Day 2: First Casualties

[FM Ferengi]

http://imageshack.us/scaled/large/833/newagey.jpg (http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/833/newagey.jpg/)

The second day began with quite interesting events. The CP9 have finally made their first move.

Their first victim was Hody Jones, who was believed to be an regular citizen at first. But when they checked his dead body, they have found an insignia with blue seagull. That insignal was the symbol of Navy.

Hody Jones's role was Detective.

But that was not the end of it! Another person, Cyborg Franky was found dead acroess the shore of the island. It appears that he was killed by Pirates by unknown reason. But what was even more surpising that Franky was an actual Pirate! Did they start some kind of internal quarrel?

Cyborg Franky's role was First Mate.

So far, there have been no casualities from the island's local populace. But it is widely believed that those bad guys will not miss their mark on the next time. The balance of power is certainly going to shift today...

At the same time, the News Coo have finally delivered the newspaper to the island. There was one notable article, directly related to the current situation on the island:


So umm, i kind of didn't notice i had been given the chance to write up an article.
This should prove Bonneys innocence, atleast in my eyes it should.
My view on the last day is as follows: The plans devised are a bit vague, but we should get a general gameplan after this night. The powerstruggle will be apparent once we know which factions have received even a minor strike as it will tip the balance drastically.

If i had noticed this earlier i would have given in detail reads on some players, but as is, i will just write a list of people we need to keep an eye on and pay more attention too. Also, the heavy lurkers need to be shot down.

Boa Hancock
Roronoa Zoro
Urouge
Cyborg Franky
Straw Hat Luffy
Trafalgar Law
Fire Fist Ace
Wet Haired Caribou

As i write this article literally 1 minute before the deadline, forgive me.


List of players:

FM Bartholomew Kuma
FM Basil Hawkins
FM Big Mom
FM Black Leg Sanji
FM Blackbeard
FM Boa Hancock
FM Buggy the Clown
FM Capone Bege
FM Cat Thief Nami
FM Crocodile
FM Don Krieg
FM Donquixote Doflamingo
FM Dracule Mihawk
FM Eustass Kidd
FM Fire Fist Ace
FM Foxy the Silver Fox
FM Gecko Moria
FM Jewelry Bonney
FM Jimbei
FM Marco the Phoenix
FM Nico Robin
FM Red Haired Shanks
FM Roronoa Zoro
FM Scratchmen Apoo
FM Sogeking
FM Soul King Brook
FM Straw Hat Luffy
FM Tony Tony Chopper
FM Trafalgar Law
FM Urouge
FM Wet Haired Caribou
FM Whitebeard
FM X Drake

Graveyard:

FM Hody Jones (Detective) - Killed by CP9
FM Cyborg Franky (First Mate) - Killed by... Pirates?

Day 2 has began, you can now continue your discussion. You need a majority of 17 players to lynch a person. If no majority occurs during 48 hours, the day ends without a lynch. Once again, I remind you to use vote tags. Day 2 will end at this time: http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=02.03.2013+19.00+MSK

You CAN end the day earlier than usual. But day will not last less than 24 hours. Once 24 hours will pass, this thread will be automatically locked once someone reached 17 votes.

And another thing... Another player has been replaced during the last night. But this is as for as we can go now with our reserves being almost depleted or unresponsive. From now on, if you decide to resign from the game or otherwise start to lurk during the day without any posts at all, your game account will be MODKILLED without any replacement. So please take your attention and try to enjoy the game to the fullest. Thanks.

17

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

No one touched me tonight. Since frank turned out to be a pirate im going to be suspicious of the people that tried to stop the wagon on him.

[FM Don Krieg]

Hi guys, I was roleblocked last night.

[Trafalgar Law]

I'm not lurker and I'm not Pirate. Person who posted the article is scum.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Nothing happened to me last night.
What the hell happened with Franky? A pirate killed by a pirate?
There's something behind this I'm sure of it.

[FM Gecko Moria]

I'm not lurker and I'm not Pirate. Person who posted the article is scum.

^Says he's not a lurker

^Only has 8 posts

^Instantly claims accuser must be scum

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Yella fella, guys! I have some funny news for you. These news are funny only for YOU, not for me exactly. I have been doused. So, I think you should prepare to see my name on the graveyard soon. luv u ol.

[FM Capone Bege]

Fantastic night, I was not touched, Pirates lost one of their own and Cp9 lost 2 potential allies.

I'd guess Witch found the Pirate Captain or Mafioso right now until there's a bus claim.

[FM Gecko Moria]

Nothing happened to me last night.
What the hell happened with Franky? A pirate killed by a pirate?
There's something behind this I'm sure of it.

Pirate getting killed by pirate can easily be explained by the presence of a badass bus driver.

[FM Gecko Moria]

Fantastic night, I was not touched, Pirates lost one of their own and Cp9 lost 2 potential allies.

I'd guess Witch found the Pirate Captain or Mafioso right now until there's a bus claim.

Or Witch. I didn't see that the CP9 had that as a possible role at first; was looking for Witch in the neutrals.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Nothing happened to me last night.
What the hell happened with Franky? A pirate killed by a pirate?
There's something behind this I'm sure of it.

That would be either a Bus Driver or a Witch. Caribou doesn't think there can be another explanation.



I'm not lurker and I'm not Pirate. Person who posted the article is scum.

How silly of you. The person who wrote the article was merely saying that they should keep an eye on us; not directly calling us scum. It is only suspicions!




Yella fella, guys! I have some funny news for you. These news are funny only for YOU, not for me exactly. I have been doused. So, I think you should prepare to see my name on the graveyard soon. luv u ol.

Well, now that is extremely problematic.
Caribou was Charged by an Electromaniac last night.
For some reason Caribou really doubts the two neutrals would be killing roles.
Caribou believes one of us was probably the target of a Drug Dealer...

[Trafalgar Law]

See I told you Neutral Killer is Arsonist. Only a few believed me. That's why I said I should lead town yesterday. One of the active players is Arsonist. Factions will not reveal her since she is an ally. We should lynch some of the active players. She is hiding among town. We should choose Marines or Rebels and ally with them today before it's too late. They might choose to side with Arsonist if we delay anymore.

[FM Capone Bege]

See I told you Neutral Killer is Arsonist. Only a few believed me. That's why I said I should lead town yesterday. One of the active players is Arsonist. Factions will not reveal her since she is an ally. We should lynch some of the active players. She is hiding among town. We should choose Marines or Rebels and ally with them today before it's too late. They might choose to side with Arsonist if we delay anymore.

The only person who would be so sure that Neutral Killer is Arsonist on Day 1 is Arsonist.

This post also reeks of scum
FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Eustass Kidd]

That would be either a Bus Driver or a Witch. Caribou doesn't think there can be another explanation.




How silly of you. The person who wrote the article was merely saying that they should keep an eye on us; not directly calling us scum. It is only suspicions!





Well, now that is extremely problematic.
Caribou was Charged by an Electromaniac last night.
For some reason Caribou really doubts the two neutrals would be killing roles.
Caribou believes one of us was probably the target of a Drug Dealer...

Then we are double-fucked.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

The only person who would be so sure that Neutral Killer is Arsonist on Day 1 is Arsonist.

This post also reeks of scum
FM Trafalgar Law

And if he's a student/skyper?

[FM Big Mom]

Sup bitches

[FM Eustass Kidd]

The only person who would be so sure that Neutral Killer is Arsonist on Day 1 is Arsonist.

This post also reeks of scum
FM Trafalgar Law

I don't think that's the actual thing. That's just predictable to have an arso to kill many people when time goes by.
But if we deal with Drug dealer (deal with dealer lol funny), then I have some thoughts about it too.

[FM Gecko Moria]

See I told you Neutral Killer is Arsonist. Only a few believed me. That's why I said I should lead town yesterday. One of the active players is Arsonist. Factions will not reveal her since she is an ally. We should lynch some of the active players. She is hiding among town. We should choose Marines or Rebels and ally with them today before it's too late. They might choose to side with Arsonist if we delay anymore.

I find it interesting that you refer to the Arsonist as a "she".

I also find it interesting that you're taking Eustass's claim as undeniable proof of an Arsonist, despite the possibilities of drug dealing and Caribou's additional claim of charged.

Methinks Eustass may have been drugged, and Trafalgar may have had a hand in the drugging.

[FM Big Mom]

That would be either a Bus Driver or a Witch. Caribou doesn't think there can be another explanation.




How silly of you. The person who wrote the article was merely saying that they should keep an eye on us; not directly calling us scum. It is only suspicions!





Well, now that is extremely problematic.
Caribou was Charged by an Electromaniac last night.
For some reason Caribou really doubts the two neutrals would be killing roles.
Caribou believes one of us was probably the target of a Drug Dealer...

I have reason to believe the dousing was drugged, as last night I was charged, either that or Caribou is CP9 :|

[FM Eustass Kidd]

That would be either a Bus Driver or a Witch. Caribou doesn't think there can be another explanation.




How silly of you. The person who wrote the article was merely saying that they should keep an eye on us; not directly calling us scum. It is only suspicions!





Well, now that is extremely problematic.
Caribou was Charged by an Electromaniac last night.
For some reason Caribou really doubts the two neutrals would be killing roles.
Caribou believes one of us was probably the target of a Drug Dealer...

*cough**cough* Just realised there's no DD in the setup...

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

The only person who would be so sure that Neutral Killer is Arsonist on Day 1 is Arsonist.

This post also reeks of scum
FM Trafalgar Law

I think you are trying to lynch a ghost/jester

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

See I told you Neutral Killer is Arsonist. Only a few believed me. That's why I said I should lead town yesterday. One of the active players is Arsonist. Factions will not reveal her since she is an ally. We should lynch some of the active players. She is hiding among town. We should choose Marines or Rebels and ally with them today before it's too late. They might choose to side with Arsonist if we delay anymore.

You make no sense.
You barely contributed anything at all; all you did was propose the code.
Why would the Arsonist be an active player and not a lurker? What hinted you towards that?
Caribou is just curious.

And SHE? Care to explain?

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Hell, there is, another fraction, shit, gotta reread the whole setup!

[Trafalgar Law]

You are just jealous that I am correct. I also hinted at CP9 that they shouldn't target lurkers and trolls. Now they killed both their allies. Nobody listens to me. You will lose sooner or later. I think we should side with Rebels, assuming that Rebels recruited active players and not lurkers. I think we should still skip day today. I suggested voting skip day yesterday and now town is going well.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

*cough**cough* Just realised there's no DD in the setup...

Now you look very silly, mister Kidd.

[FM Big Mom]

I find it interesting that you refer to the Arsonist as a "she".

I also find it interesting that you're taking Eustass's claim as undeniable proof of an Arsonist, despite the possibilities of drug dealing and Caribou's additional claim of charged.

Methinks Eustass may have been drugged, and Trafalgar may have had a hand in the drugging.

Drug dealer

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

*cough**cough* Just realised there's no DD in the setup...

Cp9 might have a drug dealer. Unless you are a Cp9 and know your team doesn't have one.

[Trafalgar Law]

I want to say that Ace is not my teammate. There cannot be ghost/jester because if there are Kidd or Wet is lying. Or there is Drug Dealer. And Drug Dealer is CP9. I think Drug Dealer will normally fake Escort than fake Neutral Killer. So I don't think they are drugged.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

I have reason to believe the dousing was drugged, as last night I was charged, either that or Caribou is CP9 :|

Then both of us were charged.

Electro Maniac - Can charge one person each day. Can charge two people on Night 1. Can also kill a person he previously charged. If one charged person visits another, they will both electrocute. Wins if he survives and Town loses. Has one auto-vest. Targets will know if they are charged.

This pretty much confirms the Electromaniac, does it not?

