Why do they do this?

[TheDarkestLight]

(This has nothing to do with mechanics)
Like in ties, MM vs SK, why does the MM win and the SK lose? Why not have an epic battle until the end? Does the SK just hate MMs so much that he kills himself when hes left alone with them? Why doesn't the Mafia just pull out their guns in the middle of a trial and shoot everyone? Why would the last Mafia lose vs a lowly Citizen? Did he get mad that he couldn't kill a lowly little wimp that he commits ritualistic suicide?

Why does the Town have to meet at day and not night and have the actions done during the day? Why does a Mafioso/Vig/other nonimmune killing role still kill when he dies? So he gets stabbed by a Serial Killer, and although hes about to die he decides to get up and go kill someone else?

Why can't the Doctor heal himself? He gets shot up a few times and decides to go heal someone else thinking "Clearly I can't heal myself."

Is the Town really the evil ones? Because after all if they get mad at the Mafia for killing people why do they let Vigilantes for killing people? When the Masons brutally murder members of another faith in genocide the Town lynches the Cult despite the first amendment.

Why does the Town lynch instead of put people in Jail permanently?

These are irrelevant questions that need to be answered.

[Mugy]

(This has nothing to do with mechanics)
Like in ties, MM vs SK, why does the MM win and the SK lose? Why not have an epic battle until the end? Does the SK just hate MMs so much that he kills himself when hes left alone with them? Why doesn't the Mafia just pull out their guns in the middle of a trial and shoot everyone? Why would the last Mafia lose vs a lowly Citizen? Did he get mad that he couldn't kill a lowly little wimp that he commits ritualistic suicide?

Why does the Town have to meet at day and not night and have the actions done during the day? Why does a Mafioso/Vig/other nonimmune killing role still kill when he dies? So he gets stabbed by a Serial Killer, and although hes about to die he decides to get up and go kill someone else?

Why can't the Doctor heal himself? He gets shot up a few times and decides to go heal someone else thinking "Clearly I can't heal myself."

Is the Town really the evil ones? Because after all if they get mad at the Mafia for killing people why do they let Vigilantes for killing people? When the Masons brutally murder members of another faith in genocide the Town lynches the Cult despite the first amendment.

Why does the Town lynch instead of put people in Jail permanently?

These are irrelevant questions that need to be answered.

To prevent 100000000 lines of error codes.

[creedkingsx]

(This has nothing to do with mechanics)
Like in ties, MM vs SK, why does the MM win and the SK lose? Why not have an epic battle until the end? Does the SK just hate MMs so much that he kills himself when hes left alone with them? Why doesn't the Mafia just pull out their guns in the middle of a trial and shoot everyone? Why would the last Mafia lose vs a lowly Citizen? Did he get mad that he couldn't kill a lowly little wimp that he commits ritualistic suicide?

MM has guns, SK has a knife.
Everyone else would pull out their guns and shoot the Mafia.
Citizen has the attack of Last Resort

Why does the Town have to meet at day and not night and have the actions done during the day? Why does a Mafioso/Vig/other nonimmune killing role still kill when he dies? So he gets stabbed by a Serial Killer, and although hes about to die he decides to get up and go kill someone else?

Niggas like sleep.
they shoot their guns while falling to their death and bullets travel through walls and are extremely accurate.

Why can't the Doctor heal himself? He gets shot up a few times and decides to go heal someone else thinking "Clearly I can't heal myself."

Have you ever tried to clean a bullet hole in your back by yourself?

Is the Town really the evil ones? Because after all if they get mad at the Mafia for killing people why do they let Vigilantes for killing people? When the Masons brutally murder members of another faith in genocide the Town lynches the Cult despite the first amendment.

Mafia always strikes first blood.
Masons are not people of faith. Cult seek to destroy all, Masons seek companionship with the town.

Why does the Town lynch instead of put people in Jail permanently?

Legally, you can only hold for 24 hours. :o

[TheDarkestLight]

MM has guns, SK has a knife.

So does the GF.

