Search:

[QUOTE=FM Wile E Coyote;269332]Sherlock for LVP.
[/QUOTE]

Grow up

Originally Posted by FM Wile E Coyote

Sherlock for LVP.

Grow up

[QUOTE=FM Sherlock;269173]I told you, it's because I never had spare time to read the day chat. I later found out Gimli's reads on Frog, and before the lynch my focus already shifted from "Gimli and Tut" to "Gimli and Frog".

I don't get why they didn't agree to use the "exclusion method". Cluseau would name Gimli or King Tut as "town" and we would have to choose between one of then and Frog.[/QUOTE]

Is that so?

[QUOTE=Inspector Cluseau]Also, as much as I hate that the idea was birthed in the depths of the pit that is Sherlock's mind, Frog is the guy I am pretty dang sure is Town.[/QUOTE]

Originally Posted by FM Sherlock

I told you, it's because I never had spare time to read the day chat. I later found out Gimli's reads on Frog, and before the lynch my focus already shifted from "Gimli and Tut" to "Gimli and Frog".

I don't get why they didn't agree to use the "exclusion method". Cluseau would name Gimli or King Tut as "town" and we would have to choose between one of then and Frog.

Is that so?

Originally Posted by Inspector Cluseau

Also, as much as I hate that the idea was birthed in the depths of the pit that is Sherlock's mind, Frog is the guy I am pretty dang sure is Town.

WOOT! GJ TEAM!

WOOT! GJ TEAM!

[U][B]Greetings/Spammy first post [/B][/U]
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#EE82EE"]Gimili [/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Rubber Duck[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Dracula[/COLOR]

[B][U]Borderline[/U][/B]
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Watson[/COLOR]

[U][B]Non-introductory first posts[/B][/U]
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Anubis[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#EE82EE"]Michigan J[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie[/COLOR]


Hmm, wonder who the scum is?

Greetings/Spammy first post
Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut
Gimili
Rubber Duck
Dracula

Borderline
Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim
Watson

Non-introductory first posts
Anubis
Michigan J
Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie


Hmm, wonder who the scum is?

It is now LYLO. If Frog comes online, game instantly ends.

It is now LYLO. If Frog comes online, game instantly ends.

[QUOTE=FM Game Master;269082]After a super long day J, town accomplished nothing at all.

1 witch vs 3 cits + 1 vig = 2 mislynches on cits required to end game.

Instead they lynched the vig and guess what: still have lynch 2 cits to end the game.

So I'm doing something that I should have done a long time ago... modkill Tut. They have 1 chance to get this right.

Edit: FM 6 still had 17 players alive and could have swung in any direction... This game clearly has come down to these 3 people.[/QUOTE]

Reset the vote counter please

Originally Posted by FM Game Master

After a super long day J, town accomplished nothing at all.

1 witch vs 3 cits + 1 vig = 2 mislynches on cits required to end game.

Instead they lynched the vig and guess what: still have lynch 2 cits to end the game.

So I'm doing something that I should have done a long time ago... modkill Tut. They have 1 chance to get this right.

Edit: FM 6 still had 17 players alive and could have swung in any direction... This game clearly has come down to these 3 people.

Reset the vote counter please

[QUOTE=FM King Arthur;269065]Where have I seen that before...

Reminds me of FM 6.



People weren't exactly blissfully happy with how that turned out.[/QUOTE]

That is what I am thinking about. DR was a semi-troll. Yayap knows much better.

Originally Posted by FM King Arthur

Where have I seen that before...

Reminds me of FM 6.



People weren't exactly blissfully happy with how that turned out.

That is what I am thinking about. DR was a semi-troll. Yayap knows much better.

I'm telling you, there is no way Yayap would change the mechanics to give scum victory at 1V2.

I'm telling you, there is no way Yayap would change the mechanics to give scum victory at 1V2.

[QUOTE=FM King Arthur;269057]If the GM ends the game after this day regardless of what happens, he's picking sides.[/QUOTE]

He would be more then picking sides. He'd be changing the game mechanics midway through to help ensure the victory of one side.

Originally Posted by FM King Arthur

If the GM ends the game after this day regardless of what happens, he's picking sides.

