{Watch List} IMPOLEXG: 1-S2-1-10186526
Register

User Tag List

Results 1 to 2 of 2
  1. ISO #1

  2. ISO #2

    Re: Mayor Threw

    SC ID VERIFICATION
    1-S2-1-10186526 is Correct.


    Respective Hotkey:

    5

    Previous Offenses:

    No

    Player Offenses:

    IGNORE.

    Key Points:
    Players in question:

    IMIPOLEXG MAYOR 4.

    Game:


    Setup: IMIPOLEXG is a new player.
    Names: IMIPOLEXG registers his name.
    Roles: None.
    D1: Nothing to note.
    N1: 4(MAYOR) is not entitled to a night action.
    D2: 6(SHERIFF) is dead from VETERAN. 13 reveals 1 as VETERAN. No lynch. 4 votes for 15.
    N2: 4 does nothing, not even update his LW.
    D3: 10(JAILOR) and 15(JESTER) are dead. 12 is hung with 4 voting to lynch him.
    N3: Nothing from 4.
    D4: 13(DOCTOR) is dead. 4 reveals as MAYOR, initiating a wave of PMs. 11 AFKs out. 5(AGENT) is hung, with a lynchvote from 4. 5 reveals that 9 is the last mafia, which is correct; this is gamethrowing.
    N4: 5 fails to update his LW.
    D5: 11(JAILOR) is dead from mafia. 7(ESCORT) and 14(SHERIFF) are also dead from VETERAN. 6 players alive, 2 town, one Mafia, 3 neutral. The EXECUTIONER at 6 has his target lynched but must survive. 4 gets an AFK warning but comes back. He tries to hang 1, who is fairly obvious VETERAN, but 5-1 sees the VETERAN killed.
    N5: 4 does nothing.
    D6: 2 calls for a lynch on 6, and mayor has vote majority. He puts 6 on trial and 6 gets his neck stretched 4-1.
    N6: 4 does nothing. Meanwhile the ARSONIST fires off and 4 is killed.
    D7: 4 and 3(JESTER) are dead. The ARSONIST wins tiebreak with MAFIOSO.

    Was the game result altered?
    If there was intent, absolutely. But I don't think there was intent. Furthermore, only the VETERAN lynch would be considered punishable.


    Additional offenses or players found in replay?

    Aleksei, 1-S2-1-10005080, AGENT 5 throws his Mafiabuddy under the bus during his execution. He has an on Hold already, so this is a 2X WL

    Punishment:

    IMIPOLEXG: INNOCENT
    1-S2-1-10005080: 2x WL

    Additional Notes:
    I'm not sure there was intent here, which is the core thing we punish. He absolutely made poor lynch choices, which ultimately cost town the game, but it's not gamethrowing to lynch a neutral(even if he is supporting you), and most of our gamethrowers will taunt in some way, which he didn't. Being bad at the game, especially when he's possibly never played before by his not having a bank, is not a crime.

    Meanwhile, the AGENT did throw his buddy under the bus and while it wasn't acted on, and Mafia didn't win the game, he did try to throw.

    Thank you for the report!
    Last edited by Arrow; November 25th, 2018 at 05:52 AM.

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •