Day 3 Dicussion

[AscendedOne]

Decided I'd make this so elixir wouldnt have to. I really don't think you needed to clarify it elixir. Screw them if they cant figure out one was a mafia kill and one was a gun user.

[AscendedOne]

I can't for the life of me figure out why raiden is holding out on information. I currently believe him to be an investigator more then I do miles, but still. My only guess is he is already culted.

[Elixir]

They couldnt tell on day 2, it's a pretty big gameplay element so I threw it in there.

[Goonswarm]

I am sad I died, I have no clue why doctor did not heal me...

[AscendedOne]

They couldnt tell on day 2, it's a pretty big gameplay element so I threw it in there.

They?

[Elixir]

I am sad I died, I have no clue why doctor did not heal me...


Went to heal, and successfully healed, the 'invest'

who also vested last night.

[Elixir]

I am sad I died, I have no clue why doctor did not heal me...


Went to heal, and successfully healed, the 'invest'

who also vested last night.

[Elixir]

And besides, the old psychological choice, do you heal the most obvious target who the mafia KNOWS will almost certainly be healed? Or do you heal the next best target expecting them to instead, go for the 2nd best?

You were the most obvious confirmed case to be healed, the secondary invest wasn't.

[AscendedOne]

Elixir PLS clarify.

[Elixir]

Elixir PLS clarify.


Clarify what?

[monster]

So doc healed MileS the "invest", gotta love the "".

[Elixir]

So doc healed MileS the "invest", gotta love the "".


Correct.

[monster]

So Plato is the crazy cult leader, this is going to be epic. At least we will know what Raiden is pretty soon, cos he said he had detected a bad guy that cant be framed as it is not with the mafia - which leaves the cult leader.

[AscendedOne]

They couldnt tell on day 2, it's a pretty big gameplay element so I threw it in there.

They?






Elixir PLS clarify.


Clarify what?

[AscendedOne]

So Plato is the crazy cult leader, this is going to be epic. At least we will know what Raiden is pretty soon, cos he said he had detected a bad guy that cant be framed as it is not with the mafia - which leaves the cult leader.


Power to the trolls? First narks now spy?

[Goonswarm]

Well the good news for town is I was culted and hit by mafia. So cult is still stuck at 2 members.

[monster]

Well, the gunsmith should suspect the guy he gave a gun to is bad, WHEN HE RANDOM SHOT ME.
If the gunsmith was culted night1 then fine....

[monster]

Btw Raiden and Illidan are real life buddies - they always join as team in sc2 mafia and stick for each other. I'm not accusing them of cheating or anything, but it explains why illidan is very supportive of Raiden, even if they are not on the same team, as Yayap correctly noticed.

[AscendedOne]

Well the good news for town is I was culted and hit by mafia. So cult is still stuck at 2 members.


Ya.... To bad you want cult to win now. Elixir told me. SUCKS TO BE YOU.

[Elixir]

They couldnt tell on day 2, it's a pretty big gameplay element so I threw it in there.

They?






Elixir PLS clarify.


Clarify what?




2 or 3 people asked how the kills happened or got it wrong

[Goonswarm]

Wait so I am confused here. Mafia 1 Hit me and Mafia 2 Hit monster... How the fuck did miles get healed and from what?

[Elixir]

Are you serious? I even said in the fucking thread, 1 mafia kill and 1 gunsmith kill.

READING GOOD SKILL TOI HAVE

[monster]

@Goon, here is a pretty accurate sum-up of the events.

The red mafia hit you. Because the orange has a cult member(falsetruth), it is assumed he would not let them go for you.

The orange mafia went to kill MileS, presumably playing mind games with the doc - in my opinion they thought the doc would decide they were going to keep blocking him and thus pick another target for a heal, but he didn't. MileS also had a vest so it would not matter.

I was killed by a unknown person wielding a gun - and it has been confirmed the gunsmith isn't part of the cult. That's why the gunsmith should start talking and accusing the person he gave a gun to, unless he is some sort of a total newbie.

[monster]

Well in a shocking turn of events - Raiden is not jester. Now to see if anyone will believe him.