He would be more then picking sides. He'd be changing the game mechanics midway through to help ensure the victory of one side.

We also deadlynched Sherlock yesterday.

Atm, I am going to say that scum's chances of winning are looking pretty high.

Today: Cluseau leads waggon on Gimili. Frog and Tut both sheep, Gimili dies.
Next Day: Cluseau may or may not realize Frog is Witch. However, I'm worried that Tut will be a complete tool and vote Cluseau. Frog quick-hammers, Scum wins.

We also deadlynched Sherlock yesterday.

Atm, I am going to say that scum's chances of winning are looking pretty high.

Today: Cluseau leads waggon on Gimili. Frog and Tut both sheep, Gimili dies.
Next Day: Cluseau may or may not realize Frog is Witch. However, I'm worried that Tut will be a complete tool and vote Cluseau. Frog quick-hammers, Scum wins.

[QUOTE=FM Game Master;268997][url]https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showthread.php/15760-Holiday-break[/url]

^ That was the only reason I didn't modkill him.[/QUOTE]

Will Tut at least go down as red for this game on the FM Database. He realy does deserve to be modkilled, but it will further hurt town.

Originally Posted by FM Game Master

https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showth...-Holiday-break

^ That was the only reason I didn't modkill him.

Will Tut at least go down as red for this game on the FM Database. He realy does deserve to be modkilled, but it will further hurt town.

Well, looks like Sherlock is going to get lynched, meaning a new hope. Sherlock realy is driving Town into the ground. Maybe they will be able to function better without his influence.

Well, looks like Sherlock is going to get lynched, meaning a new hope. Sherlock realy is driving Town into the ground. Maybe they will be able to function better without his influence.

Yeah, Sherlock is going to kill town.

Yeah, Sherlock is going to kill town.

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268792]I'm loving that the RP of my death is being used to clear Frog. I continue to serve scum from the grave! XD[/QUOTE]

I'm sure Yayap put you as scum MVP in RP just to throw Town off...

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

I'm loving that the RP of my death is being used to clear Frog. I continue to serve scum from the grave! XD

I'm sure Yayap put you as scum MVP in RP just to throw Town off...

[QUOTE=FM Game Master;268742]I decision who got mvp was mostly based on what that person knew and didn't know. Frog, although is still alive, had no idea who the mafia really was. Based on the night action PMs I got, he really did think that agahnim was scum. So it made it much easier for him to blend in.

Where as Wolverine had to consciously try to blend in as well as not putting too much pressure on frog as well as his own mafia. And he had to predict Frogs night actions to not overlap. Wolverine used a much higher level of wifom, where as witch blocked the obvious sheriff till vig showed up then used him in a rather random manner since he didn't know friend from foe.

Read the night chats where Wolverine takes over as commanding mafia, his full out reasoning as to who needed to die as well as the risks and potential gains sealed his award.

Frog being alive is mostly luck now more than anything... as are his chances of surviving. So although Frog has done a better job of surviving, Wolverine did a better job as a true scum.

I have no problems giving Frog the Players choice award. But to get scum mvp, you need to do more than just survive.[/QUOTE]

Okay then.

Frog for players choice.

Originally Posted by FM Game Master

I decision who got mvp was mostly based on what that person knew and didn't know. Frog, although is still alive, had no idea who the mafia really was. Based on the night action PMs I got, he really did think that agahnim was scum. So it made it much easier for him to blend in.

Where as Wolverine had to consciously try to blend in as well as not putting too much pressure on frog as well as his own mafia. And he had to predict Frogs night actions to not overlap. Wolverine used a much higher level of wifom, where as witch blocked the obvious sheriff till vig showed up then used him in a rather random manner since he didn't know friend from foe.

Read the night chats where Wolverine takes over as commanding mafia, his full out reasoning as to who needed to die as well as the risks and potential gains sealed his award.

Frog being alive is mostly luck now more than anything... as are his chances of surviving. So although Frog has done a better job of surviving, Wolverine did a better job as a true scum.

I have no problems giving Frog the Players choice award. But to get scum mvp, you need to do more than just survive.

Okay then.

Frog for players choice.

