Meh: 1-S2-1-2732372, Tinny: 1-S2-1-3551077

[Joirs]

Account Name: Meh
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2732372
In-Game Name: Napolean

Account Name: Mowgli
Account ID: 1-S2-1-3551077
In-Game Name: Michael Scott

Crimes Committed: Intentional Gamethrowing / Griefing

Your Account Name: Joirs

Summary: Napolean jails Ataner(me) N1, decides to exe, somehow i survive the executioner and reveal as Mayor next day. 12 continues to lie to me about being sheriff role for the remainder of the game which causes me to be unable to make informed decisions, as these 2 townies are essentially lying to me the entire game. Infact 12 claims to me that his gamethrowing buddy, (5) is NS.

mowgli (michael scott) refuses to give me any lookout leads after day 2, and tries to vote me up at one point along with 12, (cult not possible in this game fyi) he then suicides a few days later.

Wouldnt be suprised if these 2 are skyping with eachother either.


-Mafia- (1050).SC2Replay

[Arrow]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Meh: 1-S2-1-2732372 is Correct.
Mowgli: 1-S2-1-3551077 is Correct.


Respective Hotkey:

Meh: Ctrl+4
Mowgli: Ctrl+1

Previous Offenses:

Meh: Holy shit.
Mowgli: Old report from 2013; irrelevant.

Player Offenses:

Meh:
Mowgli:

Key Points:
Players in question:

Meh: Jailor, 12.
Mowgli: Lookout, 5.

Game:


Setup: None.
Names: None.
Roles: None.
D1: Banter.
N1: 12(JAILOR) has 15 in jail. 15 gives a bad story, and gets an execution piped in, but 12 is roleblocked, cancelling the kill. 5(LOOKOUT) watches 10 and sees 13 visit him.
D2: 3(JUDGE) is dead. This does indeed rule out any chance of a CULT. 15(MAYOR) reveals. Everyone PMs, but 12 lies claiming SHERIFF and that 5 is NS. (For his part, 5 is honest.) 1 is trialed and pardoned. 8 and 7 are similarly pardoned, before 4(who disconnected) is hung. Flips ESCORT.
N2: 12 cannot jail. 5 updates his LW to read "Don't care what happens now, kill mayor." He watches himself and sees nothing.
D3: 14(CRIER) is dead. 7(BEGUILER) is hung.
N3: 12 can't jail. 5 watches 13, sees nothing.
D4: 11(LOOKOUT) is dead. 12 tells mayor that 6 is Mafia (lie, 12 is Jailor and can't have that information) and writes a LW that he is "pretending to be sheriff". As he's only doing this to the Mayor via PM, whom he is aligned with, and there's no roles that can read PM, this is gamethrowing if it costs the game. 2(AGENT) is hung.
N4: 12 can jail nobody. 5 watches 1, sees him visited by 6(DOCTOR).
D5: 6 is dead. 15 threatens 12 with a lynch if he doesn't give LW. (8 players alive, Mayor can push a solo lynch though not a solo trial). 12 claims GF in PM. 14 is pardoned; 5 and 12 vote to lynch mayor despite no possibility of a cult or Disguiser being in the game based on prior deaths. Day ends up skipped.
N5: 5 quits. 12 is in jail himself and claims Jester, gets executed.
D6: 5 and 12 are dead. 9(SPY) is hung.
N6: Arsonist fires off.
D7: 1(JAILOR) and 10(SURVIVOR) are dead. Remaining roles: GF, Arson, Mayor. Town has lost. 8(GODFATHER) is hung.
N7: Night.
D8: ARSONIST wins 1v1 tiebreak.

Was the game result altered?
The active interference of 12 in sowing false information among known town members may have cost town the game. If nothing else, he was playing to lose.

Punishment:

Meh: 2x banlist
Mowgli: On-hold

Additional Notes:
I doubt these two are skyping, as they are not adjacent(which would indicate partying) nor do they leave at the same time.

Thank you for the report!

[Meh]

I appeal this. It was in no way a gamethrow. I pretended to be sheriff so a Mayor wouldn't lynch a jailor and if that's gamethrowing ya'll are retarded. It's called mafia a game of deceit, and if claiming to be a town role is gamethrowing you are actually out of touch. Tell me how that's gamethrowing? You didn't even give a reason to how it's gamethrowing and how it affected the game. A banlist for pretending to be a different role to not get lynched? No wonder this game is dying.

[Arrow]

No, the gamethrow is when you tried to push a lynch on the revealed mayor, wasting a day, and following that quit immediately, costing the town both a day and a role.

Appeal is denied.