-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Because he didn't say anything in jail. A rule follower wouldn't do such a thing, since he would greatly harm the rulefollowers' chances of winning. A cuck wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to get MODKILLED in order to win. A skyper wouldn't do such a thing, because he doesn't want to die lol. A com hunter wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to live in order to win. Which leaves... Gamethrower. Who needs to lose in order to win. Executing a gamethrower would get him on the way of the win. Which I don't want. So now execution for him. Happy?
No execution* i hate no edit rule lol
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Lol, no I'm not claiming anything. I am just trying to think logically about we are going to determine who the rule-breakers are. I was suggesting in a public forum that the mafia may be the key to stopping the rule-breakers because they all know each other's identity and have a night kill (while the MM only knows his own identity and has a night-kill).
Open to critiques on my thoughts, but it could be a good place to start.
Umm... Mind to clarify this? Rephrase, I wanna be sure of understanding what you meant. Potential slip here, bookmark #370
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Because he didn't say anything in jail. A rule follower wouldn't do such a thing, since he would greatly harm the rulefollowers' chances of winning. A cuck wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to get MODKILLED in order to win. A skyper wouldn't do such a thing, because he doesn't want to die lol. A com hunter wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to live in order to win. Which leaves... Gamethrower. Who needs to lose in order to win. Executing a gamethrower would get him on the way of the win. Which I don't want. So now execution for him. Happy?
I told you i wasnt going to say anything to you why jail me if you knew that and not execute? Makes no sense
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Suntax
MMs rhetoric yesterday indicated he was ginna kill you, so to not kill you is quite scummy tbf
I wanted him to have a reason to defend himself. I thought death threats were a good reason.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
I told you i wasnt going to say anything to you why jail me if you knew that and not execute? Makes no sense
Read post I just made.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
LMFAO you didnt kill scv you lieing sack of shit
Huh? What do you mean by that? It can be confirmed by my mafia buds and by Host.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
Just curious what is the other mafia role?
Don't know.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Huh? What do you mean by that? It can be confirmed by my mafia buds and by Host.
You can be kidnapper and gf?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Umm... Mind to clarify this? Rephrase, I wanna be sure of understanding what you meant. Potential slip here, bookmark #370
Ok gotta be real, my first forum game and I'm a little confused. But since I'm outed anyway, I guess I'll claim mafia-consort.
I'm not sure if my objective is for a mafia win or a town win. (If I am a Rule-Follower, but the town is filled with Game Throwers who need town to lose, do I want a mafia victory or a town victory?).
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
You can be kidnapper and gf?
Read role card: "You may act out for the factional kill."
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Lol, no I'm not claiming anything. I am just trying to think logically about we are going to determine who the rule-breakers are. I was suggesting in a public forum that the mafia may be the key to stopping the rule-breakers because they all know each other's identity and have a night kill (while the MM only knows his own identity and has a night-kill).
Open to critiques on my thoughts, but it could be a good place to start.
Only skypers know eachother's identity. This made me fear a skyper in the Mafia... Why do I (me only) know only my identity while you would know other's identities?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Ok gotta be real, my first forum game and I'm a little confused. But since I'm outed anyway, I guess I'll claim mafia-consort.
I'm not sure if my objective is for a mafia win or a town win. (If I am a Rule-Follower, but the town is filled with Game Throwers who need town to lose, do I want a mafia victory or a town victory?).
You actually want a Town victory. But we have no clue if the Town is filled with gamethrowers. One gamethrower in the Town doesn't mean 5 rule breakers are throwers. But you do make a point here. Mafia might have to throw in order to make the throwers lose. NotLikeThis
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Only skypers know eachother's identity. This made me fear a skyper in the Mafia... Why do I (me only) know only my identity while you would know other's identities?
I meant that the mafia know the other mafia members identities. Not that the mafia knows the MM identity.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
You actually want a Town victory. But we have no clue if the Town is filled with gamethrowers. One gamethrower in the Town doesn't mean 5 rule breakers are throwers. But you do make a point here. Mafia might have to throw in order to make the throwers lose. NotLikeThis
Throwception. A throw within a throw.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
naz
So my question to host was "is efe cit?" And his reply was yes, so Efe is not lying.