[QUOTE=FM Jack Sparrow;268730]Lolwut? If frog manages to win this she iwll surely get scum MVP over Wolverine :-P[/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=FM Game Master]Wolverine was Scum MVP! Err... Framer.[/QUOTE]

Clementine has played an amazing game, so I would be very surprised if she didn't win a major award. However, I highly doubt the GM will say that Wolverine won Scum MVP, then change his mind and give it to Frog instead. Hense, me asking if there will be an overall MVP.

Originally Posted by FM Jack Sparrow

Lolwut? If frog manages to win this she iwll surely get scum MVP over Wolverine :-P

Originally Posted by FM Game Master

Wolverine was Scum MVP! Err... Framer.

Clementine has played an amazing game, so I would be very surprised if she didn't win a major award. However, I highly doubt the GM will say that Wolverine won Scum MVP, then change his mind and give it to Frog instead. Hense, me asking if there will be an overall MVP.

[QUOTE=FM Jack Sparrow;268708]voting frog is useless she will get scum MVP anyway...[/QUOTE]

[COLOR="#00FF00"]Is there a Town MVP, a Scum MVP and an overall MVP, or just Scum and Town MVP?[/COLOR]

Originally Posted by FM Jack Sparrow

voting frog is useless she will get scum MVP anyway...

Is there a Town MVP, a Scum MVP and an overall MVP, or just Scum and Town MVP?

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268679]:D[/QUOTE]

I mean... I DID mean 25 hours...

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

I mean... I DID mean 25 hours...

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268667]If by "one hour" you mean "twenty five hours", then you are correct.[/QUOTE]

>.<

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

If by "one hour" you mean "twenty five hours", then you are correct.

>.<

Town has little over an hour to lynch. Lynching Sherlock wouldn't be that bad, but if they don't lynch, town realy deserves to lose.

Town has little over an hour to lynch. Lynching Sherlock wouldn't be that bad, but if they don't lynch, town realy deserves to lose.

I'm calling B.S. here...

[QUOTE=Frog]Maybe I'm just too seriousface about games I sign up to play (except for when I troll in s-fm). I play mafia at a bunch of different sites, and most of them start with a RVS phase where people jump straight into the game. I'd actually just chalk it up to playstyle differences because this site's meta is completely different and more laid back than what I'm used to. Also, I hate taking notes on excessive spam posts that add no value to the game except to say "hello." [/QUOTE]

[QUOTE=Clementine's first post from a different FM]Yo dawg, afrodite the afro man here.[/QUOTE]

Sadly, Cluseau seems to buy it...

I'm calling B.S. here...

Originally Posted by Frog

Maybe I'm just too seriousface about games I sign up to play (except for when I troll in s-fm). I play mafia at a bunch of different sites, and most of them start with a RVS phase where people jump straight into the game. I'd actually just chalk it up to playstyle differences because this site's meta is completely different and more laid back than what I'm used to. Also, I hate taking notes on excessive spam posts that add no value to the game except to say "hello."

Originally Posted by Clementine's first post from a different FM

Yo dawg, afrodite the afro man here.

Sadly, Cluseau seems to buy it...

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268392]Oh. In that case: Guaranteed scum victory. :laugh:[/QUOTE]

You were fated to die.

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

Oh. In that case: Guaranteed scum victory.

You were fated to die.

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268381]How about the one where it didn't matter because of the Order of Operations?[/QUOTE]

This is dead chat. We discuss what could have been if we hadn't died:P

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

How about the one where it didn't matter because of the Order of Operations?

This is dead chat. We discuss what could have been if we hadn't died:P

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268381]How about the one where it didn't matter because of the Order of Operations?[/QUOTE]

>.>

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

How about the one where it didn't matter because of the Order of Operations?

>.>

[QUOTE=Cluseau]Cake- good.
Fruit- good.
fruit cake- nasty garbage[/QUOTE]

Lol, that's actualy a realy good line.

Originally Posted by Cluseau

Cake- good.
Fruit- good.
fruit cake- nasty garbage

Lol, that's actualy a realy good line.

I think it says a lot that Town trusts Sherlocks judgement so little that they wants to lynch him, even though it will give town no extra lynches. Even when Sherlock is right, it's almost as if he were right by mistake. For the Wolverine lynch, it was almost as if he were voting out of revenge for Wolverine voting him...

