S-FM 235: Haunted Town

[Stealthbomber16]

Sb16 put our vote down

-vote Scvmurderer

[Scvmurderer]

-vote Scvmurderer

...

[Scvmurderer]

-vote Scvmurderer

I will hammer if you vote, I get off in 5 minutes, your choice

[Stealthbomber16]

I will hammer if you vote, I get off in 5 minutes, your choice

My choice was made clear a while ago: we still have another 24 hours. Lynching people without giving them a chance to defend is how games are lost. I want to hear how Boxer responds to this and extensively, other people's commentation to his response. Feel free to sleep.

[Stealthbomber16]

Anyway now that the joke is up

-unvote

[Scvmurderer]

My choice was made clear a while ago: we still have another 24 hours. Lynching people without giving them a chance to defend is how games are lost. I want to hear how Boxer responds to this and extensively, other people's commentation to his response. Feel free to sleep.

Sleep it is. I work tmrw so dont expect a reply from me till later in the day.

[Stealthbomber16]

Sleep it is. I work tmrw so dont expect a reply from me till later in the day.

Have a good night's sleep. Don't let the ghosts bite.

[PIayer]

I'm back, boo

-unvote

Angel said maf wanted to push me; then several people go "piayer is scum/can be mastermind asking himself to be pushed" rofl. I'm flattered being so respected already lol.

@MM *giggle* you'll have a list at some point don't worry. And I hope it will be full of unpopular opinions, for I am a hipster.

[PIayer]

Also won't l-1 as I agree with SB on this, too soon, and too bloodthirsty SCV, I believe him when he says he wants to hammer. Mesk could also surprise hammer. So no thx not yet. Let Boxer speak for himself and use daytime efficiently.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Based purely off of Otaku... the scum team is Boxer & Piayer.

Boxer 99.9% (notice the fucking huge scum slip lol...)
PIayer 70%, I would like to hear him more.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Also won't l-1 as I agree with SB on this, too soon, and too bloodthirsty SCV, I believe him when he says he wants to hammer. Mesk could also surprise hammer. So no thx not yet. Let Boxer speak for himself and use daytime efficiently.

Agreed. Scv is a "passive vegetable", thanks Nawa for these words I don't like that. But I won't lynch him, not yet.

You can also forget the 70% scum PIayer, it was before reading your stuff.

[PIayer]

Stay here MM, content on the way

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I'm back, boo

-unvote

Angel said maf wanted to push me; then several people go "piayer is scum/can be mastermind asking himself to be pushed" rofl. I'm flattered being so respected already lol.

@MM *giggle* you'll have a list at some point don't worry. And I hope it will be full of unpopular opinions, for I am a hipster.

hello lol, glad to hear that. As I said in my previous post, I thought you were scummy because of lurking and no contribution.. but you seem to have an intent to contribute. And for the being so respected already, I fear that you.. are... better than me... After all, you won more games than me ^^

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Stay here MM, content on the way

It'll be for tomorrow... I worked terribly late, and I am tiiiired.... zzz...... ok i woke up, time to go to sleep, it's morning here.... see you tomorrow, ill read that content tomorrow have fun, glad to see you're back in the game =)

[PIayer]

Spoiler : THE GOOD OLE PIAYER WALL OF TEXT (inb4 scum mastermind again) :

Once more with fancy colors & bullshit %'s to fully entertain your mind !


Mesk: 94% Town 3% Angel 3% Mafia, dgaf if she's vig or not but my townlean is even harder since she took time to explain her thought process about Otaku and try to convince me. Typical town behavior in my book


SB: 72% Town 28% Senior Mafia. People saw your early angel call D1 as towny behavior but didn't see it that way when I first reread thread after replacing Unknown. If you were scum this would achieve two things imo: gathering easy d1 towncred (to those who played 8-2-2, remember SJ), and get an angel claim to narrow your kill pool; afterall avoiding Angel at night should be a mafia priority.
On the other hand, I had a good vibe from your other contributions and you made sense, and this is a rare enough thing to townlean you atm.


Otaku 79% Angel 20% Maf 1% Town next-level play: since no angel cc we're all inclined to believe your claim, but

U can shoot me and confirm it if u like <3<3

this is not very a protown thing to say, you claim being night immune but both Mafia also are. If you side with town why suggest such a tpr waste?


Nawa: 69% Town 31% Whatever

@Spruance , Nawa has never roled Town yet... just so you know.

the Nawa case in a nutshell
Basically a meta case, so let's be dirty and speak meta. Y'all say he's not acting different than previous games, but
1. to me he's actually acting different than the two previous games
2. if he really never rolled Town yet, how could we(you) be able to discriminate between his town play and his scum play. It's actually safe to assume his first town play will look scummy, for habit/inexperience if not for meta.
In short, to my guts Nawa is not scum here.


MM: 63% Town 35% Senior Mafia 2% Angel

WE ARE CRUEL FUCKS THAT LYNCH SURVIVORS*
WE ARE DEMONS THAT LYNCH ANGELS*
WE ARE ASSHOLES THAT PREVENT THE POOR NEUTRAL FROM WINNING*
JOIN MESK IN HIS HERESY*

Tbh Mesk pov on this topic makes more sense than yours.
Also you keep saying Nawa is playing like I did last game and it's irking me, first he's 3rd at postcount but last game I was the lowest potscount for a while as I didn't spam. Second, instead of spamming I gave constructed thoughts, didn't see him doing this here? We don't care much but tbh you've repeated it several times already, at this point I feel it needs more explanation.

Hum. You are being anti-town by heavily suggesting to block Mesk.

Explain how? Mesk is my biggest town lean so far, she made more sense than you regarding Angel. Also I block with whoever the fack I want, how is this anti-town while you flip-flopping your vote is being okay #466 ?

Spruance is Citizen. The following hypothese is with Angel telling the truth 100%. Boxer = Junior Ghost. ???? = Senior Ghost. Mesk = Vigilante. PIayer = TPR/Scum/Low cit chances.

Ok for hypothesis, but how is Spruance cit confirmed and Boxer Junior Ghost while I have only "low cit chances"? Do you have some informations we do not? The way I see it, objectively it's hard to discriminate Spruance from Boxer atm, Spruance did some random vote there and there but that alone is NAI to me, Boxer is borderline afk but while anti-town that is also NAI 'cuz "idgaf Citizen" phenomenon

On the bright side #451 I like the fact you catched Mesk actual defensiveness here. And I see you trying to scumhunt. So please answer me, you're no lynch material atm and I'd like it to stay this way.



That leaves SCV/Boxer/Spruance in the null category. Assuming we trust what Otaku said about daychat, one of those may be Junior Mafia. Others may just be apathic town.
The possibility of 1 timid Junior Mafia teaming with 1 outspoken/active Senior Mafia is tempting to believe, at least it connects with the very little experience I got with this game so far: while Scum are never obvious, most of the time at least 1 is more or less obvious and at least 1 is sneaking with town/harder to catch based on behavior.

But still, Otaku could still be deceiving afaik, as people catched already it's a risky play as Angel to insta reveal like he did, so maybe he's maf and the true Angel is staying low profile atm.
Can't know atm, what I DO know is, we should probably continue to think for ourselves and not build too much on what Otaku told us.

going wow, i'll f5 in ~30mn

[BoxerRebellion]

Look at the game setup. The angel is most manipulative role in the entire game. From an angel's perspective, you know the townies and ghosts would never waste a night killing him because the angel can act as a tie breaker.

You guys are literally taking the words of this fucker. I voted on Otakudweeb69 because he lost all credibility when he stated this:

boxer wanted me to push piayer

It is very clear that Player wanted my ass lynched. I never said shit about wanting or asking to lynch Player.

Also, the angel stated that he was persuaded by the ghosts to push on Spruance. Why the fuck would the ghosts tell the angel that? It is clear that Mesk514 is fucking trigger happy on Spruance since day one. Based on this information either Spruance is innocent, or he is trying to make himself look like it to throw off suspicion. The main question is should this angel be trusted?

Stealthbomber16, your conclusion makes no sense to me. You stated that player and I, or Spruance and I are scum. Look back at Spruance's instant vote on me after Marshmallow Marshall. Check day one on Player complaining about my buffoonery comments. Where the fuck did you come up with these ideas?

Lynch me if you want. Just remember you are taking the words from an angel who I do not trust.

