Search Results - SC2 Mafia
Register

Search:

Type: Posts; User: RufusPL

Page 1 of 2 1 2

Search: Search took 0.27 seconds.

  1. Replies
    20
    Views
    1,368

    Re: Democracy, illiteracy, and manipulation

    Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth was called "Rzeczpospolita" which is taken from Res Publica which literally means Republic. The system used back then is often called Nobles Democracy but there was a...
  2. Replies
    20
    Views
    1,368

    Re: Democracy, illiteracy, and manipulation

    You can't really call Poland not a democracy, it's definitely not typical eastern oligarchy. Poland has really long democratic history dating back to XV/XVI century. The problem doesn't lie here in...
  3. Replies
    20
    Views
    1,368

    Re: Democracy, illiteracy, and manipulation

    The media didn't like Donald Trump that's true, but the media was still transmitting his speeches because people wanted to see them and this is profit for TV stations. Here in Poland if someone isn't...
  4. Replies
    10
    Views
    410

    [New Role] Re: Identity Switcher

    I don't know it seems OP and it doesn't fit SC2 Mafia in my opinion. In SC2 Mafia chat is very limited so it's hard to determine anything based only on chatting and this role denies any information...
  5. Thread: Crier

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    23
    Views
    970

    [Role Change] Re: Crier

    The thing is if pms are on then Witch and Auditor usually can easly contact with Mafia. Especially Auditor has easy time doing that, Witch is more tricky but she can then control GF every night if...
  6. Thread: Crier

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    23
    Views
    970

    [Role Change] Re: Crier

    Because this gives Crier actual ability to lead the town like i said in the previous thread. He can stay hidden but still tell town who should they trial for example or how should they vote in his...
  7. Replies
    12
    Views
    498

    [Role Change] Re: [Vigilante] Fun in the Sun

    I just don't think that any roles should be given ability to kill during the day, judge is already annoying enough. What's the point of roles like Beguiler, Witch, BD or sometimes even Jailor and...
  8. Thread: Crier

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    23
    Views
    970

    [Role Change] Re: Crier

    There was a discussion about that like a month ago in this section "Crier vs Judge" i think so you can look it up.
  9. Replies
    12
    Views
    498

    [Role Change] Re: [Vigilante] Fun in the Sun

    I have shot so many dumb townies who just played like total scums (govs mostly) that killing me also in return is retarded. Especially that sometimes Vigilante has to shoot blindly if town is passive...
  10. [New Role] Re: Role Suggestion: Witness Protector/Operative

    It still won't work, maybe with arson but with MM and SK it would be easy to notice if it is fake or not
  11. [New Role] Re: Role Suggestion: Witness Protector/Operative

    If real Serial Killer also killed that night (which will happen almost always if he is still alive) then everyone will know one of it is fake.
  12. [New Role] Re: Role Suggestion: Witness Protector/Operative

    I see 2 problems, firstly taking votes away from town can be really problematic taking in consideration how fast sc2 mafia games are and how dispersed playerbase in terms of skill and game knowledge....
  13. Replies
    2
    Views
    320

    {Watch List} FattyMcBane:1-S2-1-5771489:

    Account Name: FattyMcBane
    Account ID: 1-S2-1-5771489
    In-Game Name: Class Warfare

    Crimes Committed: Game-Throwing

    Your Account Name: RufusPL
    Summary: So i revealed as Mayor day 2 like i...
  14. Thread: Fortune Teller

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    14
    Views
    559

    [New Role] Re: Fortune Teller

    The thing is does neutral benign even need that ability? Most of the results would be pretty useless to him like everyone usually knows if someone is Escort or Consort, Investigator or Consgiliere...
  15. Replies
    2
    Views
    417

    {Permanently Banned} Re: llllllllllll 1-S2-1-10435802

    I know that other players shouldn't usually post in other peoples reports, but i was also in that game. I would suggest putting an eye on this guy Titus aswell who was 11 the Incense Master. 14...
  16. Replies
    4
    Views
    275

    [Role Change] Re: Neutral Killers

    It makes some sense because Neutral Killer could talk to his victim then to recognise if it's worth killing him or not, it would be helpfull especially late game.
  17. Replies
    14
    Views
    494

    [Misc. Suggestion] Re: Guys Misc. Roles and Stuffs.