And I'm town investigator, I checked someone out last night and have no idea how to process my feedback 😭
at least your feedback was not fucking useless
i investigated SCV like wtf
my host question got me better results though and im pretty happy with how i nailed a read
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
SB16's really Invest btw, so the com hunter theory is down.
EZPZ
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
You litetally jailed me and let me live lol your getting lynched today
this makes no sense. why would mm lie about jailing and executing SCV?
i think both of you are lying tbh
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Throwception. A throw within a throw.
Yea, SCV's death confirms that we'll need to lynch mafia to win game.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
actually after posting that i believe MM much more considering both mafs of the other mafs have openly claimed and would contradict such a statement
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stealthbomber16
actually after posting that i believe MM much more considering both of the other mafs have openly claimed and would contradict such a statement
fixed
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stealthbomber16
at least your feedback was not fucking useless
i investigated SCV like wtf
my host question got me better results though and im pretty happy with how i nailed a read
EZPZ
this makes no sense. why would mm lie about jailing and executing SCV?
i think both of you are lying tbh
Yea, SCV's death confirms that we'll need to lynch mafia to win game.
I didn't lie... Did you even read my post about my reasons, in answer to Naz?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stealthbomber16
actually after posting that i believe MM much more considering both mafs of the other mafs have openly claimed and would contradict such a statement
^^ right. And still, read that post where I explain my reasons of no execution and why I ask Host to modkill Blinkskater. And tell me if you agree.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Throwception. A throw within a throw.
Yep. But for now, the mason-vigilantes are still useful.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Im an indepented Turkish person and I am proud as fuck with it.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hybrid
Im an indepented Turkish person and I am proud as fuck with it.
Did you just become a Cuck? XD
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Did the host answer anybody's questions? He didn't answer mine.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Sameeee spruance s a losert hou and i still think he slipped being gt
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Spruance
Did the host answer anybody's questions? He didn't answer mine.
I got no answer but ibguess the answer was a no
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Spruance
Did the host answer anybody's questions? He didn't answer mine.
He did answer mine. It was "Is SB16 really Investigator?" and the answer was "Yes".
Also only three posts since I got off??? Wtf XD
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
I got no answer but ibguess the answer was a no
No, it was ignore. Oh wait, your question was "Can you modkill MM?" so I get why he ignored it...
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Hybrid
Sameeee spruance s a losert hou and i still think he slipped being gt
What's a losert? Oh, you meant thou art a loser? :P
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
So just to clarify
Mafia did not use a night kill
MM jailed and executed SCV under thinking he was a skyper (same here tbh, i even put it in my will)
NK did not kill
Is this the accepted explanation for the events that took place?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
The other possibility that makes blink's claims true is that we had a mass murderer as NK that jailed blink.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
I asked if Hybrid was town I don't see any reason to ignore it...
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stealthbomber16
So just to clarify
Mafia did not use a night kill
MM jailed and executed SCV under thinking he was a skyper (same here tbh, i even put it in my will)
NK did not kill
Is this the accepted explanation for the events that took place?
IS THIS SERIOUS?!
Come on man... KIDNAPPING is a DAY action. The NIGHT action I sacrificed for that night was my EXECUTE ability. I acted out for the factional kill WHILE DETAINING blink.
NK indeed did not kill, which leads to an Arson/MM possibility (I guess).
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Stealthbomber16
The other possibility that makes blink's claims true is that we had a mass murderer as NK that jailed blink.
FailFish
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Spruance
I asked if Hybrid was town I don't see any reason to ignore it...
o.O Bookmark this information, #432
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
I Like Blink
-vote Marshmallow Marshall
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
They Are Trying To Purge The Damn Town Open Your Eyes He Is Mafia Gulty Get Him Ffs
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Yeah therr was supposed to be no killing last night yet there was a kill, it us my belief that MM killed scv thinking that he was a rule follower, but again had bad judgement and ended up killing one of his rulebreakers
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
No, we agreed on the night kill. Mafia, us, sent MM to kill scv.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
secondpassing
No, we agreed on the night kill. Mafia, us, sent MM to kill scv.
