Xcel: 1-S2-1-8387374

[ownblade]

Account Name: Xcel
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8387374
In-Game Name: The Wall

Crimes Committed: Game-throwing

Your Account Name: Scion
Summary: After being sentenced to death during the day 2 trial, he calls out #6 and #7 as mafia around the time of 6:37. #7 is lynched on day 3 and is revealed as a consort. #6 is not a mafia member, though.

[Veri]

Seems like you have forgotten to add a replay to this report. Please upload a replay so we can process this. Thank you!

[ownblade]

The replay has been uploaded, sorry about that!

[Veri]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Xcel: Correct: 1-S2-1-8387374

Players Added to Report
N/A

Respective Hotkeys
Xcel: CTRL + 2

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, Triad had no chance to win.

Previous Offenses
Role-Quitting (On-Hold)
Role-Quitting (On-Hold)
Role-Quitting (2x WL) – Approved

Player Offenses
Game-Throwing

Summary
Xcel receives the role Godfather in Slot 11. His allies are 7(Consort) and 4 (Beguiler).
D2 2 (Detective) accuses 11 of being GF because he visited the guy who got killed. 11 gets trialed, claims Doc and gets lynched. He then says „7 is mafia“ „and so is 6“ „im throwing“ „6 and 7 are mafia“.
N2 7 turns into a mafioso and tries to kill 2. 2 gets healed by a Doctor.
D3 7 gets lynched due to the Detective having tracked him thanks to 11s statement that he and 6 are mafia. He tries to defend himself by claiming Escort and saying that he blocked 4 N2 (because nobody but his ally would confirm him) and reveals the last mafia in the process.
D4 4 got shot by a Vigilante, Mafia lost.

I’m not sure if Xcel was trying to fake throw by outing only 1 of his Allies but I don’t see why anyone who is trying to win should do that D2. This may be a tactic in certain situations but there is absolutely no benefit in outing your Consort –who will become mafioso the next night- to town when there is a confirmed Detective around. Thanks to Xcel’s actions, Mafia had no chance and was dead Day 4.

Recommended Action
Xcel: 2x Ban-List

Additional Notes
Thank you for this report! Feel free to report players if you think they are breaking the rules, we appreciate it very much!

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-8387374: 2x Banlist

[Xcel]

I didn't mean that I accidentally put my Consort's name I was trying to throw the town off by saying some random people's names I do apologize to my consort however for the unintentional lynch I caused him.

[Xcel]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Xcel: Correct: 1-S2-1-8387374

Players Added to Report
N/A

Respective Hotkeys
Xcel: CTRL + 2

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, Triad had no chance to win.

Previous Offenses
Role-Quitting (On-Hold)
Role-Quitting (On-Hold)
Role-Quitting (2x WL) – Approved

Player Offenses
Game-Throwing

Summary
Xcel receives the role Godfather in Slot 11. His allies are 7(Consort) and 4 (Beguiler).
D2 2 (Detective) accuses 11 of being GF because he visited the guy who got killed. 11 gets trialed, claims Doc and gets lynched. He then says „7 is mafia“ „and so is 6“ „im throwing“ „6 and 7 are mafia“.
N2 7 turns into a mafioso and tries to kill 2. 2 gets healed by a Doctor.
D3 7 gets lynched due to the Detective having tracked him thanks to 11s statement that he and 6 are mafia. He tries to defend himself by claiming Escort and saying that he blocked 4 N2 (because nobody but his ally would confirm him) and reveals the last mafia in the process.
D4 4 got shot by a Vigilante, Mafia lost.

I’m not sure if Xcel was trying to fake throw by outing only 1 of his Allies but I don’t see why anyone who is trying to win should do that D2. This may be a tactic in certain situations but there is absolutely no benefit in outing your Consort –who will become mafioso the next night- to town when there is a confirmed Detective around. Thanks to Xcel’s actions, Mafia had no chance and was dead Day 4.

Recommended Action
Xcel: 2x Ban-List

Additional Notes
Thank you for this report! Feel free to report players if you think they are breaking the rules, we appreciate it very much!

Bump

[Xcel]

1-S2-1-8387374: 2x Banlist

Bump

[Arrow]

Hello.

I'll drop this to a 2x WL, since you don't have a history and shouldn't have been on banlist.

[DarknessB]

Hello.

I'll drop this to a 2x WL, since you don't have a history and shouldn't have been on banlist.

@Xcel , while we collectively decided to lower your Ban List to a Watch List here, that decision was largely based on you not having received a Watch List alert through the map before you accumulated enough offenses to be placed on the Ban List. Our hope is that you don't confuse this with condoning either role quitting or gamethrowing, both of which are against the rules and will result in harsher punishments with each offense.

While role quitting isn't a major offense, it is against the rules and unbalances games when players do so. Likewise, fake gamethrowing can be very risky as a tactic and messing up numbers (as you claim happened with you) can turn a fake gamethrow into a real gamethrow. Please be more careful in the future, and we hope not to see you back in reports -- unless, of course, you're filing them to help keep the game clean!

[Xcel]

@Xcel , while we collectively decided to lower your Ban List to a Watch List here, that decision was largely based on you not having received a Watch List alert through the map before you accumulated enough offenses to be placed on the Ban List. Our hope is that you don't confuse this with condoning either role quitting or gamethrowing, both of which are against the rules and will result in harsher punishments with each offense.

While role quitting isn't a major offense, it is against the rules and unbalances games when players do so. Likewise, fake gamethrowing can be very risky as a tactic and messing up numbers (as you claim happened with you) can turn a fake gamethrow into a real gamethrow. Please be more careful in the future, and we hope not to see you back in reports -- unless, of course, you're filing them to help keep the game clean!

Thank you so much! But is it possible to get off the watchlist eventually too?

[Veri]

Hello,

2x Watch List means you will be on the Watch List for 2 weeks, after that it's gone unless you offend again.
Have fun playing!