[philie]

I wonder why False truth is trying to lynch Plato now

[Goonswarm]

I wonder why False truth is trying to lynch Plato now

Who knows.

It is going to be a 1-2 punch. Consig will be confirmed. Cult leader and Hooker will die. Town is going to be massively ahead if spy gets lynched and they follow up with Raiden. Bear in mind nobody has a gun as I was given one when I died.

[monster]

I am going to go ahead and predict a Red Mafia Win.

[Clawtrocity]

Spy is Cult
Miles is jester
Raiden is invest
Auckmid is Consig
Narks is culted sheriff I guess
----Guesses under this line are more inaccurate, but still plausible.---
Rumpel is the doctor
Severn is a mason
False is Mafioso/hooker?
Crimson is the exe, but everyone knew that
Jack and Vorn could be GF/Consig team. Would be cool if they were since the subtle accusation between the two would kind of clear them of any involvement.
No clue who the 2nd Mason was, but I'm assuming it might be McPwnage or Yayap?

[MrSmarter]

Well they are putting spy up, town might just win this one.

[monster]

Claw you should read some of the earlier posts, we currently know this for 100%:

Spy is Cult Leader
Raiden is invest/consig
MileS is invest/jester
Auckmid is Mafioso
Narks is sheriff
Rumpel is a mason
Severn is a mason
False is a culted hooker
Crimson is the exe

[Elixir]

Raiden just took the biggest gamble ever there.

Good guess.

[monster]

Raiden just took the biggest gamble ever there.

Good guess.


LOL. Can you elaborate please. Why do you say he was guessing?

[Elixir]

Raiden just took the biggest gamble ever there.

Good guess.


LOL. Can you elaborate please. Why do you say he was guessing?


He never investigated spy

[MrSmarter]

MAPHACKS
Well he is right at least.

[Goonswarm]

Raiden just took the biggest gamble ever there.

Good guess.


LOL. Can you elaborate please. Why do you say he was guessing?


He never investigated spy


See my last will :) If I would have lived I would have shot spy with my gun I got.

[AscendedOne]

Well false truth is giving himself up. Why? He still has a chance even if spy is definitely lynched. 4 mafia left, spy will be lynched today causing his follower to also die. His follower COULD be a mafia but it is probably a town. 11 towns, 3 maybe 4 will probably die tonight. Jester/executioner could side with mafia. Leaving a best situation for mafia at 6v7. Which could happen in theroy. If falsetruth hadnt admited to being mafia he could have had a chance of winning.

[AscendedOne]

Goonswarm you would HAVE NOT shot spy. Because you JUST got the gun that night right? Then you would have been recruited. Or you woulda shot spy and everything woulda been fine.

[philie]

Rumpel is not a mason, the recruit failed

[philie]

Also, double post hence no edit button.
If Raiden was consig, Miles would try to speak against him which he isnt doing. I fact, nobody counterclaimed investigator in 10 pages while raiden was afk this day

[MrSmarter]

Rumpel is not a mason, the recruit failed



Well... I really hope the gunsmith was culted night 1 - night 2 gave gun to cult leader - night 3 cult leader got me....... Nah.. what am I saying...

RANDOM VIGILANTE FTW!

At least we got 2 masons left to continue the good fight. Rumpel and Severn are currently masons.

[Goonswarm]

Goonswarm you would HAVE NOT shot spy. Because you JUST got the gun that night right? Then you would have been recruited. Or you woulda shot spy and everything woulda been fine.

Doctor prevents culting. Had I lived yes I would have.

[AscendedOne]

Lemme doublecheck I dont remember that being specified.

[AscendedOne]

Goonswarm where extactly do you see doctor blocking cult recruiting cuz I don't see that anywhere. Oh and I didnt realize falsetruth was cult.

[Elixir]

Goonswarm you would HAVE NOT shot spy. Because you JUST got the gun that night right? Then you would have been recruited. Or you woulda shot spy and everything woulda been fine.

Doctor prevents culting. Had I lived yes I would have.


Not true.