Maybe you three did but us townies didnt and the general consensus from the day chat was to not kill anyone cant have trigger happy mafia running around even tho we got lucly with the scv kill, there was no way of REALLY knowing if he was rule breaker or follower it was a 50/50 shot
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
blinkskater
Maybe you three did but us townies didnt and the general consensus from the day chat was to not kill anyone cant have trigger happy mafia running around even tho we got lucly with the scv kill, there was no way of REALLY knowing if he was rule breaker or follower it was a 50/50 shot
Your general consensus sucked.
Why? Because "random" killing is not really random, and that "randomly" killing anyone grants a higher probablility than setup average to hit an evil.
Without factoring in hunches and reads, in my point of view I have 4/10 chance to hit evil compared to 4/11 as I know my own role.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
We're getting nowhere.
Can you all either vote up, make reads, or just sheep my vote? If you don't take a stance, we can't have discussion.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Okay so based on these quotes:
Quote:
Originally Posted by
secondpassing
Actually, I change my mind.
-vote Soviet_Love
didn't post in night chat- probable lone scum
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Hello, posting so I don't get killed! Also some input:
It is disappointing that someone was randomly killed. I think it is more likely that a random kill (or random lynch) will kill a rule-follower than a gamethrower. Fortunately, Scvmurderer was a gamethrower. I guess something that I am wondering is - how do we go about discovering who are gamethrowers? And for us rule-followers, does it even matter if we get a town win or a maf win? Because if not, then we should rely on maf because they are basically mason-vigilantes.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Did you even read what I have wrote in night chat?? It was not random. And I actually thought he was a skyper, not a thrower.
Yes it does matter, because of gamethrowers.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
secondpassing
No, we agreed on the night kill. Mafia, us, sent MM to kill scv.
My suspicions of a non-rulefollower are Soviet_Love, especially after this
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Soviet_Love
Ok gotta be real, my first forum game and I'm a little confused. But since I'm outed anyway, I guess I'll claim mafia-consort.
I'm not sure if my objective is for a mafia win or a town win. (If I am a Rule-Follower, but the town is filled with Game Throwers who need town to lose, do I want a mafia victory or a town victory?).
I know its your first time, but why not claim rule follower if you are one?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Thoughts on Spruance?
I could be wrong, but I believe he has played this setup before(?) yet has no opinion on how we should proceed.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
I think it profits to rule followers if you reveal who was what. The feedback was provided like that, right? ("playername" is "role"/"role"/"role"/role") Fill the " " please.
So I investigated Hybrid and the feedback was:
Citizen / Godfather / Arsonist / Mafioso Vigilante / Serial Killer
.........like I'm supposed to gain anything from that. I guess I will ask host if he is neutral killing tonight? I really don't know what to ask host other than what people's secondary roles are.
And host can choose not to answer questions, he did answer mine (Is efe cit? yes)
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
secondpassing
Thoughts on Spruance?
I could be wrong, but I believe he has played this setup before(?) yet has no opinion on how we should proceed.
Thoughts on Spurance:
Where the hell is he? He hasn't posted since day two started, right?
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Marshmallow Marshall
Because he didn't say anything in jail. A rule follower wouldn't do such a thing, since he would greatly harm the rulefollowers' chances of winning. A cuck wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to get MODKILLED in order to win. A skyper wouldn't do such a thing, because he doesn't want to die lol. A com hunter wouldn't do such a thing, because he needs to live in order to win. Which leaves... Gamethrower. Who needs to lose in order to win. Executing a gamethrower would get him on the way of the win. Which I don't want. So now execution for him. Happy?
Lol well he did say he wasn't going to say anything. I recommend not jailing him tonight, maybe he is neut. killer? I'll invest him. I feel that strategy for cuck is way too obvious...everyone knows host knows secondary roles...could be the strategy of a gamethrower to lie too.
-
Re: S-FM Your Everyday Average Game
Expounding on this:
The underlying reason for why he might be doing this is:
a) most common unfortunately, that he is lazy in this instance
B!!!!!!!)has no actual intent to help town(as in followers) which highly suggests that town's interests does not align with his
c) has some master WIFOM plan because he misguidedly believes his role is game breaking. Haha.