[QUOTE=Sherlock]No hard feelings, Wolverine... but you always tried to misdirect the town into lynching me, making us think that my lynch would be the "safe choice" for town. Unfortunately for you, your method had nothing related to scumhunting at all.

So you are now the weakest link. Goodbye.[/QUOTE]

Also, this...

[QUOTE=Sherlock]Who said that Ceasar gave someone a gun? Why would he do that?

More importantly, I just noticed that he previously gave his gun to Wolverine, who turned out to be a MAFIA. Why would he risk himself giving the gun to possible witch after seeing THAT? I'm clearly sure that he chose to give a vest to one of us. None of his guns were used to kill scum. So I'm fairly confident that no one has received a gun today.[/QUOTE]

It's true. I didn't give a gun last night, but for completely different reasons. Town was going into day with 5 players alive. No matter what happens, town had 2 lynches. However, if a BS gun was fired, it would decrease town lynches to 1 which could potentialy lose the game for town. Even though I said earlier giving Cluseau the gun may have helped, I still wouldn't have done it. 1 poor town judgement call could have lost the game.

I didn't care what Wolverine's role was. I just wanted him to kill a scum-target, which I made sure to pre-assign, who he did kill. However, Sherlock makes it sound like I wouldn't give a gun because I was so shook about Wolverine's flip.

Morale of the story: Town is making the right call not trusting Sherlock's judgement in the endgame and lynching him now. He's acting like an idiot.

[vote]FM Sherlock[/vote]

I think it says a lot that Town trusts Sherlocks judgement so little that they wants to lynch him, even though it will give town no extra lynches. Even when Sherlock is right, it's almost as if he were right by mistake. For the Wolverine lynch, it was almost as if he were voting out of revenge for Wolverine voting him...

Originally Posted by Sherlock

No hard feelings, Wolverine... but you always tried to misdirect the town into lynching me, making us think that my lynch would be the "safe choice" for town. Unfortunately for you, your method had nothing related to scumhunting at all.

So you are now the weakest link. Goodbye.

Also, this...

Originally Posted by Sherlock

Who said that Ceasar gave someone a gun? Why would he do that?

More importantly, I just noticed that he previously gave his gun to Wolverine, who turned out to be a MAFIA. Why would he risk himself giving the gun to possible witch after seeing THAT? I'm clearly sure that he chose to give a vest to one of us. None of his guns were used to kill scum. So I'm fairly confident that no one has received a gun today.

It's true. I didn't give a gun last night, but for completely different reasons. Town was going into day with 5 players alive. No matter what happens, town had 2 lynches. However, if a BS gun was fired, it would decrease town lynches to 1 which could potentialy lose the game for town. Even though I said earlier giving Cluseau the gun may have helped, I still wouldn't have done it. 1 poor town judgement call could have lost the game.

I didn't care what Wolverine's role was. I just wanted him to kill a scum-target, which I made sure to pre-assign, who he did kill. However, Sherlock makes it sound like I wouldn't give a gun because I was so shook about Wolverine's flip.

Morale of the story: Town is making the right call not trusting Sherlock's judgement in the endgame and lynching him now. He's acting like an idiot.

-vote FM Sherlock

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268265]If it wasn't obvious enough based on his play style, you could have checked the deadlynches to confirm.[/QUOTE]

...

[vote]FM Wolverine[/vote]

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

If it wasn't obvious enough based on his play style, you could have checked the deadlynches to confirm.

...

-vote FM Wolverine

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268200]Out of curiosity, why are you so interested in my COM?[/QUOTE]

You were the most intelegent Mafia player.

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

Out of curiosity, why are you so interested in my COM?

You were the most intelegent Mafia player.

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268199]You'll have to figure it out for yourself. Good luck. This is my first FM. ;)

And he may be new, but that doesn't excuse him for being bad all game. I figured it out by around day 3/4.[/QUOTE]

Maybe not, but it isn't as interesting learning the COM of newer players. Some learn faster then others.

Also, this is your first game? Good job;)

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

You'll have to figure it out for yourself. Good luck. This is my first FM. ;)

And he may be new, but that doesn't excuse him for being bad all game. I figured it out by around day 3/4.