    Neutral Benign who can roleblock people seems too powerfull.

    Cult shouldn't be able to kill Masons, it defeats the whole idea of Masons. Their whole existence is to be immune to Cult this makes...
  18. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    Can you just stop arguing over me i don't feel attacked or anything so really just end this. I was just misunderstood that i think nothing should be changed because it's pointless. I actually post...
  19. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    If Any Random actually rolls Neutral Killing instead of Neutral Evil then it's probably less balance breaking. It only speeds up the game which is of course bad but from town perspective it's a lot...
  20. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    I don't expect any additional work from sc2mafia staff i don't need them to penalize anybody, i'm actually very thankfull that they are going to implement some changes after so long. I'm just very,...
  21. Replies
    6
    Views
    276

    [Other Change] Re: Adding a Standard Save Playlist

    Yes but i believe Grakylan asked for a 933/8331 playlist. So we could have a number of different 933/8331 on the one playlist to play variations of 933/8331. Setups just with different role setups...
  22. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    This slot change is basically what i said earlier and it definitely would work better than what we have now. On what u said earlier Cult should probably get a role indentical to Mason Leader. So they...
  23. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    Because if they won't be killed early they will gain too much power anyway. It's just not good balancing way in a game like this. If you put cultist as only evil faction in a setup they will be too...
  24. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    I think that would make them too based on luck, if Cultist gets unlucky and is checked by ML n1 the cult is over. If cultist gets killed by Triad/Neutral Killing n2-n3 it's also over even tho he got...
  25. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    I don't think you can include Judge/Witch/Auditor in the save then so it's not even regular save anymore so this discussion is pointless. You could just move Cult to Neutral Killing and all the...
  26. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    Well i guess we have a misunderstanding here. Neutral Evil basically is never a killing role, of course Serial Killer, Arsonist and MM are all Neutral Killing/Evil but 95% of the time they will be...
  27. Replies
    41
    Views
    1,448

    [Other Change] Re: Discussion: Cult

    The main problem with cult is that they aren't neutral evil yet they are in neutral evil slot. They have completely different win condition from other 3 neutral evils. And also they take townies...
  28. Replies
    6
    Views
    276

    [Other Change] Re: Adding a Standard Save Playlist

    If you want a balanced setup playlist you can't include 8331 as one of them. You just can't claim that any save with Any Random included is balanced. You can't claim that save with same setup options...
  29. [Role Change] Re: New Settings for Jailor/Kidnapper/Interrogator

    The thing is that not being able to jail after lynch is very important balancing factor. Jailor is easy to confirm, he is roleblocker and he can't be roleblocked, he can kill anyone and he has...
  30. [Role Change] Re: New Settings for Jailor/Kidnapper/Interrogator

    What i would like to see is a setting for Kidnapper/Jailor that would expose him to protective roles. Right now kidnapper can kill every town role he wants no matter what and this is just too much....
  31. Replies
    6
    Views
    246

    [New Mechanic] Re: Randomize or hide role settings

    The main problem with hidden setups is what Kenny said, host gains unfair advantage. It would need to be implented in some sort of playlist like SotD and it would need to be almost completely hidden...
  32. Replies
    6
    Views
    246

    [New Mechanic] Re: Randomize or hide role settings

    Hiding setup could be an interesting option but randomizing role setups would be adding even more unnecessary RNG to the game. Most role options change too much to let it be random.
  33. Replies
    8
    Views
    425

    [New Role] Re: Role Suggestion: Confidant

    I think if there would be no other evil counterpart so Town players could trust him and he could chat every night (Jailor for example is blocked by lynching) it would make this role strong enough...
  34. [Other] Re: Game froze when Bodyguard was put on trial day 5

    I think that was the game when all neuts died instantly. There was Judge and Marshall court day 2 that got rid of both of them and they also took the MM with them. Neutral benign also died somehow so...
  35. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    Majority wants to have 4 votes 2 courts as judge, almost everytime judge finds out he is reduced to 2 votes he either complains about host being shit or leaves the game right away.

