Originally Posted by
FM-Munenori
I think we should break this down. Lets assume this is a real blackmail. The role card of blackmailer says that you demand a player do something or else they die. From the looks of it, it seems that it has unlimited uses (which is pretty OP, we should try to find this role and get rid of it asap)
Ok, so assuming blackmail = real, Masa would have to be town (or maybe neutral). Mafia would not waste this on their own, else, the player would just fake it (so they don't actually die), also it's a waste of a night kill - the mafia would definitely use this on a town. The language of the sentence is interesting, especially the "My Opponent" part.
There are two scenarios that I can think of:
1) My Opponent is a true statement, and that Tokuhei is a scum, or
2) My Opponent is not a true statement, and that Tokuhei is town.
I'm more inclined to lean with scenario 1, because the way Tokuhei responded seems just like a slooooppy scum. But I also do not like that Masaharu has not posted again since this. I feel like if I were blackmailed, I would quote posts that I agree with and at least post the same sentence. Because it should not have been a list of demands, it should have just been ONE demand. (@Magoroth i hope u are hosting this right lol)
So then, if the blackmail is fake, then I doubt the mafia even have a blackmail role, or someone else is blackmailed and we don't know. But I doubt someone else is BM'd, because I'm sure mafia would not target an afk, and we would have realized it by now (Actually, I'm pretty sure a few players have not checked in yet, we are almost at the 24 hour mark). Masa was pretty scum read yesterday by many, and was a potential lynch. So why would the mafia target a scummy player? To clear the scummy player's name. So thus, if the blackmail is fake, My Opponent could really be to clear two names as town.
I've been sitting with this post open for at least 30 minutes, trying to form some train of thought. Please let me know if there's anything spotty or missing. I read it and reread it, but because its my thoughts they make sense to me. I'd like to hear what people think about this.
While I'm still here on this first page, I do have an issue with this post as well:
This is really weird to me that you knew there was a crier before anyone had claimed it? You claim to have been jailed and there is no invest type roles, so why did you go straight to talking about it?