[FM Capone Bege]

And if he's a student/skyper?

Student/Skyper have to wait until at least Night 1 to pick a master/friend, don't they?

Anyways I have to go to school now. I'll return in around 9 hours.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

I want to say that Ace is not my teammate. There cannot be ghost/jester because if there are Kidd or Wet is lying. Or there is Drug Dealer. And Drug Dealer is CP9. I think Drug Dealer will normally fake Escort than fake Neutral Killer. So I don't think they are drugged.

You have teammates?

[FM Buggy the Clown]

I don't understand why you guys don't think an arsonist can be a girl! Girls can be every role that men can be!

[FM Gecko Moria]

I have reason to believe the dousing was drugged, as last night I was charged, either that or Caribou is CP9 :|

TWO charged claims and a doused claim? I find this highly unlikely. There is most certainly a drug dealer, and/or somebody's lying.

[FM Big Mom]

I find it interesting that you refer to the Arsonist as a "she".

I also find it interesting that you're taking Eustass's claim as undeniable proof of an Arsonist, despite the possibilities of drug dealing and Caribou's additional claim of charged.

Methinks Eustass may have been drugged, and Trafalgar may have had a hand in the drugging.

TBH it seems suspicious that Gecko assumes Eustass was drugged, that was before I posted that I was charged, it implies he could be CP9 tbh. Since he claimed citizen, early I might add, I am personally finding that he is very likely to be the CP9 infiltrator.

[FM Big Mom]

FM Gecko Moria

[FM Gecko Moria]

Then both of us were charged.

Electro Maniac - Can charge one person each day. Can charge two people on Night 1. Can also kill a person he previously charged. If one charged person visits another, they will both electrocute. Wins if he survives and Town loses. Has one auto-vest. Targets will know if they are charged.

This pretty much confirms the Electromaniac, does it not?

Ah, I missed that. Thanks for pointing it out, and yes.

I am highly inclined to believe Eustass was drugged.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Here are present clues about the role list (hidden roles only!).

Hidden Pirate - First Mate
Hidden Pirate
Hidden Pirate

Hidden CP9 - Witch
Hidden CP9
Hidden CP9

Hidden Marine - Detective
Hidden Marine
Hidden Marine


Hidden Town Power - Bus Driver
Hidden Town Power - Journalist (confirmed)
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power

Hidden Neutral - Arsonist / Witch
Hidden Neutral - Electromaniac / Witch

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Here are present clues about the role list (hidden roles only!).

Hidden Pirate - First Mate
Hidden Pirate
Hidden Pirate

Hidden CP9 - Witch
Hidden CP9
Hidden CP9

Hidden Marine - Detective
Hidden Marine
Hidden Marine


Hidden Town Power - Bus Driver
Hidden Town Power - Journalist (confirmed)
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power

Hidden Neutral - Arsonist / Witch
Hidden Neutral - Electromaniac / Witch

Why was Witch listed as a possible Neutral? The Witch can only be CP9, It is not a possible Neutral role.

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

Here are present clues about the role list (hidden roles only!).

Hidden Pirate - First Mate
Hidden Pirate
Hidden Pirate

Hidden CP9 - Witch
Hidden CP9
Hidden CP9

Hidden Marine - Detective
Hidden Marine
Hidden Marine


Hidden Town Power - Bus Driver
Hidden Town Power - Journalist (confirmed)
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power

Hidden Neutral - Arsonist / Witch
Hidden Neutral - Electromaniac / Witch

Don claimed blocked.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Here are present clues about the role list (hidden roles only!).

Hidden Pirate - First Mate
Hidden Pirate - Drug Dealer
Hidden Pirate

Hidden CP9 - Witch
Hidden CP9
Hidden CP9

Hidden Marine - Detective
Hidden Marine
Hidden Marine


Hidden Town Power - Bus Driver
Hidden Town Power - Journalist (confirmed)
Hidden Town Power
Hidden Town Power

Hidden Neutral - Arsonist / Witch
Hidden Neutral - Electromaniac / Witch

Added dealer.

[Trafalgar Law]

Big Mom and Kidd might be teammates. I think they are faking Electromaniac. Because factions hate Electromaniac. Electromaniac can only kill factions and not town. I think Arsonist is more likely. Please stop being sexist.

[FM Don Krieg]

Don claimed blocked.

This I did.

[FM Gecko Moria]

TBH it seems suspicious that Gecko assumes Eustass was drugged, that was before I posted that I was charged, it implies he could be CP9 tbh. Since he claimed citizen, early I might add, I am personally finding that he is very likely to be the CP9 infiltrator.

I would like to say that I have not claimed any role yet, as you so claim.

I am assuming Eustass was drugged, because the evidence led me to believe so. I didn't realize EM could charge two targets on the first night, and combined with meta of the host and Trafalgar's initial scummy response to the article, I drew the conclusion that there was likely only one neutral killer, the EM, and that Eustass was drugged. I am thus FoSing Trafalgar based upon his avid defense that there must be an Arsonist and his quick overreaction to the article.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Here are present clues about the role list (hidden roles only!).

Hidden Pirate - First Mate
Hidden Pirate - Consort
Hidden Pirate

Hidden CP9 - Witch
Hidden CP9 - Drug Dealer
Hidden CP9

Hidden Marine - Detective
Hidden Marine
Hidden Marine


Hidden Town Power - Bus Driver
Hidden Town Power - Journalist (confirmed)
Hidden Town Power - Escort
Hidden Town Power

Hidden Neutral
Hidden Neutral - Electromaniac

Edited once more. I'll be afk for an hour or two to read the setup 10 times to not make these mistakes again.

[FM Big Mom]

I would like to say that I have not claimed any role yet, as you so claim.

I am assuming Eustass was drugged, because the evidence led me to believe so. I didn't realize EM could charge two targets on the first night, and combined with meta of the host and Trafalgar's initial scummy response to the article, I drew the conclusion that there was likely only one neutral killer, the EM, and that Eustass was drugged. I am thus FoSing Trafalgar based upon his avid defense that there must be an Arsonist and his quick overreaction to the article.

Says the player with the avatar Star Citizen :|

[FM Gecko Moria]

I don't understand why you guys don't think an arsonist can be a girl! Girls can be every role that men can be!

I'm not saying an Arsonist can't be a girl. I just think it's interesting that he ASSUMES the Arsonist is a girl.

[FM Gecko Moria]

Says the player with the avatar Star Citizen :|

An avatar does not a role claim make.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Big Mom and Kidd might be teammates. I think they are faking Electromaniac. Because factions hate Electromaniac. Electromaniac can only kill factions and not town. I think Arsonist is more likely. Please stop being sexist.

Caribou claimed, not me.

[FM Big Mom]

I'm not saying an Arsonist can't be a girl. I just think it's interesting that he ASSUMES the Arsonist is a girl.

The only real defect that I see with this line of pressure is that unless Buggy is a girl and an arsonist its not a scumslip.

[Trafalgar Law]

Moria didn't read what I said. I claimed that there is an Arsonist since yesterday. I don't believe that there is an Electromaniac. If it is true, Electromaniac will be hunted by factions and will always lose.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

.

May Caribou ask you (And those who have one) to solve their codes?

U j l w P a t i R s B H d o j
+
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5


ThisKumaIsAFake. ;)

[FM Big Mom]

An avatar does not a role claim make.

If you say so.

[FM Gecko Moria]

The only real defect that I see with this line of pressure is that unless Buggy is a girl and an arsonist its not a scumslip.

I'm not even saying it's a scumslip XD

I just said it's interesting, that's all. My FoS on Trafalgar is not based on his claim that the Arsonist is a girl.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Moria didn't read what I said. I claimed that there is an Arsonist since yesterday. I don't believe that there is an Electromaniac. If it is true, Electromaniac will be hunted by factions and will always lose.

Caribou has not claimed.
And why do you refuse to believe there is an Electromaniac, when two of us have already claimed Charged?
Can't you read?

[FM Big Mom]

I'm not even saying it's a scumslip XD

I just said it's interesting, that's all. My FoS on Trafalgar is not based on his claim that the Arsonist is a girl.

My FoS on you is not entirely based on your choice of avatar.

[FM Gecko Moria]

Moria didn't read what I said. I claimed that there is an Arsonist since yesterday. I don't believe that there is an Electromaniac. If it is true, Electromaniac will be hunted by factions and will always lose.

And you think it's more likely that half the CP9 risked exposing themselves by cooperating in a false claim that would easily be disproven when no more charged claims show up?

I could perhaps see one of the claims being faked and the other being drugged, and then the CP9 using the charge drug to keep up the illusion of the EM's presence to make PR's wary of visiting others.

Which would then make the neutral killer an Arsonist and Eustass's claim real.

[FM Gecko Moria]

My FoS on you is not entirely based on your choice of avatar.

Nor did I accuse you of such. I just wished to clarify one of the statements you made.

[FM Big Mom]

May Caribou ask you (And those who have one) to solve their codes?

U j l w P a t i R s B H d o j
+
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 0 1 2 3 4 5


ThisKumaIsAFake. ;)

Proof I have not been disguised/ventrio’d:

Solution: Kali
{Kali is a Hindu goddess whose name comes from kala which means black, time, death, lord of death.}

k a l i
11 1 12 9
{subtract 10}
1 -9 2 -1
{add modulo’s to the negative numbers and count to the value of 42, the answer to the ultimate question}
1{1} 43{2} 2{1} 987{38}
{Placeholder 0}
1 43 2 0987

[Trafalgar Law]

I thought bad roles are normally not added to games? That's why I don't think there is Electromaniac or Drug Dealer. Or Coroner.

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

Hey all!

Nothing happened to me unfortunately, from what I read the Electromaniac is confirmed while Bus Driver / Witch is a possibility of having a pirate kill himself. Those who doesn't believe in the Electromaniac - read the role! He can target two the first night and it's impossible for a Drug Dealer to target two at once.

Let's assume there is a Drug Dealer and Witch, with an Infiltrator the only guess for the final CP9 would be Agent / Ventriloquist. I'd like to warn if someone starts to behave differently if the suspicion is correct.

[FM Gecko Moria]

I thought bad roles are normally not added to games? That's why I don't think there is Electromaniac or Drug Dealer. Or Coroner.

Bad is subjective. I don't see the Drug Dealer as a bad role at all; it has unparalleled ability to spread misinformation and confuse and disorient the town.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Proof I have not been disguised/ventrio’d:

Solution: Kali
{Kali is a Hindu goddess whose name comes from kala which means black, time, death, lord of death.}

k a l i
11 1 12 9
{subtract 10}
1 -9 2 -1
{add modulo’s to the negative numbers and count to the value of 42, the answer to the ultimate question}
1{1} 43{2} 2{1} 987{38}
{Placeholder 0}
1 43 2 0987

Quite the random solution. Next time you should pick something related to the game!
But Caribou believes you; Your {Placeholder 0} gave it away. Caribou clearly remembers your {Placeholder} posts on Day 1.

[FM Big Mom]

Bad is subjective. I don't see the Drug Dealer as a bad role at all; it has unparalleled ability to spread misinformation and confuse and disorient the town.

Mayor is a bad role, yet I have a feeling it could be in the game, mostly because the town's power lies in the vote.

[FM Soul King Brook]

Ok, first of all i'd like to say that you should have listened to me. i said we should lynch franky but you didnt. though he was very suspicious

furthermore, the night was very good. we lost a potential ally with good investigative skills but we didnt lose a townie and they also got a pirate (which also gives us a lot of clues). so why did this happen? witch or bd? any other possibilities? if it was a witch and she knows now the pirate's killer this would be a big problem for us, cp9 will become very strong. this would also help the marines and they were more likely to side with cp9.

and about the drug dealer: doused seems to come from drugs, since 2 persons claimed charged. trafalgar is indeed suspicious of dd, because he could use the ability to convince town that he is good because he was right on d1

we should also pressure the ppl who didnt vote/cancelled vote/tried to stop the franky wagon

[FM Gecko Moria]

Mayor is a bad role, yet I have a feeling it could be in the game, mostly because the town's power lies in the vote.

