Search:

[QUOTE=Efekannn02;796555]I Dont See That As Breaking The Rules Since There Is No Actual Rule Except Someone Shouting ANGLESHOOTING On It
If That Can Be Angleshooting Then A Sheriff Who Checked Everyone As Town Finds The Last Mafia Because He Wasnt Checked As Town And Then They Lynch Him... I Can Shout ANGLESHOOTING On That One Too

Cmon Thats Not Breaking The Rules But Being A Dick To Everyone And If Everyone Agrees On The Idea Anyway Then Who The Hell Is To Blame?[/QUOTE]

If you break the spirit of the rules, and, as you say, are a dick to everyone, you're breaking the rules. That's literally why rules exists. This is sidetracking, though, so if you want to discuss this further, feel free to PM me.

Originally Posted by Efekannn02

I Dont See That As Breaking The Rules Since There Is No Actual Rule Except Someone Shouting ANGLESHOOTING On It
If That Can Be Angleshooting Then A Sheriff Who Checked Everyone As Town Finds The Last Mafia Because He Wasnt Checked As Town And Then They Lynch Him... I Can Shout ANGLESHOOTING On That One Too

Cmon Thats Not Breaking The Rules But Being A Dick To Everyone And If Everyone Agrees On The Idea Anyway Then Who The Hell Is To Blame?

If you break the spirit of the rules, and, as you say, are a dick to everyone, you're breaking the rules. That's literally why rules exists. This is sidetracking, though, so if you want to discuss this further, feel free to PM me.

[QUOTE=Efekannn02;796551]I Cant Understand How Angleshooting Is Against The Rules

All I See Is Some Guy Encouraging Others To Reveal Something Others Cannot So They Find Who Who Is

Someone Can Always Professionally Lie Afterall So Why Is It Against The Rules? Did I Understood The Rule Wrong? Or Is This Too Noob Friendly?[/QUOTE]

You can't understand how breaking the spirit of the rules is against the rules? Uuhhhhh.....

The rule is there to avoid something unfun: somebody revealing somebody else's identity right away.
I do think that the issue is fixed, though, since that setting isn't here anymore.

Originally Posted by Efekannn02

I Cant Understand How Angleshooting Is Against The Rules

All I See Is Some Guy Encouraging Others To Reveal Something Others Cannot So They Find Who Who Is

Someone Can Always Professionally Lie Afterall So Why Is It Against The Rules? Did I Understood The Rule Wrong? Or Is This Too Noob Friendly?

You can't understand how breaking the spirit of the rules is against the rules? Uuhhhhh.....

The rule is there to avoid something unfun: somebody revealing somebody else's identity right away.
I do think that the issue is fixed, though, since that setting isn't here anymore.

[QUOTE=Yayap;794421]Players tend to abuse mechanics/rules like this instead of following the spirit of the rule. For example town will use it like: "he can't reveal this guy, we know who this guy is so let's all say who it is and whoever can't must be the neutral"

You'll be constantly changing the rule to adapt to players trying stuff like that.[/QUOTE]

Sorry for late reply.
This is the exact definition of angleshooting, which is against the FM Rules, so it would be literal rule breaking.

There's also the easy way out of this issue in the setup rules themselves, stating that noone can claim to know who's the guy whose identity must not be hinted at, and/or highlight the "no angleshooting" rule in the setup rules.

Originally Posted by Yayap

Players tend to abuse mechanics/rules like this instead of following the spirit of the rule. For example town will use it like: "he can't reveal this guy, we know who this guy is so let's all say who it is and whoever can't must be the neutral"

You'll be constantly changing the rule to adapt to players trying stuff like that.

Sorry for late reply.
This is the exact definition of angleshooting, which is against the FM Rules, so it would be literal rule breaking.

There's also the easy way out of this issue in the setup rules themselves, stating that noone can claim to know who's the guy whose identity must not be hinted at, and/or highlight the "no angleshooting" rule in the setup rules.

[QUOTE=Yayap;794305]"Cannot reveal*Fegelein's*identity"
I know from experience that players will screw you over with something like this.[/QUOTE]

This is a valid concern IMO, I've had similar experiences... I think that putting in bold underlined all of this: "Cannot reveal, hint at or attempt to make people guess by your words Fegelein's identity" (that's just an example obviously) would be better for your future sanity.

Originally Posted by Yayap

"Cannot reveal*Fegelein's*identity"
I know from experience that players will screw you over with something like this.

This is a valid concern IMO, I've had similar experiences... I think that putting in bold underlined all of this: "Cannot reveal, hint at or attempt to make people guess by your words Fegelein's identity" (that's just an example obviously) would be better for your future sanity.