{Watch List} Shidda: 1-S2-1-8282416
Register

User Tag List

Results 1 to 7 of 7
  1. ISO #1

    Shidda: 1-S2-1-8282416

    Account Name: Shidda
    Account ID: 1-S2-1-8282416
    In-Game Name: Serafino the Strong

    Crimes Committed: Griefing / Pretending to hack / Gamethrowing

    Your Account Name: max
    Summary:

    He called out triads d1 (said 1 10 6 are triads) and evils (12 sk, 9 is auditor). It wasn't right, but he was pretending that he knew because of hacks.
    The next day he kept spamming that 1 10 6 are triad and told everyone to vote 6 up. He also claimed Lookout and said that 8 was visited by 6; 8 was Interrogator and had die to MM the night before.

    The next day, escort said 10 is immune to RB and Shidda tried to get 10 lynched and said that 10 is night immune and that he was attacked by SK.

    Day 4, he said that 1 is MM because the Escort had died while blocking him (the escort had died to mafia, not MM so that was nonsense) and was pushing for 1s lynch. He was writing in caps all the time btw.

    1 then revealed as Marshall and asked for roles and lws. Shidda pmed his role but no lw and kept pushing for lynches, mostly people he didn't like or who had said anything against him (one of the people he wanted to vote was confirmed town because he was kidnapped by interro n1).
    Marshall lynched 3 townies and MM that day and town lost afterwards.

    He also didn't really keep a lw, he kept deleting parts of it for no reason and only had the last night in it.


    shidda griefing.SC2Replay

  2. ISO #2

    Re: Shidda: 1-S2-1-8282416

    SC ID VERIFICATION
    Shidda - Correct: 1-S2-1-8282416

    Respective Hotkeys
    Shidda: 8

    Was the Game Result altered?
    Yes, the town had no chance. The various accusations stalled lynches. There was not one lynching (besides the 3 marshall lynches)

    Summary
    going to explain this since auto restore clearly doesn't auto restore....
    Shidda roles Lookout

    Day 1 Shidda say 12 = SK, 9 = Auditor.
    Night 1 he watches over #6 (no one visits)

    Day 2 Shidda says 1, 10, 6 are triad, 4 is auditor, 12 is SK
    #6 is put on trial and is voted into
    Night 2 he watches over #11 (no one visits)

    Day 3 Shidda starts spamming that 10 is the Dragon Head and that 10 is Night Immune
    10 is put on trial and voted inno
    Night 3 Shidda goes to watch over 1 who was visited by 12

    Day 4 Shidda starts spamming that 1 is a baddie
    1 reveals as marshall, Shidda PM's that he's lookout
    Night 4 Shidda goes to watch over 1 who is visited by 13 and 3

    Day 5 Shidda spams that it's either 13 or 3, no one really believes him so again no lynch
    Night 5 Shidda goes to watch over 13
    He then committed suicide.


    This game was definitely Griefing at it's finest. It's Griefing so hard it's Game Throwing.



    Previous Offenses
    Cheating // Additional Information (x3 WL)


    Player Offenses
    Pretending to Hack, Griefing // Game Throwing

    Recommended Action
    I'm kind of a firm believer that if you're staff you should have a high punishment than most. This was quite brutal to watch, so brutal i honestly do recommend Ban List x2, but if we are trying to be lenient i guess a Watch List x6 could work too.

    Additional Notes
    Thank you for your report and efforts in making the game clean.
    Quote Originally Posted by AnassRhamur View Post
    Please don't post in the punished players section if you're not involved. Consider this a warning from Thugnificent. You got one Thug ticket. Collect 3 more of those and i'll have to issue a Thug Infraction. Collect 3 Thug Infractions and you get 1 Thug Misdemeanor Charge.

    Spoiler : :
    Citizen, Agent, Citizen, Vigilante, Citizen, Godfather, Citizen, Citizen, Voter, Elder, Mafioso, BackUpSleuth, Escort, Mafioso, Detective, Citizen, Citizen, Tailor, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, TheJoker, Citizen, LadyGaga, Mafioso, Winston Wolfe, Detective, Citizen, Citizen, Masquerader

  3. ISO #3

    Re: Shidda: 1-S2-1-8282416

    SC ID VERIFICATION
    1-S2-1-8282416 is Correct.

    Respective Hotkey:

    8

    Previous Offenses:

    https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-8282416

    Player Offenses:

    Severe griefing.