Maybe not, but it isn't as interesting learning the COM of newer players. Some learn faster then others.

Also, this is your first game? Good job;)

I'm actualy not that interested in the COM of any of the unrevealed living players (I wanted to know who Clementine was, and I was interested about Cluseau, but no more). I'm more interested in Wolverine and Agahnim (Damnus?)

I'm actualy not that interested in the COM of any of the unrevealed living players (I wanted to know who Clementine was, and I was interested about Cluseau, but no more). I'm more interested in Wolverine and Agahnim (Damnus?)

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;268190]Also [vote]FM Sherlock[/vote]

He's so bad, I simply must know who he is for the purposes of future ridicule.[/QUOTE]

Sherlock doesn't strike me as an experienced FM player who is having a bad game. He seems much more like a very new player.

Who are you Wolverine?

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

Also

-vote FM Sherlock

He's so bad, I simply must know who he is for the purposes of future ridicule.

Sherlock doesn't strike me as an experienced FM player who is having a bad game. He seems much more like a very new player.

Who are you Wolverine?

I'm unhappy about the way I ended D8. Orriginaly, I realy was considering King Tut vs Frog for the night kill. However, I was way more rushed for time, so I chose the easy choice of killing Tut. During D8, I also revamped my scumlist, changing Argahnim and Cleseau to Town. Wishing I gave Cleuseau the gun, as he seems to be our only hope.

I'm unhappy about the way I ended D8. Orriginaly, I realy was considering King Tut vs Frog for the night kill. However, I was way more rushed for time, so I chose the easy choice of killing Tut. During D8, I also revamped my scumlist, changing Argahnim and Cleseau to Town. Wishing I gave Cleuseau the gun, as he seems to be our only hope.

[QUOTE=FM Agahnim;267984]Your right Frogs posts have no real substance towards scumhunting the actual scum.
The reason I put Frog down as town was due to the massive amount of time she spent doing reads and giving voting tallys and reads into that.
So far she is the only scum, aside from me, that I have ever seen ever doing that.

:([/QUOTE]

Those aren't town tells. Those are scum tells...

Originally Posted by FM Agahnim

Your right Frogs posts have no real substance towards scumhunting the actual scum.
The reason I put Frog down as town was due to the massive amount of time she spent doing reads and giving voting tallys and reads into that.
So far she is the only scum, aside from me, that I have ever seen ever doing that.

Those aren't town tells. Those are scum tells...

[QUOTE=FM Pinkie Pie;268011]Hi Auckmid I suppose.[/QUOTE]

Who you talking too?

Originally Posted by FM Pinkie Pie

Hi Auckmid I suppose.

Who you talking too?

Clementine played an amazing game. Hypo-claims were genius. Realy wasn't that useful, but put her on everyones town lists. However, waiting for now, because she is very likely to win MVP, and if she wins that, she doesn't realy need Players Choice as well.

Clementine played an amazing game. Hypo-claims were genius. Realy wasn't that useful, but put her on everyones town lists. However, waiting for now, because she is very likely to win MVP, and if she wins that, she doesn't realy need Players Choice as well.

[QUOTE=FM Agahnim;267921]Ha. All of you were wrong 'm not scum.


Also Tut is Witch.[/QUOTE]

Also, you weren't meant to die. I was giving you the BS item:(

Originally Posted by FM Agahnim

Ha. All of you were wrong 'm not scum.


Also Tut is Witch.

Also, you weren't meant to die. I was giving you the BS item

[QUOTE=FM Agahnim;267921]Ha. All of you were wrong 'm not scum.


Also Tut is Witch.[/QUOTE]

Frog...

Originally Posted by FM Agahnim

Ha. All of you were wrong 'm not scum.


Also Tut is Witch.

Frog...

[QUOTE=FM Wolverine;267911]I mean, on the one hand, goddamn that's accurate for this game. But on the other, Frog's right about sample size. You'd need to analyze a lot more FMs to apply this to any other games. Plus, even if this is true, it only requires a slight change to the metagame (everyone makes sure they say "hi" in their first post) before it is rendered useless.

But in the context of this game... Well done. :D[/QUOTE]

Policy's change very much in this game. People will see what I wrote down and go "Okay, next time I'm scum I need to make sure not to make that scumtell"

This scumtell was meant to be used for this game alone. I doubt it will be effective in future games. However, I believe it was very effective in this game... if only people would listen to my important posts...

Originally Posted by FM Wolverine

I mean, on the one hand, goddamn that's accurate for this game. But on the other, Frog's right about sample size. You'd need to analyze a lot more FMs to apply this to any other games. Plus, even if this is true, it only requires a slight change to the metagame (everyone makes sure they say "hi" in their first post) before it is rendered useless.

But in the context of this game... Well done.

Policy's change very much in this game. People will see what I wrote down and go "Okay, next time I'm scum I need to make sure not to make that scumtell"

This scumtell was meant to be used for this game alone. I doubt it will be effective in future games. However, I believe it was very effective in this game... if only people would listen to my important posts...

[QUOTE=FM Game Master;267910]I think Cluseau has gone insane... he is arguing with himself.[/QUOTE]

Imo, Cluseau's performence this game varyed between very intelegent and making people wonder if he was dropped as a child.

Originally Posted by FM Game Master

I think Cluseau has gone insane... he is arguing with himself.

Imo, Cluseau's performence this game varyed between very intelegent and making people wonder if he was dropped as a child.

And... my anger is gone... until I can flame Gimili in epilougue...

Anyway, is anyone impressed with this:p

[QUOTE=Ceasar][U][B][COLOR="#FFFF00"]PLEASE READ THIS AND GIVE YOUR OPINION![/COLOR][/B][/U]

Due to yesterday’s flips, here is the new first post list. (Btw, I missed a couple of players because I originally thought I might be wasting my time with this. However, if someone wants to fill in the blanks, please do.)

[U][B]Greetings/Spammy first post [/B][/U]
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut (Pretty much ever post has been spammy)
Gimili [/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Rubber Duck
Dracula[/COLOR]

[B][U]Borderline[/U][/B]
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Watson[/COLOR]

Non-introductory first posts
[COLOR="#00FF00"]Anubis[/COLOR]
[COLOR="#FF0000"]Michigan J
Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie[/COLOR]


While I didn't ever vote SB, as the day progressed, I wanted to lynch SpongeBob more and more, partly due to how scummy his defence was, and partly because I wanted to see how valid this chart was. New statistics for chart are...

Category #1
#Of Confirmed Towns: 18
#Of Confirmed Scum: 2
#Of Unknowns: 3
Town to Mafia ratio: 9:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 78.3%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 33.3%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 50.0%

Conclusion
Town % is much higher then Scum %. Being in Category #1 = Town Tell.


Category #2
#Of Confirmed Towns: 4
#Of Confirmed Scum: 1
#Of Unknowns: 1
Town to Mafia ratio: 4:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 17.4%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 16.7%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 16.7%

Conclusion

Town % and Scum % in Category 2 are extreamely similar. Being in Category 2 = Null Tell

Category #3
#Of Confirmed Towns: 1
#Of Confirmed Scum: 3
#Of Unknowns: 2
Town to Mafia ratio: 4:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 4.3%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 50.0%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 33.3%

Conclusion
Scum % of Category 3 is over 20 times that of Town. Being in Category 3 = HUGE Scumtell


Final Conclusion
While only 50% of scum appear in Category #3 (which is still a lot), an absolutely miniscule 4.3% (1/23) of the town appeared there. The lesson we can learn from that is that while all scum don't necessarily appear in Category 3, if you do appear in Category 3, your statistical chances of being scum sky-rocket. Incidentally, TWO of the remaining unknowns appear in Category #3, and we are looking for TWO scum.

In short, as someone who strongly believes in statistics, I would be amazed if Frog and Wolverine are both town.

Lastly, for anyone who says basing scum-tells off of everyone’s first post is invalid; this is not based off of first posts. This is based off of statistical analysis.[/QUOTE]

I filled it in with all missing roles, but I had the chart up for 2 days. Unfortunately, no one bothered to comment...

Let's see if town is cabable of reading.

And... my anger is gone... until I can flame Gimili in epilougue...

Anyway, is anyone impressed with this

Originally Posted by Ceasar

PLEASE READ THIS AND GIVE YOUR OPINION!

