S-FM 292: ★ Silent Night ★ [14P]

[Huey The Long]

Did Caustic Claim List Maker? have i just completely not seen this?

[Light_Yagami]

Oh, a carol. LISTEN UP. Caroler puts up a list of three players, in which at least one is non-town (which means that there can be 2 towns and 1 neutral in the carol).
And a List-Maker picks two players to see if they are of the same alignment or not. There are no red checks in this game, excluding the Ornamentalist's power, which was not released, afaik.

The quote from Huey here is wrong in a very strange manner, too, because he excludes Blink or Stealth from being neutral (assuming there was indeed a carol with Huey, Blink and Stealth) without saying anything, but he makes sure to claim non-neutral for himself before.

If that info is true, the one I'm lynching in that pool is definetly Huey the Long.

So If Caustic Is Truthful And If Aamirus Is Truth Full Then Yeah Huey Ozy Scum Team?

[Huey The Long]

Oh, a carol. LISTEN UP. Caroler puts up a list of three players, in which at least one is non-town (which means that there can be 2 towns and 1 neutral in the carol).
And a List-Maker picks two players to see if they are of the same alignment or not. There are no red checks in this game, excluding the Ornamentalist's power, which was not released, afaik.

The quote from Huey here is wrong in a very strange manner, too, because he excludes Blink or Stealth from being neutral (assuming there was indeed a carol with Huey, Blink and Stealth) without saying anything, but he makes sure to claim non-neutral for himself before.

If that info is true, the one I'm lynching in that pool is definetly Huey the Long.

Do Neutrals show up as scum to a carol? i thought they didnt.

[Light_Yagami]

Did Caustic Claim List Maker? have i just completely not seen this?

Perhaps, You Are Just Not Looking Into His Posts Properly..

[DJarJar]

Did Caustic Claim List Maker? have i just completely not seen this?

He had a cryptic post which I read as “if ozy is indeed scum as I think, then Huey must be town”, which I thought was basically a list-maker reveal. But it could just be Caustic’s weird way of talking.

[Huey The Long]

Do Neutrals show up as scum to a carol? i thought they didnt.

Oh yeah it just says a non town player.

[DJarJar]

He was an Unknown Variable.
Perhaps, if my Analysis is accurate and you are the Parasite.
Then Huey is indeed a Benevolent Variable.

This post is what I’m talking about. He’s quoting/replying to ozy

[Huey The Long]

The only Neutral role Blink or Stealth could be is Lover and i dont think ive seen any indication of such from either. Neither has really protected somebody in much effect. I cant see either being lover tbqh.

[Huey The Long]

This post is what I’m talking about. He’s quoting/replying to ozy

Yeah i just read this as Caustics weird talking

[Marshmallow Marshall]

just finished stealth's ISO (didn't read day 2 really because i'm caught up for the most part)
and i think he's town - this post convinced me he was

but i just have one problem

@Stealthbomber16

how could u make this (glorious) post but then 180 and put MM in ur town lean

It's not a 180: believing that someone's play is wrong doesn't mean that you scumread them... That's basic mafia 101, come on.

Also note that I had replied to his post, explaining why I had switched my vote from Efe, which might have contributed to his read on me.
Another note : the glorious post wasn't even aimed directly at me, but at all the people who had unvoted Efe.

I think your attack in the last line of your post isn't valid here.

This doesn't apply to you, Chip, but it's related to your post : Why did the narrative suddenly switch from "Stealth is in the town core" to "Hey, Stealth must be scum" for quite a lot of people? That makes very little sense, and I think there was scum influence here.

[Solid D.]

Perhaps, You Are Just Not Looking Into His Posts Properly..

LOL

[Marshmallow Marshall]

So If Caustic Is Truthful And If Aamirus Is Truth Full Then Yeah Huey Ozy Scum Team?

Do Neutrals show up as scum to a carol? i thought they didnt.

They don't "show up" as anything; it's just a list, and at least one of the player in there is NON-TOWN. Neutrals are non-town. I literally reviewed the setup, soooo.... :P

[Huey The Long]

They don't "show up" as anything; it's just a list, and at least one of the player in there is NON-TOWN. Neutrals are non-town. I literally reviewed the setup, soooo.... :P

Yeah i had a quick reaaaaaaad. Still think the Scumteam is Stealth/Ozy/Light

[Marshmallow Marshall]

So If Caustic Is Truthful And If Aamirus Is Truth Full Then Yeah Huey Ozy Scum Team?

what? Can you stop confusing me please lol? You seem to be jumping to conclusions very hard (and strange conclusions, too).

