Kelden: 1-S2-1-362622

[Etheopian]

To whom it may concern,

Please consider reviewing my report regarding the player below.

Account Name: Kelden
Account ID: 1-S2-1-362622

Crimes Committed: Gamethrowing

Summary:

Random shooting vigi costs town the game.

Kelden roles vigi in slot 5 and is silent and performs no actions until the last 2 days of the game. On night 4 the player decides to shoot a confirmed town to "confirm himself" as vigi. Unsurprisingly, town goes on to lose the game after they lynch wrong the next day.

The player he killed was confirmed lookout and would have found the serial killer that night, had he been alive. The game was thrown and the win was handed to SK, although the jester went on to win the game alone. The game result was undeniably altered because of this vigi's action.

kelden.SC2Replay

Please consider reviewing the information and determining if this is in violation of the rules. Thank you.

[DJarJar]

ID Verification:
Kelden: 1-S2-1-362622 Correct

Players Added to Report:

Hotkeys
Kelden: 6

Summary
Kelden chooses the name Sacrilege (in rainbow letters) and roles Vigilante in slot 5.

D1: he says "I AM YOUR RELIGION"

N1: he posts the lw "YOU WILL PAY FOR YOUR SINS MORTAL"
Then he clicks on somebody to shoot and gets the message about needing to find his gun first since vigis can't shoot n1.
Changes his lw to "..... SACRILEGE"

D2: mayor reveals and kelden pms him "TELL ME WHO HAS SINNED FOR I AM VIGILANTE"
Near the end of the day mayor pms him to shoot 7 who claimed bg.

N2: he shoots 7 as the mayor asked. 7 flips bg.

D3: he pms the mayor "I KNEW I SHOULDNT HAVE LISTENED TO YOU"

N3: changes lw to ".... SACRILEGE, told mayor to send prot role to him, and one to me, instead he wants me to blast em; OUR MAYOR IS A FALSE GOD"
shoots nobody

D4: he pms the mayor a lot asking him to send 1 prot to him and send another to the mayor. Near the end of the day the mayor pms him the roleclaims of all the living players: 1: sheriff 2: escort 14: surv 15: escort 6: lookout

N4: he scrolls through the log a bit. Specifically he looks at who voted up 8 (Dragon Head lynched d3). I guess he does not realize that all 3 triad are already dead... He chooses to shoot 6 (a player that didn't vote up who flips Lookout. 6 was technically essentially confirmed in that on D2 he claimed Lookout n1: 5 vb 7, and 7 has since died and been revealed to be a bg that did indeed visit 5 n1. However this is easy to miss and I think from what Kelden is looking at in the log that he genuinely believed this was a good kill choice.

D5: The mayor is dead. Kelden takes over as the confirmed vigi. 2 (escort) claims that 1 (jester) is RB immune. 15 (escort) claims 2 is RB immune. 14 (SK) claims survivor.

Since 15 (escort) went to RB 2 (escort), 2 received the message at night saying somebody tried to RB him but he turned them away. He must have misread this message and assumed his target (1, a jester) was RB immune. This confusion causes nobody to be able to solve the game and ultimately 15 (escort) gets lynched.

N5: Kelden leaves the lw "2 pays for his crimes against the town, even though 14 is SK, I ant kill"
He chooses to shoot 2. The sk also hits 2.

D6: Kelden and the SK both agree to guilty the jester. The SK then kills kelden the next night whilst suiciding from the jester lynch, which results in jester win screen.

Was the game result altered?
No. If kelden didn't shoot 2 then the result would have been the same since the SK had 2 as his target anyway.

Player Offenses
Kelden: reactionary gamethrowing

Previous Offenses
Kelden: griefing WL x2

Recommended Action
Kelden: WL x1

Additional Notes
Kelden was playing to win until night 5. He made some mistakes before that point for sure, but there was no bad intent as far as I can see. After 2's mistaken claim about 1 being NI, kelden chose to shoot a confirmed escort out of spite. The offense itself is pretty minor since the SK was going to kill 2 that night anyway, however, it is still gamethrowing to do this since Kelden doesn't know that and the town could have still feasibly won (if for example the SK went to kill 1 who was a jester).

Thanks for your report!

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-362622: 1x WL