either, but I did my best in my first FM. :D

Caribou, I'm not CmG. :D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

tell you the truth. this is my first huge fm as well. ive done a m-fm and s-fm.

i bet you know who i am based off how im typing right now.

[FM Don Krieg]

tell you the truth. this is my first huge fm as well. ive done a m-fm and s-fm.

i bet you know who i am based off how im typing right now.

Not sure. I actually had a guess I think, but I forgot them all. I only knew Big Mom to be Damus_Graves because it became painfully obvious to me after what he wrote when he FoS'd me on Day 1.
I had someone pinned as Apache, but didn't care about that.. was that you? I dunno.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

no im not apech. seeing how game is coming to a close can we real our real com names here?

i will say i did have fun with the vid battle. i cant wait to have all the rooms open. i made a log of my last 2 nights. i wanted to have some epic rp in there

[FM Don Krieg]

no im not apech. seeing how game is coming to a close can we real our real com names here?

i will say i did have fun with the vid battle. i cant wait to have all the rooms open. i made a log of my last 2 nights. i wanted to have some epic rp in there

Yeah, I laughed pretty hard. I do wonder if you know my COM. I doubt that many would know, atleast the ones who I played some S-FMs with would know I think, or atleast guess correctly.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Dangit. I know you mentionned being german at some point so I assumed. D:

Drat!

Also, I genuinely laugh at your serious post about how ''Caribou seriously lost his wallet'' and that I was vented for the next days.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Yeah, I laughed pretty hard. I do wonder if you know my COM. I doubt that many would know, atleast the ones who I played some S-FMs with would know I think, or atleast guess correctly.

not a clue i havent played enough fms around here to figure out com names. if i deafulted to who i am by start i think most ppl would figure who i am. do you have any idea who boa was? i want o say it was twenty-two if he signed

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

here i will give away my com by doing sometihng that makes it blaintly obvious on who i am. brb

[FM Don Krieg]

Dangit. I know you mentionned being german at some point so I assumed. D:

Drat!

Also, I genuinely laugh at your serious post about how ''Caribou seriously lost his wallet'' and that I was vented for the next days.

Well, I was correct in some way, I just didn't mean the real Caribou but the Caribou at that time. :D
I just wonder if I really mentioned it somewhere.. Dangit! I didn't want to do that if I did. D:
I don't think many people know that I'm German, just some from the Steam Mafia chat and Slaol since he wanted to know in which time zone I live. :D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

now then, know who i am?

[FM Don Krieg]

now then, know who i am?

LOL OH GOD!

I kind of thought that it was you ika, but then I dismissed it since ika usually has more spelling mistakes! xD

[FM Don Krieg]

Oh yeah, I got a hint for you: Mintberry Crunch pretended to be me while "trolling" you. ;)

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Oh yeah, I got a hint for you: Mintberry Crunch pretended to be me while "trolling" you. ;)

now i know. i'll let others try to find out who you are. When im doing the bigger fms i try to be grammar correct so ppl dont figure out its me as easily.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

so is/was blackbeard the accual last pirate or do you just not know?

i wish you did kill pirate i would of sided with you. i was gonna keep that promise but you didnt keep the end of the bargin

[FM Don Krieg]

so is/was blackbeard the accual last pirate or do you just not know?

i wish you did kill pirate i would of sided with you. i was gonna keep that promise but you didnt keep the end of the bargin

We actually knew all roles the night we killed Donquixote. Until then it was guessing for the PRs. The last pirate was told to us by Crocodile when he pretended to be vented.

Killing the Janitor would've resulted in our loss instantly, you know. ;D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

We actually knew all roles the night we killed Donquixote. Until then it was guessing for the PRs. The last pirate was told to us by Crocodile when he pretended to be vented.

Killing the Janitor would've resulted in our loss instantly, you know. ;D

how did you know all roles?

i see how it would cause an all loss now. but you could of killed me too XD. doesnt sanji have his gun still?

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

I had no idea who anyone's COM was this game :S

If I had lived I would have sided with town instead of the pirates. I was town originally and I felt town deserved the win slightly more. There were some derps but I think town were pretty good on the whole. We managed to lynch scum most days and got a lot of scum to claim early on. The only problem was we didn't follow through with the lynchs once they had claimed but with no counter-claims that was understandable.

CP9 probably deserve the win even if it doesn't look like they'll get it. Sanji and Mihawk were mainly caught by rebel recruits and Basil did a great job venting Big Mom. Don was one of our recruit candidates for the future so we could have ended up failing on 2 CP9 and have an infiltrator in our team :p

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i was planning on say screw you town im with cp9 near the end. it just that the illusion of infiltrator still existing is the fun part of this. were you seriously the only rebel?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i was planning on say screw you town im with cp9 near the end. it just that the illusion of infiltrator still existing is the fun part of this. were you seriously the only rebel?

besides the origional 2

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

i was planning on say screw you town im with cp9 near the end. it just that the illusion of infiltrator still existing is the fun part of this. were you seriously the only rebel?
Yup. We only went to recruit Sanji, me and Mihawk.

[FM Don Krieg]

how did you know all roles?

i see how it would cause an all loss now. but you could of killed me too XD. doesnt sanji have his gun still?

Donquixote could probably answer that second question. :D

As for your first, well.. Bonney was confirmed Journalist. Crocodile was obvious, we witched him nearly the whole game. When he pretended to be vented he revealed his Janitor.
You revealed yourself along with Marco. Donquixote was subtle in his hints but it was obvious enough for us to pick up on it, wonder why Bonney didn't if even I did. Probably not so smart. :>
Tony claimed Rebel and was plausible.. that's about it. Like I siad, we knew when we found out about Donquixote being the Gunsmith. Until then there were some speculations and we relied on our notes and when we had all the roles nailed town nobody took them anymore because.. for what purpose? ;D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

oh. well im too lazy to go back and see who he revealed. i was hoping you would kill pirate and then we have fun on the roulette of jester

[FM Don Krieg]

CP9 probably deserve the win even if it doesn't look like they'll get it. Sanji and Mihawk were mainly caught by rebel recruits and Basil did a great job venting Big Mom. Don was one of our recruit candidates for the future so we could have ended up failing on 2 CP9 and have an infiltrator in our team :p

You know, on Night 3 I actually said in our night chat that I thought I had fucked up because I have been too obvious with being citizen OR the Rebels would only aim for TPRs as to make them very strong because night chat is awesome. We decided to not care about me being recruited by you but instead kill off some Rebels because they were a threat. :D

[FM Don Krieg]

oh. well im too lazy to go back and see who he revealed. i was hoping you would kill pirate and then we have fun on the roulette of jester

My worry was that Pirate was going to kill you. You wouldn't have survived the night (which you didn't :D) and killing off the Janitor then would have only made it worse for us overall.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

the night if you killed jan i would of lived due to doc. but after you killed the doc...

i was hoping that what would of happened is its cp9, me, pirate, and jester. we all roulette the jester, pirate kills me, you kill pirate, and jester kills you. if something like that were to happen i would lolzed so hard at it

[FM Soul King Brook]

don you said you knew my COM. so you think i'm apache? why?

besides:
is 'i find you scummy' relly correct english? have read this so often
and do you also know where i am from?

