Xandithon: 1-S2-1-7694907, Phoenix: 1-S2-1-2932178

[Kazansky]

Account Name: Xandithon
Account ID: 1-S2-1-7694907
In-Game Name: Shrek

Account Name: Phoenix
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2932178
In-Game Name: Huge for Juge

Crimes Committed: Intentional Gamethrowing

Your Account Name: Kazansky
Summary:
These are not new players. They are smurf accounts. The things they do and say make it clear to me that they're not new.

I ( # 15, name is Amnesiac) got Mason Leader (only 5% chance this save) and somehow managed to kill the witch doctor (also only 5% chance) n1. I targeted 13 (the witch doctor) n1 only because of his ridiculous name, and killed him. I also announced it immediately at the start of d2, before deaths were revealed.
This should have been enough to confirm me for everyone.
A bunch of townies simply refused to cooperate, but Xandithon and Phoenix took it much further than that. They ignored obvious evidence that I was ML, both of them continuously questioned everything I was saying, 5 voted to trial me immediately on d2, 9 investigated me, withheld his findings for a day, asked why I wasn't dead yet if I was ML, then spammed that I committed murder on d4 before joining 5 and the mafia to lynch me
voted with the mafia in a 4 townie v 3 mafia setting, to lynch me (the confirmed mason leader).

Also, don't forget to watch death chat

A slightly more specific summary:
5 immediately beings voting me d2, despite me being confirmed ML.
9 investigates me n2 and sees that I have all the crimes an ML who killed has.
He withholds this information d3.
Then he says "hey 15 if your mason leader why u not dead" - why is a new player asking this question?
He investigates 8 n3.
Then out of no where on d4, he starts spamming "GUYS IM INVESTIGATOR 15 COMMITTED MURDER"
This sequence of decisions on his part says to me that he isn't a new player, he's a smurf trying to intentionally throw games, just like 5 is.

Also note that d4 # 5 says " WD killed himself "shot himself" ".
This confirms 5 as not a new player, but a smurf trying to intentionally throw games.

It's coordinated gamethrowing by 5 and 9, the only saving grace of this is that 5 is a rather useless role. If 5 or 9 were vigi, I'm sure they would've shot me.

[Nighthawk]

ID Verification:
Xandithon: 1-S2-1-7694907 - Correct
Phoenix: 1-S2-1-2932178 - Correct


Players Added to Report:



Hotkeys
Xandithon: E
Phoenix: Ctrl+6


Summary
Both Xandithon and Phoenix are announced as new players.
Phoenix receives the Battle.net name prompt and enters Phoenix.

Xandithon chooses the name "Shrek" and roles Investigator in slot #9.
Phoenix chooses the name "Hugs for Jugs" ands roles Coroner in slot #5.

Day 1
Normal

Night 1
#9 chooses to investigate #13, get a result of no crimes.
#5 does nothing but enter a LW "All I do, I do, for Titties."
#7 is killed by a Mass Murderer (Investigator).
#4 is killed in a shootout (???").
#6 dies from suicide (Bus Driver).
#12 is killed by a Mass Murderer (Amnesiac).
#13 is bludgeoned by a Mason Leader (Witch Doctor).

Day 2
#15 immediately claim to have killed #13, before #13 is even shown as dead.
Other players announced that #15 is confirmed.
#8 PMs #15 a role and LW.
#15 asks for roles and LW.
#9 votes for #15, followed immediately by #5.
Players question the votes on #15.
#1 votes for #9.
#9 changes his vote to #5.
#11 and #14 vote for #9.
#2 PMs #15 a role and LW.
#8 and #15 vote for #9.
#14 PMs #15 a role.
No one is voted to trial.

Night 2
#9 chooses to investigate #15, then changes to #11, than back to #15; finds crimes of Soliciting, Trespassing, and Murder.
#5 performs an autopsy on #4, finds the role of Bodyguard.
#10 quits.
#10 dies from suicide (???).

Day 3
#15 claims #3 is MM after receiving PM from #8, and says to vote #3.
#5 does not share info about #4.
#3 is voted to trial and found guilty 2-6 and lynched (Mass Murderer). #1 and #9 were the innocent votes.

Night 3
#5 chooses to autopsy #10; finds he was a Vigilante.
#9 chooses to investigate #8; finds a crime of Trespassing.
#11 is killed by the Mafia (Bodyguard).

Day 4
#15 says he thinks the WD healed the GF on N1.
#5 says the WD killed himself.
#15 says that he killed the WD.
#9 says that #15 has Murder.
#1 says he is Sheriff and #5 is Mafia.
#5 again says that the WD killed himself.
#15 is voted to trial and found guilty 1-5 (Mason Leader). #8 was the only innocent vote.

Night 4
#8 quits.
#5 is killed by the Mafia (Coroner).
#8 dies from suicide (Spy).

Day 5
#9 is lynched (Investigator).

The game ends on Day 5 with a Mafia victory.


Was the game result altered?
Yes.


Player Offenses
Xandithon: Game Throwing, Skyping
Phoenix: Game Throwing, Skyping


Previous Offenses
Xandithon: None
Phoenix: None


Recommended Action
Xandithon: Watch List x2
Phoenix: Watch List x2


Additional Notes
These players clearly aren't entirely new, but there's no reason to think they are smurfing. Players can appear as new for many reasons. However, both did seem to intentionally try to lose the game, and seemed to work together to do so.


Thanks for helping to keep the game clean!

[Arrow]

2x WL for both.