Alright, so by PoE of TPRs claiming, assuming Mag is town by his behavior yesterday:
Unknown1234 because it's just extremely likely that he just randomly accused Mag of having killed Blink, and that Mag happened to visit him anyway (Or that Mag is SK, that's another possibility but less likely imo)
Huey because I know I'm town, if I assume Mag is town too then it leaves one of Unknown or Huey to be scum, and Huey didn't exactly prove himself towny on D1 so I can buy that, MAYBE, but Unknown is just 10000x scummier than him.
October 20th, 2019, 12:04 PM
Efekannn02
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
im literally town because I want to kill everyone including myself
October 20th, 2019, 12:04 PM
Ganelon
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
How is that ‘extremely likely’?
I don’t see it.
If he were scum would he not go with a safer claim like that of Cop, like Huey did?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
October 20th, 2019, 12:05 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unknown1234
Is this just complete ignorance to what has happened today? You put 2/4 TPR claims as your top lynches when there have been no other claims.. One of us is guaranteed to be town with no other claims so assuming that it's both of us makes no sense.
Waait, Frinckles's post says you were susp-checked by a cop (Huey, I assume) ??? LOL
That's totally not what I've been saying since the start of the game :P
Exactly, which is why I'm having a brain overload right now. I TRUST YOU so I'm basing my theory on that, if I'm wrong well then rip me.
Facts:
There were indeed 2 attacks on blink (else you would be lying).
Unknown is either really a 2nd tracker who saw you visit blink----- OOOOH WAIT...
Couldn't that be just a shitty accusation of you being scum because Blink died, as a last chance attempt to stay alive because he knew we would most likely all be on him? I bet he presented it as an accusation.
None of this was true because I had already intended to claim my role and lead against magoroth before Huey had even presented his lead on me. Also, I actually DIDN'T think it was Magoroth, and if you read the thread instead of posting ignorant you could see that clear as day.
October 20th, 2019, 12:08 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Magoroth
How is that ‘extremely likely’?
I don’t see it.
If he were scum would he not go with a safer claim like that of Cop, like Huey did?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Both are very possible, and Tracker claim saying that you visited a dead man isn't less safe than Cop claim saying you're straight up suspicious, if both are bullshit. Hell, even on the mod, scums claim "I'm Detective, X visited the dead man"...
What makes it extremely likely is that he's just scummy as hell by D1's events for reasons I already explained on that same day.
October 20th, 2019, 12:09 PM
Ganelon
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
I tend to abandon reads when mechanical claims come into play do you not do that?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
October 20th, 2019, 12:10 PM
Efekannn02
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
im town because all of you are scum
October 20th, 2019, 12:10 PM
Unknown1234
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
@Marshmallow Marshall
if there is a framer in play, do you think it would have made sense for them to frame me?
October 20th, 2019, 12:11 PM
Huey The Long
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marshmallow Marshall
Waait, Frinckles's post says you were susp-checked by a cop (Huey, I assume) ??? LOL
Yeah i got a Sus on Unknown. Unknown claimed he planned to claim before i came out with my Sus find, i dunno why he would do this as town really but as scum i can see exactly why he would do this. Planned that night with his scumteam to hit blink and then claim tracker and go through the whole nine tails. very possible. It was just luck i guess that the sk also hit blink.
October 20th, 2019, 12:12 PM
Unknown1234
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Magoroth visited someone who died. If you expect me to not reveal that lead then you are trying too hard to pin this on me.
October 20th, 2019, 12:13 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unknown1234
[/COLOR]
None of this was true because I had already intended to claim my role and lead against magoroth before Huey had even presented his lead on me. Also, I actually DIDN'T think it was Magoroth, and if you read the thread instead of posting ignorant you could see that clear as day.
Tell me. Why would Huey lie on you being suspicious? He has no reason to, absolutely none. He wasn't being lynched today anyway if he didn't claim, assuming he's scum, I think. The only possiblity of you being town is that there is a Framer who decided to frame YOU, while you were already scummy. Why not frame someone like Frinckles, who was being "thunderdomed" by Blink, for example?
So you are arguing that you were framed, which is already not super likely. Then I add that you're just scummy from behavioral analysis (you still couldn't find any good argument against mine when I pointed out your crap case on Blink).
"None of this is true", uh, lies. You were on the brink of getting lynched today because of last day and you knew it; claiming to have a TPR guilty result is the best way to survive a few days more.
October 20th, 2019, 12:14 PM
Voss
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
we currently have a 4 way tie between Frinkles, Unknown, MM, and DS.
i fucking love it.
October 20th, 2019, 12:15 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Magoroth
I tend to abandon reads when mechanical claims come into play do you not do that?
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Only when it comes to mechanical instant solve, which is absolutely not the case here. Mechanical PoE : The TPRs. I exclude myself and yourself, leaving Huey and Unknown. The scummiest person by far in that PoE is Unknown. The mechanical leads point to Unknown. I don't exactly see your objection,
@Magoroth
.
October 20th, 2019, 12:17 PM
Huey The Long
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unknown1234
Magoroth visited someone who died. If you expect me to not reveal that lead then you are trying too hard to pin this on me.