[FM Don Krieg]

the night if you killed jan i would of lived due to doc. but after you killed the doc...

i was hoping that what would of happened is its cp9, me, pirate, and jester. we all roulette the jester, pirate kills me, you kill pirate, and jester kills you. if something like that were to happen i would lolzed so hard at it
Well that was practically impossible after Pirate decided to go straight for you. :D

We expected the Pirate to realize that going for the Doctor would be good now instead of going for the Marines AGAIN, I even told him to go for the Doctor I think so we didn't kill him, not quite sure at the moment.. Well he really wanted you guys dead, didn't he. :D

[FM Soul King Brook]

don, are you saying that drake is the last pirate? and i'd also like to know who boa was. host, mind telling us?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Well that was practically impossible after Pirate decided to go straight for you. :D

We expected the Pirate to realize that going for the Doctor would be good now instead of going for the Marines AGAIN, I even told him to go for the Doctor I think so we didn't kill him, not quite sure at the moment.. Well he really wanted you guys dead, didn't he. :D

i know. what you should of done is silenced the pirate for going after me and i would of sided with you. i would of been like i dunno how many more rebels exist so we must wipe you all out as an excuse to side with you. btw who is/was your favotire fm player in here? not com wise since we dont know em but fm wise. i love bonnie for journalist

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

and i'd also like to know who boa was. host, mind telling us?

i second that. boa was a jerk and took the game too seriously.

[FM Don Krieg]

don you said you knew my COM. so you think i'm apache? why?

besides:
is 'i find you scummy' relly correct english? have read this so often
and do you also know where i am from?
I just compared yours and Apache's writing style and concluded that you were Apache.. was on Day 1 I think. I obviously could be wrong though but your writing style's were too similar.

Well, I don't think it's very wrong. I would also say something like "I find you to be cute" so I would say "I find you to be scummy" or something, not sure if it's right though.
Dunno, too lazy to guess. :D

[FM Don Krieg]

i know. what you should of done is silenced the pirate for going after me and i would of sided with you. i would of been like i dunno how many more rebels exist so we must wipe you all out as an excuse to side with you. btw who is/was your favotire fm player in here? not com wise since we dont know em but fm wise. i love bonnie for journalist

Was a bit hard because we also had our personal aims and didn't know if we could trust the Marines, you showed big signs to scumhunt us, later you seemed to change but it still looked like you wanted to hunt us. :>

Favorite FM player? I would say Buggy because he was funny at times and didn't really care if he looked suspicious and somehow nobody ever really suspected him because of his lynches I guess. :D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Was a bit hard because we also had our personal aims and didn't know if we could trust the Marines, you showed big signs to scumhunt us, later you seemed to change but it still looked like you wanted to hunt us. :>

Favorite FM player? I would say Buggy because he was funny at times and didn't really care if he looked suspicious and somehow nobody ever really suspected him because of his lynches I guess. :D

i was planning on upholding my end of the bargin if you took the pirate. we still had the common enmy of rebels. i would say next lets get tony and then finihs this town

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

buugy i liked too just fun all around

[FM Soul King Brook]

i hope he doesn't throw the game now
mhm i find you to be scummy sounds better^^

[FM Soul King Brook]

nami when marco was dead, if you alone sided with the cp9 on the presumption that the vent is still alive, you would probably have lost too. it's 6 vs 2 now. they actually never had problems to get the votes, there was still 1 or 2 in reserve. now they can also afford a non-lynch, a mislynch or lynching the jester who doesn't deserve win ;)

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

meh i could wait it out because of rebels.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

or at least try

[FM Don Krieg]

nami when marco was dead, if you alone sided with the cp9 on the presumption that the vent is still alive, you would probably have lost too. it's 6 vs 2 now. they actually never had problems to get the votes, there was still 1 or 2 in reserve. now they can also afford a non-lynch, a mislynch or lynching the jester who doesn't deserve win ;)

Well we counted the Marines in with the town. With a simple mislynch we would have won if a Pirate and a CP9 would be left standing as to secure 2 KPN. Crocodile thought our Vent was still alive and revealed, which made mislynches impossible before one faction was wiped out.

If Marines sided with us from the beginning then we would've won pretty easily. We would've needed to convince the Pirates though, and this doesn't work as good.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Well we counted the Marines in with the town. With a simple mislynch we would have won if a Pirate and a CP9 would be left standing as to secure 2 KPN. Crocodile thought our Vent was still alive and revealed, which made mislynches impossible before one faction was wiped out.

If Marines sided with us from the beginning then we would've won pretty easily. We would've needed to convince the Pirates though, and this doesn't work as good.

was/is blackbeard the last pirate though?

[FM Crocodile]

Second Contest. Who is the last pirate?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

we were planning on using our jailor to talk to you if i happen to find you and prob side with you. but you ended up killing us off....

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Second Contest. Who is the last pirate?

so what you are saying is that blackbeard isnt the jan and hes trying for a mislynch

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

uh-oh looks like black leg made the nail in his coffin

[FM Don Krieg]

we were planning on using our jailor to talk to you if i happen to find you and prob side with you. but you ended up killing us off....

Before the reset we (I was DD) thought it was good to try to convince the Jailor to side with us. After though my teammates decided to hide from the Marines even if jailed. I proposed to ally with them if jailed but they deemed it safer. :D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

well before reste i was a cit so....

[FM Don Krieg]

It's actually funny because a mislynch wouldn't get them back into the game if my math is right.. but CP9 won't go down as easily (and maybe Sanji really wants to avenge us, but personally? :D)

[FM Soul King Brook]

kinda glad right now we won't win with marines who would betray us when they had the chance to do^^ sole winning faction, that's quite nice^^ if they sided with you from beginning, we would have lost probably, i agree, but you can't form alliances already at the beginning. if they sided with you after it was clear who you were and when it was cp9 vs town, then it wouldn't hurt us since the clues didn't give us scum and we wouldn't need the vote. and pirates would even more try to kill them off to ensure their alliance

for the last pirate, either drake x oder blackbeard. drake x voted one cp9, blackbeard never voted. anyway i tend to drake x because the cp9 tries to start a mislynch now and crocodile definitely talked much about killing drake x, who might be the last pirate who should disguise...