Why do you say Mayor is a bad role?

I don't like over-arching statements declaring certain roles as just simply "bad." Every role has a niche, a purpose, a situation in which its abilities are most suited to preserve the balance and enjoyment of the game.

[FM Big Mom]

Why do you say Mayor is a bad role?

I don't like over-arching statements declaring certain roles as just simply "bad." Every role has a niche, a purpose, a situation in which its abilities are most suited to preserve the balance and enjoyment of the game.

Overrated, overpowered, and often in the hands of a shite player. Bloody terrible mayors give scum someone to hide behind.

[FM Marco the Phoenix]

Why do you say Mayor is a bad role?

I have to agree it's a bad role, because the power is in the vote. The Mayor can join a different faction to screw over town which is what we would fear.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Here's the solution of my encrypted message: 3qT3/R9ugJw=

(Dunno if I can put a link here so I'll put the steps here)
1- Google: Encryption generator and click on the first link (should be textmechanic [dot] com)
2- Put my code in the big box and put "IMLUFFY" in the password box.
3- Click decrypt and it should give you my secret message related to my character name... Banana (lol)

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Alright,Iaccording to the claims,aI think that there ismno Arso (woohoo! Imalive!!!). Also, I think about Witch being in here rather thanrBus Driver (but if there will be a claim, Iechangebmy opinion ofc).
Alsoea role-blocker... hm... Iflthere is any other useful clues, bring them, please.

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

Alright,Iaccording to the claims,aI think that there ismno Arso (woohoo! Imalive!!!). Also, I think about Witch being in here rather thanrBus Driver (but if there will be a claim, Iechangebmy opinion ofc).
Alsoea role-blocker... hm... Iflthere is any other useful clues, bring them, please.

We could have an arso and an electro maniac. imo doused is one of the worst drugs he could have used.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

We could have an arso and an electro maniac. imo doused is one of the worst drugs he could have used.

The cp9 probably managed to kill 2 of their allies, i wouldn't be surprised if they also used the arso drug.

[FM Don Krieg]

The cp9 probably managed to kill 2 of their allies, i wouldn't be surprised if they also used the arso drug.

But the kills were likely unintentional, while the drug use is intentional in terms of choosing feedback. You can't compare that.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Fm Trafalgar law

He is either a scum/jester/ghost/mayor

If he flips neutral we will know that cp9 have a drug dealer.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

We could have an arso and an electro maniac. imo doused is one of the worst drugs he could have used.

Caribou agrees.
He really doubts the CP9 would've used it, especially if they didn't know what neutrals were around.

As silly as that sounds, we may have two neutral killers.

[FM Big Mom]

i will not tell the town who i choose. if you want to not believe me, and the person i choose refuses to write it, and you all lynch me, then ya'll are hellah dumb.

how does the code thing work? even though I don't think that i'll be disguised, as it'll auto unprove.

And i think Cyborg Franky is just one of those classic uninterested citizens that will pop in and out. not a good enough scum tell. WE SHOULD lynch someone that voted me. and i have no idea what the hell roranoa is doing. does he think i'm a veteran?


But Cyborg Franky isn't even here right now. I just find it interesting that you chose to pursue a target like him instead of someone like the Red Haired Shanks who posted 38 minutes ago after you specifically stated earlier that it's better to pressure targets who are here than people who are not here.

This is just an observation.


No use waiting for an AFK so I say we move on to another person...
FIRE FIST ACE![/vote]


I guess I can Undo my vote on Franky for now since there's no proof of him being scum...

-unvote

imo any of these guys have a good chance of being a pirate. {minus Jewelry Bonney}

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Fantastic night, I was not touched, Pirates lost one of their own and Cp9 lost 2 potential allies.

I'd guess Witch found the Pirate Captain or Mafioso right now until there's a bus claim.

This is what scums say when something goes horribly wrong. I think capone is a cp9

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Capone is probably a infiltrator becouse he keeps telling people that they are not citizens.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

He also tried to protect franky by starting a lynch train on me. Fm Capone Bege

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

And the fact that he keeps trying to start lynch trains on someone that wifoms Jester/ghost(trafalgar). Maybe drugging someone into appearing to be doused was their plan to get him lynched.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

imo any of these guys have a good chance of being a pirate. {minus Jewelry Bonney}

I'll just say that I unvoted him because we had no clue him being scum exept the fact that he was lurking.
We were putting presure on him and that presure was meningless because the code took all the place back then.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Hi everyone just catching up. Have work in half an hour but its only for a few hours just wanted to post that nothing happened to me. I'll be back when I get off work and be more active. My inactivity of yesterday was caused by a lot of collage and real life work catching up to me. I will try to be more active today though.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

Nothing happened to Buggy the Clown last night!

I think Kuma is evil.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Hello everyone. Two things to report today.

#1. My code solution:

Hurricane
Comeatmec
kjewjnsh

I have a confession to make. If you look at my finished code, you will notice there are only 8 letters, but hurricane has 9. This is because I left out the 'c' when I was adding the letters up and didn't realize it until much later. I was going to post a corrected code, but by the time I had enough free time to redo the code and post, the day had ended. My apologies.

#2. It is with great confusion that I report that I was bussed last night. If no one else claims bussed, I think we can assume that the bus driver saved me from the pirates last night and killed a pirate in the process, for which means the bus driver deserves kind of medal.

[FM Crocodile]

Nothing happened to me last night.
What the hell happened with Franky? A pirate killed by a pirate?
There's something behind this I'm sure of it.

Morning. I'm waking up and responding to posts as I go.

I suspect witch got the Pirate Captain.

[FM Crocodile]

You are just jealous that I am correct. I also hinted at CP9 that they shouldn't target lurkers and trolls. Now they killed both their allies. Nobody listens to me. You will lose sooner or later. I think we should side with Rebels, assuming that Rebels recruited active players and not lurkers. I think we should still skip day today. I suggested voting skip day yesterday and now town is going well.

This post.

I don't even.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Big Mom]

I'll just say that I unvoted him because we had no clue him being scum exept the fact that he was lurking.
We were putting presure on him and that presure was meningless because the code took all the place back then.

I find your response satisfactory

[FM Whitebeard]

I wasn't sure if it'd be considered foul play to reveal roles from before the reroll, but since others have done so too and no action was taken against them so I assume it's alright. There is no guarantee that the role list is identical anyway.

I was an arsonist before the reroll. So there was one in the game last time, at least. Yesterday when Trafalagar went on about knowing there was an arsonist I found that very suspicious, because I doubt there were 2 before the reroll. So what was he basing that on?

His explanation today seems ridiculous. Bad roles aren't used? The only real indicator of a role not being used is it not being on the possible roles list. Trafalgar might be a jester or ghost, but I'm willing to take that gamble. At the very least it will give us information about the (im)possibility of 2 neutral killers, as Ace Fist said.

FM Trafalgar Law

Caribou:
What's that placeholder thing in Big Momma's code you're referring to? I don't recall seeing that. The explanation I see here looks far fetched to me. I thought we were supposed to keep it simple so an answer couldn't be faked with all kinds of roundabout solutions.

My password: screwyouguys (I'm going home!)

idkyxrevzozl
9-4-11-25-24-18-5-22-26-15-26-12

key: pastas
16-1-19-20-1-19-16-1-19-20-1-19

9-16+26=19=s
4-1=3=c
11-19+26=18=r
25-20=5=e
24-1=23=w
18-19+26=25=y
5-16+26=15=o
22-1=21=u
26-19=7=g
15-20+26=21=u
26-1=25=y
12-19+26=19=s

[FM Big Mom]

Hello everyone. Two things to report today.

#1. My code solution:

Hurricane
Comeatmec
kjewjnsh

I have a confession to make. If you look at my finished code, you will notice there are only 8 letters, but hurricane has 9. This is because I left out the 'c' when I was adding the letters up and didn't realize it until much later. I was going to post a corrected code, but by the time I had enough free time to redo the code and post, the day had ended. My apologies.

#2. It is with great confusion that I report that I was bussed last night. If no one else claims bussed, I think we can assume that the bus driver saved me from the pirates last night and killed a pirate in the process, for which means the bus driver deserves kind of medal.

Why do you assume it was not caused by a witch?

[FM Big Mom]

I wasn't sure if it'd be considered foul play to reveal roles from before the reroll, but since others have done so too and no action was taken against them so I assume it's alright. There is no guarantee that the role list is identical anyway.

I was an arsonist before the reroll. So there was one in the game last time, at least. Yesterday when Trafalagar went on about knowing there was an arsonist I found that very suspicious, because I doubt there were 2 before the reroll. So what was he basing that on?

His explanation today seems ridiculous. Bad roles aren't used? The only real indicator of a role not being used is it not being on the possible roles list. Trafalgar might be a jester or ghost, but I'm willing to take that gamble. At the very least it will give us information about the (im)possibility of 2 neutral killers, as Ace Fist said.

FM Trafalgar Law

Caribou:
What's that placeholder thing in Big Momma's code you're referring to? I don't recall seeing that. The explanation I see here looks far fetched to me. I thought we were supposed to keep it simple so an answer couldn't be faked with all kinds of roundabout solutions.

My password: screwyouguys (I'm going home!)

idkyxrevzozl
9-4-11-25-24-18-5-22-26-15-26-12

key: pastas
16-1-19-20-1-19-16-1-19-20-1-19

9-16+26=19=s
4-1=3=c
11-19+26=18=r
25-20=5=e
24-1=23=w
18-19+26=25=y
5-16+26=15=o
22-1=21=u
26-19=7=g
15-20+26=21=u
26-1=25=y
12-19+26=19=s

:|
The {placeholder 0} is for added security

[FM Crocodile]

I used a WW2 German Nazi Enigma Machine for my code.

Settings:
III-IV-I
QKY
URY
FP GX DK UI MN QB CZ OY AR WS

Code:
D VG KJDKN VWLX!
I am still here!


Other than that, we should follow the train on Trafalgar. I sense we will gain vital information.

[FM Big Mom]

:|
The {placeholder 0} is for added security

Taking into account that I have been very active within the day chats, and from heresay, a conspicuous poster, it should be obvious that I have not been disguised/ventrio'd.

[FM Don Krieg]

Alright, with Whitebeard's explanation I feel confident voting.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Big Mom]

Time for pressure.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Urouge]

Splendid start for us. The pirates lost a big part of their early game impact and we only have 1 casualty, even that isn't on the islanders side. Considering the worst case scenario would have been losing ~ 3 islanders from the getgo this is stellar.

Going back to my advised proposition we should hunt for the CP9 next since they are a bigger threat right now.

Be it as it may i believe we have a Drug Dealer for certain, unless multiple CP9 members + a jester or ghost are pulling a huge play. Dracule seems to be trustworthy so i believe we have a Bus Driver as well. Possibly a witch, but we do not have confirmation of that as of yet. Unless we get a second bussed claim that is.

Trafalgar Law seems like a good pressure candidate right now so i'll be placing my vote on him for the time being. Also, as it currently stands, the revolutionists are likely to side with us, seeing how the pirates received a major blow and the islanders are untouched.

FM Trafalgar Law

also my code for yesterday

password: creedisniggah
cipher: creedisniggah

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Caribou:
What's that placeholder thing in Big Momma's code you're referring to? I don't recall seeing that. The explanation I see here looks far fetched to me. I thought we were supposed to keep it simple so an answer couldn't be faked with all kinds of roundabout solutions.