    Key Points:
    Players in question:

    Shidda: LOOKOUT 14

    Game:


    Setup: None
    Names: None
    Roles: None
    D1: Shidda(14, LOOKOUT) starts spamming role accusations at the end of the day.
    N1: Shidda watches 6 and sets a LW. (No visits).
    D2: 8(INTERROGATOR) is dead. Shidda updates LW. He then accuses several players of being triad, again by number, as well as an SK, and auditor. SK is not possible at this point as the MASS MURDERER takes the only possible spawn. Shidda repeats these numbers until 6(one of the accused) is on trial, though he ends up pardoned.
    N2: Shidda watches 11 but sees nothing.
    D3: Shidda again spams with more radio static, particularly about 10, who is pardoned on trial.
    N3: Shidda watches 1; sees 12 visit him.
    D4: 2(JAILOR) 12(ESCORT), and 5(WITCH) are dead. Shidda makes MORE baseless accusations, several of which are clearly false(specifically, he claims that 1 is MM and killed 12, despite the fact that 12 died to mafia, and mass murderer can't spree when an ESCORT visits.) 1 reveals as MARSHALL to save himself. 10(VETERAN), 9(INVESTIGATOR), 15(BODYGUARD), and 11(MASS MURDERER) are hung.
    N4: Shidda updates his LW to only reflect who visits 1 on N4. This is ok because all his other watch-targets are either dead or have he saw nothing at them. 1 is visited by 3 and 12.
    D5: 1(MARSHALL) is dead. Shidda reports who visited him, but votes stall and nobody is lynched. Shidda opts to kill themself at this time.
    N5: Shidda watches 13, but kills himself before getting results.
    D6: 6(DOCTOR), 14, and 7(SHERIFF) are dead. Triad wins as only a JESTER remains to oppose them and tiebreak initiates.

    Was the game result altered?
    Yes.

    Punishment:

    6x Watchlist, removal from staff.

    Additional Notes:
    Thank you for the report!
    Last edited by Arrow; November 13th, 2016 at 02:08 PM.

  4. ISO #4

    Re: SilverWolf 1-S2-1-8402014

    @Arrow -
    i would like to reference this report in my appeal.
    as you can see, targeting randoms to get the conversation started, and get leads to identify who is actually mafia/killing, is a valid strategy.

    Silverwolf used it in this replay, and was not repremanded for that specific game play, which is why i thought that yes, while not 100% practical, it is a valid application and method to play the game.

    this is not griefing, this is strategy.

    [mod]Shidda originally posted this message in this thread: https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-8402014[/mod]
    Last edited by DarknessB; November 13th, 2016 at 06:39 PM.

  5. ISO #5

    Re: SilverWolf 1-S2-1-8402014

    Quote Originally Posted by Shidda View Post
    @Arrow -
    i would like to reference this report in my appeal.
    as you can see, targeting randoms to get the conversation started, and get leads to identify who is actually mafia/killing, is a valid strategy.

    Silverwolf used it in this replay, and was not repremanded for that specific game play, which is why i thought that yes, while not 100% practical, it is a valid application and method to play the game.

    this is not griefing, this is strategy.
    I'm not sure that referencing the conduct of a player who was permabanned for toxic play is the best approach in an appeal. That having been said, please keep posts related to your request for an appeal in your report thread, not in others.

    UPDATE: I realize that thread has not been published yet -- we'll move these threads over when that takes place.

    UPDATE 2: Moved to appropriate thread.
    Last edited by DarknessB; November 13th, 2016 at 06:39 PM.

  6. ISO #6

    Re: Shidda: 1-S2-1-8282416

    An additional replay was provided to me showing further behavior, establishing a pattern. I've attached it, as well as my review of it, below.


    SC ID VERIFICATION
    1-S2-1-8282416 is Correct.


    Respective Hotkey:

    8

    Previous Offenses:

    https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...1-S2-1-8282416 2x WL

    Player Offenses:

    Griefing

    Key Points:
    Players in question:

    SHIDDA: BEGUILER 8.

    Game:


    Setup: One player is kicked by nuclear.
    Names: Shidda names himself Shidda.
    Roles: None.
    D1: Shidda(8, BEGUILER) names several people's numbers and claimed roles, which is griefing.
    N1: Shidda tries to throw off a spy, but fails because he starts posting numbers again. (There is no SPY in the game, lucky for him). He hides behind 5
    D2: 3(???) is dead. Shidda continues the numbers all day. 6(GODFATHER) is hung.
    N2: Shidda hides behind 14. The vigilante takes out the MAFIOSO.
    D3: 9(MAFIOSO) is dead. Shidda claims vig, drawing unnecessary attention. The real vig counterclaims. 13 quits. 5(DOCTOR) is hung.
    N3: Shidda leaves a fake LW claiming he was converted to mafioso. He attacks 2, which he knows is Exeter, but he's vested; meanwhile the vigilante shows up and ices Shidda.
    D4: 13(LOOKOUT) and 8 are dead. Shidda quits. 4(ARSONIST) is hung, ending game.

    Was the game result altered?
    Maybe; Shidda didn't help the situation, but the Maf was already in bad shape.

    Punishment:

    Listed above.

    Additional Notes:
    Thank you for the report!
    Attached Files Attached Files

  7. ISO #7

 

 

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •