Account Name: BashXIII
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5695257
In-Game Name: Patrick
Crimes Committed: Game throwing & Rigged Game
Account Name: Ulfhethnar
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1798139
In-Game Name: Just another Gangsta
Crimes Committed: Game throwing
Account Name: Hacker
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5992538
In-Game Name: Luzio Bellucci
Crimes Committed: Rigged Game
Account Name: Renegade
Account ID: 1-S2-1-327911
In-Game Name: Maury
Crimes Committed: Rigged Game(unlikely, here for completeness of report)
Account Name: Mortacious(myself)
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3744039
In-Game Name: Ercole
Crimes Committed: Rigged Game(unlikely, here for completeness of report)
Your Account Name: Mortacious
Summary:
This is a clear case of BashXIII(4, Marshal, Patrick) game throwing along with Ulfhethnar(7, Arson, Just another Gangsta) game throwing. The question is did they do it purposely to benefit Mafia and if so where the Mafia co-conspirators in this.
*BashXIII game threw and rigged the game for mafia by ignoring increasing evidence which pointed at all 3 of the mafia; to lynch more credible claims.
*Ulfhethnar game threw by not dousing and admitting to being arson D3.
*Hacker(Mafia) was likely BashXIII or in collusion based on entire black is town roles, prior crimes, win ratio, and similar speech patterns to BashXIII.
*Renegade(Mafia) most likely just another player as he tried throughout game and has a normal win ratio with few games.
*Mortacious(Mafia) most likely just another player as he is the one writing the report, etc... etc...
Evidence Summary: Watching from BashXIII 4 Marshal's point of view is easy way to see what happend.
BashXIII ignored lead from 1spy on Hacker, 2 silent (no pm) players, to lynch 1 confirmed escort/liaison, and 2 role claims on D2.
1spy gives info to BashXIII that would deduce Hacker is consigliere from pm's, this is ignored, D3. Ulfhethnar claims arson in discussion and is lynched. On D3 3Pro are dead with 1Pro, 1Kill, and 3TRng possible. Mortacious(8, God Father, Ercole) claims doc and Renegade(6, Janitor, Maury) claims BG on BashXIII N2, which is disputed by 11Lookout. BashXIII lynches 10(afk jailer claim) and then asks 1spy who next. 1Spy says Renegade(6) and BashXIII waits 9seconds until last second to vote after 11 has been proven lookout and said Renegade didn't visit BashXIII like he claimed.
Subjectively the game throwing was in direct benefit for Mafia explicitly which implies collusion. It seems unlikely this was just a case of game throwing as the most simple and effective route would be to lynch town members, while BashXIII made some effort to remove neutrals. Renegade and Mortacious both play normally with full commitment until D4 when it's 3/6 mafia and no need to hide. Finally Mortacious is the one writing the report.
Mere conjecture, -BashXIII speaks in a condescending and know it all way which is similar to Hacker's insulting and prejudice rhetoric. -Hacker has 457 wins out of 470 and prior offences, Mortacious has 124 wins out of 267, Renegade has 28 wins out of 51.
Evidence:
Hacker Blacklists most town roles-Setup
Hacker investigates 15- N1 3:03
Ulfhethnar doesn't douse- N1 3:15
BashXIII reveals as Marshal- D2 4:03
1Spy pm's BashXIII “spy mafia spams anti-Semitic rhetoric and visits 9(kill+clean),15- D2 4:13
Hacker claims invest to BashXIII with N1:15 NC- D2 4:19
Hacker tells mafia 15 is Vigi and to shoot him- N2 6:59
Ulfhethnar doesn't douse- N2 7:33
1Spy relays info to BashXIII and says if you have Inv claim on 15 it is cons because mafia states 15 is Vigi- D3 8:09
11Lookout pm's BashXIII “lookout N2:4vb x”- D3 8:18
Renegade pm's BashXIII “bg i'm staying on you”-D3 8:27
Hacker pm's BashXIII claiming Inv saying N1:15nc, N2:11tres- D3 8:41
Ulfhethnar claims Arsonist during discussion- D3 8:47
BashXIII asks 1Spy to decide last lynch- D3 10:50
1Spy points to Renegade- D3 11:16
BashXIII waits 9 seconds, until last second to vote Renegade which results in no lynch- D3 11:25
Conclusion:
*BashXIII game threw and rigged the game for mafia by ignoring increasing evidence which pointed at all 3 of the mafia; to lynch more credible claims.
*Ulfhethnar game threw by not dousing and admitting to being arson D3.
*Hacker(Mafia) was likely BashXIII or in collusion based on entire black is town roles, prior crimes, win ratio, and similar speech patterns from BashXIII.
*Renegade(Mafia) most likely just another player as he tried throughout game and has a normal win ratio with few games.
*Mortacious(Mafia) most likely just another player as he is the one writing the report, etc... etc...-Mafia- (344).SC2Replay