Quote Originally Posted by naz View Post
-vote aamirus
hes literally claiming a guaranteed role lol
As yzb said, there can be 2, 3, or even 4 sheriffs if I’m scum so I don’t understand why you want a counterclaim. It wouldn’t guarantee for anybody else here that Voss is scum so it’d be a dumb way to get night killed for nothing.

I think the better question to ask is if I’m scum, why wouldn’t I counterclaim as sheriff (the confirmed role) rather than claim detective? What would be the positives of me claiming detective instead?

And I really wish you would read the setup properly. It clearly states a 12% chance of zero town powers besides the confirmed ones versus 88% chance of 1 or more...