im not
he saying her claim is ireeeliveant, folloing a conclusion one could say that he is saying all claims are irrlivent. if hes saying "well sino claim is diffrent" then it could be apllied as double standard.
if anything i want him to show me a game where scums come out day one and claim like that cus i know i used to do what mesk did all the time
I would hope Sino would execute if that happens. If someone gets jailed tonight, THEIR JAILOR IS CONFIRMED TOWN. If you're not going to share everything you know and try to form an alliance with your jailor, you're being anti-town and deserve to be executed. If Mesk wanted to turn being jailed into a meme, (which, tbh, I don't think you guys are giving townMesk enough credit) then she's acting like the jailer chat doesn't exist, at which point she deserves being executed for being anti-town. We'd wake up in the morning having removed either a scum or a weak anti-productive town.
Saying that jailing Mesk won't do anything is nonsense. Either she straightens up, (possibly revealing a non-cit role that can coordinate with jailor if she's town) or we get to remove her from the game. Win-win.
Scum wouldn't just claim Citizen right off the bat for no reason. There is simply no reason to draw that kind of attention to yourself. I really think that's just Mesk. Yeah, it's bad play but it's Mesk. She doesn't seem to care which is her town meat-I don't know if it's her scum meta. And her vote on Sino is indicative of how she votes as town-if someone bothered her at all last game she voted them.
I play differently all the time and I've also had the same matching playstyle for all alignments.
Using myself a bad example, but since you've said you never saw her play as scum - why can't it be similar as to the town play?
Do you have certain expectations of them as scum?
acutaly something jsut struck my mind
is a jailor executes the emperor or pleb leader does it change the neutrals wincon to have 50%?
@Gyrlander
It's partly her play matching almost exactly from her last town game and her claim which I don't think scum would make right off the bat. Yes, she's anti-town but I can't find scum motivation in how she acts. I honestly would have to look at a scum game of hers to even know how she plays as scum.
its simple:
he says mesk claim is irrivent
anyone form that point could argue that he thinks all claims are irrlivent.
its onyl later he added in "oh its about the timing as well"
so he changed his narrative
if he said "well mesk claimed with nothign early on and i find it werid" it would be mroe vaild but the argument he was making had no substance so anyone could draw any conclusion
thats not scum claimign citizen though. your argument is shes scum who claimed cit, your point here does not argue that plz try aagin
You're either intentionally misrepping, or just not reading. ofc if Mesk were confirmed town she shouldn't be executed. But she's not. All executions have to be made in light of how likely they are to be scum and how much their lynch as any alignment would benefit town. I very clearly was making the argument that she's being anti-town, and thus her execution is a safer bet (if she acts like a troll in jail like y'all think she will) because an anti-town player is more likely to be scum, and even if they aren't their loss isn't as bad.
So why are you acting like Mesk is in fact confirmed as town?
im saying she is probally town for her claim and unknwon has basicly stated what she would do in jail, you should knwo i defend town reads ebcasue i want to lynch scum. you are saying "well if shes town shes anti-town" so you basicly gave your self a way to abolish yourself of blame if she were to be jailed and executed and flip town
when do i make snese?
ika, perhaps we're not speaking the same language here. Let me try one more time.
You say "anyone form that point could argue that he thinks all claims are irrlivent."
I am asking why could anyone from his point of view say that? If anyone could argue that all claims are irrelevant, I would like to see the argument that you think anyone could make.
I don't care if people think I'm the new hitler or whatever, but just jail Mesk and execute them lol.