    And about the...
  36. [Other] Game froze when Bodyguard was put on trial day 5

    I have no idea why it happened i haven't seen that in a couple years i think. Putting it up here won't hurt i guess.

    26182
  37. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    Well i can agree only with Cult, it's just objectively not a neutral evil, it doesn't even have the same win condition as other neutral evils. And maybe on Marshall, 8 lynchs in total is more than...
  38. Replies
    15
    Views
    523

    Poll: [Role Change] Re: DIscussion: Investigator

    Sheriff is good at confirming other investigative roles. If someone claims Investigator/Detective/Lookout with lw that basically couldn't be faked he can only be either town or triad support so...
  39. Thread: Spy

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    9
    Views
    402

    [Role Change] Re: Spy

    If you are going in this direction you could give Spy infomation about which exactly mafia role visited him if mafia targets him.
  40. Replies
    8
    Views
    425

    [New Role] Re: Role Suggestion: Confidant

    Ability to talk to someone privately is fine, but it should be announced to the player like jailor action. Mafia chat is already restricted because of spy adding another role which would 100% confirm...
  41. Replies
    32
    Views
    1,507

    [Role Change] Re: The Ideal Balance for Sc2 Mafia 2.0

    You are making a detailed balance thread in the time when most of the players use any random as a legit setup option. Seems pretty pointless to me. And still i don't agree on atleast half of the...
  42. Thread: Spy

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    9
    Views
    402

    [Role Change] Spy

    tl:dr Make ability to read mafia night chat an option not a defualt.

    I really like Spy, if he can see what targets mafia visited he can easly guess what roles they have and then he can lynch them...
  43. Replies
    15
    Views
    523

    Poll: [Role Change] Re: DIscussion: Investigator

    The main problem with Sheriff is that he is almost always impossible to confirm and that makes him overall the weakest investigative role in my opinion. You found Neut Killer? You can easly be triad...
  44. [Mechanics] Re: DH/GF won't turn Enforcer/Mafioso when he is last alive team member

    So atleast description should be changed because right now it literally states "Dragon Head changes to Enfocer if he is last alive".
  45. [Mechanics] DH/GF won't turn Enforcer/Mafioso when he is last alive team member

    This mechanic never worked since i played this game but i never thought of actually reporting it and i don't know if it was reported before. It seems like something easy to fix since there are role...
  46. Replies
    15
    Views
    523

    Poll: [Role Change] Re: DIscussion: Investigator

    Investigator is fine where it is, it pushes people to claim certain things depending on what crimes their real role has but in most cases it won't give you direct results like sheriff. But if you...
  47. Replies
    2
    Views
    207

    (Rejected) Re: Setting Max Role Counts Manually

    Of course if it's too hard to implement it would be more hassle than it is worth. Thanks for explaining.
  48. Thread: Crier vs Judge

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    16
    Views
    607

    [Role Change] Re: Crier vs Judge

    So back to Crier, what i think could really help this role and not change it's identity would be ability to speak anonymously also during the day so he can give town advice on the spot. Most of the...
  49. Replies
    2
    Views
    207

    (Rejected) Setting Max Role Counts Manually

    I think i have proposed it before but since there are many changes coming in mafia 2.0 after literally nothing changing for few years i thought to try again.
    It's really weird that host can't set...
  50. Thread: Crier vs Judge

    by RufusPL
    Replies
    16
    Views
    607

    [Role Change] Re: Crier vs Judge

    Yeah that's my point, with power roles, the problem is Escort isn't power or atleast protective/power, it's protective. That means I basically have to use it as town random only which isn't perfect....
Results 1 to 50 of 76
Page 1 of 2 1 2