[FM Soul King Brook]

we were planning on using our jailor to talk to you if i happen to find you and prob side with you. but you ended up killing us off....

i thought about pretending cp9 in jail chat and give you fake cp9 members who i thought to be town. but then i was convinced you'd let me go if i claimed citi

[FM Soul King Brook]

It's actually funny because a mislynch wouldn't get them back into the game if my math is right.. but CP9 won't go down as easily (and maybe Sanji really wants to avenge us, but personally? :D)

you're right, if they mislynch now it's over but if they lynch the confirmed cp9 now and then mislynch, because they don't know the pirate, then they still win. so they really have to be very dumb to not lynch sanji now. they don't even need his vote to lynch a pirate, they have the number. they just have to come online

[FM Don Krieg]

i thought about pretending cp9 in jail chat and give you fake cp9 members who i thought to be town. but then i was convinced you'd let me go if i claimed citi

The next person didn't quite have the same luck. :D:D
Or, did he claim cit? I don't even know. We will see. :D

[FM Don Krieg]

you're right, if they mislynch now it's over but if they lynch the confirmed cp9 now and then mislynch, because they don't know the pirate, then they still win. so they really have to be very dumb to not lynch sanji now. they don't even need his vote to lynch a pirate, they have the number. they just have to come online

Yeah it's like this:
9 players. 2 scum, 1 neutral.
6vs3
mislynch
5vs3
2 kills, no overlap
3vs3 GG scum :)

Otherwise it's
6vs3
lynch on Sanji
6vs2
only one night kill
5vs2
one mislynch maybe
4vs2
one night kill
3vs2
no GG scum :( (although it was still a good game. :D)

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

you're right, if they mislynch now it's over but if they lynch the confirmed cp9 now and then mislynch, because they don't know the pirate, then they still win. so they really have to be very dumb to not lynch sanji now. they don't even need his vote to lynch a pirate, they have the number. they just have to come online

well it depends. if cp9 died early on we would be forced with town. its just that rebels were afoot. i was truly torn between siding between cp9 and town this late game. on one hand doc saved me sevral times over. on the other cp9 does desrve a win for being so good. part of me just anted to press the sucide button

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Yeah it's like this:
9 players. 2 scum, 1 neutral.
6vs3
mislynch
5vs3
2 kills, no overlap
3vs3 GG scum :)

Otherwise it's
6vs3
lynch on Sanji
6vs2
only one night kill
5vs2
one mislynch maybe
4vs2
one night kill
3vs2
no GG scum :( (although it was still a good game. :D)

and if overlap?

[FM Don Krieg]

XD
Silly Blackbeard.

[FM Soul King Brook]

The next person didn't quite have the same luck. :D:D
Or, did he claim cit? I don't even know. We will see. :D

according to marco he did. but he talked too much bullshit i guess^^

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

did he just say that? i am lolzing so hard i was attacked and healed

[FM Don Krieg]

and if overlap?

6vs3
mislynch YAY
5vs3
2 KPN but overlap
4vs3
oh no!
*roll D20 for mislynch*
*rolls 20*
YAAY MISLYNCH
3vs3 WIN :d

[FM Don Krieg]

did he just say that? i am lolzing so hard i was attacked and healed

Well, he is speaking the truth if we are talking about night feedback. Lulul :D

[FM Capone Bege]

Hahah what a twist...Orpz here
I'm glad the dead chats are more active now :) definitely more fun than the game itself. Being a Citizen is boring especially with 48 hour nights.

I'll personally apologize to Ace/Numbertwo after for being focused on him since I really thought he was scum.

[FM Soul King Brook]

you drugged him^^ *me captain obvious*

[FM Crocodile]

AppleyNO LVP here.

X Drake is the last pirate xD

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

lolz this is great. but in all honesty you should of left doc alive and had pirate kill the doc the pirate would have to forsee that i got a doc and i wont die. HAI ORPZ! you ready for my jester game tonight. im considering sending out role cards with some rp value in it. i made my opening very rp

[FM Don Krieg]

AppleyNO LVP here.

X Drake is the last pirate xD

So it's YOUU!
No hard feelings, but I was frustrated because your message made it seem like, if at all, then X Drake would go for Basil as the Disguiser, so if we wanted to save Basil we would've witched X Drake and not you.. :D

[FM Don Krieg]

lolz this is great. but in all honesty you should of left doc alive and had pirate kill the doc the pirate would have to forsee that i got a doc and i wont die. HAI ORPZ! you ready for my jester game tonight. im considering sending out role cards with some rp value in it. i made my opening very rp

EXACTLYYYY!

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

AppleyNO LVP here.

X Drake is the last pirate xD

APPLE THATS YOU! YOUR CROCK?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

EXACTLYYYY!

they why did you kill him?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

btw we do get to know our allies in the day night 0 we are told who is our day ppl was/are

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

T_T I'm still pissed that I got lynched while I was asleep. I mean, I thought lurking with the citizens would be a strong idea... :(

[FM Capone Bege]

Hell yea, I'm ready to get driven to insanity by the Jester King

RP is great but it's your first time hosting so make sure to prioritize being a better host than a better RP'er!

[FM Don Krieg]

they why did you kill him?

Because the pirate did not kill the doc after given the hint to do so twice, the second when Dracule revealed as the CP9 and directed the Pirate to kill the doc.

[FM Don Krieg]

T_T I'm still pissed that I got lynched while I was asleep. I mean, I thought lurking with the citizens would be a strong idea... :(

You gotta seem pro-town, lurkish town is not enough. :D

But man, with you igniting that would've been game. :D

[FM Soul King Brook]

AppleyNO LVP here.

X Drake is the last pirate xD

i can't follow you right now, the first line...

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Hell yea, I'm ready to get driven to insanity by the Jester King

RP is great but it's your first time hosting so make sure to prioritize being a better host than a better RP'er!

dont worry, i will be around for a bit to watch things progress. when im not doing anything i sit on the fourm and stare. so i will be around to watch the lolz arise. i also have another one planned to make after this but be a bit diffrently. have you seen the marshmellow mafia one? i was planning on making a more complex one of it. with some fun mix in

@apoo yes if you got the ignite...

i just wish i saved you from hammer.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

wait is ace rebbel? or is he faking it?