See post #573 of yesterday. His post was ''{Placeholder}'', for some reason. Maybe he thought we could edit posts, but anyway. This is indeed a bit far fetched, but the fact that he used { }s and noone else ever did hints that he is indeed Big Mom.
Caribou did say to, next time, pick something that we can somehow relate to him in his earlier post, as this is indeed slightly shady, but for now he shall get the benefit of the doubt.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

I'm in.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Time for pressure.

FM Trafalgar Law

Pressuring this guy is probably pointless since he wants to be lynched. Im up for lynching him at the end of this day if we don't find any better target but pressuring him right now is just a waste of time. If he claims a town role it's either going to be citizen or Mayor.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Why do you assume it was not caused by a witch?

Witch is a possibility of course, but I don't know for sure that there is a witch and I do know for certain that there is a bus driver because I was bussed. So for now I will assume it was the bus driver's doing until we can somehow prove there is a witch in the game.

Unfortunately, I have to go away for a few hours. I'll try to post here and there while I'm out, but if I can't I'll be back in full force this evening. Before I go, I will leave you with this, to increase pressure:

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Also; Caribou shall be joining on Law.
He is indeed a good person to pressure right now.
Caribou is still not over the fact that he referred the Arsonist as ''She'' yet did not even try to explain it when called out for it twice. Also, his arguments made no sense at all to me.

FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Big Mom]

Splendid start for us. The pirates lost a big part of their early game impact and we only have 1 casualty, even that isn't on the islanders side. Considering the worst case scenario would have been losing ~ 3 islanders from the getgo this is stellar.

Going back to my advised proposition we should hunt for the CP9 next since they are a bigger threat right now.

Be it as it may i believe we have a Drug Dealer for certain, unless multiple CP9 members + a jester or ghost are pulling a huge play. Dracule seems to be trustworthy so i believe we have a Bus Driver as well. Possibly a witch, but we do not have confirmation of that as of yet. Unless we get a second bussed claim that is.

Trafalgar Law seems like a good pressure candidate right now so i'll be placing my vote on him for the time being. Also, as it currently stands, the revolutionists are likely to side with us, seeing how the pirates received a major blow and the islanders are untouched.

FM Trafalgar Law

also my code for yesterday

password: creedisniggah
cipher: creedisniggah

What are your thoughts on Gecko?

[FM Big Mom]

See post #573 of yesterday. His post was ''{Placeholder}'', for some reason. Maybe he thought we could edit posts, but anyway. This is indeed a bit far fetched, but the fact that he used { }s and noone else ever did hints that he is indeed Big Mom.
Caribou did say to, next time, pick something that we can somehow relate to him in his earlier post, as this is indeed slightly shady, but for now he shall get the benefit of the doubt.

Bloody hell. I will use a simpler code next time. {since people cannot seem to handle the placeholders}

[FM Ferengi]

Just a side notice, you CAN end the day earlier than usual. But day will not last less than 24 hours. Once 24 hours will pass, this thread will be automatically locked once someone reaches 17 votes. The first post have also been updated with the same information.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

I will totally hammer this guy when the time comes!

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Caribou was going to make this list for himself; but why not just post it for everyone to see.
This is the votes that happened after Boa Hancock's initial vote on Franky.

Also;

-vote FM Cyborg Franky
Picked an avatar. Implies he has interest in the game. Did one single post. 20 hours later. No reaction on anything.
Remember this was the time when it looked like FM Whitebeard might getting himself lynched.
This guy surely just tried to hide the day out.

Pretty strong Pirates candidate.

Spot on, miss Hancock. Now for the list:


Boa Hancock
Urouge
Wet Haired Caribou
Big Mom
Soul King Brook
Don Krieg
Straw Hat Luffy
Buggy the Clown
Tony Tony Chopper
Fire Fist Ace
Jewelry Bonney
Capone Bege

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Bloody hell. I will use a simpler code next time. {since people cannot seem to handle the placeholders}

This is not about the placeholder, but the word you used. You could've used something like ''Bleach'' or whatever; Something that will let people identify you. It's too easy to make ''random'' codes to decrypt something.

[FM Whitebeard]

Ok, I found the placeholder post from yesterday now that you pointed it out, but I don't understand what it has to do with the code. Why would you use anything above highschool level math in a game where the majority of people is supposed to understand how you came to your solution anyway? Seems really illogical to me if the goal is trustworthiness and a bunch of people have to rely on others to verify it for them.

Posting a lot isn't necessarily a shield against disguisers and ventriloquists. Especially when most of your posts are one-liners.

I would just like to remind people of the possibility that a ventriloquist and a drug dealer could have caused the double electromaniac charging feedback we've seen today.

That said, Big Mom's writing style does match that of yesterday so far. That I can verify, even if it's not entirely fool proof.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Boa Hancock's gut feeling 1, pirates 0.

Nothing happened to me last night, at least nothing which would give me a feedback msg. I will be back shortly after i cought up. Stay tuned.

[FM Big Mom]

This is not about the placeholder, but the word you used. You could've used something like ''Bleach'' or whatever; Something that will let people identify you. It's too easy to make ''random'' codes to decrypt something.

If you knew my COM you would realize why my code is a Lord of Death.

[FM Urouge]

What are your thoughts on Gecko?

He has not been standing out in terms of actions so i do not recall him from my memory, have to read up on his posts. My first impression of not having anything to recall about a person makes them suspicious in itself. Given, that there is somebody who finds said person memorable for some reason, this should have some merit to it. Rereading about him now.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Ok, I found the placeholder post from yesterday now that you pointed it out, but I don't understand what it has to do with the code. Why would you use anything above highschool level math in a game where the majority of people is supposed to understand how you came to your solution anyway? Seems really illogical to me if the goal is trustworthiness and a bunch of people have to rely on others to verify it for them.

Posting a lot isn't necessarily a shield against disguisers and ventriloquists. Especially when most of your posts are one-liners.

I would just like to remind people of the possibility that a ventriloquist and a drug dealer could have caused the double electromaniac charging feedback we've seen today.

That said, Big Mom's writing style does match that of yesterday so far. That I can verify, even if it's not entirely fool proof.

As I said; Benefit of the doubt for today.
And about the Electromaniac:
Caribou really doesn't think he's going to survive the next night anyway. Fairly certain the EM is going to kill one of us. It'll be pretty much confirmed at this point.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

If you knew my COM you would realize why my code is a Lord of Death.

But COM hunting is against the rules, so Caribou did not try to hunt for COM identities. ;)

[FM Sogeking]

I'm lurking too much. I want to post something helpful, but someone already brought it up.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Nothing happened to Buggy the Clown last night!

I think Kuma is evil.

Caribou almost forgot about this.
Why Kuma in particular? Caribou does agree that he is completely useless as he only posted once, but he is curious now.

[FM Soul King Brook]

i wonder why trafalgar is absent now, with 10 votes on him.

so it seems like we actually have arso AND EM. i have no good feeling about this

also, since one claimed bd, it is high likely that the friendly fire was caused by bd. he probably had a feeling that cyborg was scum. and i dont think bded was made by dd. possibly the rb was made by dd

finally
FM Trafalgar Law

[FM Urouge]

So my reads on Geck Moria:

Most of his posts are atrocious one-liners.
Posts a lot of needless spam imo.
Is a sheep.
Possible roles/factions: Citizen / Busdriver / Rebels / Neutral

The specific busdriver callout is hinted at by 2 posts:

"I have not yet claimed my role"
"...badass busdriver..."

Sorry but i'm too lazy to quote the exact posts of his, but these give me the feeling that he's that. Now that i'm reading this, he might be a Witch trying to push the focus away from the CP9.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

ipossibly the rb was made by dd


Why the Roleblock in particular?
Escort/Consort are both very much possible.

Caribou would like to know your reasoning behind this one.

[FM Don Krieg]

Why the Roleblock in particular?
Escort/Consort are both very much possible.

Caribou would like to know your reasoning behind this one.
No matter his reasoning, it's actually possible.

[FM Soul King Brook]

Why the Roleblock in particular?
Escort/Consort are both very much possible.

Caribou would like to know your reasoning behind this one.

i didn't say it is so, it's just possible, that's a fact ;)
there could be a dd and they often drug rb

[FM Boa Hancock]

claims:
FM Don Krieg roleblocked. #3
FM Eustass Kidd claims doused. #7
FM Wet Haired Caribou claims to have been charged #11
FM Big Mom claims to have been charged #19
FM Dracule Mihawk claims driven #83


thoughts so far:

I hope the last guy realised that i am not pirates aligned. =p

The interviewed guy really looks suspicious to me. He had 48 hours time to write something and he does that in the last minutes before the dead line? Why? Why even mention this? Maybe his team wasn't cabable to capitalize on the journalist article. So he waited for the last chance to write some gibberish neutral article which does jackshit. Not even a hint at his role. Why not?
Sounds to me like that guy has something to hide.

I wonder if this will be the first FM which runs 2 drugdealers on the same team. This is actually a pretty strong setup in a game with that many factions.

At the other hand 2 neutral killers? Seems too boring to me. I believe in one neutral killer though.

I wouldn't be surprised if FM Trafalgar Law is the other neutral who needs to get lynched to win the game.

The charges are interesting to be honest. I have similar pro town reads from FM Big Mom and FM Caribou. I am not sure what i should think about this right now.

Question time:
Why do you think its more beneficial to lynch a possible neutral today over a cp9 or another pirate candidate?

[FM Don Krieg]

Question time:
Why do you think its more beneficial to lynch a possible neutral today over a cp9 or another pirate candidate?

Because of two reasons.

One: Right now we don't have any other clues to go for, do we? The most of us agreed on Trafalgar being scummy, and like that we can go forward instead of turning in circles IMO.

Two: The neutral(s) can side with anyone. He won't end up in a conflict between factions, he will just try to stay away from trouble like that and win with the faction who comes out on top after some days. Until that time, he will disturb the town most likely. The neutral is the only role who can just watch most of the time and give vague answers (of course he will try to be more useful to town to not seem suspicious) and stay under the radar like that. Atleast that's what I think. Getting rid of the neutral(s) will help because there is a "faction" we do not have to focus on anymore.

[FM Whitebeard]

claims:
FM Don Krieg roleblocked. #3
FM Eustass Kidd claims doused. #7
FM Wet Haired Caribou claims to have been charged #11
FM Big Mom claims to have been charged #19
FM Dracule Mihawk claims driven #83


thoughts so far:

I hope the last guy realised that i am not pirates aligned. =p

The interviewed guy really looks suspicious to me. He had 48 hours time to write something and he does that in the last minutes before the dead line? Why? Why even mention this? Maybe his team wasn't cabable to capitalize on the journalist article. So he waited for the last chance to write some gibberish neutral article which does jackshit. Not even a hint at his role. Why not?
Sounds to me like that guy has something to hide.

I wonder if this will be the first FM which runs 2 drugdealers on the same team. This is actually a pretty strong setup in a game with that many factions.

At the other hand 2 neutral killers? Seems too boring to me. I believe in one neutral killer though.

I wouldn't be surprised if FM Trafalgar Law is the other neutral who needs to get lynched to win the game.

The charges are interesting to be honest. I have similar pro town reads from FM Big Mom and FM Caribou. I am not sure what i should think about this right now.

Question time:
Why do you think its more beneficial to lynch a possible neutral today over a cp9 or another pirate candidate?

He could also be a killing neutral, and it'll be much easier to vote them out now that the town is still strong. I agree he may be trying to get lynched, but he may also be trying to look like he wants to get lynched. We can't rely on other factions to use their night kill to remove a neutral killer suspect because they can all win with him.