Due to yesterday’s flips, here is the new first post list. (Btw, I missed a couple of players because I originally thought I might be wasting my time with this. However, if someone wants to fill in the blanks, please do.)

Greetings/Spammy first post
Ceasar
Robin Hood
Yoda
Master Chef
Terminator
Gandalf
Jack Sparrow
Indiana Jones
Thrakhath
Yosemite Sam
Mr. T
Cookie Monster
Hungry
Sherlock
Animal
Count-Von-Count
Hamburglar
Wile E Coyote
Cluseau
King Tut (Pretty much ever post has been spammy)
Gimili
Rubber Duck
Dracula

Borderline
Bridge Keeper
Arthur
Cpt. Jack
Obvious
Agahnim
Watson

Non-introductory first posts
Anubis
Michigan J
Wolverine
SpongeBob
Locutus
Pinkie Pie


While I didn't ever vote SB, as the day progressed, I wanted to lynch SpongeBob more and more, partly due to how scummy his defence was, and partly because I wanted to see how valid this chart was. New statistics for chart are...

Category #1
#Of Confirmed Towns: 18
#Of Confirmed Scum: 2
#Of Unknowns: 3
Town to Mafia ratio: 9:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 78.3%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 33.3%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 50.0%

Conclusion
Town % is much higher then Scum %. Being in Category #1 = Town Tell.


Category #2
#Of Confirmed Towns: 4
#Of Confirmed Scum: 1
#Of Unknowns: 1
Town to Mafia ratio: 4:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 17.4%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 16.7%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 16.7%

Conclusion

Town % and Scum % in Category 2 are extreamely similar. Being in Category 2 = Null Tell

Category #3
#Of Confirmed Towns: 1
#Of Confirmed Scum: 3
#Of Unknowns: 2
Town to Mafia ratio: 4:1

%Of Confirmed Towns in Category: 4.3%
%Of Confirmed Scum in Category: 50.0%
%Of Unknowns in Category: 33.3%

Conclusion
Scum % of Category 3 is over 20 times that of Town. Being in Category 3 = HUGE Scumtell


Final Conclusion
While only 50% of scum appear in Category #3 (which is still a lot), an absolutely miniscule 4.3% (1/23) of the town appeared there. The lesson we can learn from that is that while all scum don't necessarily appear in Category 3, if you do appear in Category 3, your statistical chances of being scum sky-rocket. Incidentally, TWO of the remaining unknowns appear in Category #3, and we are looking for TWO scum.

In short, as someone who strongly believes in statistics, I would be amazed if Frog and Wolverine are both town.

Lastly, for anyone who says basing scum-tells off of everyone’s first post is invalid; this is not based off of first posts. This is based off of statistical analysis.

I filled it in with all missing roles, but I had the chart up for 2 days. Unfortunately, no one bothered to comment...

Let's see if town is cabable of reading.

EVEN THOUGH ALMOST ALL MY GUNS HAVE GONE TO TOWN, THE FUCK IT UP EVERY SINGLE TIME!

EVEN THOUGH ALMOST ALL MY GUNS HAVE GONE TO TOWN, THE FUCK IT UP EVERY SINGLE TIME!

FUCK, HE IS!

YOU'RE A DUMBASS GIMILI!

FUCK, HE IS!

YOU'RE A DUMBASS GIMILI!

You're [I][B]kidding[/B][/I] me? I told Gimili to shoot Tut, but he shot Agahnim. Good scum move, but FROG is the Witch?

You're kidding me? I told Gimili to shoot Tut, but he shot Agahnim. Good scum move, but FROG is the Witch?

Gimili had the gun...

Gimili had the gun...

Dead or GG?

Dead or GG?

Shoot King Tut please gun-wielding person.

Shoot King Tut please gun-wielding person.

Lol, I remember I wanted to check something, but I can't remember what...

Lol, I remember I wanted to check something, but I can't remember what...

You have my blessing to lynch Wolverine. However, please don't hammer yet.

You have my blessing to lynch Wolverine. However, please don't hammer yet.

I'm tired, so I'm going to bed very soon.

I'm tired, so I'm going to bed very soon.

Wow guys, you are quite possibly missing the best post of the game:(

Wow guys, you are quite possibly missing the best post of the game