[Mesk514]

I had one bitch drink at 8pm... snoked a fat ass blunt and passed the fuck out. Now im up. Gonna read some of my new book i bought today and im gonna pass the fuck out.

[Scvmurderer]

Spoiler : THE GOOD OLE PIAYER WALL OF TEXT (inb4 scum mastermind again) :

Once more with fancy colors & bullshit %'s to fully entertain your mind !


Mesk: 94% Town 3% Angel 3% Mafia, dgaf if she's vig or not but my townlean is even harder since she took time to explain her thought process about Otaku and try to convince me. Typical town behavior in my book


SB: 72% Town 28% Senior Mafia. People saw your early angel call D1 as towny behavior but didn't see it that way when I first reread thread after replacing Unknown. If you were scum this would achieve two things imo: gathering easy d1 towncred (to those who played 8-2-2, remember SJ), and get an angel claim to narrow your kill pool; afterall avoiding Angel at night should be a mafia priority.
On the other hand, I had a good vibe from your other contributions and you made sense, and this is a rare enough thing to townlean you atm.


Otaku 79% Angel 20% Maf 1% Town next-level play: since no angel cc we're all inclined to believe your claim, but
this is not very a protown thing to say, you claim being night immune but both Mafia also are. If you side with town why suggest such a tpr waste?


Nawa: 69% Town 31% Whatever

the Nawa case in a nutshell
Basically a meta case, so let's be dirty and speak meta. Y'all say he's not acting different than previous games, but
1. to me he's actually acting different than the two previous games
2. if he really never rolled Town yet, how could we(you) be able to discriminate between his town play and his scum play. It's actually safe to assume his first town play will look scummy, for habit/inexperience if not for meta.
In short, to my guts Nawa is not scum here.


MM: 63% Town 35% Senior Mafia 2% Angel

Tbh Mesk pov on this topic makes more sense than yours.
Also you keep saying Nawa is playing like I did last game and it's irking me, first he's 3rd at postcount but last game I was the lowest potscount for a while as I didn't spam. Second, instead of spamming I gave constructed thoughts, didn't see him doing this here? We don't care much but tbh you've repeated it several times already, at this point I feel it needs more explanation.

Explain how? Mesk is my biggest town lean so far, she made more sense than you regarding Angel. Also I block with whoever the fack I want, how is this anti-town while you flip-flopping your vote is being okay #466 ?

Ok for hypothesis, but how is Spruance cit confirmed and Boxer Junior Ghost while I have only "low cit chances"? Do you have some informations we do not? The way I see it, objectively it's hard to discriminate Spruance from Boxer atm, Spruance did some random vote there and there but that alone is NAI to me, Boxer is borderline afk but while anti-town that is also NAI 'cuz "idgaf Citizen" phenomenon

On the bright side #451 I like the fact you catched Mesk actual defensiveness here. And I see you trying to scumhunt. So please answer me, you're no lynch material atm and I'd like it to stay this way.



That leaves SCV/Boxer/Spruance in the null category. Assuming we trust what Otaku said about daychat, one of those may be Junior Mafia. Others may just be apathic town.
The possibility of 1 timid Junior Mafia teaming with 1 outspoken/active Senior Mafia is tempting to believe, at least it connects with the very little experience I got with this game so far: while Scum are never obvious, most of the time at least 1 is more or less obvious and at least 1 is sneaking with town/harder to catch based on behavior.

But still, Otaku could still be deceiving afaik, as people catched already it's a risky play as Angel to insta reveal like he did, so maybe he's maf and the true Angel is staying low profile atm.
Can't know atm, what I DO know is, we should probably continue to think for ourselves and not build too much on what Otaku told us.

going wow, i'll f5 in ~30mn

Y am I always scum or null read in your read lists D:

[PIayer]

"always" lol, you talk about a 2 game meta, first was my first game, second I gave you town cred during the whole game =o.. Ok I knew you were town, but early-mid game at least I would've done the same as town for your efforts.

I find you far less contributive in this one atm, that could be alignment switch or a simple attempt at switching gameplay given the outcome of your last 2 games as Town, hence the null.

Also I don't want to push Boxer after his post, sounds reasonable atm and maybe people will want to react to it. Maybe Spruance?