His behavior definitely doesn't look like town, marine or rebel in any case. They have no reason to try to look like a jester. If we can find evidence to really suspect someone of being CP9 or Pirate, then I would support pressuring and possibly lynching them. But for now, Trafalgar has my vote for being very likely non-town.

[FM Big Mom]

But COM hunting is against the rules, so Caribou did not try to hunt for COM identities. ;)

Truth be told some COM ids are just obvious to me, without even trying to COM hunt. :P


I'm lurking too much. I want to post something helpful, but someone already brought it up.

Can't you post anything useful?

What are your reads on:
FM Gecko Moria
FM Eustass Kidd
FM Big Mom
FM Wet Haired Caribou


i wonder why trafalgar is absent now, with 10 votes on him.

so it seems like we actually have arso AND EM. i have no good feeling about this

also, since one claimed bd, it is high likely that the friendly fire was caused by bd. he probably had a feeling that cyborg was scum. and i dont think bded was made by dd. possibly the rb was made by dd

finally
FM Trafalgar Law

The Jester WIFOM is strong in Trafalgar Law


So my reads on Geck Moria:

Most of his posts are atrocious one-liners.
Posts a lot of needless spam imo.
Is a sheep.
Possible roles/factions: Citizen / Busdriver / Rebels / Neutral

The specific busdriver callout is hinted at by 2 posts:

"I have not yet claimed my role"
"...badass busdriver..."

Sorry but i'm too lazy to quote the exact posts of his, but these give me the feeling that he's that. Now that i'm reading this, he might be a Witch trying to push the focus away from the CP9.

What do you think of my theory that he could be the CP9 infiltrator?

[FM Big Mom]

No matter his reasoning, it's actually possible.

Interesting.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

Right now we don't have any other clues to go for, do we? The most of us agreed on Trafalgar being scummy, and like that we can go forward instead of turning in circles IMO.

You were faster than me on this one. That's exactly what I was about to said.

Sure if we suspect another one (with strong evidence) being a pirate/CP9, our vote (or at least mine) will go there.

[FM Soul King Brook]

there can't be jester if there is arso + em. 2 drug dealers? i dont think so actually
probably trafalgar IS the arso. that's why he was so sure about this

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

FM Trafalgar Law
He's been acting weird all game so I'd like to hear a role claim from him. He's at L-5 now.


I'd also like Foxy to respond to the post I made about him as he didn't yesterday.


I don't find Zoro quite as scummy as some of the lurkers like Foxy. Foxy made one post saying nothing then an hour later he makes a post analysing something that is almost old news after people had been switching to Bonney's train.


Quick look over the Whitebeard waggon.

Big Mom claims to be Coroner for no apparant reasons (likely WIFOM claim), Whitebeard attempts to push a "Lynch all liars" waggon against Big Mom, then Whitebeard makes the post which realy kicks off the waggon against him.

I do not think this is a scum slip in which Whitebeard, as a non-town player, is complaining about how inactive his faction was during the night. Smiley face at the end imply's that it's more of an ironic comment then a bitchy one, and I'm having a hard time imagining that a CP9 would be so careless when posting.

Post realy doesn't seem that overly scummy to me. Looking over thread again before placing my vote
He says he'll look over the thread again before placing his vote but 10 hours later he hasn't posted again. I think he finds it hard to appear pro-town because of the hour it took for him to write his analysis post on something that happened a while ago and because he decided not to post again, maybe because he was having a hard time writing in a pro-town way. He has also largely described and repeated what has already been said in this post.

-vote FM Foxy the Silver Fox


I'm back again briefly. Lets have a look at the scum power behind 10 votes for someone with 1 post...

~Ever cynical Foxy:P


You then came back much later and try to dissuade people from voting the pirate, Franky, by suggesting scum are voting for him. You didn't bother to defend yourself from a vote made against you, maybe because you didn't feel threatened by that one vote made a long time ago. imo most town would at least comment if voted.


Okay guys. Earlier, I was against the Franky waggon for multiple reasons...

A) If you preasure a lurker, there is no sort of guarantee that they will respond. If the lurker in question does not respond, then you pretty much have to lynch them
B) Regular lurking tends to be a null tell. Lurkers can flip scum, but they are every bit as likely to flip town
C) Little can be learned from a lurker lynch

A page later and after Franky has started posting you change your mind, giving detailed reasons why you were previously against it. As you didn't defend yourself from my vote, it's a bit weird that you felt the need to defend yourself so strongly from this. This could be the moment you decided to bus your team mate, maybe because after his posts you thought he wouldn't be lynched so an extra vote wouldn't matter and you could distance yourself from him if either of you are revealed to be mafia later. You may also have thought his defence was so bad that you had to comment on it and start bussing in case he was lynched today or tomorrow.


However, Franky's posts in the past hour intrigue me very much so. Firstly, he comes on to see he's preasured, and proceeds to immediately snap out of his slumber and make 9 posts in under 2 hours. This seems suspicious to me, since it imply's that he wasn't lurking due to limited time or lack of interest. Now look at his opening statement...

Read the underlining of this post. Franky is pretty much confirming that he hasn't been lurking due to time issues, but because he's having too hard of a time reading this setup. Pure lurking = Null. Active lurking = Realy scummy.

I didn't think the waggon had much going for it earlier, and thought it was largely scum powered. I'm now reassessing my opinion after Franky's recent post.

-vote FM Cyborg Franky


It could be the reason you are thinking about this is because you are trying not to do it yourself. This could explain why you didn't comment on my vote and why it took you so long to return as you believed it would make you look scummy to immediately start defending yourself after you've been pressured. It would give away that you've been active lurking which is what I believe you have been doing. You posted 5 times yesterday, which is definitely lurking, but you never apologised or gave an excuse for this. You have also made 2 big analytic posts which don't fall into the pure lurker category as it shows you have an interest in the game and are paying attention.


Try reading again. You might find some thing more interesting than my lack of understanding for the setup.
Interestingly, Cyborg Franky himself replies to you straight after. It is very common when someone busses a team mate for that team mate to bus him right back and fake annoyance with him. You however don't reply to Franky's post, maybe because you can't think of a way to convincingly argue of him.



I don't really think hes guilty, but because he won't say anything productive

-vote FM Cyborg Franky
*Doesn't believe to be scum, but votes anyway*

*Slow clap*

Instead your next post you attack one of Franky's voters as if you are annoyed that your team mate is being voted for such stupid reasons. You then go back to lurking, seemingly content with barely having made an impact with your few posts.

While this analysis is very one-sided, I have done this because I want a response from you. I believe you are the most likely person to be a pirate and will be voting you when the votes on Trafalgar die down.

[FM Big Mom]

there can't be jester if there is arso + em. 2 drug dealers? i dont think so actually
probably trafalgar IS the arso. that's why he was so sure about this

Agreed. I think we should lynch the neutral because worst case scenario it reveals the existence of a drug dealer.

[FM Big Mom]

The interviewed guy really looks suspicious to me. He had 48 hours time to write something and he does that in the last minutes before the dead line? Why? Why even mention this? Maybe his team wasn't cabable to capitalize on the journalist article. So he waited for the last chance to write some gibberish neutral article which does jackshit. Not even a hint at his role. Why not?
Sounds to me like that guy has something to hide.

By the way, where is Bonney? I would think an active player such as she would make an appearance before now if not blackmail/ventrio'd.

[FM Urouge]

Truth be told some COM ids are just obvious to me, without even trying to COM hunt. :P



Can't you post anything useful?

What are your reads on:
FM Gecko Moria
FM Eustass Kidd
FM Big Mom
FM Wet Haired Caribou



The Jester WIFOM is strong in Trafalgar Law



What do you think of my theory that he could be the CP9 infiltrator?
it's a possibility. With the lack of substance in his posts he could be any kind of scum

[FM Whitebeard]

The day has only been up for 6 hours. It's a bit early to assume Bonny is locked off her account. It's something to watch for though. If there is a blackmailer, a journalist claim would be a likely victim.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

I believe you are the most likely person to be a pirate and will be voting you when the votes on Trafalgar die down.

And I will follow you since your post make a lot of sense. *Put Foxy on my scum list*
I did not pay attention to his post and now I see that I was wrong doing so.

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

The day has only been up for 6 hours. It's a bit early to assume Bonny is locked off her account. It's something to watch for though. If there is a blackmailer, a journalist claim would be a likely victim.

I really hope that she's not blackmailed... It would be great if she reveal the name of the person she interviewed. (Since the interview is suspicious).

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

The day has only been up for 6 hours. It's a bit early to assume Bonny is locked off her account. It's something to watch for though. If there is a blackmailer, a journalist claim would be a likely victim.

As a small followup to Boa's/your posts, If Bonney is blackmailed, then we can probably assume that her target was not a Pirate member. Caribou is pretty sure that if a Pirates member got the interview, if they indeed decided to blackmail Bonney; they simply wouldn't have answered the article to try and make her look like a liar about her claim.
Of course it wouldn't exclude the target from being CP9, Rebel or Neutral.

Just speculations.

[FM Don Krieg]

As a small followup to Boa's/your posts, If Bonney is blackmailed, then we can probably assume that her target was not a Pirate member. Caribou is pretty sure that if a Pirates member got the interview, if they indeed decided to blackmail Bonney; they simply wouldn't have answered the article to try and make her look like a liar about her claim.
Of course it wouldn't exclude the target from being CP9, Rebel or Neutral.

Just speculations.
I had the same thought earlier. It just wouldn't make much sense for the pirates to blackmail Bonney if one of the pirates was interviewed and wrote an article.

[FM Big Mom]

I really hope that she's not blackmailed... It would be great if she reveal the name of the person she interviewed. (Since the interview is suspicious).

IMO interviews should contain information hinting at that person's role, anonymus accusations, and the like. To leave that steaming pile of dog as an interview means the person who wrote it is a shite player, or they have something to hide, personally I am thinking it is the latter.

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

So umm, i kind of didn't notice i had been given the chance to write up an article.
This should prove Bonneys innocence, atleast in my eyes it should.
My view on the last day is as follows: The plans devised are a bit vague, but we should get a general gameplan after this night. The powerstruggle will be apparent once we know which factions have received even a minor strike as it will tip the balance drastically.

If i had noticed this earlier i would have given in detail reads on some players, but as is, i will just write a list of people we need to keep an eye on and pay more attention too. Also, the heavy lurkers need to be shot down.

Boa Hancock
Roronoa Zoro
Urouge
Cyborg Franky
Straw Hat Luffy
Trafalgar Law
Fire Fist Ace
Wet Haired Caribou

As i write this article literally 1 minute before the deadline, forgive me.

I think the journalist should reveal whoever wrote this as there is a good chance they are scum (I assume you interviewed someone scummy as well). If they were a PR they should have said so in the interview so the journalist can collect claims and form a role list early. They could have also told the journalist to re-interview them for information. I think even a citizen should have claimed so in the interview but the interviewee might not be the greatest player judging by how late he wrote the article and its content. It's a little odd that he put how late he wrote it in as if he's making an excuse for how useless it is or more likely so the interview does not look like it has been planned in a mafia chat. He wants everyone to think that he wrote this on his own, which is why he is so late.

He says nothing in the interview that could not be said in day chat, so why say it? It seems like he's pressured by the interview and has to try make himself look pro-town by giving analysis, which really isn't unnecessary, especially if he is in a rush like he says he is. He says "if I'd noticed this earlier" as if he' trying really hard to make people think he's a citizen that has no reason to check his account at night. He only has 'pro-town', agreeable opinions like "wait and see with alliances" and "damn lurkers!" which show he is trying to fit in. This list is also a scum tell imo has it gives him the opportunity to list a team mate or two with the scummy players to distance himself from them.

