MakJuice: 1-S2-1-448601

[BlackAura]

Account Name: MakJuice
Account ID: 1-S2-1-448601
In-Game Name: MakJuice

Crimes Committed: Game-Throwing

Your Account Name: BlackAura
Summary: A target for killing is simply suggested by interrogator. The DH also chooses the target. In the morning the target turns out to be Night Immune and the DH calls out himself and the interrogator, angry for the poor selection. The game ends in a loss for the Triad. -Mafia- (1479).SC2Replay

[Light_Yagami]

Review In Progress.

[Light_Yagami]

ID Verification:
Makjuice: SCID: 1-S2-1-448601 Correct


Players Added to Report:
BlackAura: SCID: 1-S2-1-11353809


Hotkeys
MacJuice: Hotkey 5
BlackAura: Hotkey Ctrl+5


Summary
While Reviewing During DH Trial Makjuice Did Call Out BlackAura As Interro During His Trial Day 5
Thus Game Throwing In That Reguard. Blackaura Did Also , Confirm What DH Stated In Trial/Final Words
Thus Reactionary Game Throwing. However, Arsonist Killed Interro/BlackAura N5. Game Continues On After That
With Town Win On Day 7


Was the game result altered?
In My Opinion.. No, The Mayors Last Will Stated That The DH Was Suspect After Informant Took Over Mayor And Was Never Fixed By Informant After Take Over.
Arsonist Killed Interro The Same Night DH Died


Player Offenses
MakJuice: Game Throwing
BlackAura: Reactionary Game Throw
Both: Griefing


Previous Offenses
BlackAura: Game Throwing WLx2 https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...hlight=1353809
MakJuice: Griefing On Hold Report. https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...ghlight=448601



Recommended Action
Watch List x3 For Both Parties



Additional Notes
I Added Griefing Because, The Argument Between The Two Lasted Long After The Game Was Over



Thanks for helping to keep the game clean!

[BlackAura]

Thank you for the review. With due respect, I would like to appeal both my offenses. I'm confused as to how it is "reactionary gt" to repeat the critical info that has already been divulged. Secondly, for the rest of the game he would not stop spamming/harassing so I did do some in return. I even state "keep going and I will add grief to report". Finally the game ended so I could retrieve his ID and then he insisted I meet him on discord. I was not interested in continuing what he started once I had his ID. Admittedly, I was not pleasant after the incident occurred, but at the time, I was disturbed by the extreme move to start whispering/ town chatting harassment and throw the game over a simple night "suggestion". Why would I get the same punishment as the person who throws the game? This judgement says; If you are going to throw a game, make sure to be extra toxic in doing so, in the hopes of triggering a reaction that will make your own precipitating actions retroactively justified or diminished. Your time is appreciated

[Light_Yagami]

I Stated Reactionary Game Throw Because, You Had Another Option Avail. You Could Have Called BS To What He Stated And Claimed Town Jailor & That You Knew There Were 2 You Could Have Tried To Convince The Town To Inno Him & Let Jailors Jail With The Second Jailor On The Arsonist & You Jail The Vet Again. This Action Would Have Likely Resulted In Triad Victory Dispite The Throw.

[Arrow]

Appeal noted.

[Nighthawk]

Under audit...

[Nighthawk]

ID Verification:
Makjuice: 1-S2-1-448601 - Correct
BlackAura: 1-S2-1-11353809 - Incorrect / Correct ID: 1-S2-1-1353809


Players Added to Report:



Hotkeys
Makjuice: 5
BlackAura: 1


Summary
Makjuice chooses the name "MakJuice" and roles Dragon Head in slot #13.
BlackAura is given the name "Enzo Esposito" and roles Interrogator in slot #5.


Day 1
Normal

Night 1
#5 kidnaps #1, who implies he is a Veteran and doesn't execute.
#13 and #9 (Informant) both target #6, who does not die.

Day 2
#11 reveals as the Mayor.
After series of PMs, #11 has #7 put on trial. #7 says nothing and is found guilty 1-5 (Doctor).

Night 2
#9 disguises as #11.
#13 kills #3 (Lookout).

Day 3
#9 shows as a dead Mayor since Informant doesn't clean role.
#11 is quickly voted to trial. #11 says nothing and is voted guilty 1-9 (Informant).
The informant never cleared the Mayor's LW and it is shown to the town.

Night 3
#13 targets #4. #5 suggests to get #10 thinking he is jailor.
#4 is killed by both a Veteran and the Triad (Sheriff).

Day 4
#1 claims to be confirmed vet and players PM.
#12 claims to have seen #10 visit #4.
#10 is voted to trial and claims Jailor with a LW. #10 is found guilty 0-2 (Jailor).

Night 4
#5 suggests to kill #6.
#13 targets #6, who is immune.

Day 5
#13 starts PMing #5 and harassing him.
#12 admits to making up claim on #10.
#8 starts having a heart attack.
#5 and #13 argue in PM.
#13 is voted to trial on suggestion of someone who read the Mayor's LW.
#13 reveals #5 as the interrogator and claims #6 is the Arson and suggests the town lynch him first. #13 is found guilty 0-4 and lynched (Dragon Head).

Night 5
#5 becomes an Enforcer and targets #15.
The arsonists ignites his targets.
#8 dies of a heart attack (Sheriff).
#5 (Enforcer) and #12 (Detective) die from being burned.
#15 is killed by the Triad (Escort).

#5 and #13 argue in the death chat.

Day 6
#14 is voted to trial and lynched (Witch).

Day 7
#6 is voted to trial and lynched (Arson).


The game ends on Day 7 with a town victory.


Was the game result altered?
Yes.


Player Offenses
Makjuice: Reactionary Game Throwing
BlackAura: None



Previous Offenses
Makjuice: Griefing (OH), Griefing (WLx2)
BlackAura: Game Throwing (WLx2)



Recommended Action
Makjuice: Watch List x2
BlackAura: Ignore



Additional Notes
A couple of notes here... discussing or arguing about things does not constitute griefing, as such I did not see griefing on either party here.
Makjuice is certainly guilty of reactionary game throwing for his obvious reveal of his teammate on trial. Confirming a game throw is not itself a game throw, therefore BlackAura is found innocent of any offenses in this replay.




Thanks for helping to keep the game clean!

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-448601: 2x WL