[MrMostache]

The Gf is a great leader who can use a gun, but he does not have the required assasination and stealth skills of an SK.
Even though MM has the same killing skill as an SK, he still possesses a great selection of weapos appropriate for each time and place.
The Arsonist (in case you want to bring him in) is the master of killing people without being there, so he would win all defaults.

[Ash]

darkestlight, i hope you realize that this is a game to scumhunt. it's not a game based on realistic logic. realistically, a mafia would kill more than 1 member at night.

[creedkingsx]

So does the GF.

Not relevant to the question asked. :P

[TheDarkestLight]

darkestlight, i hope you realize that this is a game to scumhunt. it's not a game based on realistic logic. realistically, a mafia would kill more than 1 member at night.

I know that. Also they can kill more than once a night. Its called a Disguiser.

This game would be far to imbalanced if it was realistic.

[Ash]

I know that. Also they can kill more than once a night. Its called a Disguiser.

This game would be far to imbalanced if it was realistic.

that was an exception, but yes. kind of.
IRL you would have a badass swat team to fight the mafia (lol)

[TheDarkestLight]

that was an exception, but yes. kind of.
IRL you would have a badass swat team to fight the mafia (lol)

Thats an idea for a role!
First the Vigilante, the the Jailor, and then the Veteran! These roles have brought justice -and failure- to the town, and now we give you the SWAT! He is invulnerable at night and immune to roleblockings and ignores invulnerability. He is immune to Veteran and Bodyguard attacks and bypasses Doctor heals. So now the Town kills -most of which are on allies- go up! Have fun!

Mafia IRL would be retarded as hell.

[ttam]

MM has a chainsaw, all your arguments are invalid.

[RLVG]

MM has a chainsaw, all your arguments are invalid.

It's noisy and melee range. Anyone can hear the MM come and it takes a few moments to get the chainsaw starting.

The most deadly role would be one that has a .50 caliber sniper riffle and suppressed for noise.

[ttam]

It's noisy and melee range. Anyone can hear the MM come and it takes a few moments to get the chainsaw starting.

The most deadly role would be one that has a .50 caliber sniper riffle and suppressed for noise.

He has more than a chainsaw if you listen closely he also has a silenced pistol similar to a disguiser. He's well equipped for every scenario unlike the trial-deathsequence sniper who misses half the time this guy is deadly and unforgiving. But again. Chainsaw > All.

[RLVG]

He has more than a chainsaw if you listen closely he also has a silenced pistol similar to a disguiser. He's well equipped for every scenario unlike the trial-deathsequence sniper who misses half the time this guy is deadly and unforgiving. But again. Chainsaw > All.

The Sniper ain't an elite squad member if he misses.
As for the silenced pistol, it's most likely it uses round ammo instead of tipped.

And every situation you say? What about Ze Bombé?




About sniper, do you know what damage a tipped .50 caliber can do?
If shot correctly, it may actually explode the head to thousand pieces like in fallout.

It also depends on Armor Pierce to pierce layers of armor or walls / Hollow Points for unarmored targets, highly prefferably with the ability for the bullet to explode to thousand fragments upon impact.

It's easier to suppress a sniper rifle too, due to the range you can shoot at - becoming almost completely undetected.

[Damus_Graves]

I would step in here and say only this. You cannot hope to understand the game of mafia. Elixir himself went insane trying. Elixir. Himself.

[ttam]

Stuff that doesn't really matter***

Chainsaw

[RLVG]

Chainsaw

Spoiler : This is what you see with chainsaws :

Copied from some unholy site :

"While cool, there are good reasons the chainsaw is not exactly the first choice among melee weapons in the real world; chainsaws are heavy and hard to swing with any degree of finesse, have poor reach compared to their weight, require fuel or an external power source, make a lot of noise, and will tear through the person wielding them just as cheerfully as the intended victim."

[ttam]

back to the op.

MM > SK because Chainsaw.

Town meets during the day because Darkness is scurry

The mafioso/vigi/other nonimmune killing role did their deeds of the night prior to being brutally murdered, so they shot little Timmy and were having a little party at their joint when a guy with a knife came in and stabbed them in the throat.

The doctor can't heal himself becuase his religion is against masturbation.

The town have a misguided moral compass. They dislike the Vigilante but he is the hero they deserve, not the one they want. The cult are the taliban/al qaeda.

CAPITAL PUNISHMENT MOTHAFUCKA


/thread chainsaw

[RLVG]

back to the op.

MM > SK because Chainsaw.


/thread chainsaw

A knife is quicker and smaller then a chainsaw, allowing quick combat while less weight to be able to dodge. A knife may also be thrown at the target, but it requires extreme precision and sometimes luck. The one with the chainsaw will be relatively slow, so the SK can run away.

[ttam]

A knife is quicker and smaller then a chainsaw, allowing quick combat while less weight to be able to dodge. A knife may also be thrown at the target, but it requires extreme precision and sometimes luck. The one with the chainsaw will be relatively slow, so the SK can run away.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0-bZMb620c

[RLVG]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0-bZMb620c

What the heck did I just see?

Anyway, if you have a chainsaw on a freaking rope - just throw random objects like books or et cetera to disbalance the swinging making the chainsaw loose Momentum and crash on to the user.

[ttam]

You'd be surprised how proficient rednecks are in the art of chainsaw swinging mass murderering. a mere book will not derail them. Not to mention serial killers don't use books, unless a book is their calling card in which case I bet it's something lame like Twilight or 50 shades of grey. Mass Murderers read kickass books like... <insert kickass book title here>

[Ash]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T0-bZMb620c

that's just dumb... don't try that

[cookies4you]

Meanwhile, the Citizen with a Shotgun manages to one-shot the Godfather.

[TheDarkestLight]

Meanwhile, the Citizen with a Shotgun manages to one-shot the Godfather.

No no no, the GF has a bullet proof vest that never fails and can stop knives and chainsaws. Yet even though he can survive the SK at night, he can't seem to survive in the tie. So that means it ends in an eternal battle which the SK wanted because most of the Town is going to get killed in the crossfire -The random AI you see during the day that don't die- and he will have succeeded in his goal. While the Mafia's goal wasn't to kill anyone, yet to be the dominant group in the Town and have no one who can stop them, they only killed everyone else because they were the threat. The Arson beats the MM because the MM can't see his art while everyone is turned to ashes so he commits suicide because his art is ruined. The MM beats the SK because the SK tears his victims apart, doing the MM's job of entrail spilling himself, so despite it saying the MM wins, the SK loses because all the guts -what he eats for dinner- are in display cases for the MM's pleasure, so the SK starves. The Arson beats the SK -except with the option for SK to win on- because the SK can't eat ashes. The Mafia beat the Cult because although the Cult want to control the town also, they can't kill the Mafia or recruit them. Family before Faith ftw.

Fire>Everything else you say.
Clearly the Arsonist is the most badass Neutral Killer.

[Jim]

I think the deadliest is Spy, he is next to you at night and you don't even know it, give him some piano wire and he is an assassin.

[TheDarkestLight]

I think the deadliest is Spy, he is next to you at night and you don't even know it, give him some piano wire and he is an assassin.

No no no. He isn't right next to you, other wise he would know who you are. He just has a listening device in the Mafia's garage and listens in on a Radio. Even though he knows if the Mafia is going to kill him though, he clearly doesn't think its a good idea to run.

[ttam]

The SK is NOT a cannibal, he doesn't live off people's guts. He merely kills them to gain infamy. geez

Also Arson wins over MM because his chainsaw is gas powered and the Arson has a lighter.

[TheDarkestLight]

Actually, the SK is a cannibal. Its a common fact.

[Ash]

Actually, the SK is a cannibal. Its a common fact.

not the zodiac killer!

[cookies4you]

I think the deadliest is Spy, he is next to you at night and you don't even know it, give him some piano wire and he is an assassin.

Best post ever 2013.

[TheDarkestLight]

Best post ever 2013.

This will most likely change because of how early it was in the year.