[FM Whitebeard]

I don't think a ventriloquist would go for Bonney because she probably posted a good code, since she was the one who suggested using them to begin with.

While the journalist article's so-called lurker list is rather messed up, that article (while useless) isn't necessarily scummy. It could have been made by a citizen who isn't paying much attention. That could be what the excuse posted at the top implies, that they saw the day was over and initially didn't bother checking if they got any PMs. Wouldn't be the first time someone didn't show up for jail chat. What goes against this theory is that players who aren't paying attention are usually lurkers too, so it makes no sense to suggest shooting lurkers for someone like that.

Another possibility is that the article was posted by someone who is trying to look like the village idiot. I'm looking at Trafalgar here. Bonney DID say she was going to interview someone of whom she was certain that they'd be alive today, if I recall correctly.

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

I wouldn't be surprised if Trafalgar wrote it after his first post today.

[FM Big Mom]

I wouldn't be surprised if Trafalgar wrote it after his first post today.

It's not Trafalgar since the person who wrote the article does not capitalize the noun "i"

[FM Don Krieg]

While the journalist article's so-called lurker list is rather messed up, that article (while useless) isn't necessarily scummy. It could have been made by a citizen who isn't paying much attention. That could be what the excuse posted at the top implies, that they saw the day was over and initially didn't bother checking if they got any PMs. Wouldn't be the first time someone didn't show up for jail chat. What goes against this theory is that players who aren't paying attention are usually lurkers too, so it makes no sense to suggest shooting lurkers for someone like that.

Like you say, it's a possibility, sure, but to me it seems that the person is trying to look like a citizen as to not appear scummy. The report is rather useless because the interviewee could have wanted to hide information which would help scumhunting, and if the interviewee is scum then it's clear that he didn't want to help too much. For now we can't do anything about that anyway until Bonney tells us who it is.

[FM Big Mom]

So umm, i kind of didn't notice i had been given the chance to write up an article.
This should prove Bonneys innocence, atleast in my eyes it should.
My view on the last day is as follows: The plans devised are a bit vague, but we should get a general gameplan after this night. The powerstruggle will be apparent once we know which factions have received even a minor strike as it will tip the balance drastically.

If i had noticed this earlier i would have given in detail reads on some players, but as is, i will just write a list of people we need to keep an eye on and pay more attention too. Also, the heavy lurkers need to be shot down.

Boa Hancock
Roronoa Zoro
Urouge
Cyborg Franky
Straw Hat Luffy
Trafalgar Law
Fire Fist Ace
Wet Haired Caribou

As i write this article literally 1 minute before the deadline, forgive me.


i wonder why trafalgar is absent now, with 10 votes on him.

so it seems like we actually have arso AND EM. i have no good feeling about this

also, since one claimed bd, it is high likely that the friendly fire was caused by bd. he probably had a feeling that cyborg was scum. and i dont think bded was made by dd. possibly the rb was made by dd

finally
FM Trafalgar Law


i didn't say it is so, it's just possible, that's a fact ;)
there could be a dd and they often drug rb

:|

[FM Don Krieg]

It's not Trafalgar since the person who wrote the article does not capitalize the noun "i"

Could be a trick as to hide his identity.

i could also write like that and i dont think that anyone would be able to identify me or atleast not if i change some words id normally use

We can only assume, but it's better to wait for Bonney. We can't just guess the interviewee's poosible identity and then pressure him hoping it's the right person.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

The day has only been up for 6 hours. It's a bit early to assume Bonny is locked off her account. It's something to watch for though. If there is a blackmailer, a journalist claim would be a likely victim.

busy today. i'll read, but won't pay particular attention until 2:00 my time tomorrow.

I 100% FOR ANYONE THAT VOTED ME BEFORE I REVEALED.

if anyone think i'm bmed/ventriloquisted, say something, but i'd like to keep my code for now.
if anyone ever thinks i'm ventriloquisted after, i can write my own report to publish next to my interviewee.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

By the way, where is Bonney? I would think an active player such as she would make an appearance before now if not blackmail/ventrio'd.

midterm, but as soon as i'm done, i'll be free for the rest of the FM.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

I really hope that she's not blackmailed... It would be great if she reveal the name of the person she interviewed. (Since the interview is suspicious).

what's suspicious about it?

[FM Whitebeard]

How about giving the solution for your code first of all, Bonney?

There's absolutely no reason to keep it to yourself. Just make a new one each day.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

oh sorry, should read the whole thread before posting.

personally, i believe a citizen who didn't bother checking his inbox cuz he thought he'd have nothing to do. i'm totally okay with this vote, i think.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

How about giving the solution for your code first of all, Bonney?

There's absolutely no reason to keep it to yourself. Just make a new one each day.

code was lynchwhoevervotedme

password java. you check it out to see that it works.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

oh sorry, should read the whole thread before posting.

personally, i believe a citizen who didn't bother checking his inbox cuz he thought he'd have nothing to do. i'm totally okay with this vote, i think.

NOT OKAY WITH THIS VOTE. he came up with the system to guard against ventriloquist and blackmailer, i HIGHLY doubt that he would be a pirate/cp9

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

NOT OKAY WITH THIS VOTE. he came up with the system to guard against ventriloquist and blackmailer, i HIGHLY doubt that he would be a pirate/cp9

and he didn't vote for me.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Ok thanks for revealing him. But i had him already pinned down b4 that.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Ok thanks for revealing him. But i had him already pinned down b4 that.

i did not interview traflagar or however you spell that name.

[FM Big Mom]

i did not interview traflagar or however you spell that name.

Did you interview Soul King Brook?

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Did you interview Soul King Brook?

if you independently think that my interview target was scummy, i'll throw my evidence on later, but i personally believe that the basis for his 'scumminess' was similar to my circumstances.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

She interviewed Kuma!

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

code was lynchwhoevervotedme

password java. you check it out to see that it works.

It's me or your code doesn't work?

I keep having fafebyzqyxxtpqlgxow...

I did something wrong? (Took the code:vzjdrxdpowbsfppfnna
with the password:javajavajavajavajav
and by adding number, I have this:fafebyzqyxxtpqlgxow)

[FM Big Mom]

It's me or your code doesn't work?

I keep having fafebyzqyxxtpqlgxow...

I did something wrong? (Took the code:vzjdrxdpowbsfppfnna
with the password:javajavajavajavajav
and by adding number, I have this:fafebyzqyxxtpqlgxow)

ventrio'd alert :suspicious:

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

ventrio'd alert :suspicious:

Nevermind... my mistake, it work.

[FM Whitebeard]

It actually does work, but not it looks like they added their key to the password to make the encryption instead of adding the key to the encryption to decrypt it..

vzjdrxdpowbsfppfnna
22-26-10-4-18-24-4-16-15-23-2-19-6-16-16-6-14-14-1

lynchwhoevervotedme
12-25-14-3-8-23-8-15-5-22-5-18-22-15-20-5-4-13-5

javajavajavajavajav
10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22

10+12=22
1+25=26
22+14-26=10

etc

[FM Big Mom]

Nevermind... my mistake, it work.

Credibility shattered,
A mistake leads to fallen grace.
Discarded straw hat drifts tattered,
Calls consideration to his chase.

[FM Whitebeard]

And you're right I looked back at yesterday and it was Trafalgar who posted the suggestion to use the code system. I thought it was Bonney's idea first.

http://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/17547-Day-1-5-Where-we-arrived-again?p=283125&viewfull=1#post283125

So there's something redeeming about him. I still don't trust him though, so I want to hear his response to pressure.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

*scraps saying might be mistake about code*

Right now town is going strong with no death so pirates are going to be worried.

If witch exist and they found pirate it means that cp9 will most likely controll the kills that go on.

Finally FM Trafalgar Law

Also are we gonna do codes again?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

There are currently 10 users browsing this thread (including me)

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

*scraps saying might be mistake about code*

Right now town is going strong with no death so pirates are going to be worried.

If witch exist and they found pirate it means that cp9 will most likely controll the kills that go on.

Finally FM Trafalgar Law

Also are we gonna do codes again?

Well that is quite the useless/filler post.

And about the codes; of course. What would be the point of them if we only used them on the first day?

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

*scraps saying might be mistake about code*

Right now town is going strong with no death so pirates are going to be worried.

If witch exist and they found pirate it means that cp9 will most likely controll the kills that go on.

Finally FM Trafalgar Law

Also are we gonna do codes again?

What's your opinion of the game so far?
Who do you find scummy and why?
What's your reason for voting Trafalgar Law apart from the fact that everyone else is doing it?
Who would you prefer to ally with, the rebels or the marines, based on the deaths today?
Which faction should be our priority today?

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Hi guys, I'm here. Nothing happened to me last night.

[FM Big Mom]

*scraps saying might be mistake about code*

Right now town is going strong with no death so pirates are going to be worried.

If witch exist and they found pirate it means that cp9 will most likely controll the kills that go on.

Finally FM Trafalgar Law

Also are we gonna do codes again?

Interesting that you feel the need to explain the pirate death with a witch as opposed to the possibility of a bus driver.

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Code solution:

basilhawkins 2 1 19 9 12 8 1 23 11 9 14 19
hawkinsbasil 8 1 23 11 9 14 19 2 1 19 9 12
10 2 16 20 21 22 20 25 12 2 23 5
J B P T U V T Y L B W E

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Interesting that you feel the need to explain the pirate death with a witch as opposed to the possibility of a bus driver.

Not everybody has posted yet. Couldn't there be both in this setup?

[FM Whitebeard]

I completed the check on Bonney's password and it actually looks like there's a small mistake in it.

vzjdrxdpowbsfppfnna
22-26-10-4-18-24-4-16-15-23-2-19-6-16-16-6-14-14-1

lynchwhoevervotedme
12-25-14-3-8-23-8-15-5-22-5-18-22-15-20-5-4-13-5

javajavajavajavajav
10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22-1-10-1-22

10+12=22
1+25=26
22+14-26=10
1+3=4
10+8=18
1+23=24
22+8-26=4
1+15=16
10+5=15
1+22=23
22+5-26=1 NOT 2
1+18=19
10+22-26=6
1+15=16
22+20-26=16
1+5=6
10+4=14
1+13=14
22+5-26=1

It does seem so small that it's probably still genuine though, right?

[FM Big Mom]

Not everybody has posted yet. Couldn't there be both in this setup?

We shall see.

That reminds me, where is Zoro?

[FM Basil Hawkins]

Wow so much night feedback has been claimed. Personally, I think that there is an EM rather than an Arsonist just because I think it makes the most sense to have a jester/executioner/ghost and an arsonist/electromaniac/serial killer but not two from one of the neutral categories.

I'm really confused about the Trafalgar Law thing because he suggested the disguiser codes but has been acting really scummy today. For now I shall wait to hear how he responds to the pressure since it seems like there are enough pressure votes on him atm.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

What's your opinion of the game so far?
Who do you find scummy and why?
What's your reason for voting Trafalgar Law apart from the fact that everyone else is doing it?
Who would you prefer to ally with, the rebels or the marines, based on the deaths today?
Which faction should be our priority today?

Opinion on the game: Fun, too early to really give full opinion because now that our reserve list is gone I figure there will be a lot of mod killing going on which I am going to be sad about.
Scum list: A lot of the lurkers
FM Jimbei one post yesterday and now lurks. He changes his pic yet doesn't post.
FM Scratchmen Apoo make spammy filler posts from day one and says made post to waste time

Now yes in my defense I didn't post but once yesterday but that's because I had collage, work, and real life things to take care of but now I am here.

Just a fun vote and I want to feel involved. If more votes come on and hes moved to L-1 before posting I'll unvote. Me posting votes elsewhere won't help. The fact is that he is active enough to see this and that so many lurkers are around.