[Ganelon]

yea it's different irl mafia when i can scream my argument at someone but when i have to rebuttal an articulate written essay i'm just like oof i aint that bright!

Same

[Marshmallow Marshall]

ah shit I've got some quality info for y'all
I HARDCLAIM GUARDIAN ANGEL.
ergo Kovath was 100% town

Mag, how does that "confirm" you as anything?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Mag, how does that "confirm" you as anything?

Confirm Kovath*

[Ganelon]

Where the fuck did Caustic claim List-Maker? Did he actually say that or is that just your interpretation

[Ganelon]

Mag, how does that "confirm" you as anything?

I spoke to Frinckles, Lovers action happens at the beginning of the night
had he been lover two people would’ve died

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Confirm Kovath*

Oh wait, I'm dumb. Double post for nothing. If you're angel, Kovath can't be it, and can't be lover either because he died alone. Just to make sure : @Frinckles Where's the Lover in the OoO?

[Ganelon]

Ah nvm I read the posts above got it, you just think he claimed ListMaker

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Where the fuck did Caustic claim List-Maker? Did he actually say that or is that just your interpretation

Hm, I fear it's another Light made-up thing lol

I spoke to Frinckles, Lovers action happens at the beginning of the night
had he been lover two people would’ve died

This must be my most horrible streak of useless posts. I even pinged the host...

[Ganelon]

The vote is a tie... when’s EoD?

[Frinckles]

Lovers/Heartbreakers ability happens at the beginning of OoO.

[Ganelon]

Btw Mm, did you pick up on my soft claim yesterday? I got the feeling you didn’t

[Solid D.]

We got ourselves a whole another day

[Solid D.]

1 day 1 hour 38 min tbe

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Btw Mm, did you pick up on my soft claim yesterday? I got the feeling you didn’t

You are correct, I didn't. It may or may not have something to do with the ± 2300 posts made in a day and a half

[Ganelon]

Ah perfect

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Oh, btw.

-vote Huey the Long

I don't know about the bunch of night actions that have been claimed, but Huey's super-incoherent post from D1, his defense of it... that's just scummy. If he was in a carol with Stealth and Blink, I'm definetly trusting him the least.

If someone could make a list of the claims and feedbacks, it would be greatly appreciated, and very helpful so that we can stop posting tons of stupid things.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Ah perfect

May I ask to see the softclaim now, though? :P

[Ganelon]

May I ask to see the softclaim now, though? :P

Gimme a min to dig it up

[Ganelon]

I don't think so, no.
As in, what does table tell you that discussion couldn't? I'd rather have someone who has their own opinion than someone who just looked at a table and went "ya I agree with it".
Not gonna lie I don't think it's useful.
Gonna go get something to eat soon, should I have:
Entrecot
Lasagna?

This is it

[Marshmallow Marshall]

It is terrifying how right you were.
After reading EoD1 - I found that Mag, Light, Korvath to be the 3 most townie players then and there.
With Efekannn02 flipping green, that means I was wrong about a minimum of 8 players assuming that those 4 are actually green.
I couldn't be any wronger.
Which means that, whoever the Mafia are, I'm in their pocket. Only exception is Huey.


Because I remembered something wrong, I ISO'ed Aamirus again:
Before - I wanted to make a case against her
After - Close to lock town now.


This is honestly as far as my N1 thought's went.


Ohh, and also:

-vote Huey The Long

Your post:didn't age well.

Rofl, Wolfy. That guy is a very strange God of Mafia. Good memories

Also, I dare to think that the Angel claim would have been counterclaimed if it wasn't real, so I trust Magoroth's claim 100%. That means you weren't 100% wrong, eh? Plus, Huey is probably scum.

I do agree that "Efe is town, probably citizen so lynching him is fine" isn't exactly the most towny post in the universe.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

This is it

Oh lol, I had to go when I read that. I thought it was just a shitpost XD

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I also re-read the game yesterday and still feel about the same as I currently do about Ozy, My read on you will probably hinge on what kind of content you produce today tbh. I could see you being on a team with Mag, because when we were going back and forth at the start of the game Mag seemed to garner a scum read on myself during that time. It definitely felt off to me, and I could see him trying to shade me to take some pressure off of you and then thrust upon me.