[Nawa]

Agreed. Scv is a "passive vegetable", thanks Nawa for these words I don't like that. But I won't lynch him, not yet.

You can also forget the 70% scum PIayer, it was before reading your stuff.

In cykablytaish version of Mafia, passive vegetable was how cits called themself as cits couldn't do much in that version of Mafia.
Everything leaned on TPRs, and sometimes, random.
But now, as cits have way more power..

[PIayer]

Y'all can iso Spruance it's pretty quick

#118 One line, but one of the two contributions I could find on 23 posts
#128 just a bad, misleading thing to say imo, questioning host integrity so we don't focus on the actual game
#347 at first it just looked like random troll vote by bored citizen. Until this part. You appear trying to tell us you actually mean your trollvote, yet give ultra evasive/meaningless oneliner as only justification. Why a town would do that seriously?
#465 yet another misleading meta comment
#467 one line, 2nd/23 contribution I could see

@Spruance
That'll need to be answered

Only reason I don't vote you atm is we need more people to react (INSTEAD OF READING WHATEVER DEAD, STATIC, ETERNAL THING >_>), and also really don't know if I can believe Angel atm but there's still this possibility he just play badly and tell the truth. Don't have enough atm to discard this thought

@Otakudweeb69
Thought experiment: we're EoD and Mesk ask you to vote Spruance. SCV then me already parked on him earlier. What would you do in this situation and why?



ps: On the mod "HEY IM SURV" first line D1 was basically a meme in every game with neutrals. Of this meta I also remember a funny game, where one player did seriously claim town-aligned Survivor, did his best to be town, just to be turbolynched D1. He said "gg ez" during last words and flipped Jester like a boss. So, yeah. Evoking

[Nawa]

i want to remind that BoxerRebellion still didn't defend

[Hybrid]

Warning, I will have to replace @BoxerRebellion if he isn't going to contribute or doesn't reply to my pm (Which I've pmed him like 8-ish hours ago) in 7 hours.

• 00

• 00

• 00

• 00

DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Spoiler : THE GOOD OLE PIAYER WALL OF TEXT (inb4 scum mastermind again) :

Once more with fancy colors & bullshit %'s to fully entertain your mind !


Mesk: 94% Town 3% Angel 3% Mafia, dgaf if she's vig or not but my townlean is even harder since she took time to explain her thought process about Otaku and try to convince me. Typical town behavior in my book


SB: 72% Town 28% Senior Mafia. People saw your early angel call D1 as towny behavior but didn't see it that way when I first reread thread after replacing Unknown. If you were scum this would achieve two things imo: gathering easy d1 towncred (to those who played 8-2-2, remember SJ), and get an angel claim to narrow your kill pool; afterall avoiding Angel at night should be a mafia priority.
On the other hand, I had a good vibe from your other contributions and you made sense, and this is a rare enough thing to townlean you atm.


Otaku 79% Angel 20% Maf 1% Town next-level play: since no angel cc we're all inclined to believe your claim, but
this is not very a protown thing to say, you claim being night immune but both Mafia also are. If you side with town why suggest such a tpr waste?


Nawa: 69% Town 31% Whatever

the Nawa case in a nutshell
Basically a meta case, so let's be dirty and speak meta. Y'all say he's not acting different than previous games, but
1. to me he's actually acting different than the two previous games
2. if he really never rolled Town yet, how could we(you) be able to discriminate between his town play and his scum play. It's actually safe to assume his first town play will look scummy, for habit/inexperience if not for meta.
In short, to my guts Nawa is not scum here.


MM: 63% Town 35% Senior Mafia 2% Angel

Tbh Mesk pov on this topic makes more sense than yours.
Also you keep saying Nawa is playing like I did last game and it's irking me, first he's 3rd at postcount but last game I was the lowest potscount for a while as I didn't spam. Second, instead of spamming I gave constructed thoughts, didn't see him doing this here? We don't care much but tbh you've repeated it several times already, at this point I feel it needs more explanation.

Explain how? Mesk is my biggest town lean so far, she made more sense than you regarding Angel. Also I block with whoever the fack I want, how is this anti-town while you flip-flopping your vote is being okay #466 ?