I think it is still to early to decide what faction to side with. I hate to say this but I think we need to wait to see the first round of modkills because I think that will play the biggest factor in deciding what will happen on who sides with who.

Faction priority
If electromainac exist we need to find a way to out him but due to the sheer numbers of players its almost impossible to find it now.
Right now I think priority is pirates due to the fact that rebels can go to them for shelter late game. Take out pirates and rebels are forced to side with town.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

There was also someone who disliked the fact that we were doing coding yesterday. Does anyone know off-hand? I'm gonna go try and find the player but if someone knows plz post

[FM Boa Hancock]

It's college not collage EU SCUM!

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Found it it was FM Sogeking made 2 post. Both appear very scum like to me. Day one discredits journalist and gives a strong dislike to the fact that people are doing codes. Day 2 he says he needs to be more active yet continues to lurk.

[FM Big Mom]

Opinion on the game: Fun, too early to really give full opinion because now that our reserve list is gone I figure there will be a lot of mod killing going on which I am going to be sad about.
Scum list: A lot of the lurkers
FM Jimbei one post yesterday and now lurks. He changes his pic yet doesn't post.
FM Scratchmen Apoo make spammy filler posts from day one and says made post to waste time

Now yes in my defense I didn't post but once yesterday but that's because I had collage, work, and real life things to take care of but now I am here.

Just a fun vote and I want to feel involved. If more votes come on and hes moved to L-1 before posting I'll unvote. Me posting votes elsewhere won't help. The fact is that he is active enough to see this and that so many lurkers are around.

I think it is still to early to decide what faction to side with. I hate to say this but I think we need to wait to see the first round of modkills because I think that will play the biggest factor in deciding what will happen on who sides with who.

Faction priority
If electromainac exist we need to find a way to out him but due to the sheer numbers of players its almost impossible to find it now.
Right now I think priority is pirates due to the fact that rebels can go to them for shelter late game. Take out pirates and rebels are forced to side with town.

This tells me that you are not a pirate or rebel and have a non-town role that cannot be converted to the rebels. Possibly a marine {if I am reading you correctly}

[FM Soul King Brook]

nope i didn't do the interview (his english is also better than mine^^). anyway, it would be no harm if you reveal who did it, prolly even usefull.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

This tells me that you are not a pirate or rebel and have a non-town role that cannot be converted to the rebels. Possibly a marine {if I am reading you correctly}

Well my team might get mad at me but seeing how I can't hide much now I will say yes I am marine. HOWEVER, I do request that I keep my profile a secret. For now pirate will be on my ass soon. As will the rebels. My info that I have no affect for us if I reveal it so I request that I keep it to myself.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

To my marine pals: forgive me.

[FM Boa Hancock]

revealing without any pressue is just stupid. Especially if you haven't even found a pirate or a cg9 member.

You sir, cannot be trusted.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

revealing without any pressue is just stupid. Especially if you haven't even found a pirate or a cg9 member.

You sir, cannot be trusted.

so you are anti-marine? That makes me think you are pirate or town seeking rebels or are a rebel.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Well my team might get mad at me but seeing how I can't hide much now I will say yes I am marine. HOWEVER, I do request that I keep my profile a secret. For now pirate will be on my ass soon. As will the rebels. My info that I have no affect for us if I reveal it so I request that I keep it to myself.

is she being ventriloquisted? did she do a code check?

[FM Buggy the Clown]

To my marine pals: forgive me.

I am most displeased.

[FM Boa Hancock]

so you are anti-marine? That makes me think you are pirate or town seeking rebels or are a rebel.

I am anti stupidity. You just outed yourself for no reason. Do you really think your faction or town has any benefit from that? It's just stupid and even uncalled for. You just disturb discussion like that. You even endanger your teammates now to slip in day. Because everyone who doesn't question your motives now at day will be suspected to be a marine.

Well done sir! MVP right away!

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

I doubt a marine would claim for no reason. She could be a citizen trying to take a pirate kill or a CP9 trying to contact the marines.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Says the Marine Tony Tony Chopper. Jeez. Why do i even keep joining FM's? :P

[FM Big Mom]

Well my team might get mad at me but seeing how I can't hide much now I will say yes I am marine. HOWEVER, I do request that I keep my profile a secret. For now pirate will be on my ass soon. As will the rebels. My info that I have no affect for us if I reveal it so I request that I keep it to myself.

My apologies.
I was simply performing a reaction test on a lurker to obtain more information, it was not intended for you to expose yourself for no reason.


is she being ventriloquisted? did she do a code check?
This is a possibility seeing as she is more active today than she was yesterday and did not post a code check.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

is she being ventriloquisted? did she do a code check?

I was out most of day 1. I'll make a code right now.

30

The meaning of it shall be revealed tomorrow. Also before anyone says "well a vantrill can say 30 means anything" it means something very specific that if the reason I chose it will make sense when I explain it tom.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

My apologies.
I was simply performing a reaction test on a lurker to obtain more information, it was not intended for you to expose yourself for no reason.


This is a possibility seeing as she is more active today than she was yesterday and did not post a code check.

Meh live and learn is all I got to say.

[FM Whitebeard]

A ventriloquist can easily come up with something very specific that number 30 could refer to. I personally do not believe your claim, but I'm sure you have your reasons.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

revealing without any pressue is just stupid. Especially if you haven't even found a pirate or a cg9 member.

You sir, cannot be trusted.

cg9? where did you get that its cp9 the letters g and p are far apart. Care to explain that? And there is no g at all. Slip much?

[FM Boa Hancock]

yeah a slip which probably implies that i am not cp9 myself, because i don't care about them. Ever saw somebody who fails to write his own faction?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

yeah a slip which probably implies that i am not cp9 myself, because i don't care about them. Ever saw somebody who fails to write his own faction?

so you are saying you are a pirate/marine/nutral. Which means you are against the majority town. Explain that please, you are starting to look like scum yourself

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

just a reminder that i'm against the vote of traflgar! and he could possibly not care about cp9 because he's a town? towns, & revolutionaries don't care about cp9

[FM Donquixote Doflamingo]

Checking in, reading. Will give observations in a while.

[FM Black Leg Sanji]

First off nothing happened to me last night. The no Town deaths, Pirate killing of their own member, and CP9 kill of a Marine makes me happy that the hits didn't hit the Town. Despite it hitting a possible ally.

just a reminder that i'm against the vote of traflgar! and he could possibly not care about cp9 because he's a town? towns, & revolutionaries don't care about cp9

May I remind you that you were also against the lynch of Franky? Just because you are confirmed doesn't mean you are always right.

[FM Black Leg Sanji]

FM Trafalgar Law

He seemingly knows it's an Arson, despite it being a fail a nooby DD could drug doused. The only possible way he could know that would be Student/Skyper/Arsonist.

[FM Black Leg Sanji]

I suggest we stop voting for now and wait for a claim.

[FM Boa Hancock]

so you are saying you are a pirate/marine/nutral. Which means you are against the majority town. Explain that please, you are starting to look like scum yourself

Yeah i am pirate. It's obvious. Would you mind going back to day 1.5 and read it? Thank you! You start to look like somebody who is angry about his own error and blames it now on me.

[FM Capone Bege]

May Caribou ask you (And those who have one) to solve their codes?

IAMBEGEILIKEPI
31415926535897
LBQCJPGOQLPMYP


Capone is probably a infiltrator becouse he keeps telling people that they are not citizens.

When it comes to baby FMXVII....Ace....you are NOT the Citizen!
Ace claims Cp9.


He also tried to protect franky by starting a lynch train on me. Fm Capone Bege

I highly recommend you go back and read the post. I put my vote on Franky while saying that you should be pressured next while waiting for Franky to post.


Fm Trafalgar law

He is either a scum/jester/ghost/mayor

And the fact that he keeps trying to start lynch trains on someone that wifoms Jester/ghost(trafalgar).

:| Don't be so flattered, I would have voted you if Trafalgar wasn't being so scummy.


I suspect Fire Fist Ace of CP9 wifoming Rebel because he hands out CP9 accusations like candy and feel he should be pressured by more than me. I also have the feeling that Straw Haw Luffy is on the same faction as Fire Fist Ace just because of him defending Ace when I recommended pressure.

But, admittedly, Trafalgar is the main focus right now. Trafalgar come back and role claim plz, you are at L-3 according to Vote Count.

[FM Foxy the Silver Fox]

I'm online now. Vote count says Trafalgar is at L-3<.<

[FM Blackbeard]

Nothing happened to me. Law seems to acting extreme;y strange. Did he have a code/decode it and I missed it? posting mine in a sec.

[FM Blackbeard]

BDYPMQOFUQWPU

His the key 2 to the left of the one stated: cariboustopit because he found out my code.
This made me realize, why was he trying to see my code? It wasn't too subtle, but why even look at it for patterns in the first place? If he thinks he would get more pro-town points for pointing it out than he could gain by acting as me, it could be scum motive, but still has town motive. Not sure what to think.

[FM Blackbeard]

Just checked, and he did not post a decode, so this is very possible ventriloquist. I don't remember if he had a code yesterday.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Yeah i am pirate. It's obvious. Would you mind going back to day 1.5 and read it? Thank you! You start to look like somebody who is angry about his own error and blames it now on me.

like I said I live and learn. but the fact is they you are being defensive about your slip. Cp9 doesn't win with town or rebels. So the fact that you are not caring about cp9 is a telltalk to town to FoS you. If i'm gonna go back to day 1.5 where should I look?

[FM Blackbeard]

treglaffle or w/e did not post a code yesterday, so he is easy vent target and can't be proven.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

like I said I live and learn. but the fact is they you are being defensive about your slip. Cp9 doesn't win with town or rebels. So the fact that you are not caring about cp9 is a telltalk to town to FoS you. If i'm gonna go back to day 1.5 where should I look?

i personally suspect her to be a good target for 'ventriloquisted'

[FM Big Mom]

i personally suspect her to be a good target for 'ventriloquisted'

I personally suspect Bonney. Did she ever reveal who she interviewed last night?

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Hey there. I'm back at last.


BDYPMQOFUQWPU

His the key 2 to the left of the one stated: cariboustopit because he found out my code.
This made me realize, why was he trying to see my code? It wasn't too subtle, but why even look at it for patterns in the first place? If he thinks he would get more pro-town points for pointing it out than he could gain by acting as me, it could be scum motive, but still has town motive. Not sure what to think.

Personally, I think it was town motivated. At the very least we can be fairly certain he does not belong to a faction with a disguiser or ventriloquist (doesn't mean he's not a Pirate/CP9, but if he is one of those, they don't have the corresponding role the codes are designed to combat). If he solved your code so easily and DID belong to such a faction, he would have let it go and had his ally (or himself) take control of your account and post the solved code and none of us would be the wiser. By pointing it out and forcing you to change it, he thwarted (or made much more difficult) any attempts to control your account.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

I personally suspect Bonney. Did she ever reveal who she interviewed last night?

i unlocked my code. please don't say this again. i'll triple check my code for tonight.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

i personally suspect her to be a good target for 'ventriloquisted'

Lets say i am. whould a vantrill waste time making a code for me? that means vantrill has to take me yet again to explain the code i just made.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

no one jailed right? and i'd love it if cat thief nami could reveal roles that the marines have.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Lets say i am. whould a vantrill waste time making a code for me? that means vantrill has to take me yet again to explain the code i just made.

unless he plans for you to get lynched today or tomorrow. its not like the vantrill will change targets to confirm people that there is a ventriloquist, right?

