Anyway, after reading over the entirety of everything in depth, my personal current reads are:
ccantman: Leaning Town, I feel that ccantman hasn't contributed as much as he could due to being new and isn't quite sure how to act as Town to avoid being read as scum. Also claimed citizen after two others did, making it harder for our power roles to stay hidden.
Trine: Town
sinon: Leaning Town, trying not to biased by the writing style, which I like. Questioned the Whad/GET voting pair which I can appreciate but quickly claimed cit which, as others already explained, narrows the pool of citizens making it easier for witches to kill our PRs.
GET: Mostly Town, my only nit pick here in the hard claim on citizen at the very beginning and the potential early team up with Whad.
Whad: Mostly Town, has some good reads and made me go back and reconsider some of what Sinon said. I only dislike the early (seemingly random) vote on ccantman and pressing stereo so hard over his choice of words. Then again, I supposed we need some excuse to call someone out and see how they react. So I'll chalk it up to scum hunting.
ika: Null, seemed to take turns going after several people besides GET (ccantman, and sinon). I want to say that he's scum hunting and not just trying to find someone that people will line up to lynch. Difficult to say. Also claimed citizen last, effectively giving away to the witches who our PRs are (unless one of the previous citizens were lying) as I hadn't yet claimed citizen.
stereo: Leaning Town, I don't see anything suspicious in his behavior. He's mostly been defending himself about one remark where his neutral word choice (they, instead of us) made him sound scummy. But I haven't seem him contribute much.
Gauss: Town, I appreciate her questions and participation. I've never suspected her as scum.
I don't have previous game experience with anyone to go off of.