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

You gotta seem pro-town, lurkish town is not enough. :D

But man, with you igniting that would've been game. :D

I don't know, it seemed like I had a pretty diverse range of roles doused lol. Rebel leader + journalist + pirate captain + FM Buggy the Clown (whatever he is) o.O I guess it would help CP9 which is all that matters :)

[FM Don Krieg]

OH NO, BUGGY IS ONLINE

[FM Don Krieg]

I don't know, it seemed like I had a pretty diverse range of roles doused lol. Rebel leader + journalist + pirate captain + FM Buggy the Clown (whatever he is) o.O I guess it would help CP9 which is all that matters :)

Yeah I think it would've helped us more than town because Rebel Leader is out which gives hints, Journalist which is good, and a citizen (that's all that's left for Buggy's role).

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

OH NO, BUGGY IS ONLINE

What role is he/suspected to be?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

OH NO, BUGGY IS ONLINE

YA THIS IS IT MOMENT OF TRUTH!

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

*commences rapid refresh*

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

*commences rapid refresh*

100% he'll vote haha.

[FM Don Krieg]

What role is he/suspected to be?

Like I said, citizen. :D
We got the Bus Driver, we got the Doctor, we got the Coroner, we got the Blacksmith and the Journalist is still alive. That's all PRs. If there's a second Rebel it would likely be Fire Fist Ace as we suggested in the night chat, but we killed the Scout and Leader anyway so we didn't care about further Rebels like Tony.
Either way Buggy should be citizen.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Like I said, citizen. :D
We got the Bus Driver, we got the Doctor, we got the Coroner, we got the Blacksmith and the Journalist is still alive. That's all PRs. If there's a second Rebel it would likely be Fire Fist Ace as we suggested in the night chat, but we killed the Scout and Leader anyway so we didn't care about further Rebels like Tony.
Either way Buggy should be citizen.

There's another neutral, I figured him or Zoro for jester :p

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Omg i can't hammer until I finish my monologue. But I can't think of anything because I didn't interact with Sanji at all.

OMG LOLZ TROLLAGE GALORE

[FM Soul King Brook]

i can't follow you right now, the first line...

oh it's his COM, lol^^ sry i am new to the forum ;)

nah ace is no rebel, just wants to survive

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Omg i can't hammer until I finish my monologue. But I can't think of anything because I didn't interact with Sanji at all.

OMG LOLZ TROLLAGE GALORE

inb4googled quote from One Piece

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

inb4googled quote from One Piece

link plz. gtg eat brb

[FM Don Krieg]

There's another neutral, I figured him or Zoro for jester :p

It's Zoro since he played like an Executioner and revealed himself as a neutral role Day 3 or something but we noticed that someone was annoyed so Zoro has been a Jester all along. His plan was to pretend to be a Student of the real Journalist, get Bonney lynched, then as she flips Journalist they would lynch Zoro, or so he probably thought. :D

[FM Soul King Brook]

It's Zoro since he played like an Executioner and revealed himself as a neutral role Day 3 or something but we noticed that someone was annoyed so Zoro has been a Jester all along. His plan was to pretend to be a Student of the real Journalist, get Bonney lynched, then as she flips Journalist they would lynch Zoro, or so he probably thought. :D

then they would think he is exe/jester for sure lol^^ bad plan. i also thought jester until he blamed the host for making journalist his target. then i noticed that all rb's were drugged and that d2 the drugged feedback was on luffy, so it was clear. for you it was easier of course because you know who you dd

[FM Don Krieg]

then they would think he is exe/jester for sure lol^^ bad plan. i also thought jester until he blamed the host for making journalist his target. then i noticed that all rb's were drugged and that d2 the drugged feedback was on luffy, so it was clear. for you it was easier of course because you know who you dd

The Zoro actually wanted to win by pretending to be a disguiser but Crocodile, thinking he had already won, revealed everything, even Zoro's lie which would've helped us. :D

[FM Don Krieg]

Hmh, yeah, good choice of last words Sanji. *applause* I liked it.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

It's Zoro since he played like an Executioner and revealed himself as a neutral role Day 3 or something but we noticed that someone was annoyed so Zoro has been a Jester all along. His plan was to pretend to be a Student of the real Journalist, get Bonney lynched, then as she flips Journalist they would lynch Zoro, or so he probably thought. :D

Kind of sneaky.


But not really.

[FM Soul King Brook]

now hammer him^^

[FM Capone Bege]

What were the CP9 night chat names? I want to know who rolled Lucchi or Kaku

When I was a Marine, I rolled Smoker so I was pretty stoked.

[FM Don Krieg]

What were the CP9 night chat names? I want to know who rolled Lucchi or Kaku

When I was a Marine, I rolled Smoker so I was pretty stoked.

I got Lucci. Before the reset I was Blueno. :D
Witch was Kalifa, Ventriloquist was Kaku.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

What were the CP9 night chat names? I want to know who rolled Lucchi or Kaku

When I was a Marine, I rolled Smoker so I was pretty stoked.

I actually thought the Smoker reference in day chat was from Left for Dead lol.

[FM Don Krieg]

I actually thought the Smoker reference in day chat was from Left for Dead lol.

I wasn't sure how it fit in so I was kinda suspicious of why Marco voted Buggy for that. Man, it made so much sense when Marco said he suspected Buggy because of the sentence. My One Piece knowledge paid off at that moment!

[FM Don Krieg]

HAMMERED

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

I wasn't sure how it fit in so I was kinda suspicious of why Marco voted Buggy for that. Man, it made so much sense when Marco said he suspected Buggy because of the sentence. My One Piece knowledge paid off at that moment!

I confess I know nothing of One Piece. I had to go away and Google it for some time before I figured out just what the heck was going in with all the weird characters. As such, all One Piece references went totally over my head :)

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

HAMMERED

Did Buggy just claim Pirate Captain? :o

[FM Don Krieg]

Did Buggy just claim Pirate Captain? :o

Not possible anyway. He probably wants to RP a bit and may think that Buggy is a Pirate with the chance of being the Pirate King, which is absurd, everyone knows that Luffy is going to be the one. ;P

[FM Soul King Brook]

i know one piece but i don't watch it. now kill drake and we all can rest in piece

[FM Don Krieg]

I hope Drake realizes that he has lost and surrenders or Fragos ends the game, which I doubt though because he will wait for an "official" ending.

I watched One Piece up to episode 191 I think, suddenly turned boring then. I would still love to watch it though. I think it's one of the best "shounen" anime out there if you consider the most popular ones like Naruto, Bleach, Dragon Ball etc.

