Duck 1-S2-1-5975212 SoulEaterR 1-S2-1-5152845

[MasterNinja]

Duck 1-S2-1-5975212

Crier; On trial didn't claim role and just copy pasted a bunch of text.

Town
Trial
No role
take a guess whats gonna happend next.

-Mafia- (248).SC2Replay

[Oliver Queen]

Account Name: <SuperJ> SoulEaterR
Account ID: 1-S2-1-5152845
In-Game Name: Rodrigo the Sober

Crimes Committed: Cheating? Skyping? Don't really know how he did it

Your Account Name: AgentKillian
Summary:
He's a Sheriff.
Night 1: he visits 2, not suspicious.
Day 2: he claims 3 is triad (3 is DH)
Night 2: he visits 3, not suspicious, takes it out of his last will.
Day 3: 3 is lynched
Night 3: visits 11, who is triad
...
Night 8: SK and Marshall both suicide on the same night, giving Judge an achievement

Maybe I'm just overreacting, but it sure seems like some people were at least Skyping to get judge the achievement. All I know is that this Sheriff visited 2 night one, and correctly called out DH day 2.


-Mafia- (221).SC2Replay

[Mesk514]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Duck - Correct: 1-S2-1-5975212
SoulEaterR - Correct: 1-S2-1-5152845

Respective Hotkeys
Duck: CTRL + 2
SoulEaterR: 3

Was the Game Result altered?
No at the hands of Duck norSoulEaterR, however, town did lose.

Summary
At the beginning of the game, Duck is warned for intentional game throwing

Duck(#8) roles Crier

Day 1:
he updates his last will: i like big cock

Night 1:
he is jailed, tells the jailor he'll blow him to get out

Day 2:
--
Mostly spam, mentions twice he's the crier

Night 2:
first thing said: 8 here faggots

Day 3:
at this point some people are starting to PM him their roles

Night 3:
bunch of spam, but does mention that he is 8 and crier.

Day 4:
--

Night 4:
spam but says stuff like, "trust in umberto" (his in game name)

Day 5:
he tells everyone to get 6, 6 is lynched... 6 was the jester

Night 5:
bunch of spam, says more stuff about "trusting in umberto"

Day 5:
#8 is put on trial, spams the same things as he did at night. does not claim crier.

he is lynched.



game ends with Marshall && Serial Killer suiciding, giving the judge a solo win.



SoulEaterR(#1) roles Sheriff.

Day 1:
--

Night 1:
decides to check 4
decides to check 3
decides to check 2

Day 2:
Updates LW: N1- 2 ns
starts spamming 3 is triad
no lynch occurs

Night 2:
decides to check 3
updates LW: N1- 2 ns N2- 3

Day 3:
updates LW: N1- 2 ns N2- ain't gonna say
Starts spamming 3 is triad.
3 is lynched, they were the Dragon Head
Updates LW: found the dragon head for you day 2, thanks. i was almost lynched cause i told everyone to vote 3.

Night 3:
decides to check 11, who shows up triad.

Day 4:
11 is dead
nothing happens

Night 4:
decides to check 14

Day 5:
jester is lynched

Night 5:
decides to check 10
Updates LW: found the dragon head for you day 2, thanks. i was almost lynched cause i told everyone to vote 3. checked 11 the night he died, N5- 10

Day 6:
says #8 seems like the Judge or SK
he pushes #8
8 spams

8 was crier

Night 6:
Updates LW: found the dragon head for you day 2, thanks. i was almost lynched cause i told everyone to vote 3. checked 11 the night he died, N5- 10 ns N6- 13

Day 7:
court is called & 1 is lynched.


Previous Offenses
Duck:
- Griefing (x1 WL)
- Role Quitting (On-Hold)
- Intentional Game Throwing (x2 WL)
- Griefing (x4 WL)
- Griefing (x2 on top of the previous x4)
- Griefing (x2 BL)
- Using Stump Save

SoulEateR:
- Name Abuse (On-Hold)
- Name Abuse (x2 WL)



Player Offenses
Duck: Minor Griefing
SoulEateR: Additional Information?

Recommended Action
Duck: X1 BL on top of the x2 BL that has yet to be put in place.
x3 BL
SoulEateR: Given SoulEateR is an active member on the forums, I recommend a reasonable explanation as to how they knew #3 was the Dragon Head, especially since he was getting a little cocky with it in his last will. If we do not receive a reasonable explanation i recommend a x2 WL

Additional Notes
Thank you both for your reports and efforts in keeping the game clean.

[MasterNinja]

You guys got 1350 replays of mine in total and there's no "cheating here", i just wanted to trial 2 for role and if town doesn't listen up il just say that he is "this or this" and sometimes luck strikes.

that happends all the time. i also had a game where guy named long john *something* (who was in the replays we see here, triad nr 11) would report me for hacking where i guessed he was auditor.
and i was sheriff, i cant detect auditor, its 100% guessing to trial people for role and then inno / guilty. (there was few left alive)
and skyping / teaming cant see auditor either. should pretty much summ up everything.

prob not supposed to reply as SoulEaterR. but i just gave in 1350 replays and there's no cheating here.

this confirms alot too you just wrote it yourself.
Mesk
Day 6:
says #8 seems like the Judge or SK
he pushes #8
8 spams

8 was crier

There's no way that i would come up here putting a replay of myself hacking.

[DarknessB]

There's no way that i would come up here putting a replay of myself hacking.

You'd honestly be surprised -- we've received replays from people where they were overtly Skyping or otherwise breaking the rules and even admitted it to us after the fact, lol.

[MasterNinja]

You'd honestly be surprised -- we've received replays from people where they were overtly Skyping or otherwise breaking the rules and even admitted it to us after the fact, lol.

Someone dropped out of school.

[Mesk514]

There's no way that i would come up here putting a replay of myself hacking.

Let me be clear about something -- I in no way find you guilty of hacking. There's nothing indicative here that says so. Nor really Skyping.
However, I do find it odd that you checked 2 who came up NS, and you immediately start pushing 3 who was the Dragon Head. You did check 3, who did come up NS because he was the Dragon Head, yet you still pushed him.

I'm not going to argue that sometimes you can just get lucky, but let's put it into perspective for a moment. If 3 was not Triad this scenario would be Griefing // GameThrowing especially since you were so adamant that 3 was Triad.

I'm willing to change my decision to an Ignore, However I just want to make it clear that sometimes behaviour like this can be sometimes borderline.

[MasterNinja]

As a townie even as survivor and other roles you can spot who is teaming up with who, who is defending who, who is looking susp and who's not looking susp.
In this case i cant find dragon head and so my main gameplay as a townie is to trial up everyone for role.

Specially when people start defending a player that they dont know, either its because triad / maf teammates defending or skyping / teaming or just people who are not so good in the game and does not want to random people on trial.

i got games won as doctor, bodyguard, roles that could not find clues by their role alone, mafia is just about reading other people.
and by these games i mean the guy who speaks up as the main town guy who is trialing and finding mafia / triads and then towns will just think i am invest role or good player.
thats just how you become a good player at Sc2Mafia.

You get alot of training in being a survivor / exe / jester role and is acting like a sheriff / invest role for town and is lynching up triads / mafia or others. good training where failing doesn't matter so you get as many tries as you want.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-5975212: Additional 2x banlist(total 6)