That feels too planned, too agenda-y to me. I don't like this at all. + scumpoints to blink

[Chip Skylark]

Rofl, Wolfy. That guy is a very strange God of Mafia. Good memories

Also, I dare to think that the Angel claim would have been counterclaimed if it wasn't real, so I trust Magoroth's claim 100%. That means you weren't 100% wrong, eh? Plus, Huey is probably scum.

I do agree that "Efe is town, probably citizen so lynching him is fine" isn't exactly the most towny post in the universe.

I actually jumped back to that quote, Ozy deleted everything else in that post
It still wasn't good of Huey to say BUT Huey was NOT on that Efe train at all, he was voting light, and in the rest of his ISO he states that he thinks Efe is town

Ozy has a big red paintbrush for Huey

[Marshmallow Marshall]

how am I full of shit.

YOU'RE doing it again too, where did I say that you tried to lynch me? That's a lie. That is just what kenny does every time he's scum, he makes posts that you did this and you and that and that shit never even fucking happened.

You were saying I was being manipulative and cautious that's contradicting pieces of shade bro.

Umm, I wonder if that's not more hang-worthy than Huey now... this line is just terrible, Blink was definetly being openly manipulative, and he hasn't charged into people very much this game, while appearing aggressive on tone. Plus, it's not contradicting itself at all.

Plus, "Give me one read you've had this game" "You're scum"

[Light_Yagami]

They don't "show up" as anything; it's just a list, and at least one of the player in there is NON-TOWN. Neutrals are non-town. I literally reviewed the setup, soooo.... :P

OMG Im Talking List Maker And Carol Combo Identifies Huey As Basically Confirmed Scum.. Im Talking Arrmirus Carol Info And If Caustic Is List Maker.. That Makes OzyWho And Whoever He Says His Second Id Check Scum.. So Im Waiting On Caustic To Verify Some Information At This Point..

[Marshmallow Marshall]

I actually jumped back to that quote, Ozy deleted everything else in that post
It still wasn't good of Huey to say BUT Huey was NOT on that Efe train at all, he was voting light, and in the rest of his ISO he states that he thinks Efe is town

Ozy has a big red paintbrush for Huey

I do that all the time as town though. Outlining a scummy sentence is normal...?

The rest of his ISO states that he thinks Efe is citizen, but he could be TPR, but he could also be scum maybe so we should stop paying attention to him, but not really. So no, not really lol.

[Light_Yagami]

Where the fuck did Caustic claim List-Maker? Did he actually say that or is that just your interpretation

Interpretation..

[Marshmallow Marshall]

OMG Im Talking List Maker And Carol Combo Identifies Huey As Basically Confirmed Scum.. Im Talking Arrmirus Carol Info And If Caustic Is List Maker.. That Makes OzyWho And Whoever He Says His Second Id Check Scum.. So Im Waiting On Caustic To Verify Some Information At This Point..

Is it because I'm dumb, or because this makes no sense? Caroler is literally randomness, Huey could be anything in theory because none of the other people in the carol are mechanically confirmed town. Stealth is locktown to me, though, so it only leaves Blink and Huey; nevertheless, @Caustic doesn't seem to have claimed List-Maker anywhere.

[Light_Yagami]

Kinda Like I Had The Interpretation That You Were Angel Day 1..

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Also, Received No Feed Back.. And The Fact That Blinkskater Is Still Alive Day 2 Is A Scum Tell.. If He Makes It Past N1 Ever... He Is Scum...

Unless We Have A Solid Lead This Is Where My Vote Will Remain Likely For The Majority Of The Day...

-vote blinkskater

-vote Blinkskater

I think I'm actually going to sheep Light's point here... this sentence is true.

[Light_Yagami]

Does, This Mean If Mag Is Angel We Have To Put Him On Top Of The Tree After We Decorate It?

[blinkskater]

outta work not caught up but wasabi

[blinkskater]

-vote Blinkskater

I think I'm actually going to sheep Light's point here... this sentence is true.

lol, so me being alive out weighs any type of play that scum would make to leave me alive?

and also out weighs all of the content and effort i have been putting in to solve this game?

[Chip Skylark]

I do that all the time as town though. Outlining a scummy sentence is normal...?

The rest of his ISO states that he thinks Efe is citizen, but he could be TPR, but he could also be scum maybe so we should stop paying attention to him, but not really. So no, not really lol.

No he didn't say he was scum so No NoT ReALLy

[blinkskater]

has huey even checked in at all? he isn't even voting anyone that's not a good look imo

[Light_Yagami]

outta work not caught up but wasabi

U Better Be Drinking If Ur Not Ill be Disappointed In Ya..lol