As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF
Register

User Tag List

Results 1 to 8 of 8
  1. ISO #1

  2. ISO #2

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    That's really weird. I see absolutely no reason that #6 showed up as SK on n1 and showed up as NS on n5. Sheriff shouldn't have been able to see SK in the first place, given the settings in the save.

    This is definitely a bug.
    (°.°)(°.°)(°.°)(°.°)(°.°)(°.°)(°.°)(°.°)

  3. ISO #3

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    Could this have something to do with the fact the SK was jailed and killed the jailor? Seems like something in this action caused the option of "Sheriff can't detect SK" to be skipped. I wonder if this would work with other options such as MM or Triad/Mafia? Would be easy to test out.
    SC2 Username: Dante

  4. ISO #4

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    Yep it has something to do with Jailor. In one game i jailed SK and when Investigator (exact role) checked him this night he saw him as SK (ofc immunity on), when consigliere checked this SK earlier he detected him as citizen. Also i didn't get killed by jailbreak (killing roleblockers was on) when escort visited SK this night too. Later i had a game with Witch Doctor who also had detection immunity, when he was checked by sheriff the night i jailed him sheriff was able to detect him as cult.

    First replay -Mafia- (2453).SC2Replay: SK was 6 (Danil - "E" hotkey), Consigliere was 3 (Tyler - "Ctrl+3" hotkey), Investigator was 2 (Volkov - "5" hotkey), Jailor was me, 8 (RufusPL - "Ctrl+5" hotkey), Escort was 7 (SoulStorm - "Ctrl+1" hotkey)
    Consig checked SK n1, Invest checked SK n3 when he was also jailed by me and role blocked by escort. No BD/Witch/Beguiler in game.

    Second replay -Mafia- (2471).SC2Replay: WD was 9 (Gibbs - "8" hotkey), Jailor was me, 7 (RufusPL - "Ctrl+5" hotkey), Sheriff was 2 (Aegon - "1" hotkey)
    I jailed WD n1, Sheriff checked him n1.

  5. ISO #5

  6. ISO #6

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    Quick question on the topic at hand: if sheriff option to detect SK is ON while SK option to be detection immune is also ON - the sheriff can't detect the SK, right?

    I remember when I wanted to change sheriff to detect something, I had to make that Neutral Killer to have detection immunity OFF additionaly to allowing sheriff to detect him.

    Vice Versa - if sheriff detects SK is OFF and SK detection immunity is OFF - does the sheriff really not detect the SK? If it does then changing the sheriff options never changes anything as it always depends on the Neutral Killer detection immunity option.

    Edit:
    And yes, in game for the players it does show up as sheriff cant detect SK, even if in settings its set otherwise while SK is NI. So I'm talking about actual setup settings and not what the role cards tell the players.
    Last edited by OzyWho; March 2nd, 2018 at 09:50 AM.

  7. ISO #7

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    I would assume the point of those seemingly redundant settings is that you could make SOME of the investigative roles able to detect the killers and others not.
    IE: Serial killer immune to detect off, Sheriff detect sk alignment off. Invest can see SK's crimes of trespassing and murder but sheriff sees Not suspicious.

    Note: I'm not 100% sure it works that way as I haven't tested it, but that seems like it would be the point of those settings, right?


    Now, why anybody would create a save like that, I dunno.... but one could say the same for a lot of the optional settings that are rarely used. They're there so that you can't complain the option doesn't exist, I guess.


    I also kind of think being able to detect an immune SK when he's killed his jailor is a good thing(I mean... the jailor's lw should reveal who it is anyway. Having the invests find the jailed target NS just gives the SK an undeserved free pass), though of course it would need to be written somewhere that the functionality is supposed to work like that.
    Last edited by DJarJar; March 14th, 2018 at 07:22 PM.
    Have you ever heard the tragedy of Darth Jar Jar the wise?

  8. ISO #8

    Re: As SHERIFF, I detected SK on n1, when SHERIFF detects SK was OFF

    This is also still in game, being jailed takes out detection immunity of atleast both SK and WD (not sure if it works with GF). Also when SK is immune to detection he has some pretty weird interaction with Jailor, basically he won't kill Jailor even if he should because kills roleblockers is ON, i don't know if it works like that in general or it requires some additional interaction like invest roles visiting him same night since everytime it happend there was some invest role on him like Sheriff or Consigliere.

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •