CrazyPants: 1-S2-1-8638895, Kitten: 1-S2-1-2200508, donktheclown: 1-S2-1-510549, and others

[UrkiN]

Account Name: CrazyPants
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8638895
In-Game Name: ISIS HITLER AIDS (hotkey CTRL + 4)

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing
_________________________________________
Account Name: Kitten
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8638895
In-Game Name: Gurlaug (hotkey 7)

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing
_________________________________________
Account Name: donktheclown
Account ID: 1-S2-1-510549
In-Game Name: Aronne De Niro (hotkey CTRL + 3)

Crimes Committed: Rolequitting
_________________________________________
Account Name: Derick
Account ID: 1-S2-1-4023475
In-Game Name: Ercole Gallo (hotkey 5)

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing
_________________________________________
Account Name: Fluffy
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2029049
In-Game Name: Pietro (hotkey 2)

Crimes Committed: AFK
_________________________________________
Account Name: ProstaPesnya
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8610676
In-Game Name: Aronne Pacino (hotkey CTRL + 2)

Crimes Committed: AFK
_________________________________________
Your Account Name: UrkiN
Summary: Setup is standard 9-3-3. Night 1 GF (ProstaPesnya) afk day 2 arsonist (donktheclown) leaves game, night 2 GF (still afk, mafia suggests) dies to bg, day 3 disguiser (Fluffy) has a heart attack and consort (Derick) reacts by saying he will suicide (understandable?) and is instead lynched, day 4 investigator (CrazyPants) gamethrows, day 5 veteran (Kitten) gamethrows, witch is eventually lynched and town wins.

I wouldn't normally report these sorts of offenses but there were so many that game was ruined as a result. Will be interesting to see what punishments you're going to dish out.

-Mafia- (402).SC2Replay

[Helz]

1-S2-1-8638895 will be perma-banned

This replay still needs reviewed for the other players reported

[Omegasaur]

ID Verification:
CrazyPants: Correct. 1-S2-1-8638895 (already received permaban; will not be included in this writeup)
Kitten: Correct. 1-S2-1-2200508
donktheclown: Correct. 1-S2-1-510549
Derick: Correct. 1-S2-1-4023475
Fluffy: Correct. 1-S2-1-317033
ProstaPesnya: Correct. 1-S2-1-8610676

Respective Hotkeys
Kitten: 7
donktheclown: ctrl 3
Derick: 5
Fluffy: 2
ProstaPesnya: ctrl 2

Was the game result altered?
Yes. These players' actions created a chaotic game that wasn't much fun for anyone involved.

Summary
Kitten chooses the name Gurlaug and is a Veteran in slot #6.
Donktheclown is given the name Aronne de Niro and is an Arsonist in slot #9.
Derick is given the name Ercole Gallo and is a Consort in slot #7.
Fluffy is given the name Pietro and is a Disguiser in slot #3.
ProstaPesnya is given the name Aronne Pacino and is a Godfather in slot #2.

This setup skips Day 1. The game begins on Night 1.

Night 1:
#6 alerts.
#9 douses #8.
#7 does not choose to roleblock anyone. Someone attempts to roleblock him, but it is averted.
#3 does not steal anyone's identity.
#2 does not choose to attack anyone.

Day 2:
#6 mostly plays normally. He uses advanced HTML code in his last will.
#9 leaves halfway through Day 2. This doesn't appear to be a rolequit, given that he did his action on the first night.
#7 writes a last will at the very beginning of the day saying that he was roleblocked. This implies that he was not AFK during Night 1, and he intentionally chose not to roleblock anyone.
#3 does not chat or vote.
#2 does not chat or vote.

Night 2:
#6 alerts.
#7 chooses to roleblock #15, and uses -target to make #2 attack #11.
#3 does not choose to steal anyone's identity.
#2 does not choose to attack anyone, but is sent to attack #11. #2 is killed by a Bodyguard.

Day 3:
#6 plays normally.
#7 plays normally for the first minute or so. When he sees that #3 is having a heart attack, #7 says "ALRIGHT" "I QUIT" "SUICIDING TONIGHT". #7 is put up for trial. He doesn't give a defense and is lynched.
#3 begins to receive AFK warnings. He has a heart attack in the middle of the day.

Night 3:
#6 alerts.

Day 4:
#12 reveals himself as the Mayor. #6 does not PM a role claim to #12.

Night 4:
#6 doesn't alert.

Day 5:
#12 still doesn't know #6's role. #6 is put up for a trial and says:
"I have a hat."
"Hats make people innocent."
"Common Knowledge people."
#6 is lynched.

The game ends on Day 8 with a town victory.

Kitten (#6) is clearly a smurf account. Kitten only has a total of 3 games played, but seems to know each role works and uses complex color formats in last wills. Kitten made no attempt to support his fellow town members and did not cooperate when the Mayor put him up for trial. It is likely that this account is used by a player whose main account was banned for misbehavior.

Donktheclown (#9) quit on Day 2, more than a minute after receiving the role Arsonist. He doused someone on night 1. This is not consistent with rolequitting, and it is more likely that donktheclown had a real-life reason for leaving the game suddenly. He did not encourage other players to leave, so it is not a leave-train.

Derick (#7) surrendered after both of his allies died. This is acceptable behavior as described in this post about when a player can surrender. As the last living member of the Mafia, Derick arguably had a right to surrender on behalf of his entire team. Since his teammates weren't cooperating with him at all, I consider this to be a legitimate choice. Neither of those players reported this replay, so they do not seem to be upset that Derick surrendered.

Fluffy (#3) is AFK until day 3 when he dies of a heart attack.

ProstaPesnya (#2) is AFK until night 2 when he dies to a Bodyguard.

Player Offenses
Kitten: Smurfing
donktheclown: None
Derick: None
Fluffy: None
ProstaPesnya: None

Previous Offenses
Kitten: None
donktheclown: None
Derick: Griefing (On Hold)
Fluffy: None
ProstaPesnya: None

Recommended Action
Kitten: Smurfban
donktheclown: None
Derick: None
Fluffy: None
ProstaPesnya: None

Additional Notes
Thank you for your effort to keep the game clean!

[UrkiN]

Derick (#7) surrendered after both of his allies died. This is acceptable behavior as described in this post about when a player can surrender. As the last living member of the Mafia, Derick arguably had a right to surrender on behalf of his entire team. Since his teammates weren't cooperating with him at all, I consider this to be a legitimate choice. Neither of those players reported this replay, so they do not seem to be upset that Derick surrendered.

It was somewhat sad for the witch who held out until day 8, but I'm not sure if lone mafioso and witch had a viable chance of winning at that point anyway.

Thank you for your effort to keep the game clean!

[Omegasaur]

The Mafia does not have an obligation to help the Witch and vice versa. They are not on the same "team", so to speak, so it's not against the rules for the Mafia to make a choice that hurts the Witch.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-2200508: Smurfban