You claim you was gonna come out and claim before i laid a Sus on you but we cant confirm that, thats your word saying. I was gonna do X but you did X first. You claimed you was waiting for Mag to come on but i dont see why you would wait if you was planning to reveal anyway.
Furthermore just to big up my own position, I very much soft claimed Cop yesterday in a comment about Coffee and Donuts, i have no reason to come out and claim you was suspicious unless i thought it would further the town and its interests. If i was mafia i wouldnt of claimed anything and probs worked on a couple really big posts. For me to claim cop as mafia and just come in at you is a hella risky play, a real fucking risky ballsy ass play and i aint about that.
October 20th, 2019, 12:18 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huey The Long
Yeah i got a Sus on Unknown. Unknown claimed he planned to claim before i came out with my Sus find, i dunno why he would do this as town really but as scum i can see exactly why he would do this. Planned that night with his scumteam to hit blink and then claim tracker and go through the whole nine tails. very possible. It was just luck i guess that the sk also hit blink.
^^^^^^^^
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unknown1234
Magoroth visited someone who died. If you expect me to not reveal that lead then you are trying too hard to pin this on me.
The scum motivation and the scum likelihood is just much bigger than the town motivation and the town likelihood. If you're really town, well, sorry, but if you really are you played very poorly... which I don't believe, because you are a quality player. And this is not AtE, it's just a fact lol. I meta-skillread you there.
October 20th, 2019, 12:21 PM
Marshmallow Marshall
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Unknown1234
@Marshmallow Marshall
if there is a framer in play, do you think it would have made sense for them to frame me?
The following post explains this btw.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marshmallow Marshall
Tell me. Why would Huey lie on you being suspicious? He has no reason to, absolutely none. He wasn't being lynched today anyway if he didn't claim, assuming he's scum, I think. The only possiblity of you being town is that there is a Framer who decided to frame YOU, while you were already scummy. Why not frame someone like Frinckles, who was being "thunderdomed" by Blink, for example?
So you are arguing that you were framed, which is already not super likely. Then I add that you're just scummy from behavioral analysis (you still couldn't find any good argument against mine when I pointed out your crap case on Blink).
"None of this is true", uh, lies. You were on the brink of getting lynched today because of last day and you knew it; claiming to have a TPR guilty result is the best way to survive a few days more.
Everyone read this post and tell me that isn't literally and simply mechanically RIGHT.
@Magoroth
@Frinckles
@DS.
and all others
October 20th, 2019, 12:24 PM
Unknown1234
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Marshmallow Marshall
Tell me. Why would Huey lie on you being suspicious? He has no reason to, absolutely none. He wasn't being lynched today anyway if he didn't claim, assuming he's scum, I think. The only possiblity of you being town is that there is a Framer who decided to frame YOU, while you were already scummy. Why not frame someone like Frinckles, who was being "thunderdomed" by Blink, for example?
So you are arguing that you were framed, which is already not super likely. Then I add that you're just scummy from behavioral analysis (you still couldn't find any good argument against mine when I pointed out your crap case on Blink).
"None of this is true", uh, lies. You were on the brink of getting lynched today because of last day and you knew it; claiming to have a TPR guilty result is the best way to survive a few days more.
You just gave yourself an answer to two different questions based on a biased opinion. I'm going to dumb this down for you, but I find it interesting how you're willing to question what Huey would gain from picking me but not what I would gain from picking Magoroth.
1.) Like you say in YOUR OWN argument, Huey would gain everything from picking me. Before he claimed I was hinting at having found a potential killing role, which could have been pointing towards his teammate in the event that hes lying about being Cop. To add, both you and Magoroth were prioritizing me as your top lynch choice so it would be the easiest lynch to have achieved. This makes perfect sense why I could have been framed, which is why I find it believable that he may actually be Cop. Especially more than your claim.
2.) Your argument that I'm scummy is 100% biased to your opinion. I can't argue why I'm not scum, I explained to you that it's how you go about making a town core that makes it scummy versus the act of doing it yourself. You chose to ignore my arguments, if you're town than that's your fault for choosing to tunnel me like I did to blinkskater.
3.) I was not even close to being lynched yesterday, at the end of the day I was 9th on the list of being lynched. TWO people wanted to lynch me, and even magoroth did a complete flip on me and had little explanation as to why. The fact that you flipped this onto me both ways in an attempt to make your argument against me look better shows way too many obvious flaws in it for me to believe you're town.
October 20th, 2019, 12:25 PM
Unknown1234
Re: S-FM 288: La Cosa Nostra
Quote:
Originally Posted by Huey The Long
You claim you was gonna come out and claim before i laid a Sus on you but we cant confirm that, thats your word saying. I was gonna do X but you did X first. You claimed you was waiting for Mag to come on but i dont see why you would wait if you was planning to reveal anyway.
Furthermore just to big up my own position, I very much soft claimed Cop yesterday in a comment about Coffee and Donuts, i have no reason to come out and claim you was suspicious unless i thought it would further the town and its interests. If i was mafia i wouldnt of claimed anything and probs worked on a couple really big posts. For me to claim cop as mafia and just come in at you is a hella risky play, a real fucking risky ballsy ass play and i aint about that.
Read the posts at the start of day which I entirely indicated I was asking about possible Serial Killers. there is 100% reason to believe that I had that lead and was planning on claiming.