Ok for hypothesis, but how is Spruance cit confirmed and Boxer Junior Ghost while I have only "low cit chances"? Do you have some informations we do not? The way I see it, objectively it's hard to discriminate Spruance from Boxer atm, Spruance did some random vote there and there but that alone is NAI to me, Boxer is borderline afk but while anti-town that is also NAI 'cuz "idgaf Citizen" phenomenon

On the bright side #451 I like the fact you catched Mesk actual defensiveness here. And I see you trying to scumhunt. So please answer me, you're no lynch material atm and I'd like it to stay this way.



That leaves SCV/Boxer/Spruance in the null category. Assuming we trust what Otaku said about daychat, one of those may be Junior Mafia. Others may just be apathic town.
The possibility of 1 timid Junior Mafia teaming with 1 outspoken/active Senior Mafia is tempting to believe, at least it connects with the very little experience I got with this game so far: while Scum are never obvious, most of the time at least 1 is more or less obvious and at least 1 is sneaking with town/harder to catch based on behavior.

But still, Otaku could still be deceiving afaik, as people catched already it's a risky play as Angel to insta reveal like he did, so maybe he's maf and the true Angel is staying low profile atm.
Can't know atm, what I DO know is, we should probably continue to think for ourselves and not build too much on what Otaku told us.

going wow, i'll f5 in ~30mn

I agree with you on most points, only with Angel, who I see as 90% Angel 9.9% Ghost 0.1% Town

Stealthbomber COULD be the Senior Ghost, as you said, but I town read him.

Nawa is a nutshell, yes... meeehhhhh let's not lynch him today, get boxer before lol.


For the HERESY CAPS MESSAGE ABOUT BOXER, it was because Mesk wants to lynch a spy, basically. If town says KILL THE SURV, the surv will side with mafia, that's what always happens. So what if we just help him... lol... there is no CC against him, and he looks trustworthy.

For the Nawa playing like you, I mean that he's lurking, posting things that SOUND like having sense (more at beggining of game, less yet) but that don't really reveal anything. Fake contributions, that's what I thought.

Lololol that's not what I meant, excuse my bad english I meant ROLE BLOCK xD it's anti-town to suggest to roleblock a Vigilante. Sorry for the confusion <3

Spruance being Citizen would perfectly fit with (as I already mentioned) Angel's theory. Plus, it fits with my meta experience with him. Boxer did a fucking horrible awful scum slip, can't you simply go read my post???? It's terribly obvious, and there's no jester lol...

The "low cit chances" is outdated. I posted this before you got active. TPR/Scum because you looked like someone wanting to keep stuff for himself. And no, I don't have information you do not (I'm citizen, if you're so curious. Claiming this for me could help us finding actual liars, because both Spruance and Boxer claiming cit, + me, means only one more room for a citizen.)

Actually.... Otukudweeb was my scum partner in the S-FM: Pulp Fiction, the only time I got scum was my first game lol... If you want, you can go see how he played. I don't feel like his play is similar. He wouldn't risk so much in claiming Angel if he was not, imo. But yes, we msut have an idea by ourselves, that's obvious.


Thanks for your post! I think this was productive =)

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Warning, I will have to replace @BoxerRebellion if he isn't going to contribute or doesn't reply to my pm (Which I've pmed him like 8-ish hours ago) in 7 hours.

[Countdown Timers Cannot be Quoted from Other Posts]

o.o

[Marshmallow Marshall]

OMFG THE SLIP THERE LOLLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL

#477. Look at the quoted message there. He is literally saying he didn't say he wanted PIayer lynched... in night chat.

[PIayer]

Thanks for the depht of answer.

About #477, imo LOLOLOL is relevant, didn't see him ever push me in daychat. Otaku is the one claiming the passive/active maf stuff & who put Spruance & me together in maf lynchpool. Keep in mind Boxer was responding to

I’ll give my opinion on them. You and boxer wanted me to push piayer, and I assume you want mesk to night kill scv.

So-called Angel basically called him & Nawa scum but Angel can't formally know scum, only scum can. You're the one choosing to trust Angel here despite what Boxer just said about it.
Reading his answer to Otaku nothing jumped on my face, he was basically saying "never said that nowhere + you can't know scum for sure so you're full of bullshit", fair in the context imo

@Hybrid he just posted, wtf is going on

[Hybrid]

Thanks for the depht of answer.