[FM Capone Bege]

Introduced themselves and stayed active!
Big Mom/Citizen
Blackbeard/Citizen
Boa Hancock/Citizen
Buggy the Clown/Citizen
Capone Bege/Citizen
Jewelry Bonney/Journalist
Straw Hat Luffy/Doctor
Tony Tony Chopper/Citizen
Wet Hair Caribou/Citizen
Gecko Moriah/Citizen
Soul King Brook/Citizen
Black Leg Sanji/Drug Dealer
Don Krieg/Infiltrator
Dracule Mihawk/Witch
Urouge/Framer
Whitebeard/Rebel Scout
Eustass Kidd/Rebel Leader
Roronoa Zoro/Executioner


Showed interest and posted a good amount of times
Fire Fist Ace/Citizen
Trafalgar Law/Citizen
Donquixote Doflamingo/Blacksmith
Hody Jones/Detective
Basil Hawkins/Ventriloquist
Crocodile/Pirate Captain
Cyborg Franky/First Mate


Active Lurkers
Foxy the Silver Fox/Jailor
Marco the Phoenix/Enforcer
X Drake/Janitor



Lurker/AFK...3 posts or less
Bartholomew Kuma/Coroner
Jimbei/Citizen
Nico Robin/Citizen
Red Hair Shanks/Citizen
Sogeking/Bus Driver
Cat Thief Nami/Navy Admiral
Scratchmen Apoo/Arsonist

Greetings/Spammy first post
Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut
Gimli
Rubber Duck
Dracula

Borderline
Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim
Watson

Non-introductory first posts
Anubis
Michigan J
Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Not possible anyway. He probably wants to RP a bit and may think that Buggy is a Pirate with the chance of being the Pirate King, which is absurd, everyone knows that Luffy is going to be the one. ;P

Heh, funny if it messes up the game even more... :p

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

DAY 1 DISCUSSION
I saw this in the previous FM and thought it was a neat bit of information to help people for future FM's (same goes for me, this is my first FM). I didn't double check for accuracy but this should give a good idea

Introduced themselves and stayed active!
Big Mom
Blackbeard
Boa Hancock
Buggy the Clown
Capone Bege
Jewelry Bonney
Straw Hat Luffy
Tony Tony Chopper
Wet Hair Caribou
Gecko Moriah
Soul King Brook
Black Leg Sanji
Don Krieg
Dracule Mihawk
Urouge
Whitebeard
Eustass Kidd
Roronoa Zoro

Showed interest and posted a good amount of times
Fire Fist Ace
Trafalgar Law
Hody Jones
Basil Hawkins
Crocodile
Cyborg Franky

Active Lurkers
Foxy the Silver Fox
Marco the Phoenix
X Drake

Lurker/AFK...3 posts or less
Bartholomew Kuma
Jimbei
Nico Robin
Red Hair Shanks
Sogeking
Cat Thief Nami
Scratchmen Apoo

Greetings/Spammy first post
Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut
Gimili
Rubber Duck
Dracula

Borderline
Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim
Watson

Non-introductory first posts
Anubis
Michigan J
Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie

Hey, don't include me in that dirty "Lurker/AFK" list! I was a replacement for the original Apoo some nights in :(

[FM Don Krieg]

Whoop I'm active! Although I haven't posted so much.. My defense seemed citizen-like though, I think I was able to hold off against Big Mom decently.. it's just that silly Damus tried to go against me again and again hoping for a scum slip but that was his doom as his COM was easily revealed. :D

[FM Capone Bege]

Hey, don't include me in that dirty "Lurker/AFK" list! I was a replacement for the original Apoo some nights in :(

I didn't track replacements :p blame the other Apoo

[FM Capone Bege]

Whoop I'm active! Although I haven't posted so much.. My defense seemed citizen-like though, I think I was able to hold off against Big Mom decently.. it's just that silly Damus tried to go against me again and again hoping for a scum slip but that was his doom as his COM was easily revealed. :D

Basil did a good job of mimicking him, I was convinced that he was Damus up until his flip

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

I didn't track replacements :p blame the other Apoo

Damn that scoundrel.


Not that I was really any better, but by then I figured it would be very weird if I suddenly went super active.

[FM Whitebeard]

Gecko and Urouge actually STARTED lurking after day 1/2.

[FM Capone Bege]

The list is based entirely off of Day 1.5 :p

[FM Don Krieg]

Basil did a good job of mimicking him, I was convinced that he was Damus up until his flip

Yep, I even jokingly questioned if Big Mom was still vented by us in the night chat. :D

Dracule and Basil are both good candidates for MVP, I will vote for one of them I think. :)

[FM Capone Bege]

Straw Hat Luffy pulled off 2 extremely clutch heals, so he has my vote for Town MVP.

Scum MVP would be Dracule imo. All of CP9 played very well but he found Pirate Captain night1, and seemed the most pro-town throughout and as such, I was unable to gather support from the rest of the Town to pressure him as much as I would have liked.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

back. i love it when i voted big mom and ppl went like WTF

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

orpz you still here?

[FM Capone Bege]

yeah I'm here

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

I'm still sad about Big Mom. I totally called that he was vented since the beginning.
(PLUS, I ended up being the vented person the next day. Shucks.)

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

well i didnt want to reveal my role and say vent alert because pirates.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Yep, I even jokingly questioned if Big Mom was still vented by us in the night chat. :D

Dracule and Basil are both good candidates for MVP, I will vote for one of them I think. :)

Thanks. Though I have to ask... Why did you guys kill Red Haired Shanks the night after I died? I told you to kill Luffy! And Shanks was the worst lurker ever. Completely worthless to town. I think that was probably the worst kill you could have made. And it hurt my soul to see it happen. :(


Straw Hat Luffy pulled off 2 extremely clutch heals, so he has my vote for Town MVP.

Scum MVP would be Dracule imo. All of CP9 played very well but he found Pirate Captain night1, and seemed the most pro-town throughout and as such, I was unable to gather support from the rest of the Town to pressure him as much as I would have liked.

Not to take this away from Luffy completely, since obviously he healed the right people, but pirates really should have known not to attack Nami since she was likely to be healed... Though I think Don and Sanji share responsibility with the pirates for the second failed pirate attack because they didn't follow my instructions and kill the doctor after I died...


well i didnt want to reveal my role and say vent alert because pirates.

NAMI. Y U NO UNVOTE ME?!

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

NAMI. Y U NO UNVOTE ME?!

Work...... same with sanji. When im working i dont have acess to internet really i need to get my ipod touch connected when im working. but my work doesnt allow me to really do that

[FM Whitebeard]

Capone is Orpz eh?

You did really well for first time citizen in a big FM. Good job.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

white who are you i mean lets all reveal coms since the game is just about over.

