Day 5 discussion

[FM Ferengi]

I decided to sent PMs to all dead people so then that can gather out and talk in the dead chat.

Discuss the game now! You can vote to reveal one living person's COM name.

[FM Capone Bege]

Ace is so scummy that even if he was Mayor I would lynch him

[FM Whitebeard]

So we only have one guy then eh? Damn. Then Mihawk is probably scum who knows Ace isn't being witched.

At least Tony wasn't an infiltrator. I doubt he'd have claimed rebel if he was... absolutely no reason to.

Rebels would've done much better if the leader hadn't been so blatantly obvious during the day, acting like we were masons who'd still win after dying and who would be protected by the town. He didn't offer much in terms of reads on players either. I really wonder who he was. He seemed like a new guy, and I can forgive him for not knowing how to WIFOM / understand how the allegiances worked if that's the case. If he's not a new guy though... *facepalm*

[FM Capone Bege]

yeah things would have gone better if he didn't counterclaim Rebel. Marines would have jailed and executed Trafalgar for daring to claim Rebel anyways.

Are there any rebels left alive? I suspect Jewelry Bonney of being one

[FM Whitebeard]

Nah, Bonney isn't one.

Tony is the only one, just like he claims to be. I feel a bit bad for recruiting him :p

Sanji and Mihawk aren't citizens.

Sanji has become a massive lurker after day 1 so I think he isn't really an escort.

[FM Capone Bege]

Tony probably feels like a solo Mason from sc2mafia, poor guy

and I think Mihawk is Witch.
I haven't been following Day 5, but it seems like Ace managed to clear himself. Interesting.
As for the last pirate, I would guess it's Don Krieg

[FM Eustass Kidd]

I hate being team player. Before the shuffle I was First Mate. I just hate being in a team with night chat cause I'm the worst player ever. Sorry.

[FM Capone Bege]

Don't take it that way man, you should learn from this, and become a better player for the future

[FM Whitebeard]

You're not the worst player, because that's the permalurkers, afkers and sheep.

What you should learn though is to think of the possible consequences of your posts before you hit the post reply button. That doesn't only count for night chat factions, but for any role.

[FM Ferengi]

This is the list of roles that are currently alive or dead:

Pirate Captain - ?
First Mate - Cyborg Franky
Hidden Pirate - ?
Framer - Urouge
Infiltrator - ?
Hidden CP9 - ?
Hidden CP9 - ?
Hidden CP9 - ?
Navy Admiral - ?
Jailor - Foxy the Sliver Fox
Detective - Fody Jones
Hidden Marine - ?
Rebel Leader - Eustass Kidd
Rebel Scout - Whitebeard
Arsonist - Scratchmen Apoo
Hidden Neutral - ?
Doctor - ?
Hidden Town - ?
Bus Driver - Sogeking
Hidden Town - ?
Hidden Town - ?
Citizen - Nico Robin
Citizen - Trafalgar Law
Citizen - Capone Bege
Citizen - Big Mom
Citizen - Boa Hancock
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen - ?
Citizen/Rebel - ?
Citizen/Rebel - ?

Feel free to add the missing marks as you want.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Well, that REALLY sucked. I was asleep and everyone just randomly voted to lynch me because I was posting more than usual T_T

[FM Capone Bege]

Hahah Apoo :p that blows


There is no disguiser, the pirates probably has a janitor.
I haven't been following the game, but how did the Town skip over this post? This just screams "Pirate".

[FM Ferengi]

Scratchmen Apoo is not the arsonist

Why else they followed Apoo's train?