About #477, imo LOLOLOL is relevant, didn't see him ever push me in daychat. Otaku is the one claiming the passive/active maf stuff & who put Spruance & me together in maf lynchpool. Keep in mind Boxer was responding to
So-called Angel basically called him & Nawa scum but Angel can't formally know scum, only scum can. You're the one choosing to trust Angel here despite what Boxer just said about it.
Reading his answer to Otaku nothing jumped on my face, he was basically saying "never said that nowhere + you can't know scum for sure so you're full of bullshit", fair in the context imo

@Hybrid he just posted, wtf is going on

He is only posting three times or four times per day which is not enough, he has to contribute more or else he will be replaced.

[BoxerRebellion]

Want me to spam the day chat? Ok. Why not bother Spruance? He hardly contributes as well. Most of the day chat that I see is the most baseless shit ever. Waste of my time reading it. There is no need for me to response to ever comment made.

[Scvmurderer]

"always" lol, you talk about a 2 game meta, first was my first game, second I gave you town cred during the whole game =o.. Ok I knew you were town, but early-mid game at least I would've done the same as town for your efforts.

I find you far less contributive in this one atm, that could be alignment switch or a simple attempt at switching gameplay given the outcome of your last 2 games as Town, hence the null.

Also I don't want to push Boxer after his post, sounds reasonable atm and maybe people will want to react to it. Maybe Spruance?

Least contributive? I'm the most active poster again ffs. Tell you what. You want a read list? I know you love them player. I'll post one later tonight when I get back from work and not posting on mobile.

[Nawa]

Spruance posted 22 posts so far.
BoxerRebellion posted 9 posts so far.

^^ did it using search tool

[PIayer]

I know you're top postcount and you contributed to make daychat live. But talking actual content I don't see many constructed thoughts, as usual that makes it pretty hard to guess what is on your mind.. But if it makes you feel better, I want to hear Spruance, I want Mesk answer to Otaku, I want SB to answer me, I want several things atm but lynching you isn't one of them.

It's not just me man, EVERYONE love lists, especially when there is colors in it ♥

[Nawa]

Scvmurderer posted 108 posts so far.
I have posted 82 posts so far.
PIayer posted 38 posts so far.(surprise?)

[Nawa]

Stealthbomber16 posted 42 posts so far.
Otakudweeb posted 38 posts so far.

[Nawa]

Mesk514 posted 53 posts so far.

[Nawa]

Marshmallow Marshall posted 95 posts so far.

[Nawa]

BoxerRebellion posted least posts between us all. And never did the readlist.
^^ lynch him, almost day till day ends
and desperately asking to lynch Boxerrebellion is 100% bad idea if we want a lynch today.

[Nawa]

BoxerRebellion posted least posts between us all. And never did the readlist.
^^ lynch him, almost day till day ends
and desperately asking to lynch Boxerrebellion is 100% bad idea if we want a lynch today.

^^ at EoD

[BoxerRebellion]

BoxerRebellion never did the readlist.

What is a readlist?

[Spruance]

Boxer give up your partner and we will save you for last ok

[Nawa]

What is a readlist?

your opinion on who is town and who is scum
fe:

Town:
Player 2: he did alot for town
Player 3: he is confirmed mayor
Null:
Player 4: i cannot read him and he didnt post much
Player 5: though he did towny actions, he still seems sus
Scum:
Player 6: he is a general asshat
Player 7: he did alot of OMGUS

[Nawa]

Here is example of readlist from S-FM Lottery:

Ah shit, i forgot to sort them again no matter, here you go

no full town or scum, just leans

town lean
PIayer
Scvmurderer
Stealthbomber16 (in answer to MM, this is based on D1, not D2)
MM

null
Hybrid
Exeter350

scum lean
Gyrlander
Nawa

Nawa's position has been updated. he has been upping his post count with useless posts, voting me for "pressure", AFTER i posted my reads and opinions, despite having others who have not contributed at all. While this alone is not really enough for Scum read, combined with my gut feeling, i would put a scum lean rather than read

[BoxerRebellion]

Townies:
Mesk514 - Confirmed vigilante no need for argument.
Marshmallow Marshall/Player - They provide enough deductive reasoning based on what they observe. I believe one of them is a Town Power Role.
Stealthbomber16 - His responses are too consistent towards the town efforts; however, his conclusions on who are the scums are very inaccurate.