[FM Whitebeard]

I'm a lazy dog.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i revealed mine though a funny way.... XD

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i need to look back at other days of death in here

[FM Don Krieg]

Thanks. Though I have to ask... Why did you guys kill Red Haired Shanks the night after I died? I told you to kill Luffy! And Shanks was the worst lurker ever. Completely worthless to town. I think that was probably the worst kill you could have made. And it hurt my soul to see it happen. :(

The thing is, in the night chat we only talked about everything assuming Luffy died. From the day chat I somehow thought that you told the Pirates to handle the Doctor and I have not realized this mistake until now. Sanji has not noticed either it seems, atleast he didn't tell me if he did.
When he turned the night actions in they were still up to debate but that was the next day when I thought you told the Pirates to handle the Doctor and to me at that moment it seemed to me that the Pirates should go for the Doctor now since they have not done so and I hoped that they caught on to your clues from the day before. I (up until now) remembered you telling the Pirates to handle the Doctor like I said. Memory tricked me hard.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Hey! I finally have access to dead chat! :3

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

The thing is, in the night chat we only talked about everything assuming Luffy died. From the day chat I somehow thought that you told the Pirates to handle the Doctor and I have not realized this mistake until now. Sanji has not noticed either it seems, atleast he didn't tell me if he did.
When he turned the night actions in they were still up to debate but that was the next day when I thought you told the Pirates to handle the Doctor and to me at that moment it seemed to me that the Pirates should go for the Doctor now since they have not done so and I hoped that they caught on to your clues from the day before. I (up until now) remembered you telling the Pirates to handle the Doctor like I said. Memory tricked me hard.

Well I thought they would kill Luffy the night before I was lynched. But when they didn't, in the day I specifically told the pirates we would kill the doctor, which I was counting on you to follow through on.

Still, even if you thought the pirates were going to kill the doctor... Shanks? Really? That would've been the time to kill Ace since he was very pro-town and unlikely to have doc on him what with Bonney and Nami around. Shanks megalurked, which means he was unlikely to contribute/vote which would have been good for us because he would just be dead weight for the town.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Work...... same with sanji. When im working i dont have acess to internet really i need to get my ipod touch connected when im working. but my work doesnt allow me to really do that

But you posted right before I was lynched...

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

But you posted right before I was lynched...

oh then it got cut before i could unvote. i had it set to unvote but buggy came in and cut me short. i know with cp9 infil i was at work. damn....

i littarly had like one min too before i had to clock in, it stuck me as i clocked in what you were too and i went shit.

[FM Soul King Brook]

mihawk nvm you would be lynched anyway, also without cp9/pirate/marine votes, just like all the other scums

my timezone doesn't allow me to post more in the day chat. when i am online, noone posts, so i can't have conversations with ppl. i can't check in the night and morning, but that's when all the posts happen in my timezone. so i can't react to them. when i check the afternoon, there are like 20 new pages i have to read for about 2 hours first before being able to post. that sucks actually

[FM Don Krieg]

Well I thought they would kill Luffy the night before I was lynched. But when they didn't, in the day I specifically told the pirates we would kill the doctor, which I was counting on you to follow through on.

Still, even if you thought the pirates were going to kill the doctor... Shanks? Really? That would've been the time to kill Ace since he was very pro-town and unlikely to have doc on him what with Bonney and Nami around. Shanks megalurked, which means he was unlikely to contribute/vote which would have been good for us because he would just be dead weight for the town.
Yeah, like said, we seem to have missed that you told us to kill the doctor.

The thing against killing Ace in my eyes was that he talked so much bullshit if you ask me. His scum list was also not really correct and I atleast figured that he could be able to help us mislynch if we got that far. Other than that I gotta say that I tunnelvisioned on the numbers. To me that was important and Shanks, if my memory served correctly at that time, did vote whoever was voted up by the town.

Gotta say though that I enjoyed the experience since that was my first scum role in any FM game. I learned something and have the confidence to do better in the next games. :)

[FM Don Krieg]

Hey First Mate, can you tell me who the COM biersteker played as?
I asked him to join the One Piece FM, not sure if he did it because I asked him to but still a pleasant person. ;D

[FM Ferengi]

Biersteker started the game as FM Jimbei, but then he had to leave for a week. So I replaced him with Nick.

[FM Don Krieg]

Biersteker started the game as FM Jimbei, but then he had to leave for a week. So I replaced him with Nick.

Aw too bad. Shucks.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

first mate who was boa hancock?

i know you answered one already but seeing how the person just raged after dying can i know?

[FM Don Krieg]

Wow, that's a really nice RP article. So awesome. Holy god. :D

[FM Soul King Brook]

damn they'll mislynch today i think

[FM Ferengi]

I already said too much. Everything else that you want to know will be revealed what the game ends.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

so thats a no on who boa hancock was?

[FM Don Krieg]

so thats a no on who boa hancock was?

No, that was a yes and he hid the hint in his post.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

No, that was a yes and he hid the hint in his post.

well im party cluesless then. im very tired to try to figure it out.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

mihawk nvm you would be lynched anyway, also without cp9/pirate/marine votes, just like all the other scums

No. I did the math for the day I was lynched. If cp9, pirates, marines, and the jester had kept their votes off of me, I could not have been lynched. In fact, if you go back and look at who voted to lynch me, you'll see that more of my own allies voted me than town.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

damn.... if it stuck me sooner i would of unvoted. but like i said i had one min before i had to clock in. but i think you guys would of sidedwith pirates in the end wouldnt you?

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Biersteker started the game as FM Jimbei, but then he had to leave for a week. So I replaced him with Nick.

That is ridiculously unbalanced. Nick started as a marine... He had information a regular citizen wouldn't have.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i think this game became unballenced after the reroll. what we should of done is replace the person and be done with it. due to the fact that buggy knew all marines or at least smoker existed, my enforcer was aware of the cp9 roles (although didnt inform me) overall i think the game was fun but it became unballenced due to some roles knowing more then they should.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i mean the person who cracked the code asked to be replaced. i dont think we needed a reroll. i think a lot of ppl will be complaining and talking aobut the reroll and say that it became unballened.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Town may just lose this after all.
If X Drake is really the pirate, then they'll probably lose it.
They'll probably go for Gecko tomorrow.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

well seeing how fragos forgot to change the vote counter something might happen

[FM Don Krieg]

If town tunnelvisions then the Pirates have gone from weakest faction at the start of the game to the winners. xD

I consider them to be the weakest after N1 since they could not control their Pirate Captain and have lost the Cons so that would make some nice RP as Epilogue.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

if pirates win i will be laughing so hard

[FM Soul King Brook]

if pirates win i fully blame bonney

edit: but i don't think she will be so dumb to lynch gecko

[FM Soul King Brook]

mihawk, you calculated with vent i think who was already dead
it were 17 people, means 9 to lynch. your 'big' alliance would be 2+3+2+1 = 8
17-8 = 9
or do i forget something?