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

unless he plans for you to get lynched today or tomorrow. its not like the vantrill will change targets to confirm people that there is a ventriloquist, right?

i feel like there is no need to defend myself anymore unless I'm being pressured voted. So for now good day jornalist.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

i feel like there is no need to defend myself anymore unless I'm being pressured voted. So for now good day jornalist.

just don't quite believe the marine claim, unless you can back it up. =)

good day cat thief.

[FM Foxy the Silver Fox]

While Law has been acting very wierd today, which I wouldn't expect. I'm looking over the people who were refusing to vote Franky yesterday to see if there are any Pirates we can find there.

[FM Foxy the Silver Fox]

Did Law even make an anti-ventriloquist code yesterday?

[FM Boa Hancock]

like I said I live and learn. but the fact is they you are being defensive about your slip. Cp9 doesn't win with town or rebels. So the fact that you are not caring about cp9 is a telltalk to town to FoS you. If i'm gonna go back to day 1.5 where should I look?

Tell me what this slip implies. Please do it. I am defending myself against what exactly? What the fuck dude? Do you really think i am not aware that you guys think i am a rebel or something? I can assure you i am not. I am obvious town from Day 1.5 until now.

@Jewelry Bonney:
Tell me how you come to that conclusion that i am ventrillo "possessed". I am really curious.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Tell me what this slip implies. Please do it. I am defending myself against what exactly? What the fuck dude? Do you really think i am not aware that you guys think i am a rebel or something? I can assure you i am not. I am obvious town from Day 1.5 until now.

@Jewelry Bonney:
Tell me how you come to that conclusion that i am ventrillo "possessed". I am really curious.

The fact that you say you don't care about cp9. Town should care about cp9 for cp9 wants town and rebels dead. And the fact that you are saying you were town 1.5 and now change it day 2.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Also did you make a code? And if so did you solve it?

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Tell me what this slip implies. Please do it. I am defending myself against what exactly? What the fuck dude? Do you really think i am not aware that you guys think i am a rebel or something? I can assure you i am not. I am obvious town from Day 1.5 until now.

@Jewelry Bonney:
Tell me how you come to that conclusion that i am ventrillo "possessed". I am really curious.

i think cat theif is possessed, not you.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Why should i make a code in the first place?

For the disguiser who goes disguising N1 or the Ventrillo who totaly possesses somebody who isn't easy to copy and rather active?
A Ventriloquist would possess somebody like FM Trafalgar Square who had like 4 posts day 1.5. Totally easy to dublicate day 2 to get a freelynch on a not CP9 member.

Do you realise how low the chances were yesterday?
They were nearly zero.

It's not my prob if you don't invest enough time into this game and i am not angry about it. But it would be nice of you not throwing half assed accusations around you all day. Especially with such a low contribution to the game so far. Roleclaiming is not contributing.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

Hi guys, just checking in for the night. I've read through the majority of today's posts, but I don't want to participate in the lynch train until I have a better understanding of what's going on. Today/tomorrow I'm going to be very busy IRL, but after that I'll do my best to post and be much more active :)

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Why should i make a code in the first place?

For the disguiser who goes disguising N1 or the Ventrillo who totaly possesses somebody who isn't easy to copy and rather active?
A Ventriloquist would possess somebody like FM Trafalgar Square who had like 4 posts day 1.5. Totally easy to dublicate day 2 to get a freelynch on a not CP9 member.

Do you realise how low the chances were yesterday?
They were nearly zero.

It's not my prob if you don't invest enough time into this game and i am not angry about it. But it would be nice of you not throwing half assed accusations around you all day. Especially with such a low contribution to the game so far. Roleclaiming is not contributing.

do the code please, at least for the sake of giving town more information. its better to know we have a vent/disg/bm rather than guess at it and be fearful of them.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Too much spam for nothing. I refuse

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Too much spam for nothing. I refuse

but its not nothing.........

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

REMINDER, THAT FROM NOW ON, IF I INTERVIEW YOU, REVEAL YOUR ROLE. THANKS.

scum and cits will probably just claim citizen.

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

Why should i make a code in the first place?

For the disguiser who goes disguising N1 or the Ventrillo who totaly possesses somebody who isn't easy to copy and rather active?
A Ventriloquist would possess somebody like FM Trafalgar Square who had like 4 posts day 1.5. Totally easy to dublicate day 2 to get a freelynch on a not CP9 member.

Do you realise how low the chances were yesterday?
They were nearly zero.

It's not my prob if you don't invest enough time into this game and i am not angry about it. But it would be nice of you not throwing half assed accusations around you all day. Especially with such a low contribution to the game so far. Roleclaiming is not contributing.

again if you dont make a code it means you are pro cp9/pirate and not town right now

[FM Big Mom]

i unlocked my code. please don't say this again. i'll triple check my code for tonight.

You incorrectly unlocked it. Whitebeard checked. Also, a ventrio'd journalist would not know who she interviewed the previous night, which is mighty suspicious given that you refuse to reveal the name of your interviewed subject.


no one jailed right? and i'd love it if cat thief nami could reveal roles that the marines have.

A town journalist would not say this, leading me to conclude that you have been ventrio'd.
I am calling you out because of the manner that you responded to legit concerns about being ventrio'd, that you have not sufficiently addressed. You have not revealed the identity of your night target, who did not provide a useful interview, yet you said you would protect his identity anyway. If you are town you are LVP for not revealing the id of the fail article wrtier. {Why you want to protect him I will never know.}

[FM Big Mom]

again if you dont make a code it means you are pro cp9/pirate and not town right now

Who are your biggest Pirate and Rebel FoS'es?

[FM Big Mom]

I shall also use this opportunity to repeat my suspicion on Zoro and Scratchmen Apoo.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

You incorrectly unlocked it. Whitebeard checked. Also, a ventrio'd journalist would not know who she interviewed the previous night, which is mighty suspicious given that you refuse to reveal the name of your interviewed subject.



A town journalist would not say this, leading me to conclude that you have been ventrio'd.
I am calling you out because of the manner that you responded to legit concerns about being ventrio'd, that you have not sufficiently addressed. You have not revealed the identity of your night target, who did not provide a useful interview, yet you said you would protect his identity anyway. If you are town you are LVP for not revealing the id of the fail article wrtier. {Why you want to protect him I will never know.}

i don't think i should put any pressure on him, because he's inno in my eyes. the story checks out. if i really am ventrilloed, you will know tonight, because i'll have put something my own commentary next to my next interviewee person. vent won't touch me, at least not longer than a day.

you didn't think I was town on day1.5 either, but i was. your reads aren't very good, at least when it comes to me.


I shall also use this opportunity to repeat my suspicion on Zoro and Scratchmen Apoo.

i can backup zoro, just like yesterday.

FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

I shall also use this opportunity to repeat my suspicion on Zoro and Scratchmen Apoo.

What's the concern with me? o.O

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

off the top of my head: fosed pirate is FM Sogeking for not liking the fact we have the code. Lurks post once. Says s/he want to lurk less yet post nothing.

Big Mom I have to say that although you seem very pro marine, if you are cit Rebels will take you. If you are a town power and decline the rebels for now when they get too much power you might be forced. I need to look back and find pirates. I find it funny that we are missing a 2nd bus claim. This does make me think bus driver got really lucky on swaping targets. I need more time to find all the people who I think are pirates/rebels. I will need to look through the chats again but Boa Hancock is starting to act cp9/pirate.

I do find it odd that Black leg sanji (lazy to find if name is correct) isn't as active right now.

[FM Urouge]

I have a suggestion regarding the current lynchtrain on Law. I will post it in, let's say, about half a day's time (12 hours or so).
Also my ventrilocode for today is : JEDOHOZ

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

What's the concern with me? o.O

The fact that you lurk and due to one vote/mention of your names comes up and you suddenly appear?

[FM Urouge]

What's the concern with me? o.O

Posts: 4

[FM Big Mom]

What's the concern with me? o.O

You are a hardcore lurkfest, which is bad for town, because you are not scumhunting or posting reads on the situation at hand or scummy personas, which hides your true intent and helps you blend.
You have posted no content and have just posted rp or hello type posts. {You do realize post analysis is half the game and you are not playing half of the game atm}

[FM Big Mom]

The fact that you lurk and due to one vote/mention of your names comes up and you suddenly appear?

This.

[FM Boa Hancock]

off the top of my head: fosed pirate is FM Sogeking for not liking the fact we have the code. Lurks post once. Says s/he want to lurk less yet post nothing.

Big Mom I have to say that although you seem very pro marine, if you are cit Rebels will take you. If you are a town power and decline the rebels for now when they get too much power you might be forced. I need to look back and find pirates. I find it funny that we are missing a 2nd bus claim. This does make me think bus driver got really lucky on swaping targets. I need more time to find all the people who I think are pirates/rebels. I will need to look through the chats again but Boa Hancock is starting to act cp9/pirate.

I do find it odd that Black leg sanji (lazy to find if name is correct) isn't as active right now.

Sure bro. Charged people are awesome recruiting targets. Glad you take so many notes.

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

The fact that you lurk and due to one vote/mention of your names comes up and you suddenly appear?

I posted before he said that :/.

With regards to the other stuff, I'll get back to you in a sec ^_^

[FM Boa Hancock]

Just for your notes. FM Rorona Zoro changed his avatar over last night. Which implies he locked into the game over that time period. Do as you wish with that information.

[FM Big Mom]

Sure bro. Charged people are awesome recruiting targets. Glad you take so many notes.


Order of Operations:


Jailing
Architect picks up his 2 targets
Journalist Interviews
Night Chats Open
Bodyguard Protects
Veteran Alert
Witch Controls
Escort / Consort Blocks / Enforcing
Lookout / Detective Actions
Bus Driving
Framing
Investigations /Spy Report
Electro Maniac charging
Killing Actions / Dousing / Electrocution/ Jailor Executes
Disguises take effect
Rebel Recruiting / Blacksmith gives out armor/gun
Autopsies / Healing
Cleaning / Grave Robbing
Blackmailing / Ventiloquist controls / Drugs Take Effect
Amnesiac Remembers His Role / Student Chooses Mentor
Jailor Releases
Joker picks his new target
Skyper sends his message
Publishing a Newspaper

:|

[FM Boa Hancock]

off the top of my head: fosed pirate is FM Sogeking for not liking the fact we have the code. Lurks post once. Says s/he want to lurk less yet post nothing.

Big Mom I have to say that although you seem very pro marine, if you are cit Rebels will take you. If you are a town power and decline the rebels for now when they get too much power you might be forced. I need to look back and find pirates. I find it funny that we are missing a 2nd bus claim. This does make me think bus driver got really lucky on swaping targets. I need more time to find all the people who I think are pirates/rebels. I will need to look through the chats again but Boa Hancock is starting to act cp9/pirate.

I do find it odd that Black leg sanji (lazy to find if name is correct) isn't as active right now.


You were recruited last night? :O

[FM Big Mom]

You were recruited last night? :O

Pay attention.
Nami already claimed marine.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Busy evening for me; Caribou cannot contribute tonight.
He shall be back early tomorrow.

[FM Boa Hancock]

Pay attention.
Nami already claimed marine.

I mean you. Is it only me or are you getting even more stupid from game to game? :O

[FM Cat Thief Nami]

I mean you. Is it only me or are you getting even more stupid from game to game? :O

Did you check who posted it? You are derping

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

Caribou was going to make this list for himself; but why not just post it for everyone to see.
This is the votes that happened after Boa Hancock's initial vote on Franky.

Also;


Spot on, miss Hancock. Now for the list:


Boa Hancock
Urouge
Wet Haired Caribou
Big Mom
Soul King Brook
Don Krieg
Straw Hat Luffy
Buggy the Clown
Tony Tony Chopper
Fire Fist Ace
Jewelry Bonney
Capone Bege
Roronoa Zoro[/QUOTE]

Adding my correction.