Ghosts:
Otakudweeb69 - I already mentioned in my previous post about his lack of credibility on his findings in the night chat.
Spruance - Have not seen much out of him.

Unknown:
Scvmurderer - A lot of day chat flooding with no value of information.
Nawa - Seems to be enjoying himself too much.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Scvmurderer posted 108 posts so far.
I have posted 82 posts so far.
PIayer posted 38 posts so far.(surprise?)

You and SCV posted nothing very useful. PIayer's posts are more important than yours or Scv's for now. Your posts have no content.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Townies:
Mesk514 - Confirmed vigilante no need for argument.
Marshmallow Marshall/Player - They provide enough deductive reasoning based on what they observe. I believe one of them is a Town Power Role.
Stealthbomber16 - His responses are too consistent towards the town efforts; however, his conclusions on who are the scums are very inaccurate.

Ghosts:
Otakudweeb69 - I already mentioned in my previous post about his lack of credibility on his findings in the night chat.
Spruance - Have not seen much out of him.

Unknown:
Scvmurderer - A lot of day chat flooding with no value of information.
Nawa - Seems to be enjoying himself too much.

So I'm not the only one thinking PIayer looks like a TPR. Thanks for your readlist, Boxer. I am not agreeing with your Ghosts, because you simply forgot the existence of the Angel there... Anyway. I feel like your scums aren't scums and that you need further investigation. But hey, you won't get replaced :P

[Otakudweeb69]

Y'all can iso Spruance it's pretty quick

#118 One line, but one of the two contributions I could find on 23 posts
#128 just a bad, misleading thing to say imo, questioning host integrity so we don't focus on the actual game
#347 at first it just looked like random troll vote by bored citizen. Until this part. You appear trying to tell us you actually mean your trollvote, yet give ultra evasive/meaningless oneliner as only justification. Why a town would do that seriously?
#465 yet another misleading meta comment
#467 one line, 2nd/23 contribution I could see

@Spruance
That'll need to be answered

Only reason I don't vote you atm is we need more people to react (INSTEAD OF READING WHATEVER DEAD, STATIC, ETERNAL THING >_>), and also really don't know if I can believe Angel atm but there's still this possibility he just play badly and tell the truth. Don't have enough atm to discard this thought

@Otakudweeb69
Thought experiment: we're EoD and Mesk ask you to vote Spruance. SCV then me already parked on him earlier. What would you do in this situation and why?



ps: On the mod "HEY IM SURV" first line D1 was basically a meme in every game with neutrals. Of this meta I also remember a funny game, where one player did seriously claim town-aligned Survivor, did his best to be town, just to be turbolynched D1. He said "gg ez" during last words and flipped Jester like a boss. So, yeah. Evoking

Your thought experiment: Mesk is basically town confirmed at this point. But I would likely hesitate to side with my current scum reads in a lynch, especially on Spruance who is kind of neutral to me atm being one of the people the ghosts asked me to push. Therefore, I would likely not vote Spruance past L-2

[Otakudweeb69]

So I'm not the only one thinking PIayer looks like a TPR. Thanks for your readlist, Boxer. I am not agreeing with your Ghosts, because you simply forgot the existence of the Angel there... Anyway. I feel like your scums aren't scums and that you need further investigation. But hey, you won't get replaced :P

Lazy. Simply lazy. Still on that spruance push I see but you’ve at least dropped piayer now

[Otakudweeb69]

^ quoted the wrong one but you get the idea =_= boxers read list is lazy.

[Otakudweeb69]

For the record, NO. I believe boxer is LIKELY to be scum but he is in no way the ONLY suspect. All I know is that junior ghost was very silent, and senior ghost an initiative yet sporadic poster.

[Nawa]

For the record, NO. I believe boxer is LIKELY to be scum but he is in no way the ONLY suspect. All I know is that junior ghost was very silent, and senior ghost an initiative yet sporadic poster.

He is confirmed scum
He doesn't even defend