[FM Soul King Brook]

That is ridiculously unbalanced. Nick started as a marine... He had information a regular citizen wouldn't have.

this would indeed be fail. how you know that nick started as marine?

[FM Don Krieg]

Nice move First Mate, I laughed. :D

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

LOLZ is all i got to say

[FM Ferengi]

You are wrong, Nick started the game as FM Trafalgar Law, and he immediately replaced FM Jimbei after he was executed by Jailor.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

You are wrong, Nick started the game as FM Trafalgar Law, and he immediately replaced FM Jimbei after he was executed by Jailor.

ok that makes more sense. jailor becomes known to pretty much all after his execution

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

hey can we have acess to all the night rooms? i want to go say hai to pirate cap and troll him a bunch.

[FM Whitebeard]

mihawk, you calculated with vent i think who was already dead
it were 17 people, means 9 to lynch. your 'big' alliance would be 2+3+2+1 = 8
17-8 = 9
or do i forget something?

I think he may have forgotten to count Tony among the town voters.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

I think he may have forgotten to count Tony among the town voters.

hai whitebeard

[FM Don Krieg]

My math atleast said that we wouldn't have been able to prevent a lynch, only delay it.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

just wow....

[FM Capone Bege]

oh god I hope Jimbei leads the lynch against X Drake tomorrow...

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i want them to lynch zoro and in the end everyone dies. and jester gets a solo victory. that would make my day

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

mihawk, you calculated with vent i think who was already dead
it were 17 people, means 9 to lynch. your 'big' alliance would be 2+3+2+1 = 8
17-8 = 9
or do i forget something?

No. I knew vent was dead. Why would I calculate using a person I knew to be dead? It was simple. We had: 3 CP9, 2 marines, 2 pirates, 1 jester. That is 8 people. If all 8 of those people had kept their votes off me, I could not have been lynched, as there were 16 people in the game with 9 votes to lynch. The problem was that my allies voted me. In fact, as many of my allies voted me as town. Both marines, my infiltrator, and the pirate captain voted to lynch me. So I blame them for the fail voting.


this would indeed be fail. how you know that nick started as marine?

Woops. I misspoke. I accidentally confused Nick with someone else in my head. Still, he was jailed as Trafalgar before he died, so he still had more information than Jimbei would've had otherwise in terms of what was discussed in the jailed chat. But I guess it's not as unbalanced as I originally thought.


I think he may have forgotten to count Tony among the town voters.

Nope. See above.

[FM Soul King Brook]

No. I knew vent was dead. Why would I calculate using a person I knew to be dead? It was simple. We had: 3 CP9, 2 marines, 2 pirates, 1 jester. That is 8 people. If all 8 of those people had kept their votes off me, I could not have been lynched, as there were 16 people in the game with 9 votes to lynch. The problem was that my allies voted me. In fact, as many of my allies voted me as town. Both marines, my infiltrator, and the pirate captain voted to lynch me. So I blame them for the fail voting.



Woops. I misspoke. I accidentally confused Nick with someone else in my head. Still, he was jailed as Trafalgar before he died, so he still had more information than Jimbei would've had otherwise in terms of what was discussed in the jailed chat. But I guess it's not as unbalanced as I originally thought.



Nope. See above.

i don't know why you insist on your 'i could have won if my teammates hadn't failed'
as i wrote, there were 17 players. actually, if your mates weren't all confirmed scum anyway, voting you wasn't such a bad idea. and if the marines unvoted you, they would be confirmed as town enemies, so no good idea i think
of course you know vent was dead then but i thought you maybe calculated at night already

and i hope town realizes that the jester game will likely make them lose. no win for that stupid jester!^^

[FM Jimbei]

Sigh. My COM was found out in Day2. And I thought I hid well as Trafalgar.

*cries*

Knew my time was up after being called out by Boa Hancock. Why am I executed again? I mean Trafalgar.

Why is Zoro starting the Jester Game now? Should have done it earlier.

[FM Don Krieg]

Sigh. My COM was found out in Day2. And I thought I hid well as Trafalgar.

*cries*

Knew my time was up after being called out by Boa Hancock. Why am I executed again? I mean Trafalgar.

Why is Zoro starting the Jester Game now? Should have done it earlier.
Because now he is the one to turn the tide.


I also really disagree with you Dracule as you would have been lynched even if I and the pirate captain didn't vote you.
In fact the vote of the PC would've helped him to stay low if he hadn't decided to reveal himself. I blame Appley. :D
Also I had a feeling that Marco wouldn't want to side with the CP9 while Nami would want to, atleast one Marine would be on you. I thought we had it clear in our chat that you would die anyway and the only way to prevent this would be some deflecting or stuff.

[FM Jimbei]

On Dracule lynch. Your allies are in Catch-22 situation.

Pirates: Reveal yourself (so that Town and Marines will lynch you)
Marines: Snub Town (so that Town will leave you to the Pirates, and help in lynching you)

Unreasonable to expect cooperation from BOTH Marines and Pirates at the same time. Since you can only win with either.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

i don't know why you insist on your 'i could have won if my teammates hadn't failed'
as i wrote, there were 17 players. actually, if your mates weren't all confirmed scum anyway, voting you wasn't such a bad idea. and if the marines unvoted you, they would be confirmed as town enemies, so no good idea i think
of course you know vent was dead then but i thought you maybe calculated at night already

and i hope town realizes that the jester game will likely make them lose. no win for that stupid jester!^^

All of my cp9 were already confirmed scum. No one had any idea who the pirates were, but if they had not voted me, scum would've had the numbers advantage and it wouldn't matter if they were confirmed pirates. Town had no night kills (I made sure of that) and they wouldn't be able to lynch. People seem to forget that disguising as town is only to avoid death from town. Once they no longer have the ability to kill you, there's no reason to hide. And the marines would not have lynched the captain if I was alive, because I could protect them from him. I didn't necessarily know who the other pirate was, and would not be able to witch him away from them, so they could only (possibly) lynch the janitor. And they would have to find him first, by which point we'd no longer need him.


On Dracule lynch. Your allies are in Catch-22 situation.

Pirates: Reveal yourself (so that Town and Marines will lynch you)
Marines: Snub Town (so that Town will leave you to the Pirates, and help in lynching you)

Unreasonable to expect cooperation from BOTH Marines and Pirates at the same time. Since you can only win with either.

See above. As to the pirates lynching the marines, possible, but doubtful. The town would've been hesitant to lynch them, and even if they had, it wouldn't have mattered. We wouldn't have needed them after that day and could have secured a pirate/cp9 victory.

