FM 16

[Damus_Graves]

Thoughts? Comments?


Edit: For the people who don't seem to understand....... The subject is FM 16

[deathworlds]

Please elaborate. Thoughts and comments on what?

[Voss]

i hate how gunsmith commanded that i be shot after i was semi-cleared of being witch...

[Numbertwo]

All i remember was a crazy vigilante killing all the townies, including me.

[Damus_Graves]

The vigilante very nearly lost the game for town with his insistence to stay alive like he kept saying. It was a very poorly made choice and it was Slaol, Auckmid, and myself that really pulled the game into victory for the town.

[deathworlds]

I was not there so I have no comment.

[Nazzhoul]

I remember that the 20+ people in the graveyard were all entirely convinced that Damus and Slaol were the last two mafia.

And also King Tut getting modkilled on the last day

And the SK only killing people based on post count, meaning I died n1

And Vornskr getting framed, getting checked by a sheriff, and the witch witching someone to him who was already visiting him in the first place

[Numbertwo]

Modkilling the jailor when he was going to jail the witch. I think there were too many modkills in this FM, the people that got modkilled weren't completely inactive.

[Gerik]

And Vornskr getting framed, getting checked by a sheriff, and the witch witching someone to him who was already visiting him in the first place

That was easily my favorite thing that happened in the FM. Both sheriffs targeted Vorn, Clem witched one of the sheriffs into targeting Vorn, and I framed Vorn.

And the whole game people kept calling it a "lucky frame". Yup, it was totally random!

I can't believe how far we (scum) made it, considering that clem and I were the only scum that participated in day chat. That was the one thing I hated about that game. I was so lonely.

[Slaol]

Mass Citizen game.
- Top 5 Town players were Blacksmith, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen
- Bottom 5 Town players were Vigilante, Sheriff, Doctor, Doctor, Jailor

100% luck night actions on night 2. #thereisnodecisionmakinginmafia100%rngyoloswag

Daychat so key
- Lynches were like 6 scum out of 8 lynches. (1 being a decided mislynch of the Vigilante)
- Non lynch deaths (Vigilante, Blacksmith, Modkills, Mafia, Serial Killer) were like 32 town to 2 scum.

Go with your gut, and first read is best read.
- spotted framer
- loved Agahnim
- loved Col Jack
- loved Sparrow
- loved Arthur
- godfather wasn't loved
- witch wasn't loved
- etc was/n't etc.
- first post analysis out the wazoo.

[Gerik]

Mass Citizen game.
- Top 5 Town players were Blacksmith, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen, Citizen
- Bottom 5 Town players were Vigilante, Sheriff, Doctor, Doctor, Jailor

This... is fantastic.

Here, I'll do the scum version:

Top 5 Scum: Framer, Witch
Bottom 5 Scum: Consigliere, all other scum

SK would've made top 5 if he hadn't claimed doc for no reason and hung himself.

[Damus_Graves]

Events:
Agahnim:
Pointed out SK Day One
Successfully deduced Gandalfs role and attempted in some fashion to halt his lynch
Pointed out Scum MVP Framer day three/four and tried lynching him, failed due to derp lurk town
Aggressive flustered the weak link mafia members into "revealing" their scumminess
Semi-Confirmed Citizen Trollers as Town end game
Took out biggest scum suspect early game
Confirmed Cluesae(?) as Town, set up for end game leader
Caused misfire that narrowed the Witch suspects down to two people, ensuring no possible mislynches
Biggest Late Game Scum Suspect even though it was utterly illogical to think.




Gerik, Slaol, Damus, Auckmid, Clem = OP players of the match

[Slaol]

Oh. I should note
Day # I got a gun.
My FoS at the time were
- Serial Killer
- Witch
- Framer
- Citizen

Wonder who I shot?

Gerik, Slaol, Damus, Auckmid, Clem = OP players of the match

Vorn for his 2 days alive spotted 2 scum. Should be noted as he only died due to the same town that managed to find Agahnim as scum.

[Damus_Graves]

Oh. I should note
Day # I got a gun.
My FoS at the time were
- Serial Killer
- Witch
- Framer
- Citizen

Wonder who I shot?

Lol.
that just went to show how lackluster a large majority of the town were.

Borkbot, CmG, Auckmid, etc. Obvs exclusions.


The main problem is that the majority of the town just don't speak at all. You don't even have to say anything utterly imporant or game changing. Just respond to the topics at hand and don't be a complete dumbass "The sky is blue" and you'd be infinitely better off than lurking.

[Azuriae]

< Wile E Coyote
I'm still surprised I survived this long in that FM, but ultimately Frog/Clem made a good choice by using the Vigilante to kill me during one of the final nights. I was totally onto you, Clem!

It's unfortunate that the game had to happen during the holidays. It heavily contributed to the lurking of a lot of our players.

[Gerik]

< Wile E Coyote
I'm still surprised I survived this long in that FM, but ultimately Frog/Clem made a good choice by using the Vigilante to kill me during one of the final nights. I was totally onto you, Clem!

It's unfortunate that the game had to happen during the holidays. It heavily contributed to the lurking of a lot of our players.

I think "being a citizen" also heavily contributed to the heavy lurking of a lot of the players.

[vornksr]

That was easily my favorite thing that happened in the FM. Both sheriffs targeted Vorn, Clem witched one of the sheriffs into targeting Vorn, and I framed Vorn.

And the whole game people kept calling it a "lucky frame". Yup, it was totally random!

asjdio;jao;werijgaogia;xfigja

I'll survive past d2 someday.

[Gerik]

asjdio;jao;werijgaogia;xfigja

I'll survive past d2 someday.

Sorry! In both FM 16 and FM 18 I was the one who brought about your early demise (though the town certainly helped in 16).

Maybe we'll be on the same side/I won't kill you some day!

[vornksr]

I look forward to it! Perhaps in FM XX

[Gerik]

I look forward to it! Perhaps in FM XX

You're not playing 19?

[Azuriae]

I think "being a citizen" also heavily contributed to the heavy lurking of a lot of the players.

But Citizen is so much fun to play. Your load of ''responsibilities'' is so much lighter, you can pretty much play it how you want. It's a shame that so many people have the Sc2Mafia mentality about it.

I have to say though, even for I it was my most lurkish FM, since I was out of town during the holidays, even after the break. I ended up staying at my family's for much longer than planned.

[Gerik]

But Citizen is so much fun to play. Your load of ''responsibilities'' is so much lighter, you can pretty much play it how you want. It's a shame that so many people have the Sc2Mafia mentality about it.

I have to say though, even for I it was my most lurkish FM, since I was out of town during the holidays, even after the break. I ended up staying at my family's for much longer than planned.

Yeah, I enjoyed my day of being a citizen in the Halo 2 MFM. I'm sure I'd enjoy it for, you know, more than a day.

[AppleyNO]

This game was depressing. I would rather not relive my FM 16 experience.

[Damus_Graves]

This game was depressing. I would rather not relive my FM 16 experience.

You didn't do so bad. It was the other sheriff person who was all flippitany

[AppleyNO]

You didn't do so bad. It was the other sheriff person who was all flippitany

Lol, I revealed and got a framed target lynched, then proceeded to not lead the town.

There were too many modkills, but the setup was just bad.

[Gerik]

Lol, I revealed and got a framed target lynched, then proceeded to not lead the town.

There were too many modkills, but the setup was just bad.

In what way was the setup bad? Frankly, I thought it was the most balanced FM I've ever played. It's just a shame that so many people lurked.