[FM Don Krieg]

The thing is that we were pretty much confirmed CP9, yeah, but the Pirates weren't and we would've never been able to keep you alive if just one Marine decided to lynch you and if all Town players would've banded together, which wouldn't be hard for them if they decided on a target and expect everyone to vote before the time runs up. I voted to make the day faster. Pirates likely wanted a guise and saw themselves as winners already. :D

[FM Soul King Brook]

@don:
yes i had the same feeling about marco

@mihawk:
that's why i said if they weren't confirmed anyway. i agree that it wasn't a good idea to vote you for them, but it also wouldn't help if they did not. town + rebels were one more than your big alliance (jimbei is right, how do you expect such an alliance to work?) and i'm sure everyone would vote a cp9 who already confessed. killing you helped us to prevent some pirates kills and to take out the marines which were a potential risk for us.

@marines: in my opinion for you it was the best choice to side with town. cp9 could side with pirates, town wouldn't turn against the marines. but you just didn't play it out well. if you convinced the town to lynch the pirates first and not the witch, you would have survived. in fact thanks to our doc you just had to lynch the janitor instead of don krieg, then nami would survive. and you really had enough time to find him. who did you check all the time i wonder?


@jimbei:
you played quite well as jimbei (at least in the end, before that you lurked quite hard). but you failed as trafalgar^^

[FM Blackbeard]

I am disappointed in town that lynched me without any real thought; just, "ok, hes pirate, gg"

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

I am disappointed in town that lynched me without any real thought; just, "ok, hes pirate, gg"

To be fair, I'm pretty sure most of us had you pinned as the last Pirate.
Although I did call out X Drake as scum.

And what the hell he hasn't posted since Day 9. This is pretty ridiculous.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

To be fair, I'm pretty sure most of us had you pinned as the last Pirate.
Although I did call out X Drake as scum.

And what the hell he hasn't posted since Day 9. This is pretty ridiculous.

The last few days have been 3-6 hour long days, Maybe he is at work or something when these days are starting.

[FM Don Krieg]

The last few days have been 3-6 hour long days, Maybe he is at work or something when these days are starting.

Yes this seemed to be the case almost all of the time.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

I might have missed something but how did the cp9 know that nami was a marine when they vented big mom?

[FM Don Krieg]

I might have missed something but how did the cp9 know that nami was a marine when they vented big mom?

Our Ventriloquist is freaking awesome. Refer to night chat for thorough explanation.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Our Ventriloquist is freaking awesome. Refer to night chat for thorough explanation.

Did your ventro play as the rebel leader befeore the reset?

[FM Don Krieg]

Did your ventro play as the rebel leader befeore the reset?

No, he was an Infiltrator.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

I guess the pirates kinda lost this game for cp9, they wasted 4 night attacks on your allies and they killed your ventriloquist

[FM Black Leg Sanji]

lulz finally dead chat. Lulz at how the Town believed me on Blackbeard.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

lulz finally dead chat. Lulz at how the Town believed me on Blackbeard.

I didn't believe you but i guess that's why the real pirate decided to kill me. Is it true that you didn't share a night chat with the disguiser?

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

First mate didn't answer my question.

[FM Soul King Brook]

there is still no disguiser...

well for the cp9 after nami's marine claim it was pretty obvious. town however thought of course he was cp9/vented

and i feel like people who had night chat before the reroll have it again? only other team/roles? the vent of this game, a marine who was cp9

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

there is still no disguiser...

well for the cp9 after nami's marine claim it was pretty obvious. town however thought of course he was cp9/vented

and i feel like people who had night chat before the reroll have it again? only other team/roles? the vent of this game, a marine who was cp9

So basil was actually the ventriloquist? Didn't the cp9 order the pirates to kill basil?

[FM Soul King Brook]

crocodile was not vented and a pirate. so he spoke for the pirates. what he wanted to say is that the pirates are going to kill basil. cp9 misunderstood. btw, he also indicated that drake x is the last pirate, like sanji said, so sanji was right about this, only that he replaced drake by blackbeard. why didn't you even check crocodiles post again. he didn't even mention blackbeard, lol. sanji only said that basil disguised as blackbeard so you believe him (remember, if he managed a mislynch at this point he would win)

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

crocodile was not vented and a pirate. so he spoke for the pirates. what he wanted to say is that the pirates are going to kill basil. cp9 misunderstood. btw, he also indicated that drake x is the last pirate, like sanji said, so sanji was right about this, only that he replaced drake by blackbeard. why didn't you even check crocodiles post again. he didn't even mention blackbeard, lol. sanji only said that basil disguised as blackbeard so you believe him (remember, if he managed a mislynch at this point he would win)

Im surprised that the witch didn't controll crocodile when he said that the pirates were going to kill basil. It seems abit too risky to not controll him when he intends to kill their most important role.

[FM Soul King Brook]

yes you're right, mihawk explained this before

host please make sure to send a pm to all of geckos accounts to remind him to place his last vote. if he can't check in yet you may extend the day to wait for him

[FM Capone Bege]

@Ace, sorry for the unwarranted harassment in the day before I died, I actually thought you were scum

That being said, good job on the lynches while you were alive :)

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

@Ace, sorry for the unwarranted harassment in the day before I died, I actually thought you were scum

That being said, good job on the lynches while you were alive :)

Sorry for beeing so happy about your death. The train i started on apoo was mostly just luck and the other scums were like ''Hey, im a scum and you can't lynch me NANANANANANANA''

It was actually funny how all the scums started revealing themselves and trying to prove their scum role.

[FM Don Krieg]

Im surprised that the witch didn't controll crocodile when he said that the pirates were going to kill basil. It seems abit too risky to not controll him when he intends to kill their most important role.
Additionally to that, IIRC Crocodile made it seem (to me atleast) that X Drake was a Disguiser and wanted to disguise as Basil Hawkins tonight so we would've witched X Drake instead of Crocodile.

[FM Capone Bege]

mother fuckin' Gecko Moria :( get on and vote X Drake already


edit: that's game!

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

mother fuckin' Gecko Moria :( get on and vote X Drake already


edit: that's game!

If we didn't get trolled and that the mafia isn't actually Gecko. :v

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i checked gecko and he appears ns the night i checked him

[FM Soul King Brook]

btw why did you check jimbei twice? n2 you checked him instead of basil because of bd. checking bonney was a fail too. and why did you no inform the town about the second check of jimbei? since he was suspected bcause noone checked who was checked and bd n2

[FM Whitebeard]

Simple Soul King...

They were leaving the doors open to cooperate with CP9. Leaving the town clueless about some things helps with that.

[Ash]

davey jones' locker? is this spongebob?

[Damus_Graves]

davey jones' locker? is this spongebob?

